ipl-logo

What Is The My Lai Massacre A Military Crime Of Obedience By Ian Parker

1189 Words5 Pages

Ian Parker, author of “Obedience”, provides accurate depictions of the immediate and long-term effects of Dr. Stanley Milgram’s Experiment. In addition, he includes that under complex situations, individuals are easily induced to react through a destructive manner (Parker103). Americans commonly underestimate the influences of a situation; however, Parker thoroughly delineates the consequences behind blind obedience (Parker 104). Herbert C. Kelman and V. Lee Hamilton, authors of “The My Lai Massacre: A Military Crime of Obedience” construe the atrocity of blind obedience committed by the United States Military. In March of 1968, crimes of obedience occurred due to an elusive order commanded by a higher ranked officer (Kelman&Hamilton 131). Military …show more content…

In comparison, Lt. William Calley maintained his actions within My Lai were entirely in response to superior orders and did not endure any remorse by carrying out directed orders (Kelman& Hamilton 136-137). As to why Dawson and Downey instinctively followed an unethical command to inflict pain on Pfc. Santiago, Kelman and Hamilton convey that the structure that authority contributes to the situation effects the reactions to the explicit or implicit orders (Kelman& Hamilton 140).The Uniform Code of Military Justice, UCMJ, might refute Kelman and Hamilton by providing that military personnel must follow the lawful orders of his superior officer; in addition, it includes they have the obligation to disobey unlawful orders when in direct violation of the UCMJ ("A Duty to Disobey..."). If Dawson and Downey had the right to follow code and disobey the unlawful order of authorizing Santiago with a Code Red, then why would they follow through with the command? Ian Parker provides when there is a slight channel for disobedience, individuals tend to be more vulnerable to fascism and react in a destructive manner.

Show More
Related
569 Words | 3 Pages

When learning about and analyzing acts of mass atrocity during World War II, hundreds if not thousands of questions can be asked trying to gain a deeper understanding for their actions. Probably one of the most intriguing thoughts to ponder is what leads individuals and societies as a whole to descend to such a level of cruelty. According to the author of Unbroken, Laura Hillenbrand, one reason may be, “Few societies treasured dignity, and feared humiliation, as did the Japanese, for whom a loss of honor could merit suicide. This is likely one of the reasons why Japanese soldiers in World War II debased their prisoners with such zeal, seeking to take from them that which was most painful and destructive to lose” (189). To elaborate, the Japanese

Read More
629 Words | 3 Pages

The Vietnam War originated from when the North of Vietnam wanted to unify the country under a communist regime after defeating the French colonial administration of Vietnam in 1954 (“Vietnam”). This decision made by the North of Vietnam was influenced by the Soviet Union as well as China. Since the Soviet Union and China were quite dominant during the Cold War, this signifies that the Domino Effect had been successful to a certain extent. Even if the Domino Effect might have been somewhat a success there were still the nationalists who did not agree to be controlled by the communists. The United States were against the Viet Cong, who were the communists, had an impact on the war (Berman).

Read More
723 Words | 3 Pages

In 1971, Dr. Phillip Zimbardo conducted the Stanford Prison Experiment in which he recruited normal young men who were college students and drastically changed their environment in order to show what the desire for obedience can do to a person’s sense of civil responsibility.  The cruel acts committed at Abu Ghraib blurred the lines between the prisoners and the guards because the prisoners were stripped away of their freedom and their human rights.   The prison at Abu Ghraib was originally used by Sadaam Hussein to torture and execute political prisoners .  

Read More
810 Words | 4 Pages

Since the beginning of the human existence, man has always dominated and ruled over one another be it empires, corporations, or small groups. Authority and obedience has always been a factor of who we are. This natural occurrence can be seen clearly through the psychological experiments known as The Milgram Experiment and the Stanford Prison Experiment. Both of these studies are based on how human beings react to authority figures and what their obedience is when faced with conflict.

Read More
469 Words | 2 Pages

The question posed in today’s reading was whether an embedded agent should have carried out the assassination of a government official in order to further an espionage investigation. Admiral Turner pulled the plug on the investigation by not green-lighting the hit.1 While I agree with him in this case, there are more factors at play here than the mere legality of the agent’s pending act (assassination), or even the life of the government official weighed against the value of the investigation. Whether or not Admiral Turner made the “right” call comes down to a question of rational response to a moral imperative, which is where things get sticky, especially when authors start using phrases like “any means necessary” when commenting on the proposed

Read More
1101 Words | 5 Pages

From the beginning of the United States military involvement in Vietnam in 1955, to its withdrawal in 1973 public support for the war was strong at first, but began to slowly erode as military actions escalated. Among the soldiers fighting in the war a critical turning point in their support for the war occurred after the revealing of the My Lai massacre. The My Lai Massacre was a turning point in the soldiers’ about the war and their support for the Vietnam War. Because of its documentation and publicity the My Lai massacre among many atrocities had such an impact, that it turned the viewpoints of the soldiers who were present at the massacre, but also those who were not.

Read More
534 Words | 3 Pages

Watching the “Rape at McDonalds” video was very disturbing. It was shocking to see how all the participants, except for the maintenance man, complied with the bizarre demands of the supposed police, especially Donna Jean Summers. As a manager, she should have known the policies of the company, as a reasonable person, she should had handled the situation in a different way. However, there are some psychological explanations for her behaviors. The law says that we must obey the authority; she believed that she was doing the right thing by following the others given by “the cop” even if the commands were very odd.

Read More
213 Words | 1 Pages

MY LAI, Vietnam -- Truong Thi Le stares at a graphic photograph of the massacre 's carnage, then points at the pile of corpses under which she hid for four hours, clutching her 6-year-old son. Her dead mother, brother and another son sprawl nearby. "I feel pain in my heart when I look at this," she says, her voice choking. "I have to struggle not to cry. I still can 't account for what happened."

Read More
409 Words | 2 Pages

The need to follow orders blinded their possible judgment of the situation and how it could have played out. Not only the need to follow orders, but the need to follow their code, cost them someone's life along with their honor. Fromm's argument of obedience verse disobedience can be seen in multiple instances in A Few Good

Read More
432 Words | 2 Pages

Regardless of these morally jarring responses, 65% of participants continued to 450 volts, and all participants continued to 300 volts. The results of this study suggest that ordinary people are very likely to obey orders given by authority figures, even to the extreme of killing another person, if they see such authority as legally or morally based. Although this study proved to be massively influential in terms of human behaviour, the way in which it was conducted has been criticised. One of the main criticisms is the environment of the experiment.

Read More
1152 Words | 5 Pages

Obedience to Social Pressure The social pressure begins since the day a child we born. Our parents give us the first glimpse of the feel of social pressure without the newborn having the littlest idea of what it is. The social pressure of family unity begins when the child is born, and parents have the fear of their own family would retract and speak negatively of their own kids. Is the child ugly?

Read More
891 Words | 4 Pages

Hurricane Katrina was a tragedy that devastated many families, homes, and lives. Within that devastation, a tough situation arose for many public officials. Among them, police officers, were heavily affected. The question that washed among the shores of the gulf states was the moral dilemma that affected the police officers who served the community. In a situation like Hurricane Katrina, was their moral obligation to the public or their family?

Read More
1049 Words | 5 Pages

In this assignment the research study to be discussed is Milgram’s study of obedience (1963). The term of obedience can be defined as a type of community impact that incorporates carrying out an activity under orders from a dominant figure. Obedience concerns changing behaviour because a dominant figure has told you to do so. After World War II, at the Nuremberg Trials, the Nazi’s defended genocide by saying they were only pursuing procedures. In 1963, Stanley Milgram set out to investigate how far people would go in obedience to orders.

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

The first scene that these quandaries come to light is where General Geoffrey D. Miller, a specialist in interrogations, was sent to Abu Ghraib to help guards extract more information from the prisoners. The guards at the facility had been trained for years to follow every order they had been given, but this would mark the first time that the United States Army’s orders had directly conflicted with their personal convictions. This fact was stated by the soldiers themselves in the the interviews conducted afterwards. This type of obedience can be explained by Erich Fromm in his article, “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem”. Fromm states that there are two types of Obedience one that is submissive to an institution or power, and another which an affirmation of your own personal beliefs (Fromm 124).

Read More
851 Words | 4 Pages

Martial Law is, it Curtailment or Absolute Control? Einstein once said, “The world will not be destroyed by those who do evil, but by those who watch them without doing anything.” Unfortunately, it is those who we have placed our utmost trust in that are doing the evil. Whereas, those who are watching and are doing nothing, have been made incapable of doing so.

Read More

More about What Is The My Lai Massacre A Military Crime Of Obedience By Ian Parker

Related Topics

Open Document