ipl-logo

What Is The Harmful Myth Of Asian Superiority By Ronald Takaki

601 Words3 Pages

The “harmful myth of Asian superiority” an essay by Ronald Takaki, which brings to our attention the commonly held stereotypical assumptions towards Americans of Asian descent. The main idea that Mr.Takaki is trying to present, is the point of view from the Asian Americans minorities, and elaborate on the issues they are impacted by, not just how they are portrayed by media to the world. The statement “Asians should be model minority” is the belief of Asian minority groups being superior to others, including the African American community of immigrants. Furthermore, social issues faced by some of these individual groups including racism and discrimination are not taken into consideration. When looking at where they are today as a community, …show more content…

One of the many being the Vietnamese, although many have attended post-secondary and got an education. The effects of Homogenization have been so powerful, that the many who are falling into the wrong paths joining gangs, becoming victims of drugs and violence are out of the picture. By all of this Mr. Takaki believes we are attempting to simply cover up the issue and act as though it is not present. Some of the evidence used by Mr. Takaki also demonstrates how the stereotypical assumption of Asian Superiority is just a Myth by educating us on some statistics which show, three out ten Asian American families on welfare usually between four to ten years. Although many of the new generations are now getting into good salary paid position, there is still the gap, because there is only so far these individuals can go until they hit “Glass ceiling”. Furthermore, many Asian American immigrants are also not able to work the professions they worked back home because they are unqualified. Mr. Takaki introduces us to a Chinese man in his essay who tells us his immigration story to America, how

Show More
Related
994 Words | 4 Pages

African Americans on the battle front are put into segregated divisions, whereas Native Americans dealt with compliment racism or unintentional racism. Chinese Americans were concerned with being accused of being Japanese, while the Japanese Americans tried to prove they were American too. Throughout his book, Takaki demonstrates the varying levels of racism experienced, and how hard work and perseverance helped these groups prove themselves to some degree. Takaki claims, all of these minorities groups, gained some form of freedom and equality either through the military or through job opportunities and improvements.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Born in Oahu, Hawaii, Ronald Takaki addressed stereotypes of Asian Americans in the perspective of an American academic, historian, ethnographer, and an author. Nonetheless, his awareness of identity as a descendant of Japanese immigrants is clearly portrayed throughout “Double Victory.” Takaki initially studied at Wooster University, and work there led to his questioning of ethnic identity. His personal experiences, such as his wife’s family’s refusal to accept him because he is a ‘Jap’, inspired him to dedicate his life for equality for Asian Americans. He was involved in developing UC Berkeley's multicultural requirement for graduation as a professor: the American Cultures Requirement.

Read More
677 Words | 3 Pages

Is there a “model minority”? Takaki ’s essay “The Harmful Myth of Asian Superiority” . In this essay Takaki writes against the claim that has been made that Asian Americans are viewed as being the “model minority”.

Read More
1989 Words | 8 Pages

The author talks about the federal immigration statute that was generally directed at the Chinese immigrants. He specifically mentions the1882 Chinese exclusion law that was meant to address the issues of unemployment in America by restricting the entry of both the unskilled and skilled Chinese laborers. This law turned the Chinese Americans into ’illegal aliens’ and barred them from becoming American citizens (Nokes 117). Those who were already American citizens were stripped off of their citizenship and were termed as national enemies. However, this is just an example of the many challenges that the Asian Americans have face din their quest to immigrate to America.

Read More
402 Words | 2 Pages

This paragraph from Kesaya Noda’s autobiographical essay “Growing Up Asian in America” represents the conflict that the author feels between her Japanese ethnicity, and her American nationality. The tension she describes in the opening pages of her essay is between what she looks like and is judged to be (a Japanese woman who faces racial stereotypes) versus what she feels like and understands (life as a United States citizen). This passage signals her connection to Japan; and highlights her American upbringing. At this point in the essay, Noda is unable to envision her identity as unified and she describes her identity as split by race.

Read More
1446 Words | 6 Pages

Derrick Bell’s The Space Traders is a science fiction short story that illustrates Wilderson ’s claim that, “stability is a state of emergency for Black people. Although it is a realistic depiction of how society has sacrificed Blacks in return for stability, it does not draw attention to how Asian Americans affect and contribute to this ideal. In my revision I include the attitudes various Asian American groups have towards Blacks and how they would react to Bell’s proposed scenario.

Read More
302 Words | 2 Pages

Author Jason Newman writes on the history of Asian Americans in the United States in his essay, appropriately titled, “Asian American in U.S. History”. The essay describes the treatment of Asian Americans in the United States, along with the legislation passed against them. To open his essay, Newman writes, “Many Asian Americans have struggled against recurrent stereotypes that cast them as permanent outsiders despite their long history in the United States.” Afterward, Newman describes the early immigration of Asian Americans to the U.S. Specifically, he uses Chinese Americans to illustrate the negative reaction Americans had towards Asian immigration, listing the many laws passed to bar Chinese immigration into America.

Read More
1280 Words | 6 Pages

Qian Julie Wang’s memoir, “Beautiful Country” portrays her experiences immigrating from China to the United States at a young age. She discusses her challenges in adapting to a new culture and school system, changes in her family’s financial situation, and the constant fear of deportation as an undocumented immigrant. Through her personal story, the author sheds light on the struggles faced by immigrants in the United States, particularly those who are undocumented, and the emotional toll these experiences can have on individuals and families. In her memoir, Wang describes several biographical disruptions she experienced as an immigrant to the United States. These include the sudden switch in the family’s economic status, Julie’s transition

Read More
287 Words | 2 Pages

Ronald Takaki a renowned pioneer in the field of ethnic studies has over the years authored numerous books on diversity in American society. As a grandson of Japanese immigrants who became the first black studies professor at UCLA, Takaki for many years has continually tried to bridge cultures and ethnic groups in the United States. In his book “A different mirror: A history of multicultural America”, Takaki addresses the idea of multiculturalism in our society, and also talks about how for many years we have been told to acknowledge the notions that the core principles of our nation uprooted only from one group rather than a contribution from other various cultures as well. The ‘master narrative’ posed by Takaki describes the growing

Read More
321 Words | 2 Pages

Takaki's essay on 'The Harmful Myth of Asian Superiority' is littered with statistics. He uses these stats to persuade the reader that Asians are not yet and still far away from being in par with Caucasians. He explains that Asians are perceived to have a higher income than Caucasians, but considering the majority of the Asian population in the US is concentrated in large, urbanized and expensive cities such as New York and California, they are barely making enough to get by in these cities. He goes on to explain various of other reasons why Asians are not "superior" than other races like how Asians make more money because they have more people in the family who are working and how the only reason Japanese Americans make a bit more than the

Read More
652 Words | 3 Pages

In Shakespeare’s tragedy Othello, the main character is a Moorish general of the Venetian army is portrayed as a well-respected, yet disparaged for his race and how he looks by the historical and cultural background during the playwright and the intended audience of the play. Similarly, Asian American in today’s society are expected to be in the technological and medical careers as they are usually known to be high advanced in academics, yet they are still get taunted for their appearance because today’s society believe having slanted eyes and small body parts is unnatural and gives a disadvantage for the Asian American. In Othello, the main Character Othello was able to grow in power within the city because his leadership in the Army and

Read More
327 Words | 2 Pages

A friend of mine who is Asian explained to me how education is seen as a family matter and a deeply integrated value of their culture. This high expectation has resulted in Asian Americans to be viewed as the “model minority”. This closely relates to when the author

Read More
890 Words | 4 Pages

Through this video project, my group aimed to address the overarching theme of orientalism, mainly shown through the model minority myth and gender stereotyping. In this, we wanted to show a different take on how these orientalist views can play out in the life of an Asian-American. Said explained in that orientalism makes a distinction between “the West and the Orient” by defining both sides in a problematic binary. Said calls the distinctions “dogmas” in which people form the west take on the “obligation” of defining characters of people from the east (Said). We wanted to problematize the main notion that Asian-American women are passive and docile, while also including a criticism on the fact the many Asian-American men from the ghetto are

Read More
914 Words | 4 Pages

Even though the group of minorities seem to be increasing, “such as Asian Americans, Hispanics, Native Americans, and African Americans, whiteness still conveys an ideology of privilege and power,” (Blank,

Read More
1244 Words | 5 Pages

Ever since the early 1800s, immigration has been a huge factor in America’s growth. Yet when Asians first started to immigrate in the late 1800s, the “yellow peril” occurred, where Caucasians perceived Asians as a threat to their socioeconomic standings by offering to work harder for less. The US government responded by limiting and eventually banning Asian immigration, specifically the Chinese. It was half a century afterward that Asians were once again allowed to immigrate and become American citizens. Since then, an image of being quiet, industrious workers has formed around the Asian community.

Read More

More about What Is The Harmful Myth Of Asian Superiority By Ronald Takaki

Related Topics

Open Document