ipl-logo

Analyzing Christina Sommers 'Men-It's In Their Nature'

1801 Words8 Pages

Marissa Wonderly M. Schroeder English Comp. Oct. 26th, 2015 Boys—It’s Not Their Nature; It’s Society’s In the article “Men –It’s in Their Nature” by Christina Hoff Summers, the author supports the claim that men acting the way they are born and bred—that is, aggressive, competitive, and more indifferent to their feelings—is not an issue (Sommers 366). The issue, she argues, is that schools are trying to make boys less “like boys” and more “like girls”. Sommers believes that masculine qualities and behavior are rooted in men’s DNA and it is practically a hate crime to try and force them to suppress their manly tendencies. However, on the opposite end of the spectrum, men being “the way they are”, or rather, “the way they are supposed to be” …show more content…

In the third paragraph Sommer writes, “… The students sat in a circle while the girls read their impassioned reactions to the ‘haunting loneliness’ of the desert; the boys could barely suppress laughter…” (366). Her diction creates a teasing tone as if she is making fun of women for being emotional to the point of ridiculousness and generalizing men as not caring about feelings at all. Her insensitivity with this subject from the very start makes it hard for the reader, especially female ones, to see her side of the argument and take her …show more content…

Sommers states that schools across America have banned activities such as dodge ball, cops and robbers, army games with toy soldiers, and violent stories. All of these activities, she says, are enjoyed by boys (Sommers 366). Sommers then states that, “The goal is to resocialize boys, freeing them from male stereotypes… to promote genuine equality between the sexes –which for the reformers means sameness” (366). However, is the goal really only directed towards boys? Or is the focus to teach all children, both boys and girls, that violence should be taken seriously? According to the American Academy of Children and Adolescent Psychiatry (AACAP), “…efforts should be directed at dramatically decreasing the exposure of children and adolescents to violence in the home, community, and through the media. Clearly, violence leads to violence” (“Understanding Violent Behavior”). The banning of violent games in schools is not solely for the sake of targeting aggressive things that boys do and forbidding them in order to make young men gentler; violent games are prohibited because violence anywhere can cause violence in

Show More
Related
1741 Words | 7 Pages

Christina Hoff Sommers appeals that being a normal boy is a serious liability in today’s classroom. In “The War on Boys”, Sommers says that the “war on women” time has already changed to “war on boys” time, and boys cannot be boys at school today in American, because schools have little patience for boys’ natural behaviours. She has pointed out four facts that generally exist in the elementary school today: first, some loved toys and games of boys has been removed or changed in school to build a risk-free schoolyard; second, recess time has been decreased, even eliminated in somewhere; third, boys are suffering the zero-tolerance policies at school; fourth, boys are forced to be reimagining in the society. It was shocked that “many games much loved by boys have vanished from school playground” (Sommers, 39), and “Tag could no longer be played…we ban superhero toys at school…rough play is too dangerous…playing house, going fishing, doctors, office work and grocery store keeps dramatic play positive” (Sommers, 42). For young boys, paly is one way of learning.

Read More
261 Words | 2 Pages

In the essay “Masculinity as Homophobia” by Michael Kimmel, he brings up many points as to how men view masculinity as trying to be perfect to hide underlying insecurity. He then states that anything deemed less than manly (females, people of race, homosexuals, etc.) is ridiculed because of the way we view masculinity. Kimmel first brings up a story about boys on a playground, where you have to prove that you’re manly at a young age, and that it is essentially engraved into our nature that we must not be a “sissy”. This then stems off to how violence is created by this sense of manhood, since we must always fight and never run when conflict arises. Kimmel argues that we have gender coded responses to everything, and that if a man does anything

Read More
967 Words | 4 Pages

History has repeatedly given men privilege due to their physical advantages; yet it is these same advantages that have developed into “rules” or expectations that all men should conform to in order to prove their manhood. Michael Kimmel’s essay, “‘Bros Before Hos': The Guy Code” outlines the “rules” where men are expected to never show any emotions, be brave, act knowledgeable, be risk takers, be in control, act reliable, and be competitive, otherwise they would be showing weakness which is analogous to women. It is humiliating that men associate weakness with women; they should focus on the potential of the individual rather than their gender. Most insults toward men attack their masculinity because society finds it shameful for men to be

Read More
344 Words | 2 Pages

HW8: Exploration for Paper 4 In his article "Violent Media is Good for Kids," author Gerard Jones claims that violent media, a category that includes video games, has positive aspects. Jones believes, “’creative violence’—head-bonking cartoons, bloody video games, playground karate, toy guns—gives children a tool to master their rage”(Jones para.12). Video games have been played for almost fifty years, and while they have become much more violent in content in the last decade or so, research shows that the adolescent crime rate has actually dropped almost fifty percent since 1995 (Thierer para. 3). This suggests that perhaps violent video games may not have as negative of an impact on children as some suggest and can actually be seen as the

Read More
1769 Words | 8 Pages

Pascoe splits this chapter into two factions – The Basketball Girls and the Gay/Straight Alliance Girls. The Basketball Girls section starts off with a review of tomboy pasts: young girls that behaved like boys. This state of mind is often reviewed upon as revered, while the opposite (boys who behave like girls) is usually met with shame. These girls embody masculinity like straight white boys do: “taking up space, teasing girls, and positioning themselves as sexually powerful.” (133)

Read More
1217 Words | 5 Pages

In the last decades of the 20th century, Italy underwent a transformation towards a late modern society marked by increased mobility, a pluralism of lifestyles and decreased importance of religion and traditional networks. Neoliberal reforms led to privatization and the end of Fordism. While it came with the promise of social mobility, it diminished worker’s rights and led to unstable labor conditions. Neoliberalism and increased individualism stress the individual’s accountability and responsibility for his and her life, encourage the strive for happiness and self-fulfillment, and promote acceptance of individual freedom and rights. The downside is that workers are in constant competition, cases of mobbing increased and social cohesion decreased.

Read More
1718 Words | 7 Pages

Kerby Anderson, author of “Violence in Society,” states, “A child’s exposure to violence is pervasive. Children see violence in their schools, their neighborhoods, and their homes. The daily news is rife with reports of child molestations and abductions. War in foreign lands along with daily reports of murder, rape, and robberies also heighten a child’s perception of potential violence” (Anderson n.p.) Violence in this tale is extremely important because of the changing behavior in society.

Read More
1165 Words | 5 Pages

The author explains how the negative words that high school students use to call each other feminine or homosexual is done much more often among boys than it is between girls of the same age. She does in some ways explain how the issue of race matters some as far as constructing masculinity in a social context. For instance, African American males are not ridiculed for dancing, but white males would be called homosexual if they were seen dancing in public areas. However between races there is also ridicule, African American males may make fun of each other for acting in ways that a white male might act. Although much of the ridiculing and problems were between students, often times the teachers and staff members were involved in the process of reinforcing the wrong ideas of masculinity.

Read More
1008 Words | 5 Pages

This supported the concept of the act-like-a-man box, where men are consistently pushed back into a narrow box emphasizing masculinity every time they try to step out. I have the ability to enhance the parts about me I like and to play around with different looks, but men in western society do not without being ridiculed for it. I believe gender roles have a very strong influence on behavior. When one cannot do something outside of what is considered the norm without being questioned or bullied over it, most individuals will want to act in a way that keeps them from being confronted.

Read More
1348 Words | 6 Pages

Today, it is normal for modern technology to show many forms of violence. These acts of violence may influence children and teens to be more aggressive in everyday life. For example, I babysit a pair of twin boys. Their names are Devin and Gavin. Devin and Gavin like to play video games.

Read More
161 Words | 1 Pages

The documentary The Mask You Live In makes a strong case that the root of our foul culture comes from our society selling outdated and hazardous notions of masculinity. The overall image of the documentary depicts a culture that desperately needs to change. The film builds an argument about how early development of distinct attitudes in boys and negative reinforcement from authority figures and society have created men who are violent, callous, and self-destructive. We have been taught that the best man is the strong, silent type rather than the man who’s inclined to emote in a non-destructive manner when he’s upset.

Read More
691 Words | 3 Pages

They stated “Many Boys Today Define Masculinity Negatively” (Leonard Sax). They say boys are raised to be unbreakable, they don’t really have emotions and that most boys. They don’t want to do any ‘manly’ sports with girls. That is another reason why people go crazy when a girl plays video games. Majority of the boys do like to play with girls, but there is always they one guy that doesn’t.

Read More
1160 Words | 5 Pages

Gender is a biological characteristic as well as a social construct based on the characteristics of males and females. The way an individual sees themselves is termed gender identity. However, the expectations that society places on certain genders can be labeled as gender roles or gender-typing. It is a popular belief that children begin knowing if they are a boy or girl before the age of two years old. From early on everyone in a child’s life helps him or her shape their idea of what being a girl or boy is about.

Read More
1082 Words | 5 Pages

A study conducted in 2003 by Missouri Western State University on children aged 5 to 12 showed that children become more violent after being exposed to violent programs. Their behavior was recorded before they were shown the cartoon clip of “Tom and Jerry” and their behavior following the cartoon was also recorded. Each child in the study displayed more violent behavior in the final recordings. If a child is not the one behaving more violently, he or she can become too afraid of others, or desensitized to the seriousness of violence. Children start to think that violence is an acceptable way to deal with problems.

Read More
1183 Words | 5 Pages

There are games that literally replicate and give people the ability to score points for doing the very same thing that these students are doing inside schools, where you get extra points for finishing someone off who’s lying there begins for their life.” ( 6) There are several ideas that say young people benefit from these violent video games “Surprisingly, playing video games can help our physical, mental, and emotional health.” It helps them to improve hand eye coordination and thinking ability. These benefits are not worth the risk of being influenced by violent video games. (7) All in all the research and officials say that violent video games affect how children, teenagers and young adults act.

Read More

More about Analyzing Christina Sommers 'Men-It's In Their Nature'

Open Document