ipl-logo

Was The 13th Amendment A Success Or A Failure?

1503 Words7 Pages

The Era of Reconstruction, 1865–1877
Chapter 16
16.1). Was the Thirteenth Amendment a success or a failure? Discuss the reasons for your answer. Ending slavery was not the reason a civil war was fought at all the civil war was fought to bring back the south back into unison with the north and to destroy the economic advantage that the south had due to slavery because the south was growing too powerful. The 13th amendment never made slavery unconstitutional, it merely set conditions on how slavery couple with peonage could remain constitutional. Well the debates over the reconstruction amendments had actually begun before the end of the civil war, therefore President Lincoln issued his Emancipation Proclamation in 1863, but he wasn't sure that he had the constitutional authority to free the slaves and therefore it was part of his party platform in 1864 that he would pass constitutional amendments abolishing slavery.
16.2). Consider the differences between the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments. What does the Fourteenth Amendment do that the Thirteenth does not? …show more content…

So the differences between the 13th and the 14th amendment was one abolishes the slavery, while the other just made freed slaves citizens in which they lived in. The individuality of the 13th Amendment is that it applies to the individual, private acts of citizens; no state action is necessary. So the 14th amendment ostensibly was written to provide the former slaves with the same constitutional rights of freeborn american citizens, but only if they had agreed first to become subject to the jurisdiction of the corporate United states. Intent of the fourteenth amendment was to protect all rights. The amendment addresses citizenship rights and equal protection of the fourteenth amendment, particularly its first

Show More
Related

Second Founding: How The Civil War And Reconstruction Remade The Constitution, By Eric Forner

708 Words | 3 Pages

These three amendments are all very powerful and important amendments because the 14th amendment granted equal rights under the law and in Eric Forner ’s words he states “While the ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment in 1868 granted former enslaved people the right to be recognized as citizens” Downs, Jim. Sick from Freedom (p. 8). The 13th amendment abolished all slavery and the book by Eric Forner states “the passing of the Thirteenth Amendment, which formally abolished the institution of slavery.” Downs, Jim.

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Historical Causation Of The Treaty Of Guadalupe Hidalgo

765 Words | 4 Pages

When the war broke out in 1861, a year after President Lincoln’s election, he deemed it as a central goal to preserve the union, when he states, “A government cannot endure permanently half slave, half free..." Majority of southern slaveholding states succeeded in the fear that Republicans would abolish slavery, the driving force behind their economy. As the situation grew more complex the debate over wanting to still withhold its newfound territory and the institution of slavery remained at the forefront of the war. Also hindering the United States’s position and facade as an ‘International Superpower.” 1865, the U.S Congress approved the ratification of the Thirteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution which, abolished slavery.

Read More

How Did The 15th Amendment Did Not Accomplish Its Goals

634 Words | 3 Pages

After the Civil War, the U.S.A. had to reconstruct itself which means that it basically had to rebuild itself so it could go back into its normal form. While the U.S.A. was going into reconstruction they made many Amendments. But, the most important Amendment did not accomplish its goals. I am talking about the 15th Amendment that was created with purpose to let African Americans vote. But, thankfully one of the Amendments greatly succeeded and that is the 13th Amendment, which greatly succeeded.

Read More

Why Was The 13th Amendment Important

380 Words | 2 Pages

The thirteenth amendment was an amendment that was very important in history and changed how we live today. The thirteenth amendment made slavery unconstitutional and illegal to own and trade them. In response to the civil war, the thirteenth amendment was passed. It was ratified by the Congress on December 6, 1865. The thirteenth amendment was passed because many people started to believe that the slaves should be given rights and called equals to the whites.

Read More

13th Amendment Benefits

335 Words | 2 Pages

The 13th amendment has changed American society by being able to communicate, connect, and grow with Caucasian people. This amendment makes are national a whole, that we are all in this together. The 13th amendment did help to bring whites and blacks together. It gives me the benefit to be friends with the other people without the same skin tone, to share the same bathroom with other people. It gives me the chance to sit in a class with different people, of

Read More

Three-Fifths Compromise

817 Words | 4 Pages

The United States Constitution, which shows law, rule and power, was ratified in 1787. In this professional document there have mention one important concept that is slave. However it did not completely resolve the slavery issue. In the flowing paragraphs, I will explain the ways in which the Constitution did and did not respond slavery and give the answer about in the Constitution why did the founding fathers not outlaw slavery completely.

Read More

Reconstruction Dbq Essay

815 Words | 4 Pages

With the creation of the 13th Amendment, slavery was prohibited in the United States. Ratified in 1865, it stated, “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime… shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction” (Document A). African Americans were officially free after this amendment was Ratified in the Constitution and the newly Freedmen were officially viewed differently in society. Instead of being held as slaves and viewed as property, now African Americans were viewed as Americans and could participate in public life. Therefore, Reconstruction was a success because slavery was one of the main reasons for the Civil War occurring; but with Reconstruction, the issue of slavery was resolved.

Read More

Reconstruction Dbq

1250 Words | 5 Pages

The 13th Amendment was written by James Mitchell Ashley who was a U.S. congressman and was passed pass by the Senate on April 8, 1864, and by the House on January 31, 1865. The 13th Amendment eliminated slavery and obligatory servitude. The significant of the Thirteen Amendment was huge because it was the first time slavery was on written in the Constitution. The Fourteen Amendment was written by Senator Jacob M. Howard of Michigan on July 9, 1868. The 14th Amendment gave equal rights and protect to all citizens and all who were born in the United States, along with all the slaves who were emancipated after the Civil War.

Read More

Reconstruction Dbq Essay

854 Words | 4 Pages

After the Civil War, the entire United States, especially the southern states that had supported the Confederacy, were in poor condition. The country needed to rebuild itself and therefore entered a period of Reconstruction. One of the primary aspects of the Reconstruction Era was extending rights to the millions of slaves emancipated by the thirteenth amendment that were in desperate need of help. To accomplish these intentions, Congress proposed the fourteenth and fifteenth constitutional amendments aimed at giving former slaves more rights and a fair chance at being successful. These amendments were then ratified by the states, officially putting them into effect.

Read More

Why Is The 14th Amendment Important

196 Words | 1 Pages

The 14th amendment was written after the Civil War to protect Naturalized citizens of their rights and equal protection of the law. The amendment resolves the legal status of former slaves, even though there was still a lot of confusion over newly freed slaves African Americans were still restricted in the southern states. Black children weren’t allowed to attend schools with white children because of the segregation laws but after a lawsuit was filed 1954 Brown v. board of education, the separate but equal is unequal, so the segregation laws were abolished in 1964 by the Civil Rights Act. The 14th amendment gave way too many legal rights to the Americans people to proof to the Government and State that all no matter the race have rights to

Read More

Argumentative Essay About The 13th Amendment

928 Words | 4 Pages

Angela Davis Once said “Well for one, The 13th Amendment to the constitution of the U.S. which abolished slavery, did not abolish slavery for those convicted of a crime.” Although the amendment was desperately needed it made more problems for the U.S.The thirteenth amendment was about abolishing slavery. Many people had different opinions about this amendment. The amendment affected our nation dramatically. The 13th amendment to the United States Constitution says that, "Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

Read More

Essay On The Commerce Clause

684 Words | 3 Pages

The 13th amendment enforces the ban on slavery. The 14th amendment gave Congress authority to enforce the amendment’s prohibition on a state’s denial of equal protection of the laws. Also established the citizenship birthright meaning anyone born in the United States is automatically a citizen. There is also no denying the person in the United States life, liberty, or property without due process. The 15th amendment gave Congress authority to enforce the amendment’s ban on discrimination by race,

Read More

Was Reconstruction A Success Or Failure

1000 Words | 4 Pages

Under the Compromise of 1877, the government could no longer intervene with state affairs. Also, there was nothing to keep the southerners from taking advantage to disobey the law. In fact, many southerners made up their own laws or black codes that put restrictions of African Americans. Even though protection laws were in place, they didn’t have much force behind them. I guess when you ask the question, was the Reconstruction a success or a failure?

Read More

Essay On The 14th Amendment

867 Words | 4 Pages

The Fourteenth Amendment (Amendment XIV) The amendments were put into place to protect the rights and civil liberties of all American citizens from the federal government. However, prior to the fourteenth amendment, there was no certainty with the constitution. The constitution did not state in a clear enough way who was protected under it and exactly what rights you had as an American Citizen. The 14th amendment was in response to the just passed thirteenth amendment, which ended slavery in all of the southern states.

Read More

The Successes And Failures Of The Reconstruction Era

515 Words | 3 Pages

The Reconstruction period lasted from 1865 to 1877. The thirteenth, fourteenth and fifteenth amendment were created during the twelve years of rebuilding the country. All of the amendments were made to protect former slaves and their rights but on paper they did not have any rights. The reconstruction period had its successes and failures.

Read More

More about Was The 13th Amendment A Success Or A Failure?

Related Topics

Open Document