ipl-logo

Analysis Of Butch Please: The Dichotomy Of The Butch-Femme

1723 Words7 Pages

Butch Please: The Dichotomy of the Butch-Femme (1940-1970)
The role of butch-femme lesbians has shifted from the 1940s to 1970s, though what has remained constant is dichotomy of the masculine and feminine. The existence of butch-femme lesbians exists today, though very differently from the original of lesbian bar culture of the 1940s. The phases of butch-femme coexist with other important aspects of history, such as the blue-collar working class expectations, women’s rights in World War II, Second Wave feminism, and overall gender roles. This essay will demonstrate the creation and sustained social expectation of masculine and feminine lesbians as a continuation of heteronormative systems and fear of heterosexual hatred. While taking into …show more content…

Traditionally not feminine, loves women. Butch women cannot pass as straight, as femme lesbians can. The existence of butch lesbians goes both against and for gender and sexual stereotypes. Specifically, the stereotype of butch lesbians as the masculine counterpart to the feminine femme. As recounted by a butch author, “Straight people call me sir and faggots cruise me.” Masculine women are more likely to be noticed by the outside community than feminine women, because it goes against traditional gender stereotypes in mainstream culture. Considered a betrayal of gender identity: the true lesbian is butch, aggressive, and masculine. Butch lesbians are noteworthy, because in some ways, it is destroying and bolstering heteronormativity. Butch lesbian “stick out like G.I. Joes in Barbie Land” due to gender expression and easily identifiable sexuality at the time. On one hand, the gender expression of a butch lesbian is very different from the femininity established for women, as they do not match the typical housewife ideal. As well, butch lesbians are homosexual, and do not participate in the same type of misogynistic existence as typical straight men. Butch lesbians do not have the same privilege of men, and are kept at a level of disrespect both based on gender and sexuality. Even though stereotypically, butch lesbians are seen as the ‘man’ in lesbian relationships, and expected to fulfill similar emotional and sexual duties. In reality, butch women as personal identities are the bane of heteronormativity, because masculine lesbains oppose traditional gender roles, and are gay. Though, this does not stop the heteronormative binary from existing, and prevailing over other forms of lesbian

Show More
Related
1344 Words | 6 Pages

Although this supports the system of oppression for queer people, in the sense that gay men are feminine, it almost empowers

Read More
768 Words | 4 Pages

Arlene Stein’s book “Sex and Sensibility” is a literary masterpiece that develops the framework of content that was essential towards explaining the rise of the lesbian movement; though solid in its message, Stein’s bias is recognized throughout the text, she was cognizant of issues and factors that affected the movement but she fails to piece together the entire spectrum. Stein captures three fundamental factors displayed throughout the text: (1). The recognition of new sexual identities and their associated orientations (2). The separation of the Feminist and Lesbianist movements, and (3). The differentiation of the “Old Gay” and “New Gay”lesbian identities.

Read More
1707 Words | 7 Pages

These efforts were rewarded in the sense that because lesbians were seen as having done a “good work” Homophobic fears began to subside within the ranks of women. Lesbians gained I respect they had not enjoyed before as heterosexual activist chain to appreciate their arguments and saw for themselves how lesbian baiting have been used to stifle the female self-assertion. Because of the growing women's movement in the early 1970s Congress was forced to passed more legislation for women's rights than ever before or since. Document 13 illustrates

Read More
380 Words | 2 Pages

However, she also mentions how this was primarily the “white women’s movement” for sexuality and how it convinced her that lesbian sexuality was naturally different than heterosexual sexuality (Moraga, 393). This white women’s movement was problematic in that it excluded non-white, non-middle class women. Another relation between political activism and eroticism was between radical feminism and lesbianism. Moraga mentions how “radical feminism” viewed lesbianism as a political response to male sexual aggression (Moraga, 395). The Civil Rights Movement was a key moment that exemplifies the link between political activism and spirituality.

Read More
638 Words | 3 Pages

George states this caused lesbian and gay men to see more dangerous, due to an upset in gender roles of men and women and the diminished role of men in their families (p.353).   In her book “Faeries, Marimachas, Queens, and Lezzies: The Construction of Homosexuality Before the 1969 Stonewall Riots.” Author Elvia Arrioloa asserts The Stonewall Riots that erupted in June 1969 in New York City, when a group of, Black and Puerto Rican drag queens and butch lesbians, turned a bar raid into a street fight with the local police. A fight that ultimately came to symbolize and overthrow decades of State laws, Police harassment, segregation, repression, and public degradation as highlighted in the George reading.

Read More
316 Words | 2 Pages

Previously, I believe it could be said that women, while used as a symbol of sex, were never completely allowed to own and and proudly flaunt their sexuality. Another musical, Annie Get Your Gun, also pushed the limits of gender. Annie is a

Read More
1822 Words | 8 Pages

In the early 1970s, the Chicago Sun Times reportedly called the first gay pride parade “…just a bold but loosely organized stream of activist and drag queens who marched along the sidewalk …shouting and vamping for gay rights.” This statement reflected society’s view of homosexuals as "drag queens", a term traditionally used to imply a male who acts with exaggerated femininity. While “drag” is commonly associated with homosexual males, those who participate in drag actually vary in gender, class, culture, motivation, and sexual orientation. Disdain with the minimization of homosexual identity and demand for equal rights the University of Chicago Gay Liberation Front sought to take action to debunk and rid stereotypes of homosexual selfhood.

Read More
476 Words | 2 Pages

They were not considered viable women by this rubric. Radicalesbians argue that this status not only reveals the hierarchy of gender and all-women’s subordination within it but call for it to be a for a potentially liberating resistance to heteronormative categorization and patriarchy in general. Freedom (albeit limited) can be won through declaring one’s Self as beyond the grasp of heteronormativity as a Lesbian, an act of naming that becomes a resistance and disruptive act of independence within a hetero/male regime. (This is not a complete liberation though, since although no longer beholden to its reward system, Lesbians as existing as citizens of a patriarchy can still be negatively affected by its reach of

Read More
750 Words | 3 Pages

Heterosexual males strategizes their masculinity performance to impress both male and females, as a result, it rises their confidence. The article is reviewed in the context of supporting identity, gender and sexuality, and symbolic interactions. Firstly, the article is reviewed in the

Read More
1501 Words | 7 Pages

Now, because it was the 1980s, women were often stereotyped and

Read More
766 Words | 4 Pages

Southern lesbians had unique experiences compared to gay men because of how ideas of Southern femininity were tied to the concept of the Southern belle, but of course these experiences and how their lesbianism could be expressed was also heavily tied to race, class, and social status. The 1940s and 1950s in particular represent an interesting time to study the intersection of these factors because of World War II and its role in granting women more freedom. With more women entering the workforce, more women could be independent outside the home, both financially and socially without damaging their reputations . Previously, lesbians were disadvantaged because women, queer or not, existing in the public sphere without the escort of a man “would

Read More
1165 Words | 5 Pages

Some had been lesbians for as long as they could remember, some were not lesbians at all but lived among women who were, and others politicized their new lesbian sexuality, making the conscious decision to separate their lives entirely from men. This latter group of political lesbians believed in “a superior status for lesbians” in the feminist movement and imagined lesbians as one “homogenized…harmonious group.” Ironically, this mindset created divisions between political lesbians and women who did not

Read More
1336 Words | 6 Pages

Later on after saying “I am a woman” to remind themselves that they are acting as women and should not flirt with other women, since that is not an norm of the gender. As they assimilate to the gender, they are becoming more used to it, since they are repeating the same actions and thus becoming the gender of woman. As being hetero is still the norm, the film portrays a heteronormative situation, where the men cannot show that they like the women, as that is not the norm in the society and thus the film lacks a portrayal of homosexual norms, even though the men could have continued flirting with the women, and thus portraying homosexuality. If they would have portrayed that form of homosexuality, the movie would have showed less homosexual panic. Thus being more accepting of a society that is less

Read More
1075 Words | 5 Pages

Continuing the topic of how Sailor Moon further pushed gender norms would be how Amara possessed both traits of male and female, an article Questions of Gender in Sailor Moon, goes on to claim, “ we get into issues of behaviors that are more accepted or put down according to societal ideas of gender roles. Because someone’s sex plays such defining role in life, it becomes important information to individuals. It should be noted that while most societies only recognize male and female, but ideally more the opposite sex. ( Questions of Gender in Sailor Moon). Many fans are of the LGBT community, and Sailor Moon was a crucial turning point of their self-realization of themselves by showing a couple that was open about their relationship, their romance dazzled us all with wonderment and hope to find someone for ourselves.

Read More
1255 Words | 6 Pages

Since long ago, we have considered men/women who just looked like men/women (varies with cultures) as males and females and have sought for things that would strengthen the intensity of masculinity/femininity. In “Night to His Day”, Judith Lorber notes, “Even societies that do not cover women’s breasts have gender-identifying clothing, scarification, jewelry, and hairstyles” (Judith, p100), and says, “When unisex clothing… beards and mustaches for men also came into style again as gender identifications”. Judith Lorber, citing those historical facts, clearly demonstrated the fact that people seek for things that would solidify

Read More

More about Analysis Of Butch Please: The Dichotomy Of The Butch-Femme

Related Topics

Open Document