ipl-logo

Thucydides 'Placement Of Perikles' Funeral Oration

1712 Words7 Pages

Thucydides’ placement of Perikles’ “Funeral Oration” followed by the account of the plague is in every sense a “dramatic juxtaposition”[1]. The deliberate binary opposition of logos and ergon, and nomos and physis between the speech and plague makes these two events the antithesis of his work. With both the eulogy and the narrative that follows, the reader should understand a point of truth in human nature, and teach them something that time with never change, the past gives way to the events of the future.

In his writing, Thucydides uses words and phrases to contrast Perikles’ speech with the plague in such a jarring way. In the “Funeral Oration”, Perikles describes war with phrases such as, “nobly died in battle” and “conclusion of men’s …show more content…

Instead of “cover[ing] them with earth” they set fires to bodies piled on top of each other. Because nomos is followed by physis with the plague narrative, the truth of human nature comes out. When it comes to the nature of things, is shows how quickly people will abandon order of society to do what they can for themselves. At the end of the “Funeral Oration” Perikles, says, “…the city will rear their sons at public expense…” showing that the death of their sons is one caused by society, a death for and by the public (2.46). However, in talking about the devastation of the plague, Thucydides says it's “the nature of the plague” that kills these men so horribly (2.50) War is a death caused by nomos, it is a death due to society and its structure while the plague is a death through physis, a natural cause. The irony of a death that is noble and one that is destructive in correlation to nomos and physis makes this juxtaposition so dramatic. The death that is destructive to society is due to the abandonment of the nomos because of the “nature of the plague” and the real toll of death on society. The noble and worthy death in Perikles’ eyes is one society has …show more content…

The plague allows for us, the readers, to see the moral corruption of society hidden in the purpose and words of the oration. The glorification of death in war in contrast with the carnage of disease shows us moral corruption because Perikles hides expediency of the death in war with valor and courage. Perikles gives this huge speech about how men should be honored with a deed and not word, but when followed by the narrative of people dying of the plague, the oration should be then read as a fabrication of what death looks like, and the plague representing the truth of dying. Death is one action and its one that is horrific whether it is the plague, old age, or war. The plague accurately depicts the truth about the action of dying and the atrocities that follow with death at such a large-scale because it is not dressed up, but graphic and realistic. By defining it as a grand and courageous action due to war, Perikles is creating a false identity of death in order to get more men to fight a war created by society’s need to be the

Show More
Related
1287 Words | 6 Pages

It illustrates when troops are back from the war their are considering taking their lives because their feel like murders since; they took someone else’s life and all the killing that happens within the war. For example, when one of their comrade’s is killed they feel guilty, and it will lead them to feel like their should have done a better job protecting each other. As a result, what they experience during the war can cause trauma to the brain, trigger the memory system and every man’s life

Read More
1084 Words | 5 Pages

The reading of “Pericles’ Funeral Oration” and “The Plague” are situated perfectly in the story “History of the Peloponnesian War” by Thucydides. The setting of the “Pericles’ Funeral Oration” is at the end of the first year of war and the beginning of the plague. “Pericles’ Funeral Oration” is showing the customs of how Athenians buried their dead. “The Athenians, following their annual custom, gave a public funeral for those who had been the first to die in the war” (Thucydides, p. 143).

Read More
161 Words | 1 Pages

Also, Thucydides is usually viewed as one of the first true historians, because he was able to write from a direct take as it happened without romance. Thucydides was exiled in 424 since he failed to carry out a task. During exile he got information from many eye witnesses. He puts a great value on eyewitness testimony, however Thucydides recognized that it could be unreliable because two people could have different accounts on the same situation. In The Landmark Thucydides (2008) Robert Strassler mentions that, Thucydides illustrates that the funeral ceremonies as, “the dead are laid in the public sepulcher in the most beautiful suburb of the city, in which those who fall in war are always buried,” (Strassler, 110).

Read More
144 Words | 1 Pages

Considering that both speeches used logos, Pericles’ Funeral Oration presented a better logical appeal because he brings forth hypothetical examples. In the speech, Pericles says " I would ask you to count as gain the greater part of your life, in which you have been happy, and remember that what remains is not long," ( page 77, 32-34), he creates a valid argument using logic saying if you are sad because your son died just remember the parts of your life where you were happy and don’t worry because you don’t have much left to live. Furthermore, Susan B. Anthony uses logos too, for example, “It was, we the people; not we, the white male citizens… but we, the whole people, who formed the Union” (Copeland 321), she uses logos to emphasize how

Read More
1613 Words | 7 Pages

Words like “duty”, “nobly”, and “hero” were often used in obituaries, and magazine and newspaper articles, in the hope that meaning and purpose would be given to the horrific deaths (Damousi 368). However, this elevated rhetoric was not only applied to the actions of the soldiers. In order to encourage support from the citizens back home, the rhetoric was also applied to them. This is shown in the November 1914 issue of The Family Journal in a column titled “Smiling through their tears’; the scenario is a family grieving for their son: “It wasn’t that they were not suffering agony for their personal loss, but they were very glad that they had given their best – yes, the very blood of their hearts – for the cause of Right” (Acton 22).

Read More
499 Words | 2 Pages

If war and death are closely associated, then it shows how soldiers in the war must have not only been in situations where they could die, but also that in the war, many people suffered and died. War couldn’t be death, if there weren’t a plethora of causalities. This shows how death is physical. While the quote is quite literary, the implicit meaning is that there were thousands of people dying, and that there were many bodies that had to be carried to safe territory, to the hospital and ultimately to their graves. O’Brian implements the theme of death to quantify the number of those who suffered and have their lives in the Vietnam war.

Read More
559 Words | 3 Pages

In the opening year of the Peloponnesian War, 431 B.C.E., Pericles delivered, and according to Plato may not have written, a speech praising Athenian democracy while also remembering all the Soldiers that had died in the service of Athens. He took the opportunity to reinforce the Athenian constitution and to let people know that the deaths of their Soldiers was justified to uphold the democracy. Pericles cites that when Athens goes to war it goes alone. He goes onto to say that when other countries go to war against Athens that they must bring their “confederates” (Funeral Oration of Pericles) with them if they are to stand a chance at victory.

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

The Funeral Oration of Pericles: A Primary Text Analysis In Pericles’ Funeral Oration, the famous and influential text in 430 B.C was given by Pericles to traditionally honor the death of the soldiers that fought in war and serviced in the Athenian military. This interpretation of the oration is written by Thucydides, as it is a manuscript of what Pericles said to the Athenian public. Through this text, Pericles focuses on honoring the fallen soldiers, but he also emphases the values of Athenian society and the social structure of the invention of democracy, as it is introduced for the first time ever in history. The Funeral Oration of Pericles expresses the distinct values of strong moral standards for social structure and introduces democracy, as it reinforces laws and the need for equal justice.

Read More
217 Words | 1 Pages

In the play of Oedipus the King, the author demonstrates tone and diction by representing elements and rhetorical strategies that enhance the audience's imagination. Each of the characters from this play have concerns towards the knowledge they know. The first characters which are Oedipus and the priest seem to be at peace with each other.

Read More
1081 Words | 5 Pages

Thucydides was sometimes inviting challenge and reassessment, a historical rereading of his text in which details and reactions postponed or minimized in his narrative are given a second look and then seen in a new relationship, with a new weighting. Certainly he knew that his treatment of almost every major Athenian figure Pericles, Cleon, Demosthenes, Nicias,

Read More
232 Words | 1 Pages

Over this time, an approximated 15,000 people were killed due to the plague, and Shakespeare emphasizes the relevance of the plague for his audience by using it in ‘Romeo and Juliet’ to prevent Friar Laurence's message from reaching Romeo in Mantua. So as we can

Read More
970 Words | 4 Pages

The illusion of death has wondered and astonished many for years. This doesn 't exclude the fantastic author Shakespeare. Throughout the play, Shakespeare focuses on death and how society glorifies it. He often uses metaphor and analogy in order to make death seem more welcoming. Turmoil and confusion can internally destroy any country.

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

Several characters in ancient literature were willing to risk their life for some cause or goal. Through this essay we will be taking an inside on the work of Homer in the Iliad and Sophocles in Antigone to look for evidence of what ancient Greeks though it was worth dying for during this time. During Ancient Greek literature times they had a different perspective of what we would think were reasonable causes for dying. One of the mains purpose of the Greeks is the fame that comes after death. Theses two books show us exactly what were the most essentials ideas of what they considered was worth dying for.

Read More
859 Words | 4 Pages

In his Eulogy delivered before the Athenians in 431 BCE during the Great Peloponnesian war, Pericles states, “We alone do good to our neighbors not upon a calculation of interest, but in the confidence of freedom and in a frank and fearless spirit.” In this quote, Pericles is communicating the idea that Athenians perform good deeds and help other polies not to benefit from it but for the sake of democracy and chivalry. The Eulogy of Pericles is accurate to a minimal extent because, while on the one hand the Athenians offered protection to their allies, on the other hand they took advantage of them and attacked mercilessly. The idea of chivalry stated in the Eulogy of Pericles should be considered an accurate reflection of Ancient Athens because the Delian league was created in order

Read More
1017 Words | 5 Pages

The soldier hates the war, he says “I died in hell”, this implies that the honorable death that the young men believed in, was actually an inglorious death for an empty cause. All the soldiers received in return for their lives was a gilded name on a memorial tablet, where people probably wont even see it. He felt that the squire didn 't appreciate how much he risked for his country, for the people he loved, for the squire himself, "Two bleeding years I fought in France, for Squire: I suffered anguish that he 's never guessed". The words ‘suffered’ and ‘anguish ' shows the soldiers’ emotional feeling towards the war, it shows how angry and sad he feels about what is happening and that he has been through a lot.

Read More

More about Thucydides 'Placement Of Perikles' Funeral Oration

Related Topics

Open Document