Alex Young
Mrs. Moffat
English 5-6
11 January 2023
Was Chris Justified?
Everyone who has read and/or heard about Chris McCandless' story, they would have thought it was a good idea for him to leave his home without telling anyone. Which ended up costing his life. Some may think that he was crazy and had no business leaving his home. They may think that he was idiotic for thinking he would be able to survive in the Alaskan wilderness. While others believe he had a point and purpose in what he was doing. After reading Into the Wild and watching the Return to the Wild documentary, I’ve come to believe that Chris was indeed justified in his actions. For good reasons. He had a traumatizing stage in his childhood that caused him to have hate for
…show more content…
His 2 parents and his younger sister Carine. His father worked for NASA and was a rocket scientist. His mother was an entrepreneur. As Chris was growing up, he grew a deep relationship with his younger sister Carine. They were very close and never left each other's side. Chris had a lot of energy as a child. Not only that, he was smart. As a 4-year-old, he got up in the middle of the night and went inside his neighbors house and retrieved candy where he knew it was located. How unbelievable is that? He would then become an entrepreneur in his senior year of high school. He would go door to door for a kitchen remodeling company. At the same time, he would look back on his family moments and would recognize that when he family spent the least amount of money, those would be the happiest times. Yet, there weren’t always happy times. It was the exact opposite. Chris’s parents would fight each other. Their mother would have them see it in front of their eyes and say, “Look what your father is doing to me!” As young children, that is very traumatizing to witness. For anyone it would be. They would see their father hurt their mother and couldn’t do much about it. What you can take from Chris leaving unexpectedly is he may have felt guilt as a young child. That he couldn’t protect his mother from his abusive father. Even though Chris was a young child, he felt the responsibilities of an adult. He was …show more content…
Chris had more reason to leave unexpectedly with no trace of finding him. He was connected to the wild. Although Chris’s parents were abusive towards each other and made Chris’s childhood traumatizing, he had wholesome moments. He and his family would go on camping trips in nature. It’s funny that Chris has wrath towards his parents for the traumatizing childhood yet his parents were the ones who introduced the wild to him. Which is the most precious thing to him. Chris had a deep love for the qualities and feelings of nature. For him, it was the true meaning of life and where he could have true happiness. Chris also had a desire to share his perspective of nature with people he met. In the book Into The Wild on page 57, he wrote a whole essay-like letter to his friend Ronald Franz, also known as Ron. Chris had interesting things to express to Ron about what he knew was the way of life. At one point, he said, “The joy of life comes from our encounters with new experiences, and hence there is no greater joy than to have an endlessly changing horizon, for each day to have a new and different sun.” What he was explaining to Ron was happiness found in different types of experiences. He explained to Ron that enduring through new experiences would make him happy. He went on to say that he would enjoy his life by continuing to change his experiences to use the best of his life. Of course, this is all of
With the circumstances considered , Chris McCandless was justified in leaving his family without heads up because he simply wanted to be happy. The first reason he was justified in his decision was that he should make his own choices and do what he enjoys doing. Chris had a passion for wilderness and nature, he loved spending time outdoors alone, and he liked to travel. On page 33 Chris wrote a letter to a guy named Wayne Westerberg saying; “The freedom and simple beauty of it is just too good to pass up”.
He liked having a challenge and was why he decided to start his journey towards Alaska with nothing but a backpack. In the documentary, Chris’s sisters say how their parents used to take them out into the wilderness, like going hiking, and they explained how they always felt more at peace because there was less fighting going on between their parents. I think Chris grew a relationship with the wilderness because it was his safe space, a space where he knew things were going to be okay. The novel says, “Chris was fearless even when he was little. He didn’t believe the odds applied to him.
I think he just saw it has an opening and once he finally understood and saw the opening he used that as a justifiable persecution on leaving. Chris father kinda manipulated in a way since he wanted Chris to be a successful student and person, but inside he was was an abusive father, so that’s quite justified. I believe and understand another reason why he isolated himself was that he wanted to find himself and figure out what could make him happy. I think it was a time and opportunity to go out and figure out who he is as a person, and he figured that he was more happier in the wild and in the open nature with no
However, his parents would often fight and his father was abusive and seceretive. Chris also had a love for nature, and thought that if he emersed himself in it he would find the meaning to life or discover more about himself.
Chris believed that life with everyone slaving away wasn’t a good thing. He even tried to get others to follow this way of thinking. In a letter to Ron, Chris tried convincing him to do what he did and live a full life of adventure. “The joy of life comes from our encounters and new experiences, and hence there is no greater joy than to have an endlessly changing horizon, for each day having a different sun” (56). Chris believed no one should just waste their lives and should live to the fullest.
But with his mothers affair and his two life living and abusive father it would make sense how he could go without talking to them for so long. So he should 80% be justified for not telling his parents that he went out to the wild without telling them so. Chris McCanless’s life was far from normal he had complicated parents, meaning his father was living 2 lives. Because he had a different family before Chris was born but he didn't tell Chris's mother or his sons or daughter, and with his father being abusive both verbally and physically. Then on top of that with his mother having an affair it made Chris upset and he really cut off talking to them, it tells us this on page 103 and 121.
He wanted to live a life of simplicity and to be free from the materialism that he saw as corrupting society. However, his actions could also be viewed as selfish and immature. He left his family without warning or explanation and did not think about the impact it would have on them u realize this on page 37 when he gives his entry about living life to the fullest Chris's actions were also dangerous and reckless. He had no experience or training for living in the wilderness, and he put himself in a dangerous situation without any means of communication or assistance. It could be argued that his decision to leave his family was not only selfish but also stupid Now, there are still plenty of angles to look at this situation.
The book states, “Children can be harsh judges when it comes to their parents, disinclined to grant clemency and this was especially true in Chris’s case. More even than most teens, he tended to see things in black and white” (Krakauer 122). Although Chris seemed like the forgiving type, he always held a grudge against his father, which is understandable. Regarding his father’s actions, he left his mother and siblings behind with no hesitation about how they would feel or react. As a result, Chris was selfish and self-centered for leaving behind his family and his hard-earned scholarships and donations to charity.
The first reason Chris Mcandless was justified in his decision to leave is all the trauma he had growing up. Chris lived in an abusive home while he was growing up. His dad Walt was very abusive to Billie, who was Chris’s mother. According to his
Chris (Alex) McCandless was born into a fortunate family, financially speaking; the McCandless parents cared tremendously for how their children’s future were going to turn out. All they wanted for their kids was for them to have great jobs, become wealthy and successful for themselves. What these parents see as attentiveness, the children see it as headstrong and abusing their power. Which is what Chris McCandless sees throughout his life growing up in that atmosphere. This frustration causes Chris to blow up and cut all connections with his family and then proceeds to run away from home.
He also had a soft spot for his mother even though their relationship was complicated. He always found an escape and his main one for awhile was running. Eventually, Chris decided that he needed a longer distance and to leave his family. So, his next big goal was to hitchike to Alaska. “Chris was long gone.
One big reason Chris wasn’t justified is he caused his relationship with all his loved ones to fall apart and hardly ever spoke to his family because they wouldn’t understand and Chris probably felt as if they’d try and stop him from an adventure. In talking with Jim Gallien, Chris told him “he hadn’t spoken with his family in nearly two years.” (pg 6). This shows that Chris doesn’t value his relationships because the amount of time he's away and lost contact doesn’t phase him.
But his mom would talk to teacher and make sure Chris got the grade he thought he should have earned. Another example was when Billie and Walt McCandless offered to pay for Chris’s law school. Highly offended, Chris declines the offer. I believe Chris was searching for something and thought
Chris was solely focused on making it to Alaska, caring about the relationships he made, but not being unable to throw them away. We see this again in the character of Tracy. Chris almost goes out of his way to make a personal connection with Tracy, just before leaving again. A consequence of Chris’s hyperfocus on his wants and goals is that he misses the good that is around him, which is finally seen in the character of Ron Franz. Both Franz and Chris learned a lot from each other throughout the time they spent together.
One reason Chris left that I agree with is because he had an abusive home. He would always hear his mom scream because she was being abused by his dad. He couldn't deal with it anymore so he left without anyone knowing where he went. Another reason he left was because he is a grown man and doesn't want to live at home anymore.