ipl-logo

Twelfth Night And Fickman's Changing Contexts

1111 Words5 Pages

Central ideas across time periods can be reimagined to better fit modern contexts, allowing contemporary audiences to form a more relevant and deeper connection to past literature. Shakespeare’s comedic play ‘Twelfth Night’ (1602) and Fickman’s film ‘She’s the Man’ (2006) have shown how changing contexts allow for differing representations of ideas such as love, gender and disguise, posing more relevant in modern contexts. Shakespeare’s and Fickman’s texts depict how different representations of love and relationship are reimagined from Elizabethan contexts to the modern 21st century, highlighting to audiences how despite a shift in context, human nature remains unchanged. This thus allows audiences to contemplate how shifting contexts can …show more content…

Although it has improved drastically since Shakespeare’s times, there is still partial mindset of gender discrimination here and there, as shown in the adapted version of Twelfth Night Fickman has produced. “Diana’s lip is not more ruby. Thy small pipe is as the maiden’s organ, shrill and sound.” In this quote, Orsino describes how Viola as Cesario, regardless of disguise, looks rather feminine for a man. Comparably, Duke Orsino in ‘She’s the Man’ indirectly challenges Viola’s disguise, without actually knowing the deception he faces in saying “Dude, come on, you're a guy.” Both of these quotes put Viola in a difficult situation, as she cannot deny this statement, nor can she easily accept what Orsino says as she isn’t really a ‘guy’. As both text’s gender topics revolve around the idea of the ideology of men superiority, in ‘Twelfth Night’ Orsino declares “Our fancies are more giddy and unfirm, more longing, wavering, sooner lost and worn, than women’s are.” In this quote, dramatic irony is evident, as Orsino contrarily states that men’s love is more ‘unfirm’ and changes more often than women’s, in which the audience knows Viola’s true identity, parallel with the statement. Opposingly, in ‘She’s the Man’ a coach states, “It’s a scientific fact, girls can’t beat boys! It’s as simple as that.” In the quote, the coach confidently expresses his ideology of men being far superior to women in sport. Fickman’s film adapts to Shakespeare’s ‘Twelfth Night’ with less intense themes, switching from a compelled disguise due to a dangerous environment for females, to a chosen disguise to compete with equal opportunity for men. This adaptation further mitigates the confusion in relating and understanding a Shakespearean play. Fickman modifies ‘Twelfth Night’, and its central ideas to less intensify all aspects to correlate with more modern

Show More
Related
1052 Words | 5 Pages

“[Are his female character similar to the characters in the sources he used; if not how did he adapt them for his plays? Did Elizabeth influence his characters?] ” At the time Shakespeare was composing his plays, ladies were accepted to be mentally, physically and ethically mediocre compared to men. Then again, some of these female characters are astute, witty, courageous and respectable, and a large number of them even request uniformity; they are uncommon ladies.

Read More
1162 Words | 5 Pages

The lines 271-279 of Act 1, Scene 5 are spoken by Viola disguised as 'Cesario ' to the Countess Olivia after being sent by Orsino to "woo" Olivia on his behalf. The dialog is exceedingly significant to the overall plot as it establishes Olivia 's love for 'Cesario ' and an inkling to Cesario 's loyalty and love for Orsino. Viola 's description of what she would do if she loved Olivia as Orsino does attracts Olivia attention and affection. Viola 's lines to Olivia of making "a willow cabin" (1.5.271) at the gate and writing songs of "contemned love" (1.5.273) to sing them "in the dead of night" (1.5.274) conveys an agonizingly desperate love that should be pitied.

Read More
592 Words | 3 Pages

The film she's a man produce by Andy Fickman is based off of Shakespeare's “Twelfth Night”. Throughout the film the author was trying to accomplish one thing and one thing only. He wanted to address to the viewers that women have the same rights as men. Well not just rights more like abilities or capabilities that the female and then male have in common. He accomplished his goal pretty well by using viola the twin sister to Sebastian as an excuse to play on the boys soccer team.

Read More
1697 Words | 7 Pages

The play, Twelfth Night, opens with a shipwrecked Viola landing in Illyria, and is employed in Duke Orsino’s service, disguised as her twin brother. Her occupation is wooing the Countess Olivia in favor of Duke Orsino; however, Olivia falls in love with the disguised Viola, who falls in love with the Duke but cannot express her true feelings. The love triangle evolves and continues to become more complicated when Viola’s thought-to-be dead twin brother Sebastian rolls into town. Traveling with him is Antonio who saved Sebastian in the shipwreck and has fallen deeply in love with him.

Read More
1478 Words | 6 Pages

In William Shakespeare’s the Twelfth Night many characters change from the beginning of the play to the end and one can learn about the character’s behavior through that play. Viola is a great example of this as she grows as a character and has many effects on other characters in the play like Orsino and Olivia, but characters also affect her, like Sir Toby and Olivia, again. Viola shows through this play that she is character who can make mistakes and gain from them and has matured mentally than some of her other peers, but also that she cannot hide her stature in society as shown through her actions and speech, though often, these actions come from her motivation of the death of her brother. Viola, a major character in the Twelfth Night, changes in different ways from Act I to Act V. For example, she stands up to Olivia’s advances more as she goes throughout the play.

Read More
1628 Words | 7 Pages

Sydney Rhoads Introduction to Literature Second poetry paper April 09, 2018 Twelfth Night and She's the Man: Viola's Character and Feelings Comparison Twelfth Night comparing to She’s the Man is very similar to each other. The play compared to She’s the Man has similar character names and similar character traits.

Read More
1551 Words | 7 Pages

It may seem like Shakespeare treats his female characters worse than his male characters, but it is his female characters that drive the plot

Read More
1112 Words | 5 Pages

Viola, Cesario, Olivia, and Duke Orsino together form a comedy with consistently homoerotic undertones that explores the fluidity of gender. Though queer theory is rarely explicit in works such as Shakespeare, it is critical to analyze older texts to gain a clearer picture of queer identity before modern

Read More
713 Words | 3 Pages

Men were seen as masculine and powerful. Shakespeare heavily illustrates the sixteenth century stereotypical gender roles throughout his play, Twelfth Night. During Shakespearean times, women were prohibited from performing on stage, instead, men played their roles. In Twelfth Night, the imitation of the opposite gender originates from necessity and fear. Viola dressed as a man named Cesario to protect herself when she arrives upon foreign land.

Read More
1408 Words | 6 Pages

In today’s world, gender expectations and roles of men and women are a highly debated topic. However, the reconsidering of these expectations is not a new phenomenon. Set in Verona, Italy, the play Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare explores the reversal and fluidity of characteristics usually assigned to a specific gender. In this play, two young people fall in love and end up tragically taking their lives as a result of their forbidden love. Shakespeare suggests that men are not necessarily masculine, women are not necessarily feminine, and that when people are forced by society to act the way their gender is “supposed” to, problems will arise.

Read More
665 Words | 3 Pages

Prior to the 20th century, women have always been perceived as inferior to a man. It was a man’s world, they ruled the family, the workplace, the government and much more. In most modern nations reforms paved the way towards a just and equal society between the genders. This was not the case during the shakespeare’s era, even with a queen in power, all women were objectified. Shakespeare utilizes the play “A Midsummer Night's Dream” to convey the objectificatiffications–rooted from male dominance–that women have to bear, even by people who are supposed to be their biggest supporters.

Read More
1010 Words | 5 Pages

For Shakespeare’s plays to contain enduring ideas, it must illustrate concepts that still remain relevant today, in modern society. Shakespeare utilises his tragic play Othello, to make an important social commentary on the common gender stereotypes. During early modern England, Shakespeare had to comply to the strict social expectations where women were viewed as tools, platonic and mellow, and where men were displayed as masculine, powerful, tempered, violent and manipulative. As distinct as this context is to the 21st century, the play exposes how women were victimised by the men who hold primary power in the community in which they compelled women to conform to the ideal world of a perfect wife or confront an appalling destiny for challenging the system. Moreover, Shakespeare utilises the main antagonist, Iago, to portray how men are desperate to achieve what they want and to indirectly fulfil the stereotype of masculinity and power through manipulation.

Read More
1360 Words | 6 Pages

A Modern View of Feminist Criticism William Shakespeare 's "Othello” can be analyzed from a feminist perspective. This criticism focuses on relationships between genders, like the patterns of thoughts, behavior, values, enfranchisement, and power in relations between and within sexes. A feminist examination of the play enables us to judge the distinctive social esteems and status of women and proposes that the male-female power connections that become an integral factor in scenes of Othello impact its comprehension. I believe that the critical lens that provides modern society with the most compelling view of literature is Feminist Criticism because it analyzes distrust and disloyalty among relationships, women being treated as possessions

Read More
1851 Words | 8 Pages

In Twelfth Night, Viola and Olivia are the central characters to the play’s plot. Each are young women that take approaches to dealing with the people around them, which are mainly men. There is much trickery that goes on in Twelfth Night, but the ending is for the most part happy. Viola marries Orsino and Olivia marries Sebastian, but the events leading up to this are more or less chaotic. Ultimately, I argue that while Olivia uses her higher social status in order to maintain control of herself and others, Viola resorts to trickery in order to bring about her desires.

Read More
1043 Words | 5 Pages

In the play Twelfth Night, through the depiction of Orsino’s and Viola’s desires for romantic love, Shakespeare portrays how adjustable and self-delusional human romantic attraction can be, especially when blinded by wants and needs. Viola, who puts on the appearance of a man, makes everybody think she is a male. Her disguise becomes a sexual confusion throughout the play for several characters, creating an odd love triangle where Viola loves Duke Orsino, who loves Oliva, which then on the other hand loves Viola, in disguise as Cesario. On the other hand, Malvolio dreams of marrying his beloved Olivia, and gaining authority over his superiors, like Sir Toby. Shakespeare uses disguise in the play to show several confusions and internal conflicts between the characters, proving how malleable and deluded some human attractions can be.

Read More

More about Twelfth Night And Fickman's Changing Contexts

Open Document