ipl-logo

Analysis Of Holmes's 'What Is Gender?'

1010 Words5 Pages

Gender Analysis
Social constructionism starts at birth. The sex of the baby is a girl so the baby is put in pink clothing and given dolls to play with and dresses to wear. The same goes for if the baby is a boy. The baby is put in blue clothing and given trucks and trains to play with. The child is never given a choice at the beginning of their life because from birth they’re immediately told that they are either a man or a woman because of what biology has given them and society’s belief that you should be what you are born.
In “What is Gender?” by Holmes she states that most people like having the certainty of knowing whether their newborn child is going to be a boy or a girl and until then they have a hard time thinking of the baby as a …show more content…

What they don’t think about are the differences between women. Some of these differences that are overlooked far too often are race and social class.
Most improvements that have been highlighted in the history of gender equality were made by white, middle-class and educated women. This stems back to the early second wave feminism where they focused primarily on white, middle class women and male domination being the primary source of women’s oppression, but that isn’t the case at all.
The biggest problem that lies within feminism and women’s rights are that women still compete with each other. White women, whether they want to believe are not, have a privilege that black women do not have.
“Ignoring the differences of race between women and the implications of those differences presents the most serious threat to the mobilization of society. As white women…comprehend (Lorde 1994: 37). White women do not experience what black women experience and can’t even pretend that they do. Although white and black women both share that they are sometimes not treated equal to men, white women will always have a head start in this fight against inequality compared to black …show more content…

These types of feminists believe that we can achieve equality through means of legal force and social reform. In order for there to be gender equality, feminists would need to start with the social constructionism as states by Holmes, Oakley and Charles. The type of feminism that would bring about the end of categories would be Black feminism. Black feminists had to fight even harder than white feminists because of the underlying privilege mentioned before and they are always considered to be different, therefore part of a different category. “…I usually find myself a part of some group…oppressor (Lorde 1984:36). She states that she always finds herself a part of some group because she identifies herself as a “Black lesbian feminist socialist mother” (Lorde 1984: 36) It’s up to her to educate the oppressors but why is that even needed? Why can’t Lorde just say she’s a woman and not have to use so many names for all different categories? Black feminists fight to bridge the gap not only between the patriarchal racism and sexism, but within feminism as well. They’re called black feminists because of their skin color, but the fact is they’re still feminists and shouldn’t have to fight to not be

Show More
Related
1351 Words | 6 Pages

Audre Lorde's essay lacks explicit references to qualitative or quantitative research but establishes credibility through personal experiences and critical analysis of feminism's treatment of difference. She uses rhetorical questions and personal anecdotes to challenge biases and highlight limitations in feminist discourse. Lorde's logic points out the narrow scope of systems and calls for recognizing diversity as crucial for practical feminism. She challenges the audience to recognize the independence and mutual support that can arise from acknowledging differences, which is a logical step towards a more inclusive and effective feminist. Her essay has a significant emotional impact, as she urges the audience to confront their biases and the "terror and loathing of any difference" within themselves.

Read More
1238 Words | 5 Pages

In 1989, women’s rights were on fire, especially in the eyes of feminist Peggy McIntosh. At this time, she created an article titled “White Privilege: Unpacking the Invisible Knapsack” that inspected just that: white privilege. As expected, she forms an argument that argues against those who do not recognize their all-too-common- white privilege. After looking into the structure of “White Privilege”, a few obvious aspects make the piece successful in what it does. Overall, the format of the article allows for ease of a compelling reading.

Read More
511 Words | 3 Pages

In September of 1979, Audre Lorde, poet, spoke about the impossibility of dismantling the patriarchy through oppressive means. The black feminist woman, Lorde, who has cancer at the point of this speech, uses ethos, pathos, and logos in order to guilt the audience into making a change of how black feminists are represented. Ethos is the building of the author's credibility in order to become more persuasive because people tend to believe people who they deem likable or respectable. “I agreed to take part in a New York University Institute for the Humanities conference a year ago, with the understanding that I would be commenting upon papers dealing with the role of difference within the lives of American women: difference of race, sexuality, class, and age. The absence of these considerations weakens any feminist discussion of the personal and the political.”

Read More
876 Words | 4 Pages

The authors stress that the impact of patriarchy on women, along with issues of class and race, is significant. They view intersectionality as an aspect to consider when understanding oppression. By defining it as the connection between forms of discrimination like racism, sexism, and classism, they set the stage for their argument. They believe that looking at intersectionality offers an approach to addressing the hurdles black women encounter and stresses the need to consider various forms of oppression in fights for freedom. In their analysis, they show how intersectionality shapes their views on justice and feminist

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

Some may live through being sexually abused, live in extreme poverty, or even fall victim of being physical or verbally abused. Whatever the reason is, this book shows an outlet for these struggles. The only way we can help others fight these intersectionality issues is by knowing your privilege and using it to help the oppressed with no voice. In Brittney Cooper’s article “Feminism’s ugly internal clash: Why its future is not up to the white women” she states that “the future of feminism is not up to the white women. Not by themselves anyway”.

Read More
691 Words | 3 Pages

The generic feminist movement consists of “white, middle-class heterosexual women” (Tong 42). These women focus on their needs, and neglect the specific needs of many women of color, who are often of a lower socioeconomic standing. White feminists focus on liberating the oppressive “housewife role,” (Tong 214) and fail to even attempt to include minority women who may in fact dream of a life in which they were able to stay home with their children. White feminists “fail to realize that it is possible to oppress people by ignoring their differences” (Tong 214). This issue makes it difficult for many non-white women to relate to or desire to be a part of the feminist movement.

Read More
450 Words | 2 Pages

This is evident in her essay “The Master’s Tools Will Never Dismantle the Master’s House”, cited as a foundational work in the feminist movement. In this essay, Lorde asserts that the feminist movement often replicates the same patriarchal and oppressive structures it seeks to dismantle. She challenges feminists to consider the multiple forms of oppression that women face, including misogyny, racism, homophobia, and classism, among others. By acknowledging these oppressions, Lorde highlights the need for intersectionality within the feminist movement, in order to achieve true equality for all women.

Read More
3302 Words | 14 Pages

Overall, feminism has not held white women accountable for their continuance of racism and disrespect towards Black women. Feminism has failed to hold white women accountable for not using their privilege to advocate for the needs of all women. To enact change, white feminists must use their privilege to oppose white supremacy. White feminists must stop being afraid to lose their privileges in going against these systems of oppression. Instead, there is much to be

Read More
1090 Words | 5 Pages

It either includes all women, or it’s not feminism” (Makers). She frequently reminds individuals that it was disproportionately women of color, especially black women, who created the feminist movement. She contends that erasing black women’s integral contributions disgraces the founders of the movement and eradicates the efforts of feminism’s true founding

Read More
182 Words | 1 Pages

While white-dominated feminism frequently ignored or failed to appropriately represent women of color's opinions and experiences, black women performed significant leadership roles. White

Read More
477 Words | 2 Pages

Lorde mentions that she had heard this argument among white women saying, “the excuse given is that the literatures of women of Color can only be taught by Colored women, or that they are too difficult to understand, or that classes cannot “get into” them because they come out of experience that are too different.” This is a clear example of how oppressors differentiate colored women and white women. I think the white women that said this don’t quite grasp the concept that this literature of women of color can help unify us by empathizing with people that don’t come from the same experience as us. In no way women of color experiences are too “alien” to comprehend, it is the ignorance of the oppressor that refuses to look passed their distorted view of different races. I believe being taught different point of views from women of color could help enrich our culture in many ways.

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

The problem is not that white women who tend to run the anti-violence movements are different from women of color, but that they have the power to determine whether the intersectional differences of women of color will be incorporated at all into the basic formulation of policy. Thus, the struggle over

Read More
1784 Words | 8 Pages

“Unifying Difference in Lorde’s ‘Age, Race, Class, and Sex: Women Redefining Difference’”. The Morningside Review, vol. 78, no. 1, pp. 113-117. 15, May 2019, https://journals.library.columbia.edu/index.php/TMR/article/view/3449. Overstreet, Nicole, et al. “Navigating Sexual Stereotypes Across Time, Space, and Place: Exploring Black Women’s Practices of Resistance, Refusal, and Reclamation.”

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

Patricia Hill Collins’ “Black Feminist Thought” discussed the importance and power of the black feminist thought and black feminist critique, what she called the “matrix of domination”. Collins argued the critiques offered two main contributions: (1) they provided another way of looking at oppression through an intersectional lens, and (2) black feminist thought acknowledges and centers around the voices of black women, even in a field of predominantly white scholars. She argued that a subordinate group experiences a different reality than a dominant group and interprets that reality different than them; it is the connection of what a person does and what he or she thinks. This idea reminds me of how a dominant group, Whites, make assumptions about a subordinate group’s, Blacks, life experiences. Whites cannot explain those experiences of Blacks simply because they are the one group who caused the pain and suffering of Blacks, what they have experienced and are experiencing, from acts of discrimination, stereotyping, and prejudice.

Read More
923 Words | 4 Pages

Gender inequality spurred a hefty discussion, and for a good reason. Women are discriminated against in the media, politics, and the workplace, while men have countless advantages in every aspect of society (Eitzen, Zinn, Smith 223). Some will argue that there are not racial issues that still occur today. They believe the topic has been exhausted, and that there is nothing left to change. Naturally, these arguments are made by whites who have no idea what discrimination means.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Holmes's 'What Is Gender?'

Related Topics

Open Document