ipl-logo

Categorical Change In The Relationship Between Manchester And Whitehalls

483 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Steps of policy process

By pursuing a similar agenda to that set by the centre, Manchester and in particular its leaders have been seen as a “natural ally by national governments” (Harding et al., 2010:990). However, it has not always been this way; before the mid to late 1980s the city was against the centre and indeed in opposition with each other (SOURCE). The Thatcher government reduced budgets and autonomy over local authorities, which made the Labour-led metropolitan regions hostile towards the centre. But now, almost thirty years later, there has been a categorical change in the relationship between Manchester and Whitehall. Especially in the context of this current devolution agenda, the city “finds itself championed as a model of pragmatism and an exemplar …show more content…

Whilst enthusiastically adopting the centre’s approach to urban regeneration may be the largest cause of this change, the seductive narrative that the city has built for itself (which includes the centre approach being adopted) has played a key role in securing the support of government actors. This has translated through to the regions devolutionary ambitions, as evidenced by Osborne’s enthusiasm for Manchester. However, the narrative building, the change in relationship between centre and region, and the support for Manchester devolution from the centre hasn’t happened overnight. Instead, substantial resources and effort have been poured into developing the “intellectual ammunition” to help support and legitimise the claims being made by GM elites for devolution (Ward et al., 2016:421). One avenue that has been utilised has been partnership with consultancies and think-tanks, with GM elites using them as ‘research-cum-lobbying’ instruments (Ward et al., 2016, Haughton et al., 2016). Partly through developing its own research instrument in the form of the think-tank New Economy and partly through developing “external alliances” with organisation, GM elites have helped to shape the debate on regional governance (Ward et al., 2016:421). Reports that have come from these alliances have helped to make the case for devolution based upon the GM case study. This is also where the GM narrative has really been built and then disseminated, further developing the mythos of the city described

Show More
Related
344 Words | 2 Pages

Manchester is described as an ugly city that has no beauty and is so filthy and foul it can turn a good man into a savage[doc 2&5].One person questions if the progress was worth the physical suffering [doc 7]. Document 11 shows a painting from The Graphic of the horrible pollution in Manchester where the peasants live. Even though there were negative reactions there was also positive reactions. Many of the nobles agreed that the working conditions improved over the years[doc 10]. Some however, agreed that it should not matter how working conditions are because the peasants have always lived terrible lives[doc 3].Others who do not agree with the others agreed that Manchester was truly beautiful because of the tremendous growth of industry[doc 9].

Read More
347 Words | 2 Pages

Urban/political machines played a major role in late nineteenth-century American cities. These machines were powerful political organizations that controlled local government and politics in many cities. They were often led by a single powerful leader, known as a “boss”, who had the ability to influence elections and appointments to public office. The machines were able to control the city’s resources and patronage, and they used these resources to reward their supporters and punish their opponents. The machines were able to gain power by providing services to the city’s residents.

Read More
1728 Words | 7 Pages

Over the course of a century, Manchester evolved from a town of nothing extraordinary into the country’s vital trading centre. Comparing the maps of Manchester in 1750 to that of 1850, it is evident that not only has the city increased in approximately five times of size but also has built canals and railroads that pierce through the city at all angles (Document 1), including the famous Liverpool and Manchester Railway. Such expansion in urban development and increase in mobility allowed for industries to thrive; as a result, the economy prospered. Being granted a royal charter in 1852, Manchester came to be known as the “Workshop of the World”. In terms of “commerce and manufacture”, it had surpassed “any other town in the British Dominions or indeed the world.”

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

Lastly, Vrabel asserts that Boston’s mayors “cultivated ethnic and class conflicts” (6), which undermined development in Boston. Ultimately, these factors spurred Bostonians to action to change Boston. On November 8, 1949, Boston elected a new mayor, John Hynes. He saw the damage the previous mayor had done in alienating businesses from settling in Boston and worked for change. Hynes did so by “streamlining city government and reducing the waste and corruption” (8).

Read More
390 Words | 2 Pages

President Lyndon B. Johnson was our 36th president after the beloved John F. Kennedy. He had to pick up the reigns after John F. Kennedy and wanted to show he could be just as good, if not better, of a president as Kennedy or event the 2 presidents before kennedy. His use of rhetoric tries to include the entire country toward one solution. He addresses domestic policy, but instead calls it “justice”.

Read More
270 Words | 2 Pages

This view is given further weight regarding the 1983 and 1987 election. Labour’s manifesto in 1983 had infamously been described as the ‘longest suicide note in history’ by a Labour MP denoting its extreme left views that the electorate weren’t in favour of, for instance leaving the European Economic Community and re-nationalisation of previously privatised industries like British Telecom .evidence of increase In consequence, Conservatives made further substantial gains in the midlands in spite of suffering from the decline in manufacturing, while in the south outside London Labour was virtually wiped out, holding only three seats . Labour suffered what Crewe called ‘a haemorrhage of working class votes’ , thus (therefore similar to 79)supporting

Read More
592 Words | 3 Pages

Built in 1705, the Colonial Williamsburg 's capitol had made decisions that have changed the history of the U.S. with years of work put in to validate it. In fact, many decisions by historical geniuses influenced history, and majorly affected our current rights and independence from Britain. In addition, guidelines left behind from the colonial age taught us how to maintain a fair government of which a democracy takes place. Also, Virginia would still be owned by Britain without the capitol. To add on, years of work in the capitol make today a better generation.

Read More
507 Words | 3 Pages

'Labour's domestic policies should be remembered in a positive light.' Assess the validity of this view (25 marks) Labours victory in the 1997 election was first thought to be the U-turn of the socio-economic transformation that the Nation endured after 18 years of conservative premiership. However, these thoughts were quickly extinguished as the Labour party and Tony Blair took the neoliberalist ideals of the conservative party and intensified them. The rebranded new Labour looked to reform Britain in its own rendition of neoliberalism, the party executed this by making promises to the people promises to reform Education, Healthcare and Crime.

Read More
1200 Words | 5 Pages

Conclusion In conclusion, the “Parable of the Sower” portrays cities as places to avoid rather than being sanctuaries due to the lack of safety and the adverse influences of corporations. However, the novel does provide some hope by proving that if we start realizing problems and planning ahead, then, cities could change and become more livable in the future. As more people move to urban areas, the way we plan, manage and develop our cities will be fundamental in creating a fair, safe, healthy and sustainable

Read More
259 Words | 2 Pages

In the article Cities and Subnational Governments, written by Harriet Bulkeley, summarizes the growing recognition of the ‘localized’ causes and consequences of climate change. Cities and subnational governments have been key actors in the development of policy responces. It also thoroughly discusses the major roles that ctites and subnational governments have acquired in policy-making, and over the course of the last two decades, how exactly those roles and how they have played in orchrastrating a responce to the climate change. The articles as well considers why urban and reginal governments came to be at the forefront of all responces to climate change and the political geographies of that movement. Additionally, it is evident that theres

Read More
779 Words | 4 Pages

2) The Paradox Despite the efforts by council authorities to impose central cuts, the Royal Borough of

Read More
192 Words | 1 Pages

During the 1950s and 1960s, the predominant approach of comprehensive redemption has been driven by the determinist assumption that poverty could be built out and that changing the built environment would inevitably result in social and economic benefits (McDonald and et al, 2010). The Industrial Revolution, led to the unprecedented development of industrial manufacturing in Western cities. Rapid industrialisation accompanied by rapid urbanization, caused people living in the countryside moved to urban areas to seek jobs in the manufacturing sector. Consequently, urban population in western cities dramatically increased. These changes not only led to the formation and prosperity of some industrial centers in the UK cities (e.g. Glasgow, Birmingham,

Read More
1822 Words | 8 Pages

With a sprawling empire comes a sprawling history to remember as well. Historians across time all focus on some specific snapshots of the vast empire. The terms metropolis and periphery came into being to describe the relationship between the United Kingdom (Metropolis) and the periphery (colonies). The British

Read More
981 Words | 4 Pages

In The Just City, Susan Fainstein begins to “to develop an urban theory of justice and to use it to evaluate existing and potential institutions and programs” in New York, London, and Amsterdam (p. 5). She wants to make “justice the first evaluative criterion used in policy making” (p. 6). While her book centers on idealism as a way to combat inequity and issues of justice in policy and planning, some may say that this is an unrealistic perspective. Throughout this book she explains the relationship between “democratic processes and just outcomes” (p. 24) which involve equity, diversity and democracy which are the main concepts of this book. Fainstein stresses that these things are important in public policy and urban planning because policy

Read More
911 Words | 4 Pages

Similarities and Differences between Two Cities A city is a place where a large number of populations resides for the permanent period of time. City’s importance depends upon the size, location, and structure of the area. Cities have the highly organized population which is comparatively bigger than town or village. A city can provide different opportunities to know about the culture and language.

Read More

More about Categorical Change In The Relationship Between Manchester And Whitehalls

Related Topics

Open Document