ipl-logo

Chinese Room Argument By John Searle

1361 Words6 Pages

Title

In the world of philosophy of the mind, numerous debates and theories inspire exploration of the intricacies of thought, understanding, and consciousness. Within this realm exists the Chinese Room Argument, proposed by philosopher John Searle. This thought experiment highlights the enduring mind-body program: the enigma of how mental states and physical processes intertwine to shape one's reality. The Chinese Room Argument is incredibly prevalent in philosophy and has become a widely discussed topic, generating substantial debate. This debate revolves around the true nature of understanding and the limits of computational approaches to cognition. As a result, it has also faced significant criticism, especially from advocates of the computational …show more content…

This allows for a comprehensible conversation with the Chinese speakers, who may assume the person in the room is also a Chinese speaker. This scenario acts as an analogy: the person in the room serves as a metaphor for a computer executing a program, carrying out operations without any true understanding. Searle's argument ends with the conclusion that regardless of the complexity of operations, the individual remains void of genuine understanding: Since they are simply engaging in the manipulation of symbols, they do not ever attain a true comprehension of the Chinese language. Therefore, Searle concludes that this illustrates the limitations of purely computational processes in explaining consciousness and understanding associated with mental states, supporting the idea that there is more to consciousness than just symbol manipulation or …show more content…

I resonate with Searle's emphasis on consciousness and intentionality when it comes to understanding, as I believe that true understanding transcends the manipulation of symbols alone. Because of this, I agree with the point that the individual in the Chinese Room Argument does not have a true comprehension of the Chinese language. The human mind's capabilities extend beyond just syntactic processing that characterizes the Chinese Room scenario, which is why I agree with Searle to a certain extent, as intentionality and consciousness seem to be substantial components of our mental process and lay the groundwork for a deeper understanding of the mind. However, Pinker introduces an intriguing perspective to the debate, suggesting that while individual parts of a system might lack understanding, the system as a whole could still exhibit understanding. Despite this, I do not fully believe that this type of understanding can mirror the depth of human cognition, or what understanding truly is. Therefore, I am unsure of whether the computational processes of computers can be equated with mental processes. Considering both Searle and Pinker's viewpoints, I find myself navigating a nuanced perspective. The Chinese Room Argument compels us to explore the nature of understanding itself, rather than whether a system can imitate understanding. Examining this within the

Show More
Related
281 Words | 2 Pages

The chinese room argument Imagine an English speaking person,

Read More
1504 Words | 7 Pages

This research led to questions about the top down process, in which the different areas of the brain are compared to “the conductor of an orchestra, waving its [sic] baton and directing the players” (Lehrer). Miller conducts tests with monkeys, by using a series of dots and an organizational process that the animal goes through to get to the insight moment. Lehrer made a point to connect his work to people’s real life experiences. His main example is the fire in Montana in the summer of 1949.

Read More
76 Words | 1 Pages

Let us start with John Searle’s argument, or one could say counter-argument, with what he calls “strong AI.” The most famous of his arguments; “The Chinese Room.” In which you picture yourself as a monolingual English speaker “locked in a room, and given a large batch of Chinese writing “ as well as, “ a second batch of Chinese script” and “a set of rules” in English “for correlating the second batch with the first batch.”

Read More
1327 Words | 6 Pages

The first arm in understanding

Read More
1476 Words | 6 Pages

One of the most complex aspects of being human relates to the state of consciousness. It offers perhaps the most varied of experiences, from the state in which people are in when they are not conscious to the representation of semi-consciousness to the full reality of the waken state. Cognitive neuroscience may be one of the most well-explored areas of human well-being, and yet there is still so much more to learn about the inner workings of arguably the most important organ in the body. Chapter 3 delves into the concept of consciousness and the two-track mind, in an attempt to explain everything from sleep issues to addiction to the hypnosis to the ways in which the brain processes just about everything. The brain is a highly complex organ that is responsible for everything from knowledge to personality and everything in between.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

Carr noticed that theories have stated that human’s brains stop adapting at a certain point (31). The brain is not trapped; it never stops adapting to new experiences. This scientific notion is important to Carr’s philosophy because our brains are constantly changing. Using neuroplasticity as an example gives him the opportunity to show that life is about having a deep effect, not on our brains, but the way we think. Carr adds, “neuroplasticity provides an escape from genetic determinism, a loophole for free thought and free will, it also imposes its own form of determinism on our behavior.

Read More
1221 Words | 5 Pages

There were many problems facing the nation during the Articles of Confederation; economic and political problems. These problems included disputes over western lands, currency, inflation, debt, foreign relations, and a weak central government. The disputes over western lands begun when Britain gave up their land claims to the lands east of the Mississippi River and north of the Ohio River. By the 1700s, almost 120,000 people lived west of the Appalachian Mountains, hoping that one day they could join the Union as a state. However, the Articles of Confederation had no provision for adding new states.

Read More
1413 Words | 6 Pages

Grady Koester Mrs. Ragusky Argumentative Essay 9 January 2023 The Great Alan Turing “A computer would deserve to be called intelligent if it could deceive a human into believing that it was human” Alan Turing wrote in 1950 talking about his famous Turing Test. His brother was in foster care, his father was in the British Civil Service stationed in India, and his mother was the daughter of the chief engineer of the Madras railways. His life begane of to a bad start with not seeing his father very much because he was usually traveling abroad.

Read More
1005 Words | 5 Pages

She gave an example by comparing a computer software and a human’s mind working similar to one

Read More
1686 Words | 7 Pages

He uses this example to show that Schank’s computer does not understand the way a human being can because it is being fed information and is computing it without learning or getting any meaning out of it. Searle delves into this further in order to respond to claims made in support of strong

Read More
866 Words | 4 Pages

Searle talks about putting information into computers, “if you type in 2 plus 2 equals” the computer will respond “4”. (Searle 356). However, the computer lacks understanding of what four means or that it means anything at all. This lack of understanding could be interpreted as a lack of consciousness. He then brings up the point that computers have syntax but no semantics, this implies that computers can give programmed responses but have no understanding of those responses.

Read More
1919 Words | 8 Pages

Conclusion: The mind is substantively different from the body and indeed matter in general. Because in this conception the mind is substantively distinct from the body it becomes plausible for us to doubt the intuitive connection between mind and body. Indeed there are many aspects of the external world that do not appear to have minds and yet appear none the less real in spite of this for example mountains, sticks or lamps, given this we can begin to rationalize that perhaps minds can exist without bodies, and we only lack the capacity to perceive them.

Read More
2535 Words | 11 Pages

They also found that children are more likely to trust information coming from an individual with fantastical abilities (12-13). Finally, Fisch proposed a computational model of content comprehension. He explains that the brain first processes the narrative then processes the secondary content, and then computes the distance between the two of them. If the lessons being taught run parallel with the events of the story then the distance is small. He then suggests that if the distance is small then the brain can process both aspects simultaneously therefore leading to a greater increase in retention of the narrative and secondary content (Fisch 66).

Read More
2029 Words | 9 Pages

Moreover, I utilise my definitions of understanding and meaning, to explain that computers are incapable of both semantics and syntax. Where understanding regards syntax and meaning regards significance of which both are consciousness-dependent concepts. Lastly, I differentiate sensation from perception, where perception is the ability to interpret sensory information, in order to

Read More
1014 Words | 5 Pages

Level of elaboration regulates the processing route that the presented message takes. According to this theory two processing routes can be described: central and peripheral. High level of elaboration is connected with central route occurs when the information included in the message is strongly investigated by

Read More

More about Chinese Room Argument By John Searle

Related Topics

Open Document