ipl-logo

Analysis Of Stanley Eitzen's 'Slaves Of Big-Time College Sports'

1479 Words6 Pages

Works Cited
Eitzen, D. S. "Slaves of Big-Time College Sports." USA Today (Farmingdale), Sep, 2000, pp. 26-30. SIRS Issues Researcher, Accessed 4 May 2018. D. Stanley Eitzen’s “Slaves Of Big-Time College Sports” attacks the fact the college athletes are not paid by using strong language and harsh, but accurate metaphors. From the very beginning of the article, Eitzen shows strong emotion to his strong dislike of college athletes not being paid. Eitzen’s opening sentence proclaims “Athletes are Dominated, Managed, and Controlled”(Eitzen). Eitzen continues showing his strong dislike when he compares large college sports to a plantation system(Eitzen). He even goes on to compare the players to slaves, and calls legendary Indiana men’s basketball …show more content…

Eitzen continues to call the fact the college athletes are not paid “ironic” and then begins to tear into the counter argument(Eitzen). He states that the NCAA views the athletes as amateurs, and that amateurs cannot be paid. Eitzen states that the view of amateurism is “injustice” and continues his strong, emotional tear into the counter argument(Eitzen). Finally, Eitzen shows more advanced statistics to support his claim that college athletes should be paid. He shows that most college athletes do not go pro, and proves that football and basketball student athlete graduation rates are at fifty percent or under. This proves his point that in order to continue their lives after college sports, these athletes need paid in college. Eitzen then proposes his plan on how to “change the system”(Eitzen). In short, this plan states that the starting point is to pay the athletes monthly so they can afford their daily needs, and then to increase the probability …show more content…

Eitzen’s article is very strongly spoken and attacks the counter argument with his slave plantation analogy, which really jumped out at me as unnecessary. Additionally, I disliked him calling Bob Knight a “slave owner”, because as a diehard Indiana basketball fan I appreciate Bob Knight and what he helped Indiana accomplish. However, I did enjoy the statistics for how much money was involved in certain deals along with his plan to fix paying college athletes. This was not included in my other articles, so that was very helpful. D. Stanley Eitzen’s “Slaves Of Big-Time College Sports” certainly had its highs and lows, but in hindsight I would have rather found another article with more quality information and less attacks on the counter

Show More
Related

Summary Of Ryan Vanderford Pay For Play

905 Words | 4 Pages

Ryan Vanderfords’ article published in the Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal explores this issue of whether or not college athletes should be paid beyond what they receive in scholarships. Vanderford is currently a law associate at a law firm in Los Angeles, California. He played sports throughout high school and college, so the author can relate to this topic. The payment of college athletes has become a more prominent issue in today’s society then it has been in the past. He argues that at major universities, student athletes help the school generate their revenue and therefore should be paid.

Read More

Analysis Of Steven Salzberg's 'Get Football Out Our Universities'

788 Words | 4 Pages

In Steven Salzberg, “Get Football out our Universities”, he makes the argument that football in universities are holding the United States back in the race of science. He believes if the United States eliminates football all together in universities we would focus more on what universities were originally made for, which is science and math.   Throughout the argument Salzberg uses different types of rhetorical strategies to compel his audience to sway in his direction. Although, he used strong rhetorical appeals, it was hard to agree with Salzberg due to multiple logical fallacies Salzberg committed.

Read More

Summary: The Case Of Paying College Athletes

893 Words | 4 Pages

It is an undeniable truth that college athletes nationwide have participated in an excessive amount of criminal activities compared to non-athletes. This issue has existed for an extended time, and prevailed especially during recent years. The history and continuity of this problem encourages most to pose the question, what can the NCAA do to stop this? There are multiple perspectives taken on how to act on reducing these crime rates, but all are similar as they attempt to attain the same goal. Many critics argue that these athletes wouldn’t commit these crimes if they were paid enough to cover necessary living costs or allowed to receive other outside payments, but a great amount of others believe that they are already compensated enough with the scholarships and other miscellaneous benefits they receive.

Read More

Summary: College Athletes Should Be Paid

979 Words | 4 Pages

Meanwhile, the NCAA makes $11 billion from a contract with CBS. The benefits that these players are collecting “have led to a black market for compensating athletes” (Birkenes and

Read More

Summary Of Should College Athletes Be Paid

471 Words | 2 Pages

Sports writer Joe Posnanski’s article “College Athletes Should Not Be Paid” argument over Dallas Morning News Editorial’s article, “paying them is fair, but it doesn't address college athletes' real need: an education” is more convincing to believe that college athletes should not be paid while receiving the benefits of a free education. DMN states that college athletes should be paid, because NCAA generate millions of income because of these players through private contracts. However, Posnanski’s claim that big time players already are paid through free college tuition, as well as covered room and board (Posnanski, 585). Even though DMN claims that college athletes go through difficult education process and may not be able to have chance to play professionally, he then correlated his source of information to the website of the NCAA, however, there is concern if this institution inflated the facts on the website (DMN). In contrast, Posnanski says argument of “College players are the reason why these schools generating so much money and they deserve a much bigger piece of the pie” is not really right.

Read More

Case Study: College Varsity Athletes Should Be Paid

356 Words | 2 Pages

With the revenue quickly escalating, college athletes appear more as employees because of the money they are generating for their school program (Berry III,

Read More

College Athletes Rhetorical Analysis

1103 Words | 5 Pages

As we all know, college can be very expensive. With the scholarships and grants, college student-athletes can go to school for free and get their day-to-day needs such as food, housing, clothes, etc. Ackerman and Scotts, purpose is to show that college is a learning experience and with the help of college sports, the student-athletes will have a chance to grow and be successful in life rather than being exploited. However, critics believe that college student-athletes should be paid salary, like professional athletes, because they want people to see the “athletes are the rule, not the expectation” (par 11). They want the audience to think that it’s a rule for student-athletes to go play pro after two years, will no expectation.

Read More

Analysis: Why College Athletes Should Be Paid

537 Words | 3 Pages

In his article "Should college athletes be paid to play?", Kenneth J. Cooper states, "These young men are laboring under strict and arduous conditions, so they really are laborers in terms of the physical demands on them while they 're also trying to go to school and being required to go to school. " This quote helps me prove that these students are actually workers that is bringing in business for the school. Athletes are the reason the fans are in the arena, the reason the school makes consistent money, and the reason they recruit

Read More

Annotated Bibliography: Should College Athletes Be Paid

904 Words | 4 Pages

Mike says”Students all over the world work hard at the sport that true love and don’t get a lot in return for it”. While college athletes may not exactly be employees, they are more than just students. Consider the life of a student-athlete, though. The average Division I football player dedicates over 43hours per week to his sport, meaning that he spends more than a typical American work-week training and playing football, in addition to his class work. Their work, which generates exorbitant amounts of money year in and year out, deserves Compensation.

Read More

NCAA Paid Case Study

1676 Words | 7 Pages

The fight for payment of college athletes has not been quick one as more and more issues keep popping up. The NCAA has never allowed payment of its athletes, but small steps towards the overall goal has questioned the NCAA’s past. Its’ decisions has stayed constant since its founding in 1906. The first issue in this decision would not occur until 1952 when the NCAA ruled to give The University of Kentucky the ‘death penalty’ for paying their athletes. This ‘death penalty’ is a one year program ban from participation, the harshest penalty the NCAA can give.

Read More

College Athletes Should Be Paid Analysis

1317 Words | 6 Pages

After graduating from High School one may choose to further his or her education through college. People do this for many reasons. Some people do it for professional benefits, while others do it for sports athletics. This paper will be focusing on those who do go to college for athletic benefits. Specifically, this is focusing on how these college athletes do not get paid and why they should be paid.

Read More

College Athletes Deserve To Be Paid

1538 Words | 7 Pages

College athletes put in a lot of time, effort, and work into the sport they’ve played since they were young, but they aren’t getting paid for it. These student athletes deserve to be paid because they put in countless hours of hard work and balance sports with school work. The first reason athletes in college do deserve to be compensated is because they don 't have time to fit in work with a school and athletic schedule. College athletes don’t have time to get a real job. Student athletes have a very busy schedule, they don’t have time to fit in a job.

Read More

Should College Athletes Be Unionized

1489 Words | 6 Pages

The argument made by these two professors state that Division 1 players qualify as employees under Federal Labor Laws. Since players are under this law, the McCormick’s feel players should get financially compensated due to the physical rigors and balance education simultaneously (Cooper, 2011). It’s unbelievable how this couple thinks Division 1 athletes should get paid. The privilege to attend a university that is costly on full scholarship should be more than enough. Furthermore, student-athletes received stipends as an allowance assist with their livelihood.

Read More

Essay On Should Student Athletes Be Paid

1121 Words | 5 Pages

A growing debate in the National Collegiate Athletic Association is whether or not student athletes should be paid. The controversy began in 2011 after three hundred coaches and athletes signed a petition to pay college-level athletes, and since then other athletes have made several more arguments. The NCAA has rightfully denied all of the requests, saying they include too much. To pay student athletes could be hugely expensive for colleges, especially because they would not only pay for each athlete’s degree and equipment, but also provide a salary and give bonuses revenue for tournaments. Moreover, college athletes should not be paid because there is not enough money, it takes away a student’s focus from schoolwork, and not every athlete is guaranteed a professional career after graduating; however it is argued that it they are already paid in a way.

Read More

Amateurism In Amateurism

1646 Words | 7 Pages

Amateurism in college athletics is an exploitation of the athletes who participate in National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) sports. The amount of work that is done by these athletes to help their respective institutions generate millions of dollars in revenue, goes seemingly unnoticed when identifying the substantial amount of money flow in NCAA sports and the amount of people, from stakeholders to alumni, that benefit from this source. Amateurism, the foundation of NCAA sports, has been in place for over a century of time dating back to the early 1900s. Any athlete who is making money for work they’ve done outside of their institution is not being exploited, however, an athlete can easily be placed on the other end of the spectrum when he or she is withheld from recognizing the true monetary value of their talents and likeness that are being used for the profit of the school or others. The NCAA is understandably satisfied with the continuous growth of its’ revenue each year, yet the problem they face of having people accept that “student-athletes” are just amateurs is growing as well.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Stanley Eitzen's 'Slaves Of Big-Time College Sports'

Related Topics

Open Document