ipl-logo

Analysis Of Herbert Hoover On The New Deal

884 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Roosevelt new deal speech analysis

Primary Source Analysis 2
Herbert Hoover on the New Deal (1932)
Alice Banks

Content:
The source "Herbert Hoover on the New Deal” primarily focuses on the 1932 speech that President Herbert Hoover delivered as part of his reelection campaign against Franklin D. Roosevelt. The source gives information about the arguments Hoover made in relation to Roosevelt and his New Deal proposal. As explained in the source and speech, Hoover argues that Roosevelt's proposed New Deal program could result in socialism and the “destructions of the very foundations [of the] American system.” In the speech, Hoover makes the case that the New Deal is not a plan but rather a "contest between two philosophies of government." As mentioned in the source, Hoover argues …show more content…

Roosevelt, the Democratic candidate, and Herbert Hoover, the present president, served as the backdrop for Hoover's speech on the New Deal in 1932. The nation had been severely affected by the Great Depression, and Hoover was under fire for how he handled the financial crisis. At the beginning of the source, it is mentioned that “the economy crashed in 1929,” and how “the nation descended deeper into the Great Depression” afterwards. This made politicians struggle in office. As presented in the source, Roosevelt had suggested the New Deal, a comprehensive plan of government action to deal with the situation. However, Hoover was addressing Roosevelt's proposals in his speech mentioned in the source and defending his own record as president. According to Hoover, he claimed that the New Deal constituted an extreme break from American ideals and values and that it would result in the growth of the state's authority and the diminution of individual …show more content…

The records and information in the source related to the critiques and point of view of Herbert Hoover on Roosevelt’s new Deal plan could be considered trustworthy because it matches with other historical accounts and information found in articles, journals, and other sources written by trustworthy scholars on the promises of the New Deal to offer recovery of the economy, reform of the financial system, and a relief for the poor and unemployed. The information in the primary source also matches with the data of historical accounts related to Hoover’s denouncements and opposition to the New Deal. Herbert Hoover’s speech was based on his interpretation of the New Deal and this is a personal historical

Show More
Related

President Hoover Applauds Limited Government 1931, And President Franklin D. Roosevelt

811 Words | 4 Pages

Nathaniel Ortiz HISTORY 152 Professor Jonathan Rosenberg Section Leader Hamilton Craig December 2022 Paper #3 Documents: “President Herbert Hoover Applauds Limited Government 1931” and “President Franklin D. Roosevelt Says Government Must Act, 1933” President Herbert Hoover and President Franklin D. Roosevelt were both significant government figures during the time they were president. During the time both were presidents, the United States was in a crisis known as the Great Depression which lasted from the early 1930s to the early 1940s, ending during World War II. The great depression is known to many as a time of economic disaster. During this time there was a stock market crash, the money supply plummeted, banks failed, and

Read More

Comparison Of Hoover And Roosevelt's Policies During The Great Depression

928 Words | 4 Pages

One of his excuses was “ These shocks have in a large sense come from without our borders” meaning that it was some external country that plunged us into the great depression. Even though this was at least partially true, the American people didn't see it that way, and blamed hoover for most of their problems. This is painfully evident in the names of the “Slums” that formed as a result of the depression, commonly known as Hoovervilles. The Public was further outraged by Hoover and his plan to bring america back from the Great Depression. Hoover's plan was essentially a hands off approach, His party believed the country would fix itself given enough time.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Hoover And Fdr

802 Words | 4 Pages

The Great Depression was a time of strife and hardship for the American people and as expected, a remedy was called for. Hoover and Roosevelt were the two presidents at the time of this crisis and their philosophies for improvement, while sharing some similarities, had two very different stances. Hoover’s belief was held in the people and he thought that with the right motivation the country’s problems would be solved through one another. Roosevelt however thought that help laid within the federal government. He believed that America had a strong government exactly for the purpose of helping the people.

Read More

New Deal Dbq

208 Words | 1 Pages

From 1929-1939 there was a devastating dust bowl and depression sweeping through the United States in the wake of World War I, forcing the nation to search everywhere for a beneficial solution to the crippling unemployment, horrible distribution of wealth, and consequent pain. Franklin Delano Roosevelt, the president from 1933 to 1945, was one such person who searched for a solution, and started the New Deal, a radical theory for the time period. Although early on, FDR tried to distance himself from radicalism, as seen when he called out the strikers at the Republic Steel Mill for turning against the government, the source of help in the despair, his proposed legislation did not reflect this anti-radicalism. He began his presidency even, with

Read More

Compare And Contrast Hoover And Fdr

953 Words | 4 Pages

However, even though Hoover used these programs, they still did not succeed in getting the nation out of the great depression because his actions were too small to have any effect on the problem. In comparison, FDR believed in direct action; he thought that the government should get more involved in the economy in order to fix the nation's problem. FDR proposed the new deal, containing relief, recovery, and reform in an attempt to save the nation from the great depression, saying its a “new instrument of public power” (American Liberty League). FDR provided relief by spending “huge sums upon

Read More

Comparison Between Presidents Hoover And Franklin Roosevelt

713 Words | 3 Pages

The transition between presidents Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt marked the transformation from a weak, to a strong form of government, which became directly involved in the lives of the people. This was primarily caused by the difference in the executive leaders ideologies, where Hoover was more focused on individual responsibility and capitalism, Roosevelt was more concerned with immediate action based on government intervention. Overall, the New Deal sacrificed the amount of personal responsibility that the people had with their own economic security. The power of the federal government was strengthened, but the long-lasting effects based on the social and economic policies was beneficial for the United States. Herbert Hoover began

Read More

Franklin Vs Roosevelt Dbq

609 Words | 3 Pages

Roosevelt took office during the Great Depression and helped restore confidence to the American people. Franklin himself asserted in his inaugural address, "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself." He gave hope to the American people by promoting a domestic New Deal policy in response to a crisis in American history. In his book New Deal Thomas Riggs maintains that “The New Deal began immediately after Roosevelt's inauguration in 1933 and set out to relieve the suffering of the unemployed and impoverished, restore the economy to a healthy level, and reform the financial system in order to prevent future fiscal catastrophes.” His plan sought to control agricultural production, stabilize wages and prices, and create a large public works program for the

Read More

Hoover's Response To The New Deal

957 Words | 4 Pages

The longest and most dreadful downturn in economic history tossed millions of the hardworking people of America into poverty, for more than a decade neither the federal government or the free market were able to restore themselves from prosperity. Due to the Great Depression, an impetus was provided for President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal, this deal would forever change the relationship between the government and the American people. The New Deal was considered to be one of the most remarkable times of political reform in American history. In hindsight, it began to become easier to view the New Deal as the essential response to the Depression. However, the New Deal at the time was only one of the countless possible responses to an American capitalist system that had professedly lost its way.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Hoover And Fdr

462 Words | 2 Pages

Jaiah Jackson U.S. History 2 Mr.Grillo May 31, 2023 The Great Depression marked a significant turning point of the United States, and the leadership of Herbert Hoover and Franklin Delano Roosevelt played a crucial role in shaping the nation's response to the crisis. While Hoover and Roosevelt shared a common goal of restoring the country’s economic prosperity, their approaches differed significantly. This essay will compare and contrast the backgrounds, policies, and leadership styles of these two presidents, to better understand their impact on American History.

Read More

Comparison Of Hoover And Roosevelt's Collapse Economy

872 Words | 4 Pages

Roosevelt, who created ample government programs to aid both the economy and the people. FDR immediately began his prospective presidential career by differentiating himself from previous president Herbert Hoover, through his identification of Hoover’s errors and his provision of solutions to those errors. An example of this was seen in one of FDR’s candidacy speeches (doc E) where he argued Hoover made too many unnecessary departments, that had too much money tied up in them, additionally arguing that Hoover’s tax increases were unsuccessful in lowering the federal government’s deficits. The solutions to these mistakes were posed in the New Deal, a series of programs designed to provide relief, recovery, and reform. Relief programs provided immediate help to the economy and prevented further collapse, recovery programs were supposed to reinvent the economy, and reform programs were put in place with the purpose lessening the impact of future depression on the economy as well as individuals.

Read More

New Deal Dbq Analysis

1944 Words | 8 Pages

Beginning with President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s inauguration in 1933, the New Deal was passed in the context of reformism and rationalism as the United States proceeded through the Great Depression. The American people looked to the President to instill reform policies to help direct the country out of an economic depression, and thus often sought to abandon the society that existed before the Great Depression. Roosevelt instituted New Deal policies to attempt to combat this period of economic decline, many of which were successful and appealed to the American people’s desires. President Roosevelt’s New Deal is often criticized for being excessively socialistic in nature, thus causing dramatic changes in the fundamental structure of the United

Read More

Why Did Hoover Try To Stop The Great Depression

2279 Words | 10 Pages

Franklin Roosevelt didn’t reverse course upon moving in the white house in 1933; he went further down the same path that Hoover had blazed over the pervious four years.” Roosevelt knew in order to win the election he must appeal to the common and gain their trust. He ran with the idea of the New Deal. The New Deal would correct the shortcomings that the US government had when dealing with the people during the panic; it was also the plan in which the economy would be turned around

Read More

Explain What Problems Did The Us Face In The Vietnam War

1059 Words | 5 Pages

Millions had lost their jobs, their homes and they were hungry. The nation was in crisis and Roosevelt took advantage of this situation. During the 1932 presidential election, Franklin Delano Roosevelt promised a “new deal for the American people.” Roosevelt sent Congress several proposals to fight the Depression. These proposals collectively would become known as the New Deal.

Read More

How Cheerleading Is A Dangerous Sport

585 Words | 3 Pages

Majority of people in world watch some type of professional, college or high school sport if its football, soccer or even golf something about that particular sport is it’s the team that plays in your hometown or if you are actively playing the same sport or even if they just have the love for the game. A sport the generally has a lot of controversial is it is indeed is a sport is Cheerleading. Not only has cheerleading evolved into a large a actively participated since the 1970s where the Dallas Cowboy cheerleaders were first introduced and is considered a dangerous sport. According to a recent survey by the National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS), there are almost 400,000 individuals involved in high school cheerleading in the United

Read More

How Does Climate Change Affect Polar Bear Populations

571 Words | 3 Pages

Polar Bears are a very specialized species that has adapted relatively recently (around 150,000 years) to live in the Arctic where the living conditions are extremely harsh and finding food is difficult. Any changes to an environment like this will be challenging. Polar bears have been through much warmer times in their past when the Arctic was ice free in the summer and the tree line was 100’s of kilometers north of the current tree line, so this is not the first-time polar bears are experiencing great change. Change does affect polar bear populations, more in some areas then others. Polar bears rely on different types of ice (multi-year ice and seasonal ice) for hunting and transportation to get to denning and hunting areas.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Herbert Hoover On The New Deal

Related Topics

Open Document