ipl-logo

Vandiver's Argumentative Essay

954 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Military strategies of the civil war

In the article There was no Offensive-Defensive Confederate Strategy Donald Stroker wanted to prove that Vandiver, a celebrated historian and professor was wrong about the strategy used in the Confederacy during the civil war. Stroker brought up points such as “The biggest problem is Vandiver’s first words: “His strategy was the offensive-defensive.” At no point does Vandiver present any evidence that Davis ever decided to prosecute such a strategy.” (Stroker, pg. 8) Stroker had jumped from explaining how the offensive-defensive could have possibly been a strategy in the Confederacy, to proving how it was not an option, and how there was no evidence to show that it was an option. The article Guerrilla Warfare, Democracy, and the Fate of the …show more content…

3) Sutherland stayed on the same topic of guerrilla warfare for the majority of the article, and when he did change topics to democracy or the fate of the Confederacy he transitioned smoothly and did not make any extreme jumps in topics. Daniel Sutherland wrote Guerrilla Warfare, Democracy, and the Fate of the Confederacy using more evidence, explanations, and more effective structuring to prove his points more thoroughly than Donald Stroker had used as he had tried to prove Vandiver wrong in his article There was no Offensive-Defensive Confederate Strategy even though Stroker had brought up some very well thought out, and well written points of evidence which proved that he was correct in his belief in the Confederate …show more content…

Throughout the article it is repeated many times that there is a difference between tactical military action, and strategy, which is why Vandiver had stated that the Confederacy had used the offensive-defensive strategy. “Not understanding the difference, Vandiver took Davis’s tactical reference and then stretched it to cover the strategic realm. Moreover, Vandiver noted that Davis used this term in reference to the Seven Days contest, reinforcing the point that Davis referred to tactical military action on the part of the Confederacy, not strategic.” (Stroker, pg. 6) In the article Stroker did say that the Confederacy did practice a small section of the Offensive-Defensive spectrum in Richmond in the summer of 1812, for the sat and waited so that they could later counterattack (Stroker, pg. 7), but what I gathered from the article, this was the only time that this strategy was used, so it can not be really considered a Confederate strategy. Vandiver had stated that the offensive-defensive strategy would fit extremely well to the southern conditions at the time with their many shortages, and few advantages that the Confederacy had (Vandiver, 44), but Stroker had disagreed with almost everything that Vandiver had said, and replied by saying that there

Show More
Related
739 Words | 3 Pages

Using a series of different sources he created a historical narrative of two vital events in United State’s history. In the book, Lason notifies the audience that, “However strange or macabre some of the following incidents may seem, this is not a work of fiction. Anything between quotation marks comes from a letter, memoir, or other written document.(XI)” Just a few of these sources are the Olmsted Papers, Burnham Archives, and the Chicago Tribune. Larson’s reasons for creating this book are to show two very different people, one who created, and one who destroyed.

Read More
854 Words | 4 Pages

Confederate General Joseph E. Johnston removed his army from Manassas to Culpeper, a move defensible area. When Union troops inspected the area the enemy held “Confederate works revealed that the enemy’s defenses had been far weaker than McClellan had claimed”(The Civil War Trust). Lincoln knew McClellan had overestimated the Confederate army, McClellan was most likely afraid that Johnston had a very well thought out defense strategy. Therefore, to save the lives of his troops he held back instead of attacking. Though McClellan was tricked by Johnston, he continued his march to the Confederate capital.

Read More
212 Words | 1 Pages

Due to high causality figures and with constant confrontation, Sherman come to a decision to broaden the weight and Emotional distress of the war further than rebel soldiers and to include the civilian advocators Particularly, the common People in general of the Confederacy who filled the ranks of the confederacy. Sherman considered that forcing civilian to feel what he called the “hard hand of war” was a military essential. Making the war ruthless and remorseless would bring victory more swiftly and with a minimum loss of life. He considered that by doing this Confederate morale would be weakened and irregular armed force that were fighting the union forces by sabotage and stalking would withdraw. This would disseminate the message that

Read More
776 Words | 4 Pages

Longstreet told Lee not to invade but Lee thought that if the invasion worked the Confederates would be victorious. So Lee told his men to invade the Union and the Union stood their ground and stopped the Confederates

Read More
187 Words | 1 Pages

John Colter and Tom Murphy, where two men who had the same dream. The dream of exploring Yellowstone park. Yellowstone park is in Wyoming Both men had packs Johns weighing thirty pounds and Toms weighing around 70/80 pounds with every thing he need to live including... food, A portable stove, camera gear, down jacket, huge warm mittens, a small emergency kit, a headlamp, two water bottles, and a three pound sleeping bag, john on the other hand had a thirty pound pack, some ammunition and his gun John Colter's shelter was much different from Tom Murphy's . For John Colter's shelter he had a trading fort. Tom Murphy however had only a tarp tied onto a stick frame with rope.

Read More
1091 Words | 5 Pages

McPherson discusses how he found countless of confederate soldier’s letters filled with phrases like “the holy cause of southern freedom, duty to one’s country and death before Yankee

Read More
540 Words | 3 Pages

“ many Northern voters shifted their attention to such national concerns as the Panic of 1873 and corruption in Grant’s administration… Although political violence continued in the South… the tide of public opinion in the North began to turn against Reconstruction policies.”. Because of the economic depression of 1873 and corruption in the Grant Administration, Reconstruction policies became less

Read More
1297 Words | 6 Pages

After continually losing to the rebel Confederates, Sherman learned that the only way to demolish the opponent was to target matters beyond the battlefield. This included resources keeping the rebels alive, the land they fought to protect, and the people they loved. These tactics of war and demolition were known as “extreme or modern warfare strategies” and had been used in wars before. Sherman openly conveyed his total warfare ideals to the public, and his concepts were turned down immediately. His fellow Union soldiers thought he was insane and put him on leave from the Union army.

Read More
493 Words | 2 Pages

Under those circumstances, the Union blockade was a portion of a tremendous strategy known as the Anaconda Plan. This was another plan to to limit supplies for the South. The Union General Winfield Scott was determined to constrict the

Read More
636 Words | 3 Pages

Lincoln thought that the beginning of reconstruction would help speed the war effort and bring it to a close sooner. Wade and Davis would have preferred to delay and wait for the war to end and for the South to be completely beaten with pre-secession institutions gone and needing to be rebuilt. There were a number of concepts that both Lincoln’s 10 percent plan and the Wade-Davis bill had in common. In 1863, with Union victory apparently on the horizon Lincoln “announces a policy for the reconstruction of recanting Confederates”, “Whereas it is now desired by some persons heretofore engaged in said rebellion to resume their

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

Lee was so fearless he determined to invade the North reiteratively. Robert E. Lee strategy was to drift the fighting away from Virginia and into the Union Territory. He wanted to move the fighting, because the Confederate were under siege in Virginia. Lee hoped to gain recognition from Britain and France for the Confederacy. Joesph Hooker,the Union commander, was exposed to the worst defeat of the Army of Potomac in the Battle of Chancellorsville.

Read More
740 Words | 3 Pages

  They could even have a plan of all the strategies in a battle to prepare themselves on how they attack the other side.   In the Civil War, the north had done all of these tactics to defeat the South.   They had some setbacks during some battles, but ended up pulling through and winning.   The North won the war by having a larger army than the South, by being the more prepared with their supplies, and by utilizing the Anaconda plan.

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

Lincoln was on the side of the fence leaning towards lenient punishment against the defeated confederate side. He was under the impression that a more lenient punishment would lead to a quicker recovery of the Union as a whole, which was believed to be his main goal. There were radical members of the Republican party, led by Thaddeus Stevens and Charles

Read More
1354 Words | 6 Pages

It took just forty five days for United States citizens to acquiesce their rights to freedom and privacy for the sake of safety following the events of September 11, 2001. Forty five days is how long it took the United States Congress to pass a law that gave up the very concept of liberty upon which this country is founded. The morning sky was a brilliant shade of blue with not a cloud in sight in New York on that fateful day of September. That all changed at 8:45 AM when a Boeing 767 jet plane tore into the north tower of the World Trade Center. Eighteen minutes later, a second Boeing 767 bit into the sixtieth floor of the south tower.

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

Reconstruction and the Myth of the Lost Cause has been misinterpreted and in some cases, not even taught by most teachers. Reconstruction failures have affected “race relations” throughout the United States. Eric Foner said “ Today’s scholars believe that if the era was “tragic,” it was not because Reconstruction was attempted but because it failed.” Students throughout the United States need to be educated on the importance of Reconstruction and The Myth of the Lost Cause. Also, the Confederate monuments can relate back to the failure of Reconstruction and the Myth of the Lost Cause.

Read More

More about Vandiver's Argumentative Essay

Open Document