ipl-logo

Comparing Macbeth And Patrick Stewart

995 Words4 Pages

In theatre class, we watched the 2010 PBS movie of Macbeth with Patrick Stewart as Macbeth. I had high hopes for this movie as I know Patrick Steward is a highly respected actor. However I felt with most of the actors that played in this movie, the were miscast or should not have been casted at all. Macbeth play written by William Shakespeare about a a married aristocrat couple who fall under a witch’s curse. With their dream of becoming royalty causes their ultimate downfall. The PBS film represented this play as been taking place around a world war (possibly World War II). The original Macbeth play was sent in Scotland around the 11th Century. This is when the real characters Shakespeare based the play off of reigned. The film itself never …show more content…

It made the choosing for Patrick Stewart more ideal. However, even though I think Patrick Stewart has the right physical appearance for the setting. I believe that him as Macbeth was not very strong. Patrick Stewart is a great actor because he show emotion through eyes. This is what makes turning plays into films difficult. Characters in plays (especially in William Shakespeare’s plays) have so much face and body emotion. This makes it hard for actors like Patrick Stewart to portray the characters feelings when they can only successfully have emotions seen in their eyes. Macbeth is especially hard to play in films because he is and extremely emotional character. This means eye emotions are not enough for the character and made Macbeth seem almost boring. It did not work for the film in general either. It did not show Macbeth’s true outwardly feelings. I felt this with most main characters. I also felt the entire film itself was unclear. The only people that can really watch and enjoy the movie are the people that have a understanding of what a Shakespeare is saying in Macbeth. If you have no idea what Shakespeare wrote, then you will have no clue where you were in the film. The transitions are so unclear. For example, the transition from the celebration dinner to Lady Macbeth poisoning the guard is so unclear. However, even for people that would know what Macbeth is saying and the transitions, they

Show More
Related

Macbeth Book Vs Movie Analysis

304 Words | 2 Pages

The movie by Roman Polanski doesn’t follow completely the movie setting. For example the duel between Macbeth and Macduff had a humorous side. The acting of the Actors was not the best and it could have possibly been better. Shakespeare introduced Macbeth as a hero, but on the film the acting from the actor John Finch (Macbeth) did not reflect this trait on his character.

Read More

Macbeth Compare And Contrast Essay

690 Words | 3 Pages

First, in The Tragedy of Macbeth [film] Lady Macbeth has a very abrupt climb towards insanity (Coen 2021), while in the play Macbeth it's a slow crawl that escalates as she becomes more and more worried about the murders that had been committed (Shakespeare 38). Thus, representing how the film left out key information about Lady Macbeth causing her to be seen as a crazy lady fairly quickly. Secondly, in The Tragedy of Macbeth when Macbeth sends the third murderer to kill Banqou the audience sees that it is Ross (Coen 2021), but in the play Macbeth it is never revealed to the reader who the third murderer is, only that he was told to show up by Macbeth in both (Shakespeare 35). Thirdly, in the play Macbeth the resolution shows Malcolm being named king and talking to all his subjects of what the future holds (Shakespeare 72), and while The Tragedy of Macbeth [film] also shares this scene it's very last scene is Ross going back to find Fleance and riding off with him to show he isn’t as evil as he seems earlier in the film (Coen 2021). Lastly, in The Tragedy of Macbeth [film] Macbeth is beheaded by Macduff as he is reaching for his crown that fell from his head (Coen 2021), but in the play Macbeth Macduff's beheading of Macbeth isn’t fully explained (Shakespeare 72).

Read More

Examples Of Foil Characters In Macbeth

769 Words | 4 Pages

Shakespeare’s diction forces readers to feel one way or another about certain characters in the story. Each character is really a foil of the other ones. You could compare any good character with any bad character and the good one would make the bad one look really bad, and the bad one would make the good one look really good. We’re made to feel bad for Macbeth because of how he comes off as weak.

Read More

Differences Between Macbeth Movie And Play

298 Words | 2 Pages

In most novel to film adaptations, directors will often change certain elements of the work for the movie to move at a different pace. These changes may range from the main character’s hair colour to larger transformations like an important character being left out. In the case of William Shakespeare’s Macbeth, the largest difference from the play to film was the role of Ross. In the film adaptation of Macbeth, Ross is a developed and crucial character to the plot. This is shown through his involvement in Macbeth’s schemes, relationship with Macbeth, and loyalty to power in Scotland.

Read More

How Does Macbeth Control His Fate

484 Words | 2 Pages

These things Macbeth did made him start to lose his mined. This is something out of his control that will affect him greatly. His mind's deterioration plays a great part in his destiny and could have changed many things thought out the play.

Read More

Character Changes In The Film 'Macbeth'

973 Words | 4 Pages

Ari Mattes again gives a great point of view in her statement, “ We watch her cry as the wife and children of Macduff are executed, and note the look of regret in her eyes as Macbeth becomes increasingly mad” (Mattes 1). Showing from the eyes of Lady Macbeth we watch her wreath in pain of sorrow as she witnesses her husband go “mad” from all his actions. The character of Macbeth manifests into a completely different person in the eyes of film maker Justin Kurzel, as the character seems to be suffering from the pains of his tragic past, also known as post traumatic stress disorder. The memories of battles and violent times in the life of Macbeth, from war times to murders he has committed, puts a serious toll on his mental state. Macbeth can be seen dragging many bodies after the aftermath of war, and the killing of Duncan has shown that it has put a scar into the character of Macbeth.

Read More

The Rationality In Shakespeare's Macbeth

483 Words | 2 Pages

Macbeth is very rational at the beginning of the novel and makes decisions that he know’s would help other people plus himself, later on after the murder of Duncan his rationality decreases, his mind goes crazy and he kills people for no reason, this illustrates his good morals and values being destroyed. Before the killing of Duncan, Macbeth is very reasonable, and notices the good from the bad, the smart from the dumb, so every little detail catches the eye of him. Therefore, when the three witches come over to him he is amazed at there beauty and willfulness, “speak if you can. What are you”(1.3.50)? The way the witches praise and talk to Macbeth makes him feel powerful and almost as their leader.

Read More

Macbeth Play Vs Movie Essay

463 Words | 2 Pages

A Play that was written back when technology was not yet created can be found difficult to interpret in the modern days, therefore, each modern’s days movie producers may interpret it in their own way. The 1978 movie version of Macbeth demonstrates how a movie can be different and similar from its original play. The staging of the movie Macbeth is very different from the stage direction of the play Macbeth. This is clearly seen in the appearance of the three witches in the very first act, the banquet part, and the last visit of Macbeth to the witches. The long screaming of the witches as King Duncan prayed in the movie Macbeth shows how the appearance of the three witches is very different from the play Macbeth.

Read More

How Does Macbeth Create Objectivity

516 Words | 3 Pages

The two productions are the 1979 Trevor Nunn's Royal Shakespeare Company production staring Ian McKellen as Macbeth and the 2010 Rupert Goold production staring Patrick Stewart as Macbeth. The 1979 production “was greeted with ecstatic reviews and audiences who departed into the night in a state of terror”, with some stating it was “the most unforgettable Shakespeare they had ever witnessed”. The 1979 production is set in a traditional context with Macbeth being a member of the Scottish military in the 16th century. The 2010 production was set in a contemporary context, in a battle ridden totalitarian dictatorship styled country during the 20th century. This production also received glowing reviews, with some declaring it "The best Macbeth I have seen".

Read More

The Lion King Macbeth Comparison

879 Words | 4 Pages

As quoted before, Lady Macbeth said, “your hand, your tongue; look like the innocent flower, but be the serpent under’t” (Shakespeare 1.6. 70-71). This clearly demonstrates the theme of appearance versus reality by saying not everything is what it appears to be on the outside as it is on the inside. Many characters in Macbeth changed their personality to present themselves as good, meaningful characters. In the meantime, many of them were also plotting deaths upon their enemies.

Read More

How Does Shakespeare Create Sympathy In Macbeth

696 Words | 3 Pages

Through keen use of action, soliloquy, and dialogue, Shakespeare causes any audience to react sympathetically to Macbeth’s negative attributes and perhaps even relate. For instance, Lady Macbeth’s manipulation is an aspect many readers can level with. Once it becomes clear that Macbeth’s mental health is diminishing, the audience inevitably begins to pity him. In his final moments, the desperation Macbeth feels is hard for the audience to ignore. Evaluating Macbeth’s character in full rather than focusing only on his negative attributes inevitably evokes sympathy from the reader.

Read More

Rene Descartes: A Huge Figure In Early Science And Philosophy

887 Words | 4 Pages

Francis Bacon and Rene Descartes are huge figures in early science and philosophy. Bacon is considered the father of empiricism, or the theory that knowledge comes solely from human sensory experiences; and Descartes practice strict rationalism. Combined, these two approaches form the modern scientific method. These contemporaries published numerous works on a variety of topics, from moral philosophy to natural science.

Read More

Macbeth Directed By Rupert Goold

502 Words | 3 Pages

“Tongue nor heart cannot conceive, nor name thee.” The pain of seeing an individual’s king dead displays the emotion packed Macbeth directed by Rupert Goold as being tasteful and creative due to the fact that it is based during WW2. This reenactment of the play Macbeth was transferred to a later period of time being WW2, however, it was produced in 2010 by Rupert Goold and Macbeth was played by Patrick Stewart. Lady Macbeth was played by Kate Fleetwood and this particular scene took place inside to what seems to be an underground bunker.

Read More

Pity And Fear In Macbeth's Tragedy

1931 Words | 8 Pages

This debate between the pity found in Macbeth’s mental state and the fear he evokes through his actions continues as Macbeth becomes a vicious tyrant. Not only does he kill off more of those around him, including the family of MacDuff, all for the sake of proving his power over those around him, but he rains famine and tragedy across the land. Macbeth’s inhumane actions easily draw fear from the audience as it expresses how uncontrollable and deranged, he has become; Macbeth is truly far from the hero first introduced. Extensively Macbeth begins to trust fewer and fewer individuals, he becomes more paranoid about the things going on around him. Specifically he can’t sleep and fears loosing his power.

Read More

Who Is To Blame For Macbeth Analysis

999 Words | 4 Pages

This led to him going insane. Macbeth didn 't have to do this, he had already been promoted and had a better job than he had had beforehand. he was very well off and did not need the responsibilities of a king. he could have moved on and lived his life but, he killed the king. This event in the movie was portrayed with much more emotion than expected.

Read More

More about Comparing Macbeth And Patrick Stewart

Related Topics

Open Document