ipl-logo

The Trial Of Anne Hutchinson: Heretical Teacher Or Guardian Of Religious Liberty

823 Words4 Pages

The Trial of Anne Hutchinson: Heretical Teacher or Guardian of Religious Liberty
Lanie Riley-Collier
Liberty University
HIUS 221: Survey of American History I
Professor Wolfe
February 27, 2023
2
The Trial of Anne Hutchinson: Heretical Teacher or Guardian of Religious Liberty
When thinking of an inspiring, Christian woman, who comes to your mind? Anne
Hutchinson may not be your first thought, but I believe she deserves to be. Hutchinson wasn’t as well known, but she truly stood up for her Christian beliefs. Anne Hutchinson was a Puritan spiritual advisor and religious reformer who changed the Massachusetts Bay Colony forever
(Michals, 2015). There were a couple new facts that I learned from researching Hutchinson such as that it was against …show more content…

When I began researching Hutchinson and found out what she stood for, I questioned and couldn't quite understand why what she believed in was persecuted by the
Puritans. The article called “Anne Hutchinson - significance, beliefs, banishment - history” stated, “Hutchinson, like Cotton, stressed salvation by God’s grace alone (the Covenant of
Grace), and she disavowed the Puritan belief that good works were a sign of God’s grace,”
(2009). This quote encapsulates what Hutchinson believed and I feel the same as her. I originally thought the Puritan Doctrine was just like a regular Christian religion, but a little more strict. I never knew that this doctrine didn’t agree with having a personal relationship with God on your own terms. Ephesians 2:8-9 states, “For by grace you have been saved through faith. And this is not your own doing; it is the gift of God, now a result of works, so that no one may boast,”
(ESV). This verse is a perfect explanation of how I believe and what I think Hutchinson would agree with as well. As much as it shocked me to find out that the Puritan Doctrine didn’t allow …show more content…

After reading various resources on Hutchinson’s life story, at the end of each one it told how she had passed. I was expecting a peaceful passing, but this was not the case for Hutchinson. In 1643, Hutchinson and her family were at their home when suddenly they were attacked by an Indian tribe,
(Michals, 2015). This attack resulted in fifteen people dying, including Hutchinson. Michals states, “Initially, historians thought the attack was in response to whites taking Indian lands, however, some historians also speculate that it may have been provoked by Puritans,” (2015).
You would think this was enough and the Puritans would leave it alone. However, this was not the end. John Winthrop still held a grudge against Hutchinson and after hearing of her death, he claimed that his prayers were answered and she was finally gone. Anne Hutchinson - significance, beliefs, banishment - history claimed that Winthrop eventually wrote an essay about
Hutchinson and referred to her as the “American Jezebel”, (2009).
Moreover, I learned that there is a piece of land dedicated to Hutchinson’s honor. This piece of land is located in New York and called the “Hutchinson River Parkway”.

Show More
Related
254 Words | 2 Pages

Why did Winthrop think that the Puritans were a special people? And why did he believe they had to be especially careful in their new endeavor? Puritan wanted to reform their church and opposed to the corruption of the Church of England so they moved to the New World. John Winthrop wanted to show England that their way was wrong; therefore he wanted to prove it to them by presenting that the Puritans have a successful colony.

Read More
196 Words | 1 Pages

Hutchinson held meetings with women to discuss her own theological views, recent sermons, and question church policies. In the text of “The Massachusetts Bay Colony Case Against Anne Hutchinson (1637)”, the governor tells Mrs. Hutchinson, “Why for your doings, this you did harbor and countenance those that are parties in this faction that you have heard of”. The governor is accusing Anne of disrupting the laws of God and causing instability because when one person speaks out it creates a chain reaction. This includes more people questioning and even rebelling against their leaders and religion. In another incident in the writing of The Massachusetts Bay Colony Case Against Anne Hutchinson (1637)”, the governor ask Mrs. Hutchinson a question

Read More
584 Words | 3 Pages

Mary Dyer had not agreed with the Puritan religion. She believed that God spoke to everyone through the urgings of his or her conscience; Puritans thought God only spoke to authorities of the church. Dyer also did not believe that the church should govern all aspects of life in the colony. At first, she kept an uneasy silence. But once a woman, Anne Hutchinson, began publically opposing the church, Dyer decided to step in as well.

Read More
842 Words | 4 Pages

Two main people who fought to express their personal beliefs were Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson. However, these two were both banned from the colony for stating their faith. The documents “Trial and Interrogation

Read More
96 Words | 1 Pages

In 1634, a woman that would play one of the biggest roles in the development of early America came to Massachusetts from England. Before immigrating to the New World though, Anne Hutchinson lived in London with her husband William Hutchinson. There, a minister, John Cotton, who believed you didn’t need to follow the laws and rules of society to connect with God, resonated greatly with Anne. The idea that religion is based on personal views would be taken with her to the New World, where she would become an icon for conservative Puritanism and steadfast determination.

Read More
1092 Words | 5 Pages

2. Anne Hutchinson was an outspoken woman who challenged predestination. B.Roger Williams was a outspoken preacher who wanted to break with the Church of England. He questioned the Bay Colony charter’s legality.

Read More
662 Words | 3 Pages

Anne Hutchinson went to trial to argue with the Governor Winthrop during 1637.This happened because the governor was feeling threatened by Anne Hutchinson during the years of Massachusetts Bay Colony. Anne Hutchinson was a women that challenged the traditions that the puritans had in the role of women in their society because of her opposite beliefs. She was the first women to be against the puritans traditions and that’s one of the reasons why she was sentenced to banish from the massachusetts colony and also excommunication from her church, They said that she was a treat to the puritan experiments. Puritans were convinced that many of the church’s beliefs and practices were wrong, they also thought that England church had broken away

Read More
660 Words | 3 Pages

Bostonians received a new ally when the Reverend John Wheelwright arrived from England, and immediately aligned himself with Cotton, Anne Hutchinson and other "free grace" advocates. This really helped Anne Hutchinson. John Wheelwright was not only a close neighbor of Anne Hutchinson, but his wife is a sister of Anne Hutchinson’s husband. More people were beginning to follow Anne Hutchinson and her allies. When the young Henry Vane was elected as the governor of the colony, it was another boost for the free grace advocates.

Read More
514 Words | 3 Pages

“THE TRIAL OF ANNE HUTCHINSON” (1637) was written by John Winthrop. This document was conducted to ascertain whether Anna Hutchinson's religious views were consistent with those of the Massachusetts Bay Colony's Puritans. In terms of American religious freedom history, it was a turning point. This trial was notable because it was the first time in American history that a woman had ever been tried for her religious beliefs. Governor John Winthrip says to Mrs.Hutchinson, “the sentence of the court you hear is that you are banished from out of our jurisdiction as being a woman not fit for our society, and are to be imprisoned till the court shall send you away (Foner 76).”

Read More
856 Words | 4 Pages

They believed everything was a result of god’s grace. In order to gain salvation one must be entirely good and always stay in god’s favor, as god is the supreme ruler while human beings are all sinners. Puritans also held the bible in the highest regard, in

Read More
830 Words | 4 Pages

Ann Hutchinson was a woman who was banished from Boston in 1638 by John Winthrop, due to her being unfit for the society. Hutchinson was deemed unfit by Winthrop because she believed the minister, John Wilson, was preaching against the Puritan belief of predestine or covenant of grace. Ann thought Wilson preached more off the ideology of the covenant of works; meaning if a person worked hard enough to be good and do charitable things, such person would earn a place in heaven. Puritans believed that God chooses people to be a part of his “elect” (people who would go to heaven regardless of their sins) and this spot in heaven could not be earned. Since Ann Hutchinson accused Wilson of preaching against Puritan views, she was soon banished for

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

Hawthorne noted, “…the sainted Ann Hutchinson, as she entered the prison door, --we shall not take us to determine” (36). Anne Hutchinson did not let the fact that she got banned from Boston get to her and her freedom was not confined she did what she wanted and did not care. Hutchinson was a perfect example of the ominous tone because she was not afraid of what would happen to her and she did not let the confinement get to her. Hawthorne states, “… to symbolize some sweet moral blossom, that along the track, or relieve the darkening close of a tale of human frailty and sorrow.”

Read More
588 Words | 3 Pages

Religious freedom and toleration in the English North American colonies provided little room for those who did not practice the exact same form of government and religion. Although a similarity to America today is that the Puritan "court" provided a ruling to determine the punishment of an individual, however, the similarities stop there. When people came outright to declare their individual practices, such as Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson, they were denounced and, in certain cases, sent into

Read More
1079 Words | 5 Pages

Puritans are a people with a very strong belief in both God and the power of God. When people see power, they interpret it in different ways. Some know of power through anger and impulse, while others see power through the goodness the powerful one shows. Although Anne Bradstreet and Jonathan Edwards are both puritan poets, their writings convey mainly different, though sometimes similar, views on God because they have different perceptions of His will and the use of His power. Anne Bradstreet listens to and accepts anything that God wishes, and that is shown through her poem Upon the Burning of my House.

Read More
920 Words | 4 Pages

Essentially, Puritans are expected to follow a strict set of religious and moral guidelines from which their actions and morality are derived. According to Hall’s A Reforming People, these moral expectations first introduced by the pilgrims were the driving force behind the power that the Puritan ministry had over society: “Ministers and laypeople looked first to congregations as the place where love, mutuality, and righteousness would flourish, and second to civil society. …Alongside love, mutuality, and righteousness they placed another set of values summed up in the word “equity.” Employed in a broad array of contexts, the concept of equity conveyed the colonists’ hopes for justice and fairness in their social world.”

Read More

More about The Trial Of Anne Hutchinson: Heretical Teacher Or Guardian Of Religious Liberty

Related Topics

Open Document