ipl-logo

Argumentative Essay On Cherokee

464 Words2 Pages

The white settlements expanded west, they threatened to take over Cherokee land in the southern U.S. The historical question is trying to tell if the Cherokee should leave or stay in their territory. People might disagree with this because the Cherokee’s do not want to leave their homes and want to stay to fight. People think they should stay because it’s their land and it should not be taken away from them and how they should stay to fight for their territory. The Cherokee have had this land for a while, since before they could remember. “We have taken care of this land respectfully. It contains the ashes of our father.” They have had the land for a long time, do not think they should just give it up. They respected this land, it contains the burials and ashes of their fathers. The CHerokee need to stay and fight for what they believe in because they need to show the government that they own this …show more content…

“We cannot agree to give it up for a far inferior land. If you take away our liberty and country, you will cause our nation to fall apart and be humiliated.” When protesting, the Cherokee want to keep their land. While the Cherokee are pushed away they are being humiliated. People will slow down or stop for the Cherokee’s ever becoming civilized and in learning the christian religion.
If the Cherokee leave and go to the land they are being forced to go to, they do not have any control over what happens next. “They will be ruled by laws that they did not help make and which they do not understand.” Boudinot is trying to say if the Cherokee leave they could be out ruled and forced to do things by the government all because the Cherokee are on new land owned by the U.S. If the Cherokee leave they will not know what is gonna happen to them all because the U.S. government wants their land. People should reject this because the Cherokee need to believe in themselves to fight for what is

Show More
Related
413 Words | 2 Pages

In 1742 the chief of Onondaga of the Iroquois Confederacy knew that his land that the people shared would become more valuable than it has ever been. (Doc B)The reason for this was because the “white people” also known as the Americans wanted the land of the chief. The feelings of the Chief result in complaining to the representatives of Pennsylvania, Maryland and Virginia,

Read More
303 Words | 2 Pages

Indians had lived in the same areas for many years and had become much more accustomed to being civilized and had even started schools, making laws and becoming farmers. But all of that didn’t matter, there was increasing pressure to open up the area the Indians inhabited so the white men could settle there. The Indian Removal Act stated that all Indians must move to lands west of the Mississippi River, Jackson said the Indians would receive money for the land they lost and that all expenses would be paid for. The act was supposed to be voluntary but they were pressured to go and the tribes that did not go peacefully were forced. While most tribes did go peacefully the Cherokee Indians wanted to fight the Removal Act and took it to the Supreme

Read More
609 Words | 3 Pages

Have you ever been told what to do even though the law says otherwise? Was it easy or fun, but the same thing happened to the Cherokees and it was harder than what you had to go through because there wasn't as much help back then. The Cherokees were told to either move off of the US land or to follow the US rules. The Indian Removal act of 1830 was not justified because Andrew Jackson did not follow the constitution that he signed, the US forced the Cherokees to leave, and the US compelled the Cherokees to rebuild their nation.

Read More
875 Words | 4 Pages

White man promised to keep them well supplied with everything necessary to comfortable living. But they didn't kept their promise. This explains that white man did what they liked with Indians and lived where they liked and moved the Indians. So basically they made the Indians believe them and moved them to west and never did as they said they well. However, white man's idea was to remove the Indians and take over their land.

Read More
858 Words | 4 Pages

The statement, "We solemnly and earnestly protest against that false treaty," supports the author's argument that the Cherokee Nation was deceived and forced to move even further west. However, the strength or weakness of this source remains unclear as it is unclear whether the Cherokee Nation didn't understand the Treaty or if they were intentionally tricked into

Read More
1184 Words | 5 Pages

According to the textbook, it states, “The law did not say that the Indians should be removed by force, and... An angry Jackson disagreed. Groups that refused to move west voluntarily were met with

Read More
174 Words | 1 Pages

The Cherokee had several major objections to moving to new locations. The Cherokee wanted to stay instead of moving to a place such as Arkansas because it is “unknown” to them and is already occupied by the Indians. Therefore, the Indians would look at the Cherokee as if they did not belong or be seen as an enemy when the Cherokee meant no harm. Also the Indians were not really supplied by wood and water, which was bad for the Indians because they could not live as agriculturalists, but also bad for the Cherokee because they were worried there was not a lot of land for farming. Furthermore, the Cherokee had major objections because the people around the Cherokees were so different compared to them.

Read More
1334 Words | 6 Pages

They hoped that by agreeing to the government’s terms they would get to keep some of their land, they could protect themselves from the whites, and they would be viewed as a more civilized nation. But their hopes were of no avail. Just like the other tribes, the Cherokee were forced to

Read More
554 Words | 3 Pages

Hundreds of Cherokees were moved from their land by white people for selfish reasons. The Cherokee lived in northern Georgia. The Cherokee were not citizens of the American so they couldn't vote. The didn't have any rights. They had a lot of land and access to the rivers and lakes.

Read More
1239 Words | 5 Pages

As their chief explains, "But if we are compelled to leave our country, we see nothing but ruin before us. The country west of the Arkansas territory is unknown to us...with whom we have lived in perfect peace for the last forty years…to bid adieu to our homes, our farms, our streams, and our beautiful forests? No... On the soil which contains the ashes of our beloved men we wish to live" (Document G). Speaking for all Indians, they never wanted to leave at all, it would only hinder the work they've made through 40 years of peace.

Read More
1824 Words | 8 Pages

Ross related that it was more than just the taking of their land. Those expanding the frontier were acting like barbarians, destroying and pillaging, while the federal government, that had pledged to protect the Indian in exchange for severe limits on their military forces and their foreign relations.” Ross was also pointing out that it was not just encroachment with people attempting to take their land but it was much bigger than that when people were stealing Cherokee property and destroying their stuff. The representatives of the Cherokee complained on a normal basis they were just asking for the US to uphold its part in the many treaties that they signed with the Cherokee

Read More
152 Words | 1 Pages

Our homeland taken away Betrayed so easily at the thought of gold By those we thought would never sway The Indian Removal Act became a well-known name Relocating us west from our Cherokee homeland However, they weren’t all the same Some supported, while others pitied

Read More
1064 Words | 5 Pages

The removal of the Cherokees threatened

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

Unfortunately, the Cherokee knew if they wanted to keep their land it would not be worked out

Read More
402 Words | 2 Pages

In the letter, the Cherokee nation addresses several reason on why they should not have to move. One reason is that the new land if foreign to them. They are being expected to pack up, leave everything they know, and move to the unknown. Another reason to add on to the above is that there are other Native American tribe already

Read More

More about Argumentative Essay On Cherokee

Related Topics

Open Document