ipl-logo

Battle Of Lake Trasimene Case Analysis

1057 Words5 Pages

The Battle of Lake Trasimene is reviewed and analyzed to extract military lessons learned for use by military commanders when planning operations. The scenario preceding the battle are identified and the battle itself is outlined in chronological order. The successes and failures of Hannibal Barca and Consul Gaius-Flaminius are deconstructed and evaluated. The identification of cause-effect in relation to each step of the battle is exploited to develop consistent relevant lessons pertaining to war. An alternate outcome for the battle is proposed and analyzed by conducting scenario-driven backwards analysis. The hypothesis of the validity of the alternate outcome is tested against facts and reasonable assumptions which provide parameters …show more content…

This statement can apply from making a personal decision about buying a house, to deciding whether or not to go to war. While the exact same situation may not occur, history provides a solid case study as to what happened, why it happened, what decisions were made, and what were the results of those decisions. In the case of military commanders, analysis of historical events can lead to better decision making which can save lives, alter battles, and win wars. When leaders make faulty decisions it can result in the failure of a mission and the loss of lives. The Roman army was powerful and had seasoned commanders and soldiers serving throughout its ranks. They had fought and won countless battles, but even with all this experience, even one fault can result in defeat. One such example is that of the Roman army in its skirmishes and battles with the Carthaginian army during the Second Punic War. The Roman army suffered defeat during several battles throughout this war. One instance of this was the Battle of Lake Trasimene (Cottrell, 1992). While several factors contributed to the victory by the Carthaginians and the defeat of the Roman army, there is one cause that served as a basis for their failure. Had the Roman army effectively employed intelligence and reconnaissance assets, it would have won the Battle of Lake Trasimene, and ended the Second Punic War. The Battle of Lake Trasimene took place in late June of 217 BC along the north side of what is today known as Lago Trasimeno in the Province of Perugia, Italy. This battle consisted of two major armies, the Roman army led by the Roman consul Gaius-Flaminius, and the Punic Carthaginian army and its allies led by Hannibal Barca (Grundy,

Show More
Related
171 Words | 1 Pages

The Battle of Trenton was one of the battles of the American Revolution. The battle was fought in the morning of December 26, 1776. George Washington was the commander of the American Forces. Colonel Johann Rall was the leader for the Hessians. The war took place near Trenton, New Jersey.

Read More
1098 Words | 5 Pages

Sean Green Block: 5 APHUGE The Fog of War Study Guide Summary: The documentary is about Robert McNamara, a World War II Veteran who was the ex-owner of Ford Motor Company and served as Secretary of Defense for President Kennedy and Johnson during the Vietnam War. This film gives Robert Mcnamara a chance to explain his life and actions before and during the Vietnam War and his eleven lessons of life.

Read More
1388 Words | 6 Pages

Throughout this article I will examine the background and details of the Battle of Saratoga and look at the insurmountable leadership from Major General Horatio Gates. In the late summer

Read More
213 Words | 1 Pages

Battle of Trenton The battle of Trenton occurred on December 26, 1776 in Trenton, New Jersey. George Washington and his troops were retreating from New York after the British troops invaded. The continental army had to cross the icy and cold Delaware River.

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

The First Punic War occurred when Rome sent an army to Sicily. Carthage defended this island because they believed Sicily was rightfully theirs, and the Romans were threatening to overtake it. Carthage’s one advantage on Rome was their great navy. In order for Rome to be on equal footing with the Carthaginian navy,

Read More
272 Words | 2 Pages

Although the beginning of the second Punic war, Hannibal seemed to be leading victorious throughout Italy after crossing the Alps into Roman territory, the outcome of the Punic war led to the downfall of Carthage. During the second Punic war, Hannibal fought the Romans in the battle of Cannae, where “Poylbius estimates Hannibal had close to 40,000 infantry and 10,000 cavalry versus the Roman force of 80,000 infantry and 8,000 cavalry” (History Extra, 2009). It was one of the most famous battles in military history and is said to be taught in modern military colleges because of it's significance. Hannibal was outnumbered but used his cunning tactics to close his troops around the charging Roman soldiers to slaughter them in this battle.

Read More
787 Words | 4 Pages

“History shows that there are no invincible armies and never have been. ”- Joseph Stalin. Over the centuries, many leaders have risen and fallen, including Hitler, to whom Stalin is referring in the previous quote. If you were to break it down, all leaders have fallen out of favour because of little mistakes, be it

Read More
924 Words | 4 Pages

The first and second Punic wars occurred over a period of around 60 years in the mid and late second century B.C. Although this is a relatively short timeframe in comparison to the vast history of the Roman Empire, these wars would shape the fundamental outlook on Roman foreign policy for years to come. However important to the Romans, though, these repeated military conflicts would spell the end for their adversaries – the Carthaginians. Though at times in the fighting the Carthaginians definitively maintained an upper hand, I assert that the Romans were destined to win both wars. The Carthaginians simply could not overcome the Roman’s intrinsic courageousness, their superior political and armed forces organization, and, most importantly, the manpower the Republic possessed.

Read More
591 Words | 3 Pages

This action was not just a conflict created at the level of political confrontation against Marius, but it also showed the role the army had already taken over. The army lost its national spirit, it took a business form and became a tool in the hands of Sulla used in order to serve his ambitions. It led to wars not intended for the greatness of Rome

Read More
568 Words | 3 Pages

On October 24 year 1917 combined army of Germans and Austro-Hungarians descended across the Isonzo River at the town of Kobaird. The combined Army made it all the way to the Piave River . Cadorna’s troops were mostly dispersed too far advanced for there to be an adequate defense. This greatly contributed to the battle becoming a disaster along with some other minor details. Cadorna have been on leave for most of October and his immediate subordinate was severely ill at the time.

Read More
621 Words | 3 Pages

“I am not afraid of an army of lions led by sheep. I’m afraid of an army of sheep led by lions” once stated Alexander the Great. This quote once stated by Alexander himself represents a lot more than what he blankly said. What Alexander meant by this is that it does not matter how strong your army is it matters how strong your leader is. This quote is wrong because the leader could be more experienced in war and killing people, than the army.

Read More
957 Words | 4 Pages

“Rommel, Rommel, Rommel! What else matters than beating him?” This famous quote by Prime Minister Winston Churchill describes best how Field Marshal Erwin Rommel was perceived by his adversaries in the summer of 1942: “he had an uncanny ability to dominate the minds of his adversaries.” This paper will provide a brief book review of An Army at Dawn before focusing on Rommel – the famous “Dersert Fox” – and his leadership capabilities. Thereby, Rommel´s traits, characteristics and style will presented through the lens of leadership concepts, especially System 1 and System 2 thinking, emotional intelligence and organizational culture.

Read More
984 Words | 4 Pages

One of Machiavelli’s most known works is The Prince which focuses on the qualities a prince must have to be successful (Jacobus 39). One section of his writing The Prince, is about war and the duties a leader has concerning military matters. Machiavelli stresses the need for a prepared army at all times. “It is evident that when princes have given more thought to personal luxuries than to arms, they have lost their state” (Jacobus 40). If a nations military is not prepared, the nation will be taken away piece by piece.

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

The conflict between Rome and Macedon began in the third century BC, when the two nations competed for control of the Mediterranean region. The competition between Rome and Macedon exploded into four key wars between 214 BC and 148 BC. The causes of the battle between Rome and Macedon will be examined in this assignment. Body: What caused the wars between Rome and Macedon?

Read More
737 Words | 3 Pages

The victory at Pydna cemented Rome's position as the dominant power in the Mediterranean region and demonstrated it's military might to its rivals. In conclusion, the Battle of Pydna was the most significant event of the Rome-Macedonian conflict because it marked the end of Macedon as an independent kingdom, and demonstrated the military superiority of Rome over its rivals. The battle had significant political, cultural, and military implications that shaped the history of the Mediterranean region. What were the consequences of Macedonia’s defeat by Rome? The defeat of Macedonia by Rome had significant consequences for both Macedonia: 1.

Read More

More about Battle Of Lake Trasimene Case Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document