ipl-logo

Analysis Of Maggie Nelson's Essay 'Great To Watch'

1565 Words7 Pages

Maggie Nelson emphasizes in her essay “Great to Watch” that constrictive or restrictive boundaries contribute to the formation of liberating boundaries by allowing different sub-spaces to be created. If there wasn’t a factor limiting one’s ability to act as they wish, there would be no opportunity and need to find a sub space to act freely. Too much freedom and having no limitations on what one can do, makes the need to break free and be different disappear because there are no boundaries to what is allowed and what isn’t. This is evident in both “Selections from reading Lolita in Tehran” by Azar Nafisi and “The Naked Citadel” by Susan Faludi. In all three essays, the environment in which the people live have exclusive rules and standards, …show more content…

Maggie Nelson states how the third term “relates people to each other, with relation signifying the process of being brought together and given a measure of space from each other at the same time”(308). In Nafisi’s essay, the book club represents a third term being created by a liberating boundary. The book club is a safe space where the women are able to connect to each other while being themselves and even disagreeing on things. They are able to have shared confusion and opposing thoughts because they are sharing this sacred book club experience together. This represents a middle ground for the women, while they are living in such an age of extremity. In the essay, Nafisi brings up the term called “Upsilamba” which possesses no particular meaning but is used however the women chose to use it. Nafisi states, “Upsilamba became a part of our increasing repository of coded words and expressions, a repository that grew over time until gradually we had created a secret language of our own”(292). The purpose of the term “Upsilamba” is to show that there is not one distinct meaning of things, everything is up to interpretation and is allowed to have multiple meanings. For the women in the book club, this gives them a chance to use the word as they please and play a game that the liberating boundary makes possible. Being able to take …show more content…

Maggie Nelson makes it clear that the only way to not feel pressured and contaminated is to change people’s attitudes towards life. This is evident in Azar Nafisi’s essay and Susan Faludi’s where both groups of people create a liberating boundary from the harsh environments they’re currently living in. A few lonely woman living the Islamic Republic of Iran create a book club that enables them to escape from their totalitarian reality and act as they wish. Creating this safe space, liberated the woman and gave them the freedom they’ve been striving for in their lives. Making the choice to create this book club and act however they please with a disregard to breaking the law, they have let their positive attitudes allow them to be happy. In the Naked Citadel, it is relatively the same situation. The Cadet’s found liberation while being suffocated and confined in the pressures of becoming a “Whole Man”. While living in an environment that punishes emotional behavior, the Cadet’s look to their feminine qualities to feel liberated in such a reserved institution. Their attitudes allowed them to escape their required job, and feel and explore different emotions they were not able to. Restricting boundaries have a

Show More
Related
1303 Words | 6 Pages

In “Great to Watch” by Maggie Nelson, she emphasizes how the “third term” is a solution for how people should live in this age of extremity. It is a middle ground where people connect and become engaged with one another. Through the “third term” people have shared confusion and are on the same page with any situation happening. The world is in such an age of extremity where people are extremely overflowed with emotions or feel nothing at all. With the third term, an in between space is created where people must react and acknowledge things that are normally ignored and where there are no severe reactions.

Read More
1116 Words | 5 Pages

The experience of transitioning from one world to another can be prevented due to obstacles that can possibly be challenging which may result in the growth of an individual. One may encounter barriers that can prevent successful transition, thus having an effect on their perception and the perception of others. The remarkable play ‘Shafana & Aunt Sarrinah: Soft revolution’ -2010 by Alana Valentine portrays the experience of venturing into a new religious world as both protagonists exhibit their juxtaposing perspectives on devotion towards religion as the cultural significance of the hijab becomes a barrier between generations. This provides the audience with an insight into Muslim women’s world, exploring their own identities in regards to

Read More
1396 Words | 6 Pages

Felicia Cadawas Professor Denise Craft ENG 112 26 April 2023 A Rhetorical Analysis of Liberated: The New Sexual Revolution College is a time in one’s life that is meant for furthering one’s education and becoming a successful part of society; however, it would be naive to believe that learning is the only thing that happens during someone’s college career. The traditional path to college is one that begins straight out of high school. At this point in their lives, the newly graduated students are finally getting their first taste of freedom.

Read More
1975 Words | 8 Pages

Within any particular system, there is present an underlying motive for success in every sense of the word. While in some scenarios, that motive can be hidden beneath the desire to fit in, above all this, the idea of prosperity is the main factor in motivating individuals toward their goals. Susan Faludi, the author of “The Naked Citadel”, explores how at the all-boys college, students are pressured into conforming to the “Whole Man” standard where they develop brotherhood, a sense of structure, and belonging. When these men are able to develop such strong bonds with one another, several flaws come about. The majors issues at The Citadel, lie in their denial of women into the school, and the traumatic hazing new students endure.

Read More
1173 Words | 5 Pages

In each woman’s encounter with their personal challenge, this goal is expressed in a form specific to them. Audiences see this interest of reaching equal status conveyed through the work and intentions the women produce. The female characters present a side to themselves that, at times, switch the gender roles their society is accustomed to. At other points, women’s abilities to lead in times of distress or confusion establish themselves as the same types of leaders that society grows to associate with men. Finally, the female character’s voicing of society’s unjust contradictory standards for women furthers paints the idea of a movement towards equality.

Read More
1684 Words | 7 Pages

With the rapid-development of technology and economy, digital world endow people ability to obtain much more information than before. With the huge information base, people’s behavior might be multicultural and complex. Human behavior is the guideline of the society development. Any social change is related to the social behavior, social opinion and social ideology.

Read More
1263 Words | 6 Pages

Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi is a graphic memoir that reveals the life of a woman growing up in pre-revolution and post-revolution Iran, as well as her experiences in Western countries. In this book, Marjane recalls and highlights historical events that affect her life during her upbringing in Iran. These include the oppression of the Shah, along with the rise and effects of the regime. These events are integrated into Persepolis in order to showcase their effects on Marjane and the other citizens of her country. These events’ inclusion are important due to the context and understanding that they grant readers unfamiliar with the text.

Read More
1201 Words | 5 Pages

This point of view makes sense because memoirs could be taken as a one sided opinion. However, a memoir’s purpose is not to submit one side over the other, but just the author’s personal accounts. This memoir can be used to see how the Iranian Revolution affected a family against the new regime and new laws. Although it does follow a girl and family against the Revolution, it still informs the reader of all the historic events that were affecting the whole country.

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

Contracts not only exist between the business side of the world, but also between the social side. The social contract is the idea that sets morality as a compromise agreement that results in social benefits for all. I do believe the social contract exists in the world we live in. Whether it comes to a basic promise between friends to an agreement between partners in crime. However, the social contract seeks out to benefit equally between both parties of the agreement which ensures society will act according with their contract in a political and social setting.

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

Without God as a guiding presence in her life, Marji began to rebel against the ever-encroaching fundamentalist institution as much as possible. Under the pretense of religion, Iran strictly enforced new laws against social gatherings and all items of decadence, “They found records and video-cassettes at their place. A deck of cards, a chess set, in other words, everything that’s banned… It earned him seventy-five lashes”(105). This sudden loss of mediums to enjoy one’s self and prevalence of excessive punishment enforcing the declared moral code (132) were invitations to rebel for Marji.

Read More
1744 Words | 7 Pages

There is an established thought that every person must be an active participant in their life, and this is done by making choices; however, it is accepting responsibility that controls our lives and the people around us. Marjane Satrapi is an outspoken female, who is not afraid to stand up for something she believes in. As she grew up, Islamic Fundamentalists created strict moral and dress codes for the people of Iran. As a woman, she was forced to wear a hijab in a certain manner. At the time, Marjane was studying at an art school.

Read More
1130 Words | 5 Pages

It is also through Kincaid 's use of her setting, constructive atmosphere, and one sentence structure that some readers can better understand the mother 's belief of how productivity will lead to a respected life. After reading "Girl" readers are now made more aware of the direct relation between domestic knowledge and strict gender roles being forced onto

Read More
1321 Words | 6 Pages

Most nations can be identified with a particular culture; this is evidently important. A country establishes a culture which allows other individuals to understand the background on a country like Iran. Within the bearings of certain cultures, individuals can face dilemmas. In addition, these dilemmas can turn into social differences within a society. In the country of Iran Marjane Satrapi encountered many social discrepancies in her youth.

Read More
1436 Words | 6 Pages

After the Iranian Revolution, it became compulsory for women to wear the veil as the Islamic dress code and all women were removed from government positions, leading to increasing oppression and inequality in Iran. The use of black and white on the first page of the book creates a very clear image that a lot of people are unhappy with the new rules that are introduced by the government. The use of images shows us the oppression of freedom in a way that it would be hard to imagine with words. The first panel shows Marjane in a somber mood, crossing her arms to show her defensive thinking against the veil and the world. In the following panel, the girl’s expressions range from neutral to dislike or discomfort, which shows the general thoughts from people on how they think of the veil.

Read More
826 Words | 4 Pages

This novel is also autobiographical. Throughout history, women have been locked in a struggle to free themselves from the borderline that separates and differentiate themselves from men. In many circles, it is agreed that the battleground for this struggle and fight exists in literature. In a

Read More

More about Analysis Of Maggie Nelson's Essay 'Great To Watch'

Related Topics

Open Document