ipl-logo

Codified Constitution Analysis

1521 Words7 Pages

The United Kingdom is one of three states that are said to not have a codified constitution, with no single document defining the fundamental principles upon which the country operates. It is instead composed of Acts of Parliament that have been deemed ‘constitutional statutes’ , judgements of the court, various constitutional conventions that are largely political in nature, influential academic writings, particular international treaties (i.e the European Union) and royal prerogative.

Anthony King summarily defines the relationship between a country’s constitution and the codified document often termed ‘The Constitution’. The full constitution of any country is rarely, if ever, defined in a single prevailing document (what King terms the …show more content…

They both operate on a similar party system, with the leader of the relevant party becoming the head of the government. Large parts of these electoral processes are completely unconfirmed by statute or document, existing only as political conventions – such as the office of Prime Minister, or the ‘primaries’ held in the US for the purposes of determining party leaders.

King’s commentary on the overstatement of a capital-C Constitution’s importance to the United Kingdom is, therefore, a valid one. When the function, purpose and substance of a codified and uncodified constitution are the same, with differences arising only when it pertains to the execution and maintenance of the constitution, there can be said to be no great issue with the United Kingdom’s uncodified constitution as compared to that of a codified one. The rights and powers established within the differing systems are fundamentally the same, and thus the argument becomes one of constitutional implementation.

Therefore, the question arises of whether or not the United Kingdom should pursue constitutional reform in the form of codifying our existing …show more content…

The rights of the people may be enumerated in peace time and withdrawn in times of conflict, providing a greater degree of governmental control over the country. This is all a result of the uncodified constitution, and by extension, parliamentary sovereignty.

However, the lack of a codified constitution and the resulting dearth of constitutional supremacy have problems of their own. Albert Dicey’s writings on parliamentary sovereignty encapsulate some of the greatest issues with the uncodified nature of the constitution. Dicey reduced the issue of parliamentary sovereignty to three primary principles , each of which demonstrate the potential for constitutional crisis and instability in the United Kingdom.

The first principle states that ‘Parliament is the supreme law making body and may enact any laws on any subject matter’. In theory, this means that there are no substantive legal limits regarding what Parliament may or may not legislate about, with only democracy acting as a foil for this power, effectively enabling Parliament to create any law no matter how absurd, impractical or unjust. As Sir Leslie Stephen said , ‘If a legislature decided that all blue-eyed babies should be murdered, the preservation of blue-eyed babies would be

Show More
Related
1159 Words | 5 Pages

DBQ Essay The United States Constitution is a document that or founding fathers made in order to replace the failing Articles of Confederation (A of C). Under the Constitution, the current government and states don’t have the problems they faced when the A of C was in action. The Constitution was created in 1788, and held an idea that the whole nation was nervous about. This idea was a strong national government, and the Federalist assured the people that this new government would work. The framers of the Constitution decided to give more power to the Federal government rather than the state governments because the A of C had many problems, there was a need for the layout of new government, rights, and laws, and there was a need for the Federal

Read More
506 Words | 3 Pages

Written in 1787 and established in 1788, The Constitution is one of the most famous government systems in the world, laying down the foundation for the world we know today. It’s predecessor, the Articles of Confederation, was not nearly as long-lasting, being scrapped after just 10 years. However, both documents had a similar idea: giving power to the people and preventing the rise of a king. One huge difference is that the Constitution established a much stronger government than the Articles of Confederation. With the Articles, there was almost no government, leading to big problems.

Read More
790 Words | 4 Pages

From the failure of the Articles, should the new government, the Constitution, be approved? In 1788, the Constitution was created as the Articles of Confederation wasn’t successful and strong enough for their new government. During that time, a debate went throughout America about the Constitution whether to ratify it or not. Yes, the Constitution should be ratified because a Bill of Rights was promised, no one overpowered (in the government; checks and balances), and it is fair to both citizens and officials. Starting off, a bill of rights was promised which would ensure many things for the citizens.

Read More
521 Words | 3 Pages

The two constitution I am gonna compare are the United States of America constitution, and the Canadian constitution. Like the U.S constitution, the Canadian constitution is mostly the same since it got many of its laws from the U.S constitution. Both constitution have many provinces that they are divided into since the place is too big, as well as to divide power, as well as that they both have an executive power since they need someway to be able to divide the power. Unlike the U.S, Canada has a Queen that controls the executive government. Canada has its own version of the Bill Of Rights called Charter of Rights and Freedoms in the end of its constitution.

Read More
831 Words | 4 Pages

Created in 1789, the Constitution was the final piece in making the United States official. Starting off with the famous “We the people”, this document protects citizens’ rights, gives the branches of government their power, and is used as a reference when creating laws. The first technical constitution of the United States was the Articles of Confederation, which was lacking in many areas and was defective. The Constitution we have now focuses on the rights of the individual, and is referred to quite often to determine if an act is constitutional or not; however, it didn’t start off that way.

Read More
523 Words | 3 Pages

The United States Constitution is a vital part of the country’s government and society. The Constitution was written in June of 1788, and it would become the center of a country. The Constitution insures the rights of all Americans, from birth to death. It also insures a strict set of rules-which can ensure justice is perused, and laws are made. The Constitution wasn’t always the center of the United States government however.

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

Texas Constitution V. Maine Constitution What is a constitution? According to Merriam Webster Dictionary a constitution is a document that describes the system of beliefs and laws by which a country, state or organization is governed. In numerous ways, the Texas and Maine constitution are similar documents.

Read More
647 Words | 3 Pages

The US Constitution is a document based on the US Federal government’s law and it presents legal checks and balance for the branches of government. The reasoning behind this system was to give an in depth set of values and guidelines for the American people. It is separated into three parts: The Articles, the Bill of Rights, and the changes and additions. The initial three articles are written to establish the responsibilities, powers, and balance each branch the federal government has.

Read More
494 Words | 2 Pages

The new constitution, a document granting the framework for a new democratic government, replacing the Articles of the Confederation. This new document gained approval from some of the citizens, but also raised questions and concerns from others. There was a constant back and forth between the two groups on whether or not the constitution should be ratified. This editorial provides historical background on the issue and expresses my opinion on which side I would’ve chosen.

Read More
946 Words | 4 Pages

The European Union (EU) is an international organisation which originates from the European Economic Community and consists of twenty-eight member states. The United Kingdom (UK) became part of the European Community (now EU) in 1973 and this essay explains how and why this decision impacted on the UK, mostly focusing on how it influenced Parliamentary sovereignty, how the Single Market impacted on economy and trade, and the importance of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). European sources of law are divided into two components, primary and secondary. Primary sources are predominately treaties, such as the Treaty of Rome (ToR), the Treaty on European Union (TEU) and the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU). Secondary sources include regulations and directives.

Read More
171 Words | 1 Pages

The Constitution makes the system by giving the essential political and lawful structure that issues the principles by which a legislature works. It additionally designates the forces to the different branches of government which thusly, structures the legislature and in this way restricting the energy of any branch through the balanced governance framework. Of the three branches of government, (Legislative, Executive, and Judicial), the official is the most complex influencing the other two to appear to be moderately irrelevant when thought about. For instance, the official branch which is going by the president, contains the parts that serves to actualize national arrangements built up by both protected and authoritative means. Inside the

Read More
651 Words | 3 Pages

There are many arguments for having a codified constitution, or keeping our unwritten one. Since 1997, many constitutional reforms have been made. The difference between an uncodified and codified is that in an uncodified constitution, it is not confined to one document, but in a variety. In Britain, our constitution comes from a range of sources including common and statute law, treaties, conventions and historical documents such as the Magna Carta. However, a codified, or written, constitution is found in one document.

Read More
617 Words | 3 Pages

As United Kingdom is one of the member of the European Union, European legislation creates the English law, and it has the power to create rules and regulations which apply in its member states. Sources of the European Union law include Primary Sources (Treaties), Secondary Sources, Directives, Decisions and Recommendations and Opinions (Cited in lecture notes, 2017). One example is that the Human Rights Act incorporates the main provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights into UK law. Besides, the European Communities Act 1972 provided that Community law should be directly in the UK courts (Macintyre E, 2014, p28). If the English law is in conflict with European legislation, held that “the power of the UK courts to suspend conflicting

Read More
1128 Words | 5 Pages

Introduction: John Stuart Mill essay on Consideration On representative Government, is an argument for representative government. The ideal form of government in Mill's opinion. One of the more notable ideas Mill is that the business of government representatives is not to make legislation. Instead Mill suggests that representative bodies such as parliaments and senates are best suited to be places of public debate on the various opinions held by the population and to act as watchdogs of the professionals who create and administer laws and policy.

Read More
1538 Words | 7 Pages

First, the words and the framing of the document are deliberatively vague, and secondly, the notion of the constitution as a ‘living tree’ has created tremendous progress for the country. Therefore,

Read More

More about Codified Constitution Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document