ipl-logo

Business Law Case Summary

1137 Words5 Pages

Sidney Stratton petitions for a motion to dismiss Burnley Mills’s complaint. Mr. Stratton did not breach his contract by not adhering to the non-compete clause, because § 16600 of the California Business and Professions Code states that, “Except as provided in this chapter, every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void.” Additionally, the complaint does not possess enough factual matter to suggest that Burnley has a valid claim. (Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly) The complaint is not well argued because it is not non-conclusory and irrefutably supported by facts, it is not plausible under the circumstances of the case, nor is it factually true. (Ashcroft v. Iqbal) The complaint is not proper under Rule 8 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and it would most likely be dismissed under Rule 12(b)(6).
Questions Presented

I. Whether California or New York law should govern the validity and interpretation of the non-compete clause?
II. Whether it is likely the court would grant a motion to dismiss the complaint against Stratton under FRCP 12(b)(6).
Statement of Facts

Sidney Stratton was an employee of Plaintiff, Burnley Mills, Inc., for ten years. Burnley Mills is a North Carolina based company; Stratton worked at their California research facility. On …show more content…

Hirshberg. This case states that: “A restrictive covenant in an employment agreement is reasonable only if it: (1) it is no greater than is required for the protection of the legitimate interest of the employer, (2) does not impose undue hardship on the employee, and (3) is not injurious to the public.” These requirements are not impossible to meet. Burnley believes their complaint will have a better chance at succeeding in New York because of its more lenient approach to upholding non-compete

Show More
Related

Summary Of Steinberg Vs Chicago Medical School

464 Words | 2 Pages

Decision The trial court dismissed the complaint for failure to state a true course of action. Reasons

Read More

Case 20-1 Shoenberger V. Chicago Transit Authority Case Study

773 Words | 4 Pages

The recruiting chief told him that it was a mistake and would settle, and accept the offer now. When the increase was not given, Schoenberger resigned and filed a claim to recover damages for the contract The court of first instance ruled in favor of CTA and Schoenberger appealed. Issue The problem is that a new employee was offered a raise a promised time but the person who offered it was only a manager an employee of CTA, which, he did not have the authority or the power to do so.

Read More

Matheson Flight Extenders Case Study

384 Words | 2 Pages

Matheson Trucking, Inc. vs. Matheson Flight Extenders warehouse workers The discrimination case that I am discussing is the recent victory of five former and two current warehouse workers of Denver Colorado’s Matheson Flight Extenders, a branch of the Sacramento, California based-Matheson Trucking Company. This suit, stemming from incidents beginning in 2010, involved managers committing the atrocity of race discrimination, defamation of character, and demoralization. My thoughts are intense anger at the treatment of these workers. What training or ethics class, or intro to being a decent human being did these managers miss?

Read More

What Is The Jennifer Lawson's Jewelry Case

1768 Words | 8 Pages

Lawson was not bound by the non-compete covenant, she was bound by a confidentiality agreement which precluded her from sharing that information with another entity. In Captain & Co. v. Towne, (Kline & Floyd) the plaintiff had employed the defendant on a contract basis, requiring him to sign both a non-compete and a confidentiality agreement. The Plaintiff employed Towne in insurance cleanup and restoration work. Towne sought employment with a competing company that performed the same type of work. The Plaintiff pursued an injunction to prevent Towne from using alleged trade secrets, such as how they acquired clients, to lure customers away by intentionally underbidding for jobs.

Read More

Case Study Of Turner V. Hershey Chocolate USA

1045 Words | 5 Pages

The plaintiff is not estopped by her SSDI and long term disability claims. However, the issue should have been decided by the jury. The court foreclosed to grant the plaintiff was not a qualified individual. The issue is whether the district court correctly granted summary judgment in the favor of the defendant because the shaker table rotation rule at issue was an essential function of the employee’s job.

Read More

Turner V Hershey Chocolate Case Analysis

955 Words | 4 Pages

In determining whether a genuine issue of the material fact whether a genuine issue of material fact occurs regarding the reasonableness of the requested accommodation, we first examine whether Turners facial presenting that her proposed accommodation is possible. If appellant has made out a prima facie showing, the load then shifts to prove a favorable defense, that the accommodations requested by Turner are unreasonable or would cause an undue hardship on the employer. In contrast, If Turner has satisfied her initial burden, Turners proposed accommodation seems practical. At this time, Hershey rotations policy is new one which had never been required of employees in Turners position. If Turner 's proposed accommodation would permit the new rotation program to endure, even though on a modified basis.

Read More

Tennesse Valley Authority Case Summary

552 Words | 3 Pages

1.1. What were the legal issues in this case? What did the appeals court decide? In this case Mr. David Dunlap, a fifty year-old black man, filed a lawsuit against Tennesse Valley Authority, alleging racial discrimination under Title VII of the the Cival Rights Act of 1964.

Read More

Sun Company Vs Nlb Case Summary

1097 Words | 5 Pages

Sun Co., Company, Petitioner) and the Washington-Baltimore Newspaper Guild (Union, respondent-intervenor) were renegotiating the collective bargaining agreement for the Union members working for the Petitioner (Balt. Sun Co. v. NLRB, 2001). Balt. Sun Co. is a newspaper publisher and distributor in the Baltimore and Washington, D.C. area. “For more than 50 years, the [Union]…has served as the collective bargaining representative for all of the non-managerial news and editorial employees of the Company” (Balt.

Read More

Jordan V. City Of New London Case Study

692 Words | 3 Pages

The case of Jordan v. City of New London and Harrigan (1999) centers around Jordan bringing a civil rights action against the city and Harrington alleging that they denied him equal protection in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment and Article 4, Section 20, of the Connecticut Constitution (Jordan v. City of New London, 2000). The facts as presented to the court are that Jordan and 500 other police applicants voluntarily took the applicant screening examination for being a police officer in the state Connecticut in early 1996. The testing material included the Wonderlic Personnel Test and Scholastic Level Exam (WPT), which purports to measure cognitive ability. An accompanying manual listed recommended scores for various professions and

Read More

United States Vs Ec Knight Company Case Study

926 Words | 4 Pages

EC Knight Co., the sugar refining industry was monopolized by a handful of companies. When the American Sugar Refining Company completed a business agreement with a collection of other refineries, the company gained complete control over the industry. As a result, the United States government sued the sugar trust under the standing that the business agreement was in violation of the Sherman Act. The sugar companies held the opinion that they weren’t in violation because the agreement was made under the purpose of manufacturing that is in state control, opposed to federally controlled commerce. Chief Justice Fuller and the court decided in favor of the appellee, or E.C. Knight Co. under the idea that the Sherman Act wasn’t intended to limit manufacturing.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Competition V. Marin

669 Words | 3 Pages

The non-compete Mr. Marin signed is not likely to be enforceable because it is broader than necessary to protect the legitimate business interests of GMH, and it imposes undue hardship on Mr. Marin. Under Colorado law, when a covenant not to compete is valid under any of the four exceptions, it must still be considered reasonable by a court in geography, scope, and duration to be enforceable. Colo. Rev. Stat. § 8-2-113(2) (2017). To be reasonable, a non-compete agreement must not be broader than necessary to protect the legitimate business interests, and it must not impose undue hardship on the employee.

Read More

Contract Law Case Summary

234 Words | 1 Pages

I do not believe there is a contract to convey real property between Wilbert Heikkila and David McLaughlin. McLaughlin agreed to buy three parcels of property for $145,000, $32,000 and $175,000. McLaughlin submitted his offer to Heikkila and earnest money checks. However after McLaughlin submitted the written offer to Heikkila, Heikkila changed the selling price of all three parcels, change the closing dates, and added a reservation.

Read More

Specialty Detergent Case Summary

163 Words | 1 Pages

Kate’s claim is that she was wrongfully dismissed from Specialty Detergent and that she should be awarded $500,000 for damages. Kate was not given reasonable notice of her termination from Specialty Detergent; despite of her skills, seniority (14 years of experience with the company), and age (55 years old). However, the other sales representative, Freddie, with 15 years of experience at Specialty Detergent had received a fair severance package with the inclusion of 12 months pay and benefits. Taking into consideration that Freddie and Kate had been working at Specialty Detergent for a similar period of time, had similar duties, and earned similar salaries; they should both receive equivalent severance packages.

Read More

Lack Of Employment Contract

884 Words | 4 Pages

Issue Does the collective bargaining agreement require the employer to have "just cause" to fire an employee, even if the language is not in the CBA? (Carrell &Heavrin, 2013) Fact A truck driver failed to deliver his deliveries on time as instructed by the employer and was discharged from work. The driver had been hired in the year 2000 and during the period he worked in the company, he was given four employee warning report due to poor performance. The employer indicates that the driver showed a continuous pattern of failing to work as instructed on many occasions.

Read More

Wonder Widgets Case Study

1199 Words | 5 Pages

The first section of the clause would not be enforceable. As seen in a similar case, Clark’s Sales and Service, Inc. v. Smith, the geographic area restricted and the scope of activities are unreasonable. Limiting the employee from doing similar activities in any state Wonder Widgets conducted business is too broad and could severely restrict the employee from finding a job (Mallor 441). The two year time frame, used in both the first and second sections of the Wonder Widget non-compete clause, was found to be reasonable in the case against Smith. However, that does not mean two years is always reasonable and the Virginia courts may determine that two years in this case is also unreasonable.

Read More

More about Business Law Case Summary

Related Topics

Open Document