ipl-logo

Analysis Of The Men We Carry In Our Minds By Scott Russell Sanders

869 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Theory about parenting styles

Men Lives vs. Woman Lives
In “The Men We Carry in Our Minds” by Scott Russell Sanders he discusses growing up and seeing different gender roles. He elaborates on certain aspects of growing up to convince you of his argument. Russel Scott spends time expressing that men live harder lives than women. Second, men are responsible for certain domestic responsibilities and financial support for their families. Lastly, he convinces us that its men’s fate, if you are in the blue collar world, that you and your body will age faster than someone in the white collar world. Throughout his arguments I agree with some of his statements about the lives of women at home, that they are more desirable, him relating to women’s struggle of not having the worlds …show more content…

His father is his prime subject because he sees what his father goes through at work and at home. Russel Scotts father was a laborer rather than a boss. When Russel Scott gets to college he sees that as his colleges fathers have white collar jobs in offices, where as his father has a blue collar labor job. In his story he dreads growing up because of the physical toll it took on his father and Russel recognizes the domestic responsibilities. He would have to support his family when in fatherhood or do even more work at home when he comes home from his job. Russel Scott shares that he wants to be more of a boss in the white collar world rather than blue collar because unlike his father, laboring all day for no gain in the work place is not what he …show more content…

Personally I believe that men’s lives were harder than women’s in the past because of the features they went through on everyday basis. Men had to work all day and come home to do even more work on the house or provide a hot meal every night. In trying to figure out which one was more difficult, I feel men’s lives were because their body’s aged faster than women and they faced a bigger toll in the long run. He has pointed out that men might have domestic responsibilities and I agree they do. After they come home having to do tasks around the house is one of the responsibilities. I don’t agree with Russel Scotts statement that this is every man’s fate because not everyone ends up in a blue collar job forever or some can start in white collar. For more opportunities to work your way up instead of staying at one economic

Show More
Related
216 Words | 1 Pages

In response to “The Man We Carry in Our Minds”, having a different point of view after discovering what I woman actually goes through in life can be related to a life situation. A man always put a title on what I woman can or can not do. I believe a woman can perform any work that the mankind has placed together rather it is welding, cutting grass, or driving truck. No man should label a woman wellbeing. The purpose of the story was to show how man stereotypes a woman.

Read More
558 Words | 3 Pages

“The Men We Carried in Our Minds” Essay In this essay “The Men We Carried in Our Minds”, Scott Russell Sanders put on display, for all to read, the most talked about controversy. Gender roles/norms of the twenty-first century remains an unavoidable topic along with the fight for gender equality. Sanders discloses the different perspectives he had throughout his life on this particular topic.

Read More
1196 Words | 5 Pages

Death and destruction caused by war can become permanently embedded in the minds of those who actively participated in combat long after the conflict has officially come to an end. Their memories, decisions, and personality can be influenced by what they experienced while serving in combat. The burdens that were placed upon them by horrible circumstances have the ability to become a permanent fixture, never leaving a person for as long as they exist. Tim O’Brien explores the origin of these burdens throughout one of his most famous works. Through a psychological analysis, it can be determined that O’Brien’s “The Things They Carried” connects the temporary physical burdens with the permanent emotional burdens experienced by soldiers during

Read More
1314 Words | 6 Pages

He says “keep watching me if I am, nobody has to convince me to do what I do. I do what I do, because I do what I do, because I’m built from something, and man didn’t create it”. In this part of the speech, I think he is saying that age shouldn’t define you, or you shouldn’t have limits no matter who you are or what your flaws may be. You must fight to overcome adversity. When he says “I do what I do, because I do what I do”, I think he means that the reason he is successful at what he does even at his age is because of what he does to stay at the top.

Read More
924 Words | 4 Pages

The mention of men is either absent or regarded with topics they usually aren’t associated with. Slaughter mentions men throughout her article, however they are placed in the position of the domestic perspective, rather than the breadwinner character. She also mentions men, such as her husband, throughout her paper, and states that they are able to maintain a work-balanced lifestyle more easily than women. Her approach to regarding men seems to always place them in the light of constantly being more privileged. Although she doesn’t necessarily place a negative connotation on the topic, she makes sure to reiterate her point that “men are still socialized to believe that their primary family obligation is to be the breadwinner” (Slaughter 10) and will continue to have an easier work-balance lifestyle until women are fully in power.

Read More
845 Words | 4 Pages

Deja Patterson English 3 Honors 2nd Block Mr. Colagross 4 January 2016 Doubt Analysis: Oppression of Women It is said that as a woman you are suppose to stay home, clean up, breed and raise the children. Women were not allowed to hold a higher job or success than men because they might feel intimidated and their ego might actually shirk instead of being inflated. The concept of how women are suppose to portray, have been suppressing women into these roles by both men and women since the earth has been created.

Read More
74 Words | 1 Pages

The struggles that young men and boy are going through the societal expectations of being a man will affect their life. According to Jennifer Siebel Newsom; the author of the documentary, The Mask You Live in, young males learn from their peers and their environment surrounding that “express compassion or empathy is to show weakness.” Well, in this enlightened 21st century, the pressure of being a man supposedly lesser, however, very little has changed.

Read More
371 Words | 2 Pages

Gender roles are prevalent in American culture. Yet, the gender roles have adapted through the social changes because gender roles are socially constructed. Previously, gender roles used to be distinct and defined, for example, women have babies and men go to war (Policing Gender). The primary income provider of the family has shifted, in various households, to the women, while the man stays at home with the children. In a study done by the Pew Research Center, in 1960s eleven percent of women were the primary monetary provider of the family.

Read More
969 Words | 4 Pages

Synthesis #1 Our concepts of gender are constructed by our biological characteristics and societal factors. In many societies, these concepts of gender, and the differences in men and women are rooted in tradition. The moment a child is born a kind of social construction begins. A child whether girl or boy will most likely be shown some behaviors on how they should behave according to their biological characteristics. Throughout history, we have seen the same stereotypes placed on gender, men should be strong and brave.

Read More
241 Words | 1 Pages

I believe the roles assigned to men and women in American society are cultural. Because of traditional gender roles men and women were expected to fulfill. For example, traditionally men worked outside the home in the workforce and women were the caretakers of the home and the children. But the traditional setup of the home has changed dramatically where work outside of the home is not just for the man. Women have successful careers and men now share the responsibility of chores around the house as well as taking care of the children.

Read More
509 Words | 3 Pages

From birth, men and women were born equal to one another. Both genders have the ability to share the same opportunities, and achieve whatever desires they choose in life. In our current society as well as the past, this does not entirely follow through. “Gender is a social construct that specifies the socially and culturally appropriate roles that men and women are to play” (Kearl 2011). Going along that “it is one of the most universal measures upon which status is based (Kearl 2011).

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

In nearly all historical societies, sexism was prevalent. Power struggles between genders mostly ended in men being the dominant force in society, leaving women on a lower rung of the social ladder. However, this does not always mean that women have a harder existence in society. Scott Russell Sanders faces a moral dilemma in “The Men We Carry in Our Minds.” In the beginning, Sanders feels that women have a harder time in society today than men do.

Read More
287 Words | 2 Pages

When it comes to if gender or social class being more important in shaping the life of an individual born in the United States today, I think that both gender and social class play a role in shaping the life an individual. “Gender refers to the personal traits and social positions that members of a society attach to being female of male.” Gender is important when it comes to shaping the life of an individual because in a social class there is a separation between people like gender. Gender isn’t just biological, gender is also based on the way someone acts and reacts to situations. In this chapter it talks about how males are considered more masculine and females are more feminine.

Read More
738 Words | 3 Pages

Directions: Please type your entire synthesis essay on this document. Be sure to leave time to proofread your essay to avoid losing points for grammatical errors like capitalization. Gender Roles in society is used to label a specific gender to have one specific role. Men are supposed to be the dominant one to go to work all day and put food on the table. Meanwhile, the women are the ones staying home and caring for the children.

Read More
1779 Words | 8 Pages

introduction Women in the contemporary labor market an increasingly holding positions of power. With equal opportunities as any other man, it could be argued that the female gender is increasingly gaining more notoriety within the modern contemporary world. In some societies, the dominant belief is that women should be allowed to participate freely, and equally to males, in employment outside the home. In others, there is the very different view that the appropriate place for women is within the home, and they are discouraged from participating in activities outside the domestic sphere.

Read More

More about Analysis Of The Men We Carry In Our Minds By Scott Russell Sanders

Related Topics

Open Document