ipl-logo

Comparing Socrates Phaedo-A Quarrel Of Soul And Body

519 Words3 Pages

Phaedo- A Quarrel of Soul and Body
The Phaedo is a platonic dialogue that relates the conversation between Socrates and his friends on the day of his execution. Given the circumstances, the conversation naturally turns to questions concerning death the soul and the afterlife. The friends of Socrates are sad about his impending death but Socrates tells them that he is cheerful at the thought of death. In this argument, Simmias, a friend of Socrates, rises a fine argument which conflicts Socrates theory about soul, body, and death. Socrates claims to believe that soul is eternal and immortal; therefore it never dies. He then claims that body is just a carrier of soul and when body weakens and die, the soul remains. However, Simmias, who is also a philosopher put forwards the view that the soul is a harmony and the body is like instrument; Therefore, when the instrument (body) is weakened by illness or disease then the harmony would also perish. In response to Simmias' quarrel, Socrates presents two arguments which include the existence of the soul (harmony) before the body (instrument), and the soul's direct ability to control itself, unlike harmony which is controlled by the instrument. …show more content…

His argument is legitimate since it directly refers to Simmias theory of harmony and instrument. Simmias before said, that if the instrument of life which plays the attunement is weakened by illness or a disease, the attunement will be lost forever. However, Socrates claims that attunement was always there, even before the instrument was created which roughly translates to the soul existing way before human body ever coming to life. After listening to Socrates rebuttal, Simmias immediately surrenders. He understands that even though the instrument is broken, the harmony will always exist. Maybe in another form, but harmony exists and will continue to resonate

Show More
Related

Analyzing Plato's Entry Of Phaedo

242 Words | 1 Pages

In the entry of Phaedo, Plato claims that the soul is immortal and that when the body dies the soul gets reincarnated. Throughout his story, Socrates provides arguments that help support his claim about the soul being immortal. I will be explaining and evaluating 2 of Plato’s arguments that will help him support the statement that the soul is immortal. An argument Plato uses is called the argument from opposites, which is the first argument he uses in the selection.

Read More

Thrasymachus Vs Socrates Research Paper

571 Words | 3 Pages

Thrasymachus agrees to this statement, allowing Socrates to see a contradiction in Thrasymachus

Read More

Socrates Argumentative Analysis

1225 Words | 5 Pages

In Plato’s dialogue Phaedo, he explains the soul and comes to the conclusion that the soul is immortal. Through describing the last hours of Socrates life before his execution, he lays out three arguments in support of the idea that while the body may cease to exist the soul cannot perish. In this paper, I will explicate Socrates three arguments for the immortality of the soul and their objections. Then I will argue on the presupposition of the Law of Conservation of Mass, that the universe, entailing the soul, must be cyclical. The Law of Conservation of Mass

Read More

The Final Argument Of Plato's Phaedo

411 Words | 2 Pages

However, the number three cannot ever be even for it holds a natural form of oddity that cannot be changed, the same is found with immortality. A soul cannot admit to death, which is the opposite of its essence immortality just as the number three cannot admit to being even. Leading to Plato’s conclusion of how a soul then must have to retreat, connecting back to Socrates believing death is best characterized by the soul separating from

Read More

Analyzing Socrates Argument In Plato's Meno

1060 Words | 5 Pages

In order to establish my thesis, I will start by stating and explaining the argument that Socrates presents, I will

Read More

Socrates: A Threat To The Athenian Society

912 Words | 4 Pages

The Athens believed a certain way during their time period. Those who did not implement their system into their lives were considered a threat. So how exactly was Socrates a threat to the Athenian society? Well, my proof was given from the passage,

Read More

Plato's Point Of View Of Socrates Research Paper

767 Words | 4 Pages

Part A- Socrates In thinking of Socrates we must recognize that what we have is four secondhand sources depicting him. That of Plato, Xenophanes, Aristophanes, and Aristotle. All having radically different accounts on Socrates and his views. Out of all them we consider Plato’s to be the most possible account, even though we face a problem of different versions of Socrates.

Read More

Socrates Vs Phaedo

371 Words | 2 Pages

There are multiple emotions that are shown by people when a loved one, friend, or family dies. The most common emotions are thoroughly shown in the painting The Death of Socrates by David and “The Death Scene” from The Phaedo by Plato. Although they bear some minor differences, the similarities in the way they express the emotions between The Death of Socrates by David and “The Death Scene” from The Phaedo by Plato are evident. The emotion that is thoroughly shown throughout both works is sadness.

Read More

Thrasymachus Definition Of Justice Analysis

1470 Words | 6 Pages

One of the potentially faulty arguments Socrates uses to ponder Thrasymachus’ definition of justice involves considering injustice within a single person. In other words, this means thinking about conflict within an individual’s “soul”. In his treatment of Thrasymachus’ position that

Read More

Alcibiades Plato Analysis

1013 Words | 5 Pages

Socrates in the dialogue Alcibiades written by Plato provides an argument as to why the self is the soul rather than the body. In this dialogue Alcibiades and Socrates get into a discussion on how to cultivate the self which they both mutually agree is the soul, and how to make the soul better by properly taking care of it. One way Socrates describes the relationship between the soul and the body is by analogy of user and instrument, the former being the entity which has the power to affect the latter. In this paper I will explain Socrates’ arguments on why the self is the soul and I will comment on what it means to cultivate it.

Read More

Trial And Death Of Socrates Analysis

1191 Words | 5 Pages

Socrates states that a good philosopher should not fear death, but rather embrace it and look forward to it. This is also where he comes out with the four claims of the separation of the soul and the body. With this point Socrates is trying to explain to Cebes, Simmias, and the others in the room that the soul is everlasting and outlives every body that it is ever in. They agree that the soul is long lasting but does not live forever. This is the end for Socrates as him and Crito head to the bath chamber and return to say goodbye to his three sons and the women of the household.

Read More

Argument Of Opposites In Plato's 'Phaedo'

633 Words | 3 Pages

In Plato’s, Phaedo, one of the arguments that Socrates makes for justifying his theory about the soul being immortal is the argument of opposites. The argument of opposites is found from 70c to 72c in the Phaedo. The argument is not logically valid as there are a few fallacies that occur with the definition of opposites with which Socrates defines his argument. This argument ultimately fails at being logically valid as contrary to premise 1, all things that have an opposite do not come from only their opposites. Socrates also does not specify in this argument whether he is referring to the soul dying or the body dying in the final premises.

Read More

Plato's Argument On Why The Soul Is Alive

524 Words | 3 Pages

Socrates’ original argument was not valid or sound. The premises were corrected but the argument needed another premise to make the conclusion true. Adding premise two takes away any confusion there was to what immortality meant. Since Socrates’ spent almost the entire book creating a just person and a just city the information about what is good and bad for a soul makes sense. It also makes sense that those things cannot destroy the soul because injustice and other vices could only lead the body to make poor choices and possibly get sick or die from those poor choices.

Read More

Was Socrates Life Worth Living Analysis

799 Words | 4 Pages

The Phaedo proposes thought provoking questions that one should ask themselves. There are four questions posed, either explicitly or implicitly, throughout the book: what happens when you die? What constitutes a good life? What does philosophical inquiry look like? And lastly, “Was Socrates’ life worth living?”

Read More

Socrates Life Is Not Worth Living Essay

631 Words | 3 Pages

Finally, the goal of life is to cultivate and develop one's immortal soul, therefore is one does not enrich his soul then he claims that life is not worth living. This explains why Socrates had no fear towards death, as he worked on flourishing his soul in many different ways. But adoring and cultivating your soul was not as easy as it sounds, in order to truly own a adorn soul you must not pursue only pursue ethical beliefs as most of them may not be completely

Read More

More about Comparing Socrates Phaedo-A Quarrel Of Soul And Body

Related Topics

Open Document