ipl-logo

Was Abraham Lincoln Justified Essay

867 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Impact of American civil war on economic social and political

The constitution of the United States is justifiably built just as much for war as it is for peace. This can be seen during 1861, the midst of the Civil War, when Abraham Lincoln was faced with national security challenges that no American president had been confronted with before. Lincoln was put in a position that required him to walk a fine line between civil liberties and national securities. Some argue that Lincoln is one of the top presidents this nation has seen, yet others argue that the action to suspend habeas corpus eradicated him from that pedestal. Since the peak of the Civil War, historians have dissected and debated president Lincoln’s decision. Argued unconstitutional, completely necessary, and everything in between, it is a simple fact that Lincoln was rightly justified as president to push the limits of the constitution when suspending the writ of habeas corpus in order …show more content…

While Lincoln faced the possibility of jeopardizing the capital and risking the fall of the nation, he made the controversial decision to suspend the writ of habeas corpus. Then, on the night of May 25, 1861, troops arrested John Merryman for various acts of treason. Merryman’s lawyer, within days of imprisonment, appealed to Chief Justice Taney for a writ of habeas corpus. Taney “issued the writ, ordering the soldiers to produce him in court and explain the law for the arrest” (Mark E. Neely, Jr.,The Constitution and Civil Liberties Under Lincoln, 38). George Cadwalader refused, relying on Lincoln’s suspension of habeas corpus. Outraged, Taney authored Ex Parte Merryman, leading to the question asked by many; Does congress hold all of the power to suspend habeas corpus, and does the president lack any power to suspend the writ even when there’s a threat to public safety when congress is not in

Show More
Related
1023 Words | 5 Pages

When people think of how government works, unless they’ve taken a government class, they usually think of Congress making laws and the President doing pretty much everything else. No one pays much attention to the Supreme Court unless there is a landmark case or something else to grab the news — like the recent death of Justice Antonin Scalia. But the Supreme Court does much more than you’d think regarding keeping the political machine running like a well-oiled … machine. Through not only interpretation of the law, but also judicial activism, the Supreme Court shows it can have as much influence over the laws of the land as either of the other branches of the federal government. In this paper, I will analyze the decision-making methods of the Court using the cases of Gideon v. Wainwright and Betts v. Brady.

Read More
635 Words | 3 Pages

Dr. Samuel A. Mudd Was Falsely Accused Of His Role In Lincoln’s Murder A little after the confederates surrendered at Appomattox, Lincoln went to see a play at Ford’s theater in Washington. D.C. The only security guard left to get a drink at a nearby bar, while he was gone Booth seized his chance and shot Lincoln In the head. Booth then jumped off onto the stage and broke his left ankle in the process and left.

Read More
362 Words | 2 Pages

In William Brennan’s view on the American Constitution he focused on human dignity to determine his interpretation. As he states in his essay, “But we are an aspiring people, a people with faith in progress. Our amended Constitution is the lodestar for our aspirations. Like every text worth reading, it is not crystalline.” (Brennan).

Read More
644 Words | 3 Pages

Also there is no link to police power so there was not enough evidence or laws in favor of congress. I believe that the supreme made the right decision at first because he shouldn’t even have a gun in the first place. 1 The precedent that Youngstown v. Sawyer created was the Taft Hartley act. The Taft Hartley act gives the power to the president to seize the union.

Read More
933 Words | 4 Pages

Both of these cases go to show that judicial interpretation allows some flexibility into the constitution. It allows things that are not expressly stated in the constitution to be made

Read More
1135 Words | 5 Pages

1. When President Lincoln was elected there were only two significant forts in the South that flew the Union flag. Explain in paragraph form Lincoln’s middle-of-the road solution to bring needed supplies to Fort Sumter in the harbor of Charleston, South Carolina. When President Lincoln was elected, only two significant forts in the South still flew the Union flag. Fort Sumter, in the harbor of Charleston (South Carolina), needed supples in order to support its men.

Read More
113 Words | 1 Pages

Franklin D. Roosevelt deviated substantially from the Declaration of Independence in his State of the Union address by proposing the rights to freedom of speech, establishments of religion, searches without warrants, and convictions without trials. In this he proposed the second bill of rights, which promised positive guarantees for all Americans. He also promised to ensure the “pursuit of happiness” that was promised in the Declaration of Independence. The recurring theme throughout the speech is “security” and the necessary action to call war for the unrelenting war against the enemies of the New Deal both foreign and domestic.

Read More
867 Words | 4 Pages

We can state the obvious, that we are not all perfect, and we certainly say things we don’t mean. Was President Lincoln really a racist? There is documented text that could point evidence that leans in either direction. Things said in the heat of long debates and drawn out conversations that ran for hours, does not make such a monumental man a poor or hypocritical person. Looking at the Constitutional right that “All men are created equal” to the thought that things won’t change without action, and to a man with no moral obligation other than to share his personal option that slavery was wrong, we dive into President Lincoln.

Read More
1230 Words | 5 Pages

On August 2nd, 1964, three North Vietnamese Navy Cruisers were “unprovoked”, and fired on the USS Maddox while it was on a “standard patrol” in the Bay of Tonkin.[1] President Lyndon B Johnson proclaimed this event in a speech that provoked the first attack, ordered by him before war was declared on Vietnam. However, that event was most likely a fake created to increase action in North Vietnam.[2] Does the United States Constitution protect the United States from tyranny of the president over the people’s peace like that? The United States Constitution was written to give strength to the failed Articles of Confederation, and to protect the citizens from tyranny. Sadly, it was written in the 1700s. Tyranny is defined when one group or individual

Read More
559 Words | 3 Pages

Article 1 section 9 of the Constitution states that the privilege of the Habeas Corpus cannot be suspended unless in cases of rebellion invasion in which naturally the public safety is threatened. On the other hand, the article 1 of the Constitution deals with the legislative branch, which may suggest that it is the Congress who gets to decide to suspend the writ. Lincoln agreed to some extent that it is the Congress who was vested with this particular power but he maintain that the Constitution does not specify which branch legislative or executive is to exercise that power. He continues by arguing that it is hardly believable that the framers would live such an emergency power to the Congress who would need time to organize an assembly while it might be too late. Lincoln argued that the executive branch is more equipped to exercise that power due to the fact that the decision can be made much

Read More
529 Words | 3 Pages

The first Amendment declares, “Congress shall make no law… abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press…” However, after the Espionage Act was passed, during World War 1, Schenck was arrested for violating this Act by printing 50,000 leaflets that contradicted the war and the draft. As illustrated, U.S. citizens should be granted the ability to protest wars and drafts since it violates the first Amendment’s right to free speech. The Supreme Court made an invalid choice.

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

During the late 1800s, Abraham Lincoln’s abuse of power during the American Civil War. Despite his abilities to keep America sane and together, some of his most controversial decisions might actually be considered now to be abuses of the Presidential power. During his terms as president, he suspended the Writ of Habeas Corpus, and upheld the Declaration of Independence above the Constitution. The writ of Habeas Corpus protects Americans from being unjustly imprisoned. Without it, law is a sham.

Read More
173 Words | 1 Pages

- In the early morning of April 21st, 1865, a train draped with black cloth slowly arrived in Washington. In the second to last car of the train rode the body of America's first assassinated president, Abraham Lincoln. Over the next 17 days, the funeral train would ride its way across the country. Millions paused to stand by railroad sightings, or they would file past his open casket to glimpse at the president's face. Lincoln was an authentic hero who's bigger than war, and almost bigger than America by the time he died.

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

Many of America's leaders were assassinated such as John F. Kennedy and MLK. The motives to their assassinations were most from disagreements which is the same motive for the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. On April 14th 1865, John Wilkes, shot and killed Abraham Lincoln at a play at ford Theatre . John Wilkes Booth was born in Maryland and was born in 1838. He lived in the north during the civil War but but yet he still didn’t agree with Abraham Lincoln.

Read More
463 Words | 2 Pages

Abraham Lincoln made his speech persuasive by using a lot of figurative language like repetition, and by using a lot of pathos styled techniques. One of the ways he made his speech persuasive to people is by using repetition. “We CANNOT” is the main one example that president Abraham Lincoln used. He used this quote to really emphasize the thing we cannot do to make this country great and to make sure all people, no matter the color nor the race, shall always be free.

Read More

More about Was Abraham Lincoln Justified Essay

Related Topics

Open Document