ipl-logo

'To Be': A Comparison Of Hamlet And Simba's Journey

986 Words4 Pages

Revenge and the Question of ‘To Be Or Not To Be’: A Comparison of Hamlet and Simba’s Journey

The classic tragedies of Shakespeare's Hamlet and Disney's The Lion King share many similarities, from themes and character archetypes to the famous phrase “to be or not to be.” In this essay, it will compare and contrast the themes of Hamlet and The Lion King, analyze their character archetypes, and explore the meaning behind the quote “to be or not to be” in both works. The comparison of Shakespeare's Hamlet and Disney's The Lion King reveals the enduring relevance of the themes of power, revenge, and identity in human nature. This is in addition to the universal appeal of character archetypes, such as the tragic hero and the wise fool. By analyzing …show more content…

In Hamlet, the protagonist is motivated to avenge his father's death, while in The Lion King, Simba is driven to reclaim his rightful place as king. Both works feature protagonists who must face their enemies and overcome obstacles in order to restore order. However, the contexts of these two works differ significantly. Hamlet is set in a monarchy with a rigid class structure, while The Lion King is set in a world of animals. These differences create distinct themes and messages in each work. Hamlet's story is one of revenge, while The Lion King is a tale of coming of age and redemption. Moreover, the two stories have different endings. In Hamlet, Hamlet dies in the end, while in The Lion King, Simba is able to reclaim his throne and restore order to the kingdom. While both works explore the theme of revenge, they do so in distinct contexts and with different outcomes. As McElveen and Rohlfs (1998) note, “The themes of revenge and justice are explored in both Hamlet and The Lion King, but they are presented in different ways.” Thus, while both works have a shared theme, they differ in terms of context, characters, and ultimately, their …show more content…

The author explores how character archetypes are used in both stories. The author discusses the differences between the two works. He notes that while both stories use archetypal characters, the archetypes in The Lion King are more simplified than those in Hamlet. This is because the former uses a more straightforward narrative structure. For example, the protagonist in The Lion King, Simba, is characterized as a young, naive lion cub who must learn to take responsibility for his actions and rise to the challenge of ruling his kingdom. On the other hand, Hamlet's characters are more complex. For example, Hamlet is a complex, multi-faceted character who is torn between his duty to avenge his father's death and his own morality. The author argues that this complexity makes the story more engaging and thought-provoking. This archetype is in stark contrast to Hamlet's protagonist, who is much more complex and must navigate a web of conflicting loyalties, doubts, and emotions as he seeks to avenge his father's death. Additionally, the antagonist in The Lion King is Scar, who is portrayed as an evil and conniving lion who seeks to take the throne for himself. This archetype stands in contrast to the antagonists in Hamlet, who are much more nuanced and represent a variety of different motivations, ranging from political ambition to

Show More
Related
565 Words | 3 Pages

Hamlet and Simba: One and the Same, or the Complete Opposite? Hamlet, the renowned play written by William Shakespeare, tells the story of a boy who loses his father and faces hardship triggered by his uncle during the time of mourning. The Lion King, the famous Disney book, movie, and play, tells the same story in a different setting with different characters. Although Hamlet and Simba share many similarities, such as their relationships with their fathers and being exiled by their devious uncles, they also have differences in relation to their interactions with other characters in their stories. Hamlet and Simba share a similar relationship with their fathers.

Read More
608 Words | 3 Pages

The Lion King adapts the story of Hamlet to reach its audience by showing Nala and Simba’s relationship way more healthy and how the characters are seen as animals in the Lion king.

Read More
527 Words | 3 Pages

Both are born into royal families. Since Mufasa was the father of Simba and the king of the lions, that made Simba the prince. Hamlet was the son of Old Hamlet, the tragically murdered king. In both stories the uncle characters were very similar. In Lion King, Scar kills his brother to get what he wants.

Read More
839 Words | 4 Pages

In more ways than one the world of Disney has somewhat interacted in the world of Shakespeare. Hamlet and The Lion King ,all though years apart in the making, have been drafted to be almost similar with little to no differences. They are similar in the ways of the plot and the moral background, but different as far as the ending transition of Hamlet and Simba are combined. The plot of Hamlet and The Lion King alike are about an Uncle to the King, or a heir next in line to the throne trying to gain power. Thus including some of the main characters being the King, the Queen, the King and Queen’s son, the son’s first love, his first loves’ father, two of the son’s instigating friends, and of course the son’s one and only true friend.

Read More
789 Words | 4 Pages

Disney’s Happily Ever After Meets William Shakespeare’s Tragedy Two completely different kingdoms about two completely different types of species can be more in common than someone would think. Character is a suicidal, depressed Prince of Denmark and the other a singing, animated young prince of the jungle. How does William Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet relate to the Disney movie, The Lion King? Although Simba, the main character in The Lion King has an ending that is more compatible with its juvenile audience, and Hamlet’s ending would put a Greek trinity to shame.

Read More
677 Words | 3 Pages

First, pop culture shows us how much of an effect Hamlet has had on Western culture. One example of Hamlet being referenced in pop culture is Disney’s The Lion King. The plot of The Lion King is very similar to the plot of Hamlet. In Hamlet, the play starts with Hamlet’s father being killed by his uncle Claudius. In The Lion King, Simba’s dad, Mufasa, is killed by his uncle Scar.

Read More
649 Words | 3 Pages

Hamlet and Lion King Hamlet and the movie Lion King have many similarities. They are composed of the same storyline and have many of the same symbolisms. They both are about a royal family and the betrayal of the King 's death by their brother. It also holds in common the son and how he seeks revenge upon his father’s death. In comparing Hamlet and Lion King there are many differences too.

Read More
567 Words | 3 Pages

Hamlet is a powerful story of love, life, revenge, and death. The themes within the play are written to live on for eternity. It is difficult to fully and accurately represent a play as great as this one. The movie that we watched in class did not wholly represent the wonders and the magnitude of the themes within Shakespeare’s work.

Read More
1940 Words | 8 Pages

Hamlet Character deception is a common characteristic that has and will be a reflecting characteristic in literature for centuries. In many of William Shakespeare’s tragedies, deception, whether positive or negative, is being used to mislead, to protect characters, or to hide a crime or future crime. Analyzing why the characters are using deception against each other is very important to the reader’s understanding of the work as a whole. In William Shakespeare’s Hamlet, He uses Hamlet’s deception of character and also the character’s use of deception towards Hamlet to carry out the overall theme of the tragedy. The theme that is represented, is that in able to get malicious revenge, you must be able to act as if you are someone different than your true self while in turn, being able to deal with others deceiving you.

Read More
390 Words | 2 Pages

Compare and Contrast Lion King and Hamlet After reading the book hamlet and watching the movie Lion King I discovered there were many similarities and differences. Both come from royalty and both fathers are killed by thier uncles that reaper as ghost with helpful advice, although in hamlet the uncle gets the Queen in lion king the uncle does not, hamlet is a tragedy but lion king was a happy ending. First off. Hamlet is the prince of denmark and the son of the tragically murdered King Hamlet. Simba is the son of Mufasa the king of the lions.

Read More
1170 Words | 5 Pages

Hamlet Comparison Essay There are many qualities that make an effective and powerful leader. Some leaders strive for greatness; others strive to make history. Though their goals may differ, all can agree that the most important component of leadership is earning the respect of those who follow you and being responsible with the power you earn. There are many strong leaders in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, though not all are effective.

Read More
1844 Words | 8 Pages

Hamlet is William Shakespeare 's renowned tale of mystery, intrigue, and murder, centered on a young misguided prince who can only trust himself. Some may say that the actions of Prince Hamlet throughout the play are weak and fearful, displaying a tendency to procrastinate and showing an apathetic nature towards his family and peers. Others spin a tale of a noble young scholar, driven mad by the cold-blooded murder of his father by his uncle. In truth, I believe Hamlet is neither of these things. Hamlet is a sort of amalgamation of the two, a bundle of contradictions thrown together into one conflicting but very human mess of a character.

Read More
880 Words | 4 Pages

Through the entirety of the play “Hamlet” by William Shakespeare, the characters were overcome with the need for revenge as the outcome of many deaths. Therefore, no one was happy through “Hamlet” and it resulted in a tragedy. The character Hamlet played a big role in turning towards revenge and never would classify himself as being happy. Hamlet displays positive and negative behavior throughout the play. Hamlet exhibits strengths and weaknesses as well, although his weaknesses of over-thinking, bitterness, and his inability to accept the death of his father overshadow his strengths.

Read More
556 Words | 3 Pages

Majority of the FAF conversation was about fieldwork since that is what has posed the most difficulty for me. I live in Los Angeles, California and the competition is very competitive especially with brick and mortar schools. I have sent my portfolio out to over a dozen locations and most of them had said they are already full and won’t have openings until next year. I was fortunate that I have one community mental health organization contact me and hire me no the spot. I have already been volunteering to get to know the programs they offer.

Read More
685 Words | 3 Pages

Firstly, they compare as they are both tragic heroes. A tragic hero is not a normal hero. A tragic hero is someone that has a flaw that can lead to the destruction of themselves. Hamlet is a tragic hero because he was blinded by his want for revenge of his father 's death. Hamlet pretended to be crazy for so long that he blocked out his true self and the people who cared for him, like Gertrude and Ophelia.

Read More

More about 'To Be': A Comparison Of Hamlet And Simba's Journey

Related Topics

Open Document