ipl-logo

Argumentative Essay: Is Afghanistan Another Vietnam?

1821 Words8 Pages

Is Afghanistan Another Vietnam?
“If you had to pick two of the hardest countries to operate in, Vietnam and Afghanistan would be high on the list.”
Nathan Packard, Marine Corps Historian
During the Bush administration, President George W. Bush applied the Vietnam analogy to the situation in Iraq to address the growing discontent with the US. occupation and military involvement in other countries. Since then this Vietnam analogy has been utilized by United States news reporters and journalists to describe the US’s position in Afghanistan. However, the validity of the application of the Vietnam analogy to Afghanistan is not sound. The context in which the United States entered the war, the rationale for its commitment there, and the circumstances …show more content…

First, Vietnam and Afghanistan are very different countries, one located in Southeast Asia and the other in the Middle East. Vietnam has a strong national identity derived from strong anti-Chinese sentiment developed over thousands of years. Afghanistan is extremely diverse with over 30 different languages and 14 ethnic groups, leading to a weaker national identity. Second, the United States is not a main actor in both of the wars. In the Vietnam War, North Vietnam’s North Vietnamese Army (NVA) and guerilla force Viet Cong (VC) fought against the government of South Vietnam and its principal ally the United States. In the Afghanistan War, the United States invaded Afghanistan to fight against the Taliban, its allies and its militias. The United States eventually supported the Government of the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan and provided the country with aid and infrastructure support. Third, the United States did not have the same motivation for entering the Vietnam War as the Afghanistan War. The United States involvement in the Vietnam War was rooted in its international fight against communism and corruption during the Cold War. It was essentially a preventive war while the Afghanistan War was a reactionary one. On September 11, 2001, also known as the 9/11, a series of airline hijackings and suicide attacks were committed by 19 militants associated with the Islamic extremist group al-Qaeda. This was the deadliest terrorist attack on American soil in U.S. history, taking the lives of 2,977 people. After 9/11 the U.S. invaded Afghanistan in October 2002, with President Bush titling it a “war against terrorism.” The United States authorities demanded that the Taliban regime deliver them all the leaders of al-Qaeda “who hide in your land.” Fourth, the motivation behind the wars for the

Show More
Related
457 Words | 2 Pages

The Vietnamese War was fought between the United States against North Vietnam. The war with the Hmong was not known to the world. The war impacted Laos and the people in it today because of the hatred between the Hmong and Laos, divided families, and impacted a lot of innocent lives. Even still to this very moment most Hmong people who are

Read More
583 Words | 3 Pages

The Vietnam war is known as the longest war in the U.S. history. It was situated in Vietnam, a country located in the southeast of China, during the cold war. Vietnam was a French colony and like in most colonies, the natives (Vietnamese people) were not treated right; Ho Chi Minh, that later became north Vietnam leader, asked for help to western countries, which was denied. The Soviet Union offered to help Vietnam, however, in order to do so they had to become communists, the country was divided into North Vietnam (communist) and south Vietnam (democratic), eventually North Vietnam wanted to take over South Vietnam. The U.S. got involved in Vietnam to keep communism from spreading, thus the country was divided because not all Americans agreed with the participation in this war, and the division between Americans made the U.S. foreign policies to change.

Read More
1558 Words | 7 Pages

Bibi Barrera APUSH 3/13/18 P1 Short Answer Rewrite The Vietnam War was a war that happened to last 20 years. The United States did not agree with the spread of communism so they sided with South Vietnam. The U.S happened to get involved due to wanting to stop the war because they didn’t want it to spread. It impacted the world due to it being the first war to become televised and people were upset because people were dying.

Read More
1525 Words | 7 Pages

The Vietnam War was fought between the North and South Vietnamese over Communism. The North pushed for a communist regime while the South favored a more democratic government. During the time of this war, the U.S. was pushing towards containing Communism, and vowed to support any nation resisting communism. Although America’s policy of containment had good intentions, this often led to the support of corrupt leaders and governments. President Ngo Dinh Diem of South Vietnam was Catholic and did not lead well.

Read More
2557 Words | 11 Pages

The Vietnam War, which lasted from 1955 to 1975, was one of the most divisive and controversial conflicts in American history. It was a military conflict between the Communist North Vietnam, and South Vietnam, with the United States and other Western powers supporting the Southern Vietnamese. The war was fought in the context of the Cold War because the United States feared that Communism would spread throughout Southeast Asia if North Vietnam managed to take control of the entire country. The war had such a profound impact on American society, and still remains a subject of intense debate and analysis today. After World War I, Vietnamese leader, Ho Chi Minh, expressed many grievances against the French colonialists.

Read More
1222 Words | 5 Pages

The Vietnam Was devastating time for not just America, but worldwide. This War lead to 1 million, four hundred and fifty thousand casualties from Vietnam, Cambodia, and Laos. This devastating number only increased when you also take into account the other side, the Americans, with more than 50,000 casualties. One may argue that a major reason the Vietnam War occurred was due to the disagreement between the Soviet Reds and the Great Uncle Sam after World War 2. The Reds wanted to spread communism, this left Americans not too pleased because they were capitalist all the way.

Read More
732 Words | 3 Pages

November 1, 1955 marked the beginning of the conflict in Vietnam. The Vietnam War was a fight against the Domino Theory, or the idea of the spreading of communism. Northern Vietnam was a communist territory, and the United States government feared that Southern Vietnam would soon become a communist state as well. In order to prevent this from happening, the US government drafted many young Americans to fight against Northern Vietnam. At first, many Americans supported the country’s involvement, though as time went on, many people became weary of the country’s involvement in the battle.

Read More
1353 Words | 6 Pages

The Vietnam War was fought to stop the spread of communism that threatened the United States way of life. War strategies that were used were harsh, major battles bloody, and war opposition at home was high. The leaders of our countries decisions caused devastating effects that not only shook our country but the whole world. The United States had fought wars in the past to stop the spread of communism.

Read More
1104 Words | 5 Pages

With this constant warfare mind set that the United States has maintained, it was not very shocking that there was engagement in the Afghanistan War while reasons for entering were valid. In Sebastian Junger's War and Philip Caputo's A Rumor of War, the effects of war, transformations

Read More
548 Words | 3 Pages

I agree that the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan was driven by Soviet regional concerns, and was not based on the Cold War rivalry with the United States. I did a lot of research on this topic as well as read The Hidden War book. On page 4 of The Hidden War it states, “there are all kinds of theories as to what actually triggered the fateful

Read More
496 Words | 2 Pages

The Vietnam war was preceded by a very turbulent time in our history with problems here in the states such as racism, women’s rights, and a president being shot. But in Vietnam they were going through a civil war, which they had done before, but not to this extent, this time they got the U.S.S.R. involved. It was communist Russia and North Vietnam against South Vietnam. The U.S. started to get

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

There are several differences to note between the U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War and the Canadian involvement in the Afghanistan War. The first major difference is that The United States had conscription during the Vietnam war, which fueled massive antiwar protests, some even leading to the death of protesters. This was not true for the Canadian troops heading to Afghanistan, Canada has an all-volunteer armed force. Yes, there were some protests against Canada’s involvement in the Afghan War, but these were much smaller and more infrequent than anti-Vietnam protests. Anti-Vietnam protests became escalated by the public 's discovery of several massacres of Vietnamese civilians, including women and children.

Read More
533 Words | 3 Pages

The Vietnam War was the most controversial war in American history. The United States promised to help any country who was threatened by communism. In the beginning, many Americans supported the United States getting involved and helping South Vietnam. When the truth started coming out and people realized the war was not almost over, people’s feelings changed toward the idea of war. Many Southern Vietnamese people were killed because the American soldiers couldn’t tell who was who.

Read More
1056 Words | 5 Pages

Afghanistan and the United States of America are both countries that first formed around the same period of time. The first time the region of modern day Afghanistan was united was in 1823 by the Emirate of Afghanistan. Similarly, the United States of America first declared independence from Britain in 1776. However, these two countries took completely different paths in the way they have developed. Although, both countries have similar governments, there are a lot of differences between the economy and infrastructure, and history and culture of Afghanistan and the United States of America

Read More
531 Words | 3 Pages

During the Vietnam War, The United States went into the war thinking that the only enemy was the North Vietnamese, and the South Vietnamese were all their ally. However,

Read More

More about Argumentative Essay: Is Afghanistan Another Vietnam?

Related Topics

Open Document