ipl-logo

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Hero Inflation By Nicholas Thompson

1117 Words5 Pages

Hero Inflation
Nicholas Thompson wrote his article Hero Inflation in January 2002 which was not long after the tragedy of the September 11, 2001. It is not surprising that the argument of the article focuses on the way this tragedy influenced American society and its understanding of heroism. Despite the fact that the author's claim that it is not wise to apply the title of heroes to firemen and rescue workers who executed their duties in the World Trade Center after the terrorist attack may seem rude and morally inappropriate, the way Thompson supports his argument provokes interest in its reader, since it calls to reconsider the common approach towards heroism. This is the attribute of the article that has provoked my personal interest as …show more content…

He does not simply lists the three elements of a hero, but also traces back their origins and attempts to explain why they are important nowadays. All in all, the author's thesis about the nature and purpose of heroes for any society can be put in a short and simple proposition: heroes are role models (Thompson). From this thesis it is easy to logically conclude that the development of the image of a hero in America, and its being associated with people who transformed the world in a courageous manner. Thompson also describes the rise of the fourth element of a hero as an objective process and supports this argument by noticing the fact that “books about overcoming adversity clog the bestseller lists, and perseverance during illness – any illness – is grist for the heroic mill” …show more content…

The use of ethos is to be seen in the author's reference to the experience and legacy of Ancient Greece concerning the definition of a hero. Along with the already mentioned contribution this reference makes to the logical support of Thompson's argument, it also appeals to the great cultural authority and value we give to Ancient Greece. Another example of appeal to authority in the article is the use of the quotation of Emerson in the last line of the article. This appeal to authority of the prominent American philosopher seems to be called to perform double function. On the one side, it supports the author's mode of thinking about the issue. On the other side, it shelters Thompson from possible accusation in cynicism because he approaches the delicate issue of the memory and contemplating of the victims of the attack at September 11, 2001 (bearing in mind that the article was published only four months after the tragedy) in distinctly dry and unemotional manner. Therefore, the appeal to authority helps Thompson to justify this approach to some extend in the eyes of

Show More
Related
783 Words | 4 Pages

In this chapter James Loewen approaches “Herofication” in history as a sense of idolization and false misinterpretation of figures in history. Loewen throughout the chapter surrounds the making of heroes, in which he describes as a degenerative process. He explains that “heroes” are shaped and built up and taught in the classroom most times leaving out and belittling other heroes even when having extensive backgrounds. The chapter ties back to what he believes the textbooks got wrong, he compares to notable figures in history, Helen Keller and President Wilson and how they are depicted. Loewen argues that text books fail to show the relationship between a hero and a person instead they give highlights of the “hero” and don’t give a full

Read More
566 Words | 3 Pages

Thompson utilizes allusions to emphasize the magnitude of 9/11. In the first paragraph, Thompson equates 9/11 to events like “Pearl Harbor, the San Francisco earthquake” and “the Battle of Antietam,” three large-scale tragedies that dramatically affected America, these comparisons help the audience understand the magnitude and significance of 9/11. Thompson later declares “It will be a Religious War, a sort of Christian Jihad, fueled by religious hatred and led by merciless fanatics on both sides.” This reference draws parallels to the Islamic holy war and suggests that the state of America isn’t far from the state of Islamic countries. Lastly, Thompson uses the phrase “Loose Lips

Read More
932 Words | 4 Pages

Though LaBarge harms his argument by discussing the cynicism of heroes, his article, “Heroism: Why Heroes are Important,” provides a convincing argument that the idea of heroes as we know it is under attack by the modern generation and their influences. The most compelling piece of information

Read More
268 Words | 2 Pages

In the first chapter Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your AMerican History Textbook Got Wrong, James Loewen explores the common process of heroification within America’s history. The flaws of many individuals, specifically Woodrow Wilson and Helen Keller in this chapter, are usually overlooked when recounting their achievements. Loewen points outs that when heroes are recognized for certain things it only covers a short person of the person’s life. The media and schools filter out the bad to leave room for inspiration and good.

Read More
491 Words | 2 Pages

After careful examination of the article, “Where I Find My Heroes” authored by Oliver Stone, it became apparent that Stone uses the rhetorical devices of examples and imagery to help convey his definition of a hero. To help portray his image of a hero, Stone provides examples of heroes all throughout his lifetime. For example, he later stated that as a child, “My heroes were always people like George Washington and General Custer and Abraham Lincoln and Teddy Roosevelt. Men, generally, and doers” (Stone 1). Then as he talks about what he believes fits the definition of a hero now, one can see that he has mentally evolved to that of someone who should be honored for sacrifices made, not actions that led them to fame.

Read More
790 Words | 4 Pages

Scott LaBarge’s essay “Heroes: Why Heroes are Important” is well written because he effectively uses pathos, logos, and karios when explaining heroes to his audience. When something goes wrong or we feel like we cannot continue, we could all use someone to step in and change our situation. Everyone needs a hero. LaBarge gives an excellent example from his high school days; Thoreau inspired him and became his hero. The high school period of one’s life is a difficult period.

Read More
644 Words | 3 Pages

Courage is defined as the ability to do something that frightens one. All children dream of finding themselves in dangerous situations and rising above everyone else in the situation to become a hero. Heroes can be defined a person who is admired or idealized for courage, outstanding achievements, or noble qualities. In 1982, Roger Rosenblatt, an award-winning journalist, wrote an article for Time Magazine about a man who risked his life in order to save his fellow passengers from the icy waters of the Potomac River. In the end, this man lost his own life in the process of saving others.

Read More
641 Words | 3 Pages

Heroes in our society are revered and respected as Joseph Campbell reminds us: “A hero is someone who has given his or her life to something bigger than oneself” (Joseph Campbell). Heroes exist in all societies and throughout history. Maybe they are not always on the news or from the movies, but their words and their actions never fail to resonate across their feats. A hero gives of himself and dedicates himself to causes which better others and their society unlike individuals who are self serving, greedy, and cruel.

Read More
1272 Words | 6 Pages

The majority of authors or movie writers have one common factor; they have a hero somewhere in the plot. Ask a friend to summarize a favorite movie or book. They could easily point out who the hero or villain is. However, heroes do not only exist in movies or in books, but they exist in real life. Despite our culture’s fascination with Marvel Comics and DC Comics, we most commonly hear about war heroes.

Read More
740 Words | 3 Pages

In this article, “Why We Love TV’s Anti-heroes,” the author Stephen Garrett argues that in today’s society our whole perspective of heroes has changed since the mid-twentieth century. Garrett is appealing to all American’s who love watching their favorite TV heroes and heroines. In addition, Garrett’s main focus is the fact today’s heroes entirely different from what the idea of a “hero” was two or three decades ago. The author relies on generally accepted ideas from the American public to base his main idea; he uses sources from popular TV shows and movies which have anti-heroes that draw the attention of their audience.

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

Thesis: In “What Makes A War Hero”. Karl Marlantes portrays the influential truth of what makes one a war hero, while differentiating heroism and bravery, and explaining how heroism has come to be so loosely defined. I. The characteristics that makes one a war hero is derived from ones self-sacrificing behavior that impacts others without a reward. a) In the article “What Makes A War Hero” there are many examples of brave warriors yet there are very few heroes within those warriors.

Read More
1431 Words | 6 Pages

Considering the common man as a hero was spread in America and the hero was the one who separated from others by his voluntary positive actions for society. The hero should not be necessary to follow the society’s rules. The American romantic hero should do innovations and adventures.

Read More
459 Words | 2 Pages

Pitts uses emotion and logic to persuade the Americans that the terrorists can do what they want to us, but America is tough enough to handle it. In life everyone comforts each other in times of grieving. Pitts explains that this one small obstacle can 't stop

Read More
660 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout the ages, heroism has been defined and redefined by society. Looking at countless quotes and articles spread across the Internet, heroism is defined and redefined again and again, each quote similar, yet different. According to some, heroism is only an act of bravery or courage, while others see it also as small acts of kindness. Soldiers, firefighters, and doctors are often seen as modern day heroes, and they are. However, often overlooked, medics, dads, and even comic book superheroes are real heroes in ways some would not consider.

Read More
601 Words | 3 Pages

The definition of the hero has evolved dramatically since the beginning of this myth. Today, I will argue why I dislike heroes in three parts. First, I will demonstrate that heroes can be anything and everything. Then, I will explain that the origins of the hero are based on a myth. Finally, I will prove that the hero is an ideal who doesn’t exist.

Read More

More about A Rhetorical Analysis Of Hero Inflation By Nicholas Thompson

Related Topics

Open Document