ipl-logo

Analysis: Should Hazen Be Allowed To Limit Students Online Speech

975 Words4 Pages

Prompt: Should Hazen be Allowed to Limit Students' Online Speech

The purpose of a school is to educate students and to prepare them for their upcoming years. It is supposed to be an environment where students can learn valuable skills, as well as grasp a concept on how to tackle the world on their own. How can students learn to face the real world if they’re constantly being babied by their own school? As a senior, and a student of Hazen High School, administration should not limit what students post or say online. It violates our freedom of speech, our growth, and our opportunity to stick up for ourselves.

To begin, it’s understandable that Hazen would want to monitor what their students post online. Majority of the kids that attend high …show more content…

But, by neglecting the students their freedom of speech outside of school, it’s just plain ridiculous. For example, in a survey conducted in London, UK, 85% of British school teachers claimed that they were never a victim of cyberbullying (Document B). If our school is worried that students are threatening to harm our fellow teachers or specific students, that’s a valid reason as to why they’d want to monitor what we post. If a student is simply saying “Mrs. (insert name here) sucks as a teacher” on their twitter/facebook/etc, that’s their personal opinion. You can’t discipline that student for having an opinion. The first amendment clearly states that, “The United States Constitution prohibits…abridging the freedom of speech" which supports this situation as well. In addition, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) does not stand by schools monitoring …show more content…

It’s not only students who are affected by harsh words or actions, but teachers as well. What’s posted online can affect school life and life at home. For example, in J.S. vs. Blue Mountain School District talks about the effects of what was posted online. The article says, “Nunemacher had to tell the students to stop talking three times...he had to tell his students to stop talking about various topics about once a week…” (Document D). Although what people post online is online, it will always find a way to disrupt reality. In addition, the US Department of Education states that, “schools are responsible for addressing harassment incidents about which it knows or reasonably should have known” (Document G). Schools should be a safe place for everyone attending. Regardless of how petty an ignorant or hurtful comment may be online, schools work to create a welcoming environment year round. Some students use school as their sanctuary to get away from things happening in their own life, and if the one place they finally felt comfortable in turns out to be a crappy atmosphere like they’re used to, it won’t result in anything

Show More
Related

Censorship: The Case Of Tinker Vs. Des Moines

125 Words | 1 Pages

As seen in previous cases like Tinker vs. Des Moines, students have the right to political say, unless it causes disruption at school of students are promoting something that goes against the law. In the case of Tinker v Des Moines the students were not promoting anything illegal but showed their thought on the Vietnam War by wearing black armbands (Tinker). Argued in court by Kenneth W. Starr in the Morse v. Frederick case, he gave the idea that the foundation for school censorship was the case of Tinker v. Des Moines (Morse). The Justices responded back saying, that case was a different scenario as the students weren 't doing anything against the law while Frederick was encouraging the use of marijuana which was illegal (Morse).

Read More

Justice Hugo Black And Armbands Essay

477 Words | 2 Pages

One must have evidence that a disturbance has been make. Fear cannot take away freedom. In one of the court cases mentioned, it says, “the vigilant protection of constitutional freedoms is nowhere more vital than in the community of American schools,” (13). This is saying that our constitutional freedoms are most valuable in American school communities. The freedom of expression is one of the reasons that makes America a superior country.

Read More

Dbq Cyber Bullying Research Paper

769 Words | 4 Pages

In recent studies, researchers have found that on average 41.7 people have been bullied in their lifetime and 14.5 people have been bullied in the last 30 days(Doc A). The number of people being bullied has been increasing a lot of the past years and schools should do everything in their power to limit it and make the school environment better for everyone. Schools should be allowed to limit student’s speech because it disrupts teachers lives, it disrupts students lives, and it can physically and mentally harm other people and the people around them. The first reason why schools should able to limit students speech is that cyberbullying is harming teachers. In Document B, it shows that 51.1% of teachers get cyber bullied in their career and 38.6% of teachers had lower self-esteem because students bullied them online.

Read More

Doug Hann's Argumentative Analysis

1207 Words | 5 Pages

For centuries, the first amendment has protected each citizen across the nation to be able to express themselves freely. However, there comes a time when this right is not protected and occasionally the individual can be faced with consequences. This typically occurs in a learning facility or a place of business. Outrage has ensued because some believe that these facilities are too limiting when it comes to the first amendment right; thus making a mockery of it. Nevertheless, the limits exist for a reason; they exist to limit harassment and to uphold moral conduct.

Read More

Social Media Dbq

507 Words | 3 Pages

But, in order for schools to be able to do anything about the bullying they may need evidence in order to make a change or get the bullier in trouble. One reason why schools should monitor student’s social media posts is in Doc. E. Document E is a cyberbullying cartoon. In this cartoon there is a teacher and a principal, the teacher is in the principal 's office stating that somebody is cyber bullying him.

Read More

Essay On Brown V Board Of Education 1954

956 Words | 4 Pages

In 1969, the supreme court ruled in the students’ favor, stating that a student’s right to free speech does not disappear when on a school campus. As long as it causes no disruptions at school, students keep their right to free speech. This affects schools in a couple of ways. A student is allowed to exercise their right to free speech on any topic they would like. A school only has the right to put a stop to a student’s free speech when there is evidence that it is affecting school procedures and student learning.

Read More

Cyber Bullying Dbq

738 Words | 3 Pages

In Document C, K.K. created a group discussion after school on MySpace, she used her home computer and only spoke in the chat at home, outside of school hours. Although the discussion was about a fellow student, all activities took place outside of school so even if the school took measures to block websites or limit speech at school, there are no restrictions outside of school and therefore would be ineffective in limiting cyberbullying. In Document G, the assistant secretary for Civil Rights in the U.S. Department of Education says the actions that violate civil rights laws are harassment based on race, color, national origin, sex or a disability. Schools should address harassment incidents about which is knows or reasonably should know, as cyberbullying creates a hostile learning environment. In this case, online speech should not be limited, only harassment that substantially disrupts the school environment, especially when it involves

Read More

Censorship In School Libraries

298 Words | 2 Pages

The first amendment guarantees freedoms of religion, expression, assembly, and the right to petition. Censorship mainly violates the freedom of speech. The definition of freedom of speech specifically states “the right to express any opinions without censorship or restraint.” Therefore, the use of censorship at all needless to say in school libraries is a clear violation of our constitutional rights, which can

Read More

'Free Speech Is Flunking Out On College Campuses'

830 Words | 4 Pages

This is used to “protect” the students from hate speech and other things like it. The very concept of speech would be tested as student, Bryan Stascavage, wrote an Op-Ed in his college’s newspaper. The Op-Ed criticized the Black Lives Matter Movement’s use of anti-cop tactics. This well worded Op-Ed that didn’t aim to call anyone out or offend anyone started a wave of protest on the campus. Stascavage had actually hoped that from his Op-Ed he would have a “Constructive dialogue that college is supposed to nurture.

Read More

Bullying Dbq

446 Words | 2 Pages

The law regarding schools’ ability to punish students for disrupting the learning environments in schools needs to be strengthened. Schools in this day and age have been facing a more and more frequent problem of having to deal with harassment and bullying online for while the internet does not increase the amount of bullying it does provide a medium to do so that our legal system is not fully prepared to handle. The internet gives students the ability to put out opinions that can very easily make it to a wide audience and indirectly impact the learning environment regardless if there are at school or not. Teachers have even become targets of their own students harassment and it is uncertain whether it is the school 's responsibility to deal with it or not.

Read More

First Amendment Should Be Allowed In School Essay

649 Words | 3 Pages

Imagine a student put a poster in the school explaining what should be changed about the dress code, but the administration quickly tore down the sign because they did not like what it said. The first amendment in the constitution says that “Congress shall make no law… abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble… ” It is appropriate for a public school to limit what a student can say when the expression is not peaceful, when the message is harmful to others, and if the demonstration is a disruption to learning. To begin, a public schools should be able to limit what a student can say if it is a violent demonstration. For example, the article, “Do Students Still Have Free Speech in School?”, by David R. Wheeler states “... schools can punish any speech as long as they can cite “intimidation.” Intimidation is not a form of peacefulness and should not be tolerated at any school.

Read More

Cyberbullying: First Amendment And Legacy Traditional School-Casa Grande, Arizona

745 Words | 3 Pages

The school suspended the girls for ten days, the girls appealed the suspension through the court systems. The court determined that the girls have a right to free speech, the website was created off campus, and nobody was threatened and overturned the suspension. Now that we have considered the rights of the student that was posting what the reporting female called bullying comments on the facebook page we will consider LTSCG and the First

Read More

Should First Amendment Be Allowed In Schools

1255 Words | 6 Pages

Common curriculum in Schools teach students their first amendment rights however schools themselves take the steps to block public information on computers that students should be able to access. Public schools teach Constitutional rights in America, yet every school uses Internet blocker programs the prevent students’ free access to information. All public schools are required to teach a civics class yet these schools restrict the first amendment from students on the Internet. A common debate is whether or not schools should be allowed to censor information posted on the internet from their students. Students have the right to freedom of the press even if that means the information is biased or otherwise “classified” harmful.

Read More

Media Bias Against Students

450 Words | 2 Pages

Media bias School officials should use activities documented on social media against students because students are answerable for their behavior, they must remember their responsibilities to themselves and others, and issues of students safety must be addressed. Most schools care about the safety of their students. When talking about using documentaries against students by school officials it involves the safety of their students. A reason that it can conflict with that is cyberbullying. When you're at school 8 hours of the day it's the schools staff responsibility to keep you safe.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Free Speech And College Campuses

709 Words | 3 Pages

Byrnes, Benjamin. " Free Speech Protest Will Burn The Patriot Act." As stated by the author, restricting free speech in schools and campuses will restrain the Patriot Act. Students are entitled to free speech to give out their ideas and air their grievances. Through this they are able to promote and bring to the attention of key shareholders their endeavors in schools.

Read More

More about Analysis: Should Hazen Be Allowed To Limit Students Online Speech

Related Topics

Open Document