ipl-logo

William James The Varieties Of Religious Experience

1492 Words6 Pages

William James was a late 19th and early 20th century American philosopher. In this paper, I will be examining a portion of one of his works The Varieties of Religious Experience. Specifically, section 11.2 Mysticism which delves into the topic of mystical experiences. First James lays out some definitions that are key to understanding his arguments. He then argues three warrants for why a person should believe in mystical experiences. It is these three warrants and their arguments that I will be summarizing in this paper. I will also be providing my objections to his arguments as I address each of them in turn.
Before delving into the primary argument James’ defines what mystical experience means in his paper. He does this by defining mystical …show more content…

He lists them as “…less sharply marked, but are usually found” (James, 99). Transiency is one of these criteria that is frequent but not required. It refers to the observation that mystical states do not usually have a lengthy duration. According to James, these experiences commonly last at most one or two hours. Afterward, they can only be partially remembered unless something linked to the topic of the experience causes the memory to resurface. James lists passivity as the final criteria to a mystical experience. This is described as being gripped or guided by a higher power. Symptoms of this include prophesies, speaking in tongues, alternate personalities, and writing or drawing during the experience. While not all mystical experiences include these, I do agree with James’ observation that they are common enough to warrant listing among his “marks” of mystical …show more content…

While I do not completely denounce his point of an experience having authority over the mystic, I will argue against the claim of its absolute authority. A mystical experience that is as enlightening as is required to fulfill James’ criteria would undoubtedly change a person’s perspective in any number of ways. So, it is entirely reasonable to believe such a person’s perspective would be highly resistant to alteration from external challenges. However, this does not render these beliefs invulnerable to debate. I see no reason to interfere with the religious practices of a mystic enlightened by an experience, but this does not mean I cannot question why the mystic follows the beliefs they formed from a mystical experience. If the mystics new creed is deserving of such authority, then it is in the interest of all to ascertain why, as it clearly means the mystic knows something everyone else doesn’t. But as I mentioned earlier ineffability becomes a problem here. I think beliefs should have sufficient justification and if a belief is justified it should be explainable to someone else. It is here that ineffability forms a barrier between rational thought and the authority a mystical experience has over the mystic. James’ claims that rational thought cannot question, critique, or explain mystical experience. I believe this is immensely convenient for mysticism. This warrant, and as I will discuss later the entire

Show More
Related
2185 Words | 9 Pages

Kegan says that a strong focus on self-discipline exists in this stage, such as praying, meditation and fasting. Illumination: An increased connection with others. “A deeper, more prolonged awareness of light, or greater reality, or God.” The person in this stage regarding the mystical theory is said to experience pleasure/satisfaction because they reached illumination, however, Underhill states that “pleasure or satisfaction must be abandoned if the individual is to continue the self-transcendent journey.”

Read More
791 Words | 4 Pages

Thirdly, James illustrates to us that a mystical experience should or usually does give us knowledge after this bring us onto James’ idea of the “noetic”. This quality often means that mystical experiences go beyond just emotion, feeling and the extradition of the senses, but leaves us with a profound amount of knowledge about the self, reality, the divine, or any spiritual knowledge in general. This goes with evidence, many people who have experiences these experiences often report gaining a “deeper understanding” of the

Read More
2250 Words | 9 Pages

These “sense experiences,” are the experiences that one is subject to through the interpretation of sensory data. Man discovered this restriction in the ability to gather knowledge long ago, and came to realize its implications. An unlimited thirst for knowledge can never be quenched by a limited experience of the world. Thus religion was born. The conception of religion was to serve as a means to explain what is beyond the traditional breadth of comprehension.

Read More
1701 Words | 7 Pages

The experiences patients go through are one like no other. They come to, “...express a spiritual realm and a loving presence that some refer to as God…” (Lichfield). During this period they might also come, “into contact with relatives that have been deceased, and at the same time, recalling previous events that occured in one's life” (Lichfield). These experiences have been documented to change people's lives as some go on to new professions and ending marriages as a result of their subconscious experience.

Read More
180 Words | 1 Pages

Qualia are perceptual subjective experiences that vary widely in character, such as touching sandpaper or seeing the color blue. Jackson’s “The Knowledge Argument” about qualia challenges physicalism by arguing that these conscious and unique experiences have non-physical features. His example of Mary the Scientist refutes the statement that everything is just physical, nothing more. Prior to Mary’s release she knew everything physical about color, but when she was released she learned about other people’s color experience. She has important discoveries of seeing the flowers being red and grass being green, which she did not seem to know before.

Read More
712 Words | 3 Pages

It was used in the past to obtain and gain control over their spiritual power (329). In this case, power is used in a religious sense, healing the sick as well as signifying a sense of status in Native American communities. The power of the religious priests, for the Salish, is believed to be received from their spirits or ancestors, which allows them to enter their states of consciousness (331). Another example of this is when Jilek examines the Sun Dance of the Sioux. He states that, for the sun dance, the dance is performed to focus on supernatural power, using it for the health and success of a devotee, to communicate with spirits, to combat suffering within a community, or to combat evil (333).

Read More
1656 Words | 7 Pages

In what follows, I will argue that the meditator has adequate reasons to doubt everything he has come to experience

Read More
570 Words | 3 Pages

Paper #3 A mystical experience can have a great impact on the lives of those who experience them. They may be rare and transcendent, but their impact is deep and may have a significant impact on one’s life. We often imagine that these experiences only happen to those with saintly characteristics that have a deep connection with the divine.

Read More
184 Words | 1 Pages

College graduates are more likely to rise from the income ladder than those who haven’t finished or chosen to go to college. But, “economic mobility in the United States is now below that of most developed countries, suggesting the American Dream is becoming a myth” (Matthews 2017). Jobs that are demanding skills needed are slowly disappearing, which cuts down the opportunities given to those without an education after high school. However, Mobility Report Cards: The Role of Colleges in Intergenerational Mobility proves otherwise. Students who are less fortunate financially and are accepted into elite schools benefit the same as rich students.

Read More
1054 Words | 5 Pages

It is irrefutably clear that Mary gained new knowledge when she saw colour for the first time and has learnt what it is ‘like’ to experience colour. Therefore, Jackson claims that her knowledge was previously incomplete and thus, “Physicalism is incomplete” 3(p130). Jackson has revealed that Physicalists do not account for the subjective quality of experience and mental states. Hence, Physicalism cannot be absolutely true since they ignore this important

Read More
1268 Words | 6 Pages

In comprehending why Esotericism should be studied as part of Religious Studies, it is essential to explore the concept of Transmutation, which is prominently seen to emphasise individual experience in attaining self- empowerment through achieving inner-knowledge. This also coherently links to the Esoteric concept of Gnosticism, with a focus on tradition/transmission paralleling the master/teacher relationship commonly seen within religious practice. This opinion is supported to through the growth of New Age Activities in Western society, for example meditation, in which the concept of Philosophia Perrenis is commonly seen to be explored. Similarly, another parallel between religion and esotericism is the combined beliefs of the Esoteric and the religious thinker, supported through the example of Jung, with his concept of the Self “principium individuationis,” (1944)) coherently connecting individual religious experience with elements of

Read More
742 Words | 3 Pages

Paul regards a transformative experience as “a kind of experience that is both radically new to you and changes you in a deep and fundamental way” (Paul, 16). Paul claims that there are two types of experiences: personally transformative experiences, and epistemically transformative experiences. A personally transformative experience is one that can change who you are in regard to your point of view (Paul, 15). An epistemically transformative experience, however, is one that provides you with new information

Read More
1994 Words | 8 Pages

Mystic experience. Self-actualizers have had peak experiences or experiences in which they have attained transcendence. 1) I’m still young and I don’t think that I’ve had all my peak experiences in life yet. I’ve had experiences that have shaped that person that I am today, but I think I have more growing and experiences to come.

Read More
1474 Words | 6 Pages

Walton’s invocation of the haloed “celestial spirit” is evidence for his romantic and reverent outlook on humanity. To him, we are fundamentally divine, much more than flesh and blood. Later, he writes that, “There is something at work in my soul, which I do not understand” (Shelley). The ways of God and the functioning of the mind are thus left inscrutable to Walton; however, he is not paralyzed by existential dread. Rather, he accepts on faith that there is a divide order in the world, and that he is part of something

Read More
724 Words | 3 Pages

Last Christmas, I had the opportunity to experience the fireworks show in Disney World. The theme park’s magic and wonder fascinated me and thus compelled me to choose Gehry’s Walt Disney Concert Hall as my building of study. Both its exterior and interior uphold a quote mentioned in Professor Speck’s lecture by Abbot Suger, “Man reaches contemplation of divine through the senses.” In other words, an individual is able to understand a deeper meaning through use of the five senses. Therefore, every person that passes this building goes through a unique experience when his/her eyes first detect the building.

Read More

More about William James The Varieties Of Religious Experience

Related Topics

Open Document