ipl-logo

China's # 1 Daddy: Celebrated Cases Of Judge Dee

1280 Words6 Pages

Chloe Liu East Asian Straton 5 April 2024 China’s #1 Daddy: Judge Dee At the front of the city gates, the heads of beheaded criminals dangle on the wall. This grim spectacle was a common scene during the Tang Dynasty and is also portrayed in the novel, “Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee.” From 618 to 906 AD, the Tang Dynasty, also deemed as the Golden Era, rose to power in Asia. The dynasty was founded by Li Yuan, a military commander who declared himself Emperor Gaozu after garnering supporters amid a rebellion during the Sui Dynasty. Over three generations, Emperor Gaozu and his descendants forged a unique cultural identity that consisted of having a peaceful coexistence of different religions within the government. Most notably, Confucianism …show more content…

This daring act further solidifies Judge Dee’s character as a good Legalist, as he is committed to enforcing the impartiality of Legalism. Although opponents may argue that Judge Dee is not a good Tang Dynasty Magistrate as he abuses his power to torture individuals and is impatient and reckless with civilians, however, his discipline to maintain the virtue of Confucian principles, and uphold the impartiality of Legalist thinking, proves his excellence as a Tang Dynasty Magistrate. As a good Confucian, Judge Dee upheld the Chinese Penal Code and vowed to de-cap as a magistrate if Mrs. Djou were proven innocent. This principled act exhibits Dee’s profound reverence for adhering to virtue, which is a characteristic of an honorable Confucian. Accordingly, when Hsu, a well-regarded student from a prestigious family, cited his family’s wealth to evade being tortured, Judge Dee ignored his familial connections and punished him accordingly, demonstrating his commitment to preserving the impartiality of Legalism. Ultimately, it can be deduced that Judge Dee is a commendable Tang Dynasty Magistrate with his embodiment of Confucian and Legalist

Show More
Related

Confucian And Legalist Values In The Book 'Celebrated Cases Of Judge Dee'

1019 Words | 5 Pages

In the book Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee (Dee Goong An), the main character is Judge Dee, a magistrate in China’s Tang dynasty. The roles of a magistrate include but are not limited to, being a judge, detective, jury and police officer. The book follows three of Judge Dee’s cases, the Case of the Double Murder at Dawn, the Case of the Strange Corpse, and the Case of the Poisoned Bride. In order to be a distinguished and powerful magistrate, one must lead with Confucian and Legalist values. Judge Dee is an effective magistrate because he blends both Confucian and Legalist values seamlessly, and is well aware of the Tang dynasty’s social hierarchy.

Read More

Comparing The Government Of Charlemagne And Tang China

538 Words | 3 Pages

The ideals and methods of Tang China and Charlemagne’s government, both are powerful political figures of their time. Each government has their own similarities and differences that make them unique and suited to the areas they ruled. Starting with Tang China, the ideal ruler was known as the "Son of Heaven" and was believed to rule by the Mandate of Heaven. The ideal ruler was expected to be wise and follow the Confucian principles, and ruling with the welfare of the people in mind. In Tang China, the ruler was expected to be benevolent and just, taking care of the welfare of the people(Lecture).

Read More

Unit 7 Han Dynasty

509 Words | 3 Pages

This leads into the ideas of the fourth primary source. As the Han dynasty became prudent, the officials had constructed a goal of enhancing the government by supporting the "Legalist" idea of an autocratic state. Ideologies of

Read More

Chae Chan Pang V. United States Case Study

291 Words | 2 Pages

Although the decision on the Chae Chan Pang v. United States case was decided over 150 years ago, it still bares much relevance and similarity to President Donald Trump’s executive order, especially in the separation of powers. The Chae Chan Ping case came before the Supreme Court on the basis of an appeal of the 1888 Chinese labor restriction bill. Furthermore, the appellant was a national of China and had resided in San Francisco, California, under a work visa. Much to the surprise of the appellant, when arriving back in San Francisco, after visiting his homeland of China for 8 years, he was detained and told his entry into the country was unlawful. Rather shockingly, while the appellant was out of the country, the Government (The President)

Read More

Legalism And Gulik's Celebrated Cases Of Judge Dee

594 Words | 3 Pages

“In the end, as a general rule, no criminal escapes the laws of the land. But it is up to the judge to decide who is guilty and who is innocent” (Gulik 5). In the court rooms of Chang-Ping, a town district in the province of Shantung, a magistrate delves deep into the cases presented to him to do just that. Dee Jen-djieh, referred to as Judge Dee, was a Chinese magistrate who became well-known for his ability to solve mysterious cases. When most would consider a case impossible, Judge Dee would look past the obvious and interpret the clues to pass a fair judgment.

Read More

Research Paper On Judge Dee

778 Words | 4 Pages

You will forgive that I, seeing that your methods fail to produce the slightest result, plan to bring this case before the prefect. We will see whether he shares your views." (160). If Judge Dee had listened to Mr. Hua, he would have made the wrong conviction because Mr. Hoo would have confessed to the murder under the pressure of the torture. Judge Dee also dealt fair sentences for the actions of the guilty convicts.

Read More

Spread Of Buddhism Dbq

1110 Words | 5 Pages

Because the Chinese during the Tang dynasty liked to create statues, they created a statue of Buddha, which represents the blend of cultures with the religion because of the Chinese’s devotion to the religion. Zong Mi, a leading Buddhist scholar, described that “Confucius, Laozi and the Buddha were perfect sages.” and states that their teachings were similar and that “...they must be observed with respect.” (Doc 6). Confucianism, founded by Confucius, and Daoism (Taoism) founded by Laozi are philosophies that were all founded in China and was very popular to Chinese people. With the spread of Buddhism in China, Zong Mi wanted to compare the three philosophies together to where they blend with one another, so that Buddhism would be a religion that can be accepted into the Chinese

Read More

Abuse Of Government Power In Shiji By Sima Qian

640 Words | 3 Pages

Shiji by Sima Qian provides invaluable insight into the history of the Qin dynasty, while the movie Hero directed by Zhang Yimou presents a modern interpretation of Qin’s successful unification of China. Therefore, Shiji and Hero reflect historians’ different attitudes toward government power: Shiji demonstrates the importance of centralizing government power in Qin’s reforms as well as the danger of abusing power shown in Qin’s totalitarian governance, while Hero conveys the necessity and legitimacy of utilizing strong government power to achieve long-term peace through military expansion. In Shiji, Sima Qian illustrated the benefits of centralizing government power to establish a unified empire, but at the same time he revealed the problems of abusing government power to impose totalitarian rules. On one hand, Sima Qian recognized that government power played an important role in Qin’s successful unification of China.

Read More

How Did Shi Huangdi Use Legalism During The Qin Dynasty

639 Words | 3 Pages

Legalism is a type of "Classical Chinese philosophy" (Legalism and Chinese Philosophy) that grasped strong eminence during the bold, storming, Warring States Era (475 BCE–221 BCE). Legalists struggled to improve the human lifestyle by noble examples, education, and moral/righteousness laws or rules. During the Qin dynasty, it was needed for a strong government in addition to a carefully designed set of rules and principles. Qin Shi Huangdi, "first emperor" (Legalism) with this was a defending force that would factually, enforce these rules/laws and punish severely in even the most minor violations or mistakes. Throughout the years and understandings, the conceptual/elements of Legalism has been decaying, and starting to become more lenient

Read More

Differences Between The Roman Empire And The Han Dynasty

1525 Words | 7 Pages

Gaozu, the founder of the Han dynasty was the first low-ranked official to found a dynasty in imperial China. In 209BC, Gaozu spearheaded the rebellion against the tyrannical practices of the Qin dynasty. The changes enacted by the Han’s first emperor are central to understanding the political rule and authority in Han China due to the fact that the rulers that succeeded him follow suit in a majority of his policies. Throughout

Read More

Religion In The Han Dynasty

673 Words | 3 Pages

Connection of Religion & Culture: In the Han Dynasty Throughout the whole world there has been evidence of different civilizations, each having their own distinct ways. Archeological discoveries have found similar connections that each civilization develops such as language, art, artifacts, and most importantly religion and culture. For instance, the Han Dynasty in ancient China lasted over 400 years developing new advancements such as silk, the wheel barrow, and metal working while believing in religions like Confucianism. Both religion and culture are connected because they each determine the ways of how a society acts, practices, and lives; giving it its own name.

Read More

Sui Dynasty Analysis

896 Words | 4 Pages

It had a profound influence taking place the selection of talent in Chinese history. One of the best-known eras in Chinese history is the Tang dynasty, which ruled from 618 to 907 CE. The Tang dynasty considered to be one of the high points in China 's history due to their implementation of innovative forms of governance, as well as an approach to trade that included ideas, innovations and communication as well as material goods. The economy of China was dynamic during this period, alternating between devastation and moments of new economic growth. Tang policies helped shape a period in time that saw increased stability, population, and happiness for those in

Read More

The Importance Of The Han Dynasty

1955 Words | 8 Pages

Not only that, the people in the Han followed more of Confucian principles rather than Legalism, and “soon became the basis for the creation of a new state philosophy.” However, despite the differences, there were similarities as well. The ruler, Han Gaozu, and his successors kept some of the practices the Qin Emperor followed. These practices are the system of local government and the division of the central government into three ministries: the military, civil service, and censorate.

Read More

Similarities Between Tang And Song Dynasties

485 Words | 2 Pages

Confucianism thought that a ruler should be like a father by setting good examples for the people of China. He also thought that a ruler should be honest, good, and wise in order for the people to follow him. “But he said the best way to rule was through an honorable government and right relationships”

Read More

Mozi Vs Mencius

636 Words | 3 Pages

As such, Mencius prescribes such legitimacy within the Tian, which for Mencius includes aspects of fate, nature, and deity. He believed that through Tian, deeds and actions popular to society would be revealed (5A5). Moreover, the rule of a moral king is compared to the rule of Tian. Mencius attributes certain values such as “Benevolence in relation to father and son, righteousness in relation to ruler and minister, […] the sage in relation to the Way of Heaven” (7B24) to Tian. As a result, Mencius sees a ruler to be legitimate if he posses such virtues, is conferred with divine sanction, Tian, and rules with popular

Read More

More about China's # 1 Daddy: Celebrated Cases Of Judge Dee

Open Document