Rhetorical Analysis of Nicholas Carr’s “Is Google Making Us Stupid? We are at a time where technology is widespread; it has become a part of our everyday life leading to advantages and disadvantages. Technology nowadays has become the most important topic to discuss and everyone has developed their own unique opinion. In Nicholas Carr’s article published in 2008, “Is Google Making Us Stupid” he argues that as technology progresses people’s mentality changes.
In his book Smarter Than You Think, Clive Thompson aims to persuade the readers into believing that technology has had a positive impact on our society and the World as a whole. He claims that technology has improved our retention rates, allows us to write and think with global audiences and even improves our senses. How does he persuade us to believe his claims? He gives us many examples of people and their inventions, and how these inventions have had positive impacts on our society. One example he gives us is Ory Okolloh, a woman who created a website that played an important role during the disputed presidential elections in Kenya in 2007.
Shawntae Aikens Technology has a found a way into our lives where we use it everyday, and some have come to the point where they depend on it. People have become concerned that the Internet is becoming a distraction and has taken over our lives. The Internet, and social media has become very addicting our smartphones have given us the chance to have the internet and social media at our hands at all times. Nicholas Carr, a writer for the Atlantic Online, wrote the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Within his article he discusses his opinion on how the internet is something that is not helping us at all.
Nicholas Carr’s article “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” published in 2008 to the Atlantic magazine brings forth the argument of how modern technology, like in the past, has affected us into changing the way we think, and go about taking in information. Throughout the article he supports arguments with personal accounts of colleagues as well as past accounts in advancements in technology that shaped modern day. Carr’s article begins with dialogue from Stanley Kubrick’s 2001: A Space Odyssey in which he relates with the supercomputer HAL as it loses its mind when Bowman disconnects its memory circuits. Carr like many of us today states that when reading he now finds himself distracted, unable to concentrate and make connections with the text.
Comparative Analysis In a world of rapid technological advancements, the use of technology has become a presence found everywhere. Many smart devices and large screens of bright lights have engulfed the human population, including day-to-day living. However, there have been conflicting reports on whether or not the influence of technology is a benefit to human knowledge or a detriment to it and the remnants of traditional learning. In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid,” author Nicholas Carr insists that the use of technology and specifically the internet can alter the brain’s neurology, which in turn can lead to negative side effects on the body. On the other hand, in the article, “The ‘Google’ Paradox: Is Technology Making Us Smarter,”
the use of technology is extending radically. " Is Google Making Us Stupid?" By Nicholas Carr talks about how technology is negatively effecting our brains. This article begins by discussing how the Internet is an tool we can use for just about anything. In result, we are getting to be indigent upon it in things like to expand work profitability, writing, and reading.
In today’s society, technology plays a very important role in its ability to function, it helps people find information, communicate with others far away and provides entertainment. In “Fahrenheit 451”, a book written by Ray Bradbury, a dystopian future where books have been made illegal is presented. In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” by Nicholas Carr, raises many questions about technology and its effects on society. It’s quite evident that we have become quite dependent on technology due to our overconsumption of it.
For my first piece of evidence, technology helps us in many ways, from travel, to seeing stars. In the text, “is Google making us stupid” It directly states “Just as a car allows us to move faster and a telescope lets us see farther, access to the Internet lets us think better and faster.” With complete certainty, these technologies impact and improve our lives, some better or worse. It is true that technology like guns and harmful devices exist, but they are overshadowed by the amount of good these electronics bring to the world.
Carr’s writing style is a collection of blogs, best essays, and history that focusses on technological culture. His books are also New York Times bestsellers. The excerpt “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” was published in the Atlantic
Out of all the controversial topics in the world today, one of the well-disputed arguments is the following: is technology taking over the world? Many people argue against this, claiming that technology is responsible for many important contributions to the world. However, many agree that technology is evolving way too rapidly to maintain a functioning society. One individual that agrees with this claim is Nicholas Carr, who in his essay titled “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” discusses this idea of the negative effect associated with the rapidly growing state of technology. Although, I do agree that technology is very beneficial to the current state of the world; I find the growth to be much too rapid.
Novels, articles, and publications have been a part of our culture for an abundance of years. People all over the world are quick to engulf themselves in the fantasy land where their favorite heroes are battling for their home and freedom. From action to romance, books are lionized and adored no matter the size or style they are written. However, our society has developed the internet and it went public in 1991. With this, people rush to post, blog, comment, and create their own work to be proud of and receive feedback on how it could be better.
“Technology should improve your life...not become your life”(Billy Cox). We use technology to make our life easy, but it becomes our life. For example, we can stay alive without food, but we cannot live without technology. We use different technologies in our daily life. Days without technology seem colorless.
In any case, society needs to be balanced and recall that these progressed devices can be a control measure that makes people keep returning for more information. Carr also states that the web guarantees to have specific sweeping consequences for understanding (737). Carr’s overall goal is to get the audience to view technology in a negative light by referring to it as the cause of our growing stupidity. He wants the audience to understand that technology is taking a greater toll than anyone ever thought. He does this by providing logical information not only from what he knows but also from what he gathers from credible
In the articles “Is Google Making us Stupid” by Nicholas Carr, and “The Taming of Tech Criticism” by Evgeny Morozov, the same topic is addressed and criticized in two very different ways. The topic that both articles are discussing is the effects of technology on human both physically and socially. Carr’s article attempts to display how it is shorting our attention span and mental capacity while Evgeny Morozov discusses the shortcomings of average tech critics such as Carr. Morozov states that Technology critics are avoiding the more complicated and troublesome topics such as the adverse political and economic effects technology is having on society. Though this topic can be at times controversial, technology does serve as a formidable foe
The Influence of Technology In the essay, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” Nicholas Carr argues that utilization of the internet has an adverse effect on our way of thinking and functioning in everyday life. Whether it be reading a newspaper, or scrolling through Facebook, internet media has forever stamped its name in our existence. Carr explains to us that the internet is a tool used every single day in today’s society, but also makes most of us complacent with the ease of having the world at our fingertips.
