ipl-logo

The Siege Controversy

1062 Words5 Pages

The 20th Century Fox film, The Siege, released in theaters November 1998, was such a controversy that people protested the thought that Middle Eastern “terrorists” could be motivated by their Islamic faith to perform acts of terrorism. During the film production, Arab-American organizations criticized it for reinforcing known U.S. stereotypes of Muslims and of Islam as a religion of terrorism. This film depicts a scene that would have never been expected only to have a devastating terrorist attack happen in NYC three years later. I chose to analyze this movie because of the fact that the issue of terrorism is still a very prominent issue in today’s society. The recent terror attacks in London only prove the fact that this terrorism threat is …show more content…

Bush announced after the attack that the fight against international terrorism is "the first war of the 21st century. It will be the focus of my administration" (CNN, 2001, September 13). A few days later, President Bush announced to the world, “Every nation in every region now has a decision to make. Either you are with us, or you are with the terrorists” (Patterns of Global Terrorism 2001, 2002). In this way, the film varies significantly from progress in historical reality. In the film the armed forces are the ultimate answer to U.S. security but also a threat bigger than terrorism to civil society. Martial law limits civil liberties and makes innocent citizens terrorist suspects. The film hand-over the armed forces to the megalomaniac, General Devereaux, whom the FBI agent takes down at the end of the movie, consequently reinstating the balance of power in the civil …show more content…

Even though the film pulls from the historical and political U.S. experiences with terrorism, its portrayal of Middle-Eastern terrorism, in particular fundamentalist Islamic terrorism, does not rise above the past stereotype of the news, media, and film images. The film suggests to viewers a misrepresentation, that is, a narcissistic view of Arabs and a depiction that Islam as a religion has terroristic tendencies. In the movies image of detention camps home only to Arabs in New York City, and the mass public protest against it, the film has somehow generated a sense of sympathy near the end for the Arab

Show More
Related
917 Words | 4 Pages

After the attack on the World Trade Centers in 2001, conspiracies began to fly, fingers were being pointed, and accusations were being made. Nine years after the attack, Omar Ashmawy wrote an essay “Ten Years After 9/11. We’re Still in the Dark” to the Washington Post. In his essay, he argues that US citizens are not well enlightened on the cultures of the Islamic and Arabic people and that ignorance gets in the way of obtaining a healthy relationship with Arab and Muslim countries. With his wise use of pathos, logos, and ethos, Ashmawy creates a well written essay that captures the heart of his readers and gives an inspiring glimpse into the effects of 9/11.

Read More
884 Words | 4 Pages

The men that murdered people at Charlie Hebdo in the name of Islam, in no way represent all of Islam. In fact, Younge argues that these men only represent themselves and only a small, notorious section of Islam would support their actions. This article published on the anniversary of the opening of Guantanamo Bay definitely made a great impact in the debate on this issue. Younge makes strong arguments, while at the same time defending them.

Read More
1145 Words | 5 Pages

This plan specifically affected all Americans, not to mention many nations around the globe. Bush declared war on terrorism as a whole, and threatened to attack any nations that supported terrorist groups. He also pledged to not stop American aid until “every terrorist group of global reach has been found, stopped and defeated”. Bush successfully used literary devices;

Read More
1468 Words | 6 Pages

Samira Ahmed’s realistic fiction novel, Love, Hate, and Other Filters, takes place in modern-day Chicago where a suicide bombing has engrossed the attention of America. Maya Aziz, a Muslim teenager, is targeted for her heritage while attempting to lead a life free of high school drama, controlling parents, and difficult relationships. As Maya copes with Islamophobia, prejudice against Muslims, she begins to understand the horrors and shortcomings of violence. One lesson the story suggests is that hatred is an infectious and blinding motive. From the very beginning of the story, readers are familiarized with the source of terrorism through thorough description and sentence structure.

Read More
1297 Words | 6 Pages

This weekend I am engaged in extensive sessions with members of my National Security Council, as we plan a comprehensive assault on terrorism” Whitehouse.gov (2001) Here, the Former President has associated the attackers with “terrorism” and has explained that the National Security Team is planning a comprehensive assault on terrorism. Again, security is the primary issue, and it is the first topic of the speech. Further into the speech, in his words, “In Washington D.C. the political parties and both houses of Congress have shown a terrorist attack designed to tear us apart has instead bound us together as a nation”

Read More
1581 Words | 7 Pages

The objective of these speeches was to change the world politically, economically and socially, and they succeeded. By materializing this enemy known as “terrorism”, George Bush changed the world. In his Remarks Following a Meeting With the National Security Team, George Bush labels the attacks of 9/11 as “acts of war” (Bush 2001, 1100). For the first time in

Read More
280 Words | 2 Pages

Following the 9-11 attacks, on September 17th 2001, President George. W.Bush confirmed to America and the watching world Osama Bin Laden the,dictator and ruler of the terrorist organisation Al-Qaeda was the plotting mastermind behind these vicious attacks. The President made a history defining speech on November 10, 2001, declaring a Global “War on Terror”, which in turn highlights the overall large scale significance of 9-11, and furthermore highlighting the renewed stance and direction US Domestic and Foreign Policy was taking as well as an unprecedented Presidential phase within US Politics and Government, in the wake of these terror attacks. Furthermore the significance of 9-11 was evidenced in Bush’s speech in which he articulated, “we

Read More
549 Words | 3 Pages

He continues, criticizing Trump and how he subjectively attributes terrorism to certain acts based on ethnicity and religion. By enumerating other examples the author underscores the double standards in the political usage of terrorism. He assumes that terrorism is a tool in the hands of politicians to target what they consider as enemies and avoid using it for other certain acts that they just describe as marginal. This tool supposedly reinforces the security of an

Read More
1024 Words | 5 Pages

Bush used the speech as a reference to Iran, Iraq, and North Korea as the "axis of evil" for the first time. The speech was mostly focused on foreign policy. President Bush unveiled a comprehensive strategy to track out and neutralize terrorists worldwide following the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on the United States. The term "Global War on Terror," or "GWOT," was used to refer to the conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq as well as additional military, diplomatic, and other measures used to prevent terrorists from receiving funding or safe haven. The GWOT included participation from global coalition partners as well.

Read More
1298 Words | 6 Pages

Violence aids in the prolonged recollection of certain events. However, the accuracy of the representation of those events can and must be called into question. Despite acts of brutality helping to construct collective memory, the use of violence by ‘terrorist’ groups is often an attempt to create a potent form of political communication. By inflicting harm and spreading images of their atrocities, terrorist groups aim to provoke strong emotional reactions and shape the narratives that define a society's collective memory. However, the legacy of these violent acts is ambiguous.

Read More
612 Words | 3 Pages

On September 11, 2001, two planes were flown into the New York World Trade Centers by Islamic terrorists. This violence shocked America into an acknowledgement of the growing threat of international terrorism, and sparked the Global War on Terror. The U.S. President at the time, George W. Bush, described this “mass murder” as “despicable acts of terror”, and, in his subsequent address to the Nation, assured the American people that their government was doing all that they could to bring those who planned the attacks to justice. Throughout his address, Bush most prominently uses repetition and analogy to help his grieving nation better understand the situation, what will be done in response, and that it is worthy of their defense through war.

Read More
1100 Words | 5 Pages

As a result, the media that cover these events dictate what and how they are shared. However, it only helps to feed our sense of fear towards terrorism as well as fuel the Muslim stereotype. In fact, according to a study on deconstructing the terrorism- news media relationship, “terrorists use media as a tool to gain increased coverage and communicate their message,” but sometimes the news does it for them (Ross). For example, in the UCLA shooting, where two men were killed in a murder-suicide, the news’ portrayal of the situation led many to believe that there were multiple attackers instead of just the one. While this may not directly convey terrorists’ message, it helps to spread unnecessary fear of terrorism in our communities.

Read More
1888 Words | 8 Pages

Background & Context: The War on Terror has plagued the wellbeing of nations across the globe since its start in 2001 (Peters). This ‘war’ has been viewed as: an “ideological struggle” between the US and who the United States believes is involved in terrorist organizations (Peters). Post 9/11, the United States was in culture shock. This was due to the sudden intrusion of fear that blossomed in the hearts and minds of Americans. Terrorism was making itself a real and imposing threat.

Read More
968 Words | 4 Pages

This insightful novel takes a deeper look at the harrowing effects of Islamophobia and the struggles Arab Americans deal with in the post 9/11 era. This book demonstrates how the intolerance and suspicious nature of Americans leads to the fragmentation of assimilated Arab Americans and to have their world turned upside down truly exposes the dark side of government policies, such as racial profiling. Furthermore, this novel exemplifies the hidden costs of the pursuit of the American Dream, including the loss and exiles the characters, Jassim and Salwa experience in

Read More
1716 Words | 7 Pages

In the Constitution of the United States entrench a requirement and action to have a profession, which ensure the protection and safety of the Nation and State, “We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, …, provide for the common defence” . Basically, this statement is the presumption, that part of society gain a mandate to render an essential obligation to the Nation in a specific area, in particular case this is a defence. In order to fulfill stated obligation, part of society must have the necessary knowledge and skills. Next, they have to ensure and gain public trust and autonomy in their action. Finally, set high moral standards that reflect the values of society.

Read More

More about The Siege Controversy

Related Topics

Open Document