ipl-logo

Analysis Of Diane Murley's Article In Defense Of Wikipedia

849 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The importance of critical reflection

On January 6, 2011, the internat activist Aaron Swartz was arrested for downloading approximately 4.8 million journal articles from Jstor. He wanted to make the content available for everybody and for free. He commited suicide under the pressure of a potential jail sentence of 35 years. This case shows that academic knowledge is not for free; furthermore, it gives an idea how difficult it is for a freely available plattform like Wikipedia to provide good quality knowledge of academic standards. In her article In Defense of Wikipedia, Diane Murley argues that the academia has cause to revise its opinion on Wikipedia as a scholarly tool. The article is a feature of the Law Library Journal, the edition was published in 2008. The author makes …show more content…

In academic contexts they should be prepared to work with sources and to critically reflect where these sources come from. In 2011 Traphagan et al. tested the influence of being fully fully involved into the process of publication on Wikipedia on students. After being involved students showed more sensitivity towards the process of publication and the reliability of publicly assessed sources. Hence, the information literacy of students was improved. Wikipedia would support those students due to the fact that they have to get prepared for working in science which includes challenging statements of different …show more content…

Wikipedia has the potential to cause an educational shift towards a freely available, transparently organised knowledge system. Maybe this shift of knowledge was not visible in 2008, but nowadays you could argue that if academics do not go along with this trend they might soon be outdated. Eijkman states that it needs to give a new discussion about the “control of academic knowledge production” (173). If the academic institutions do carry on in denying the use of publicly accessable knowledge data bases, such as Wikipedia, they obviously fail their obligations. The hierarchic university system is changing and now academics need to focus on integrating this form of knowledge into their work. Otherwise, the traditional academic arrangements of knowledge can be outdated

Show More
Related

What Is William Badke´s Is Google Making USupid?

234 Words | 1 Pages

William Badke assessment of the article by Nicholas Carr “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” has a unique twist. As an associate librarian at Trinity Western University, he feels online search engines like Google or Yahoo restricts profound thought and retrains comprehension. Badke states “we can keyword search right to the best stuff without reading much of the book itself.” (online) He accepts research by Gary Small and Gigi Vorgan called iBrain, which submits the brain, adapts to the surrounding environment.

Read More

How Facts Backfire

1091 Words | 5 Pages

Humanity is in a perpetual state of trying to make living in the world an easier place. In just a few seconds, people can access information at their disposal, instead of having to look through different books to find what you need. But the question arises; does this boundless place for information honestly make us more informed than before we had the internet? Joe Keohane, the author of the article “How Facts Backfire,” is a political journalist who has also written articles on technology and culture.  

Read More

Historians Support Cesar Chavez

468 Words | 2 Pages

The second author received an award for her service at the Cornell University Libraries. I found the information on the process to create a bibliography helpful in providing questions one might ponder. Moreover, the embedded links such as “How to Critically Analyze Information Sources” were extremely useful in creating questions for this handout. Fitch, Bob. " Tilting with the System.

Read More

Summary Of What's The Matter With Kids Today By Amy Goldwasser

508 Words | 3 Pages

Amy Goldwasser claims reading and writing online to be aesthetically and intellectually equivalent to the more traditional methods, in her persuasive essay, “What’s the matter with kids today?”. She is absolutely correct. Reading and writing online volutarily shows the same quantity as previous nonelectronic modes, uses the same thought process and problem solving, and reveals a less of importance for knowledge of fun facts in order to concentrate on analyzation. When compared to generations prior, this next generation is more inclined to write about themselves without pressure from others. They share key moments of their lives and display them over social media.

Read More

The Right To The City David Harvey Summary

1355 Words | 6 Pages

Mirroring the process by which Harvey describes low-level workers are driven out of cities that they were integral in creating. Capitalists are removing the lower class from their land, and academics from their informative influence, so just like how low-level workers should make an effort to utilize their proverbial "right to the city", academia must make an effort to enter the conversation. This is not to say that academic work should become less academic, it just needs to be freely digitally accessible to the public, so that the public need not depend on commercialized taint and summary of facts. Although academic articles are for experts, in an age of democratized information and opinion, oversimplifying information and limiting facts to an elite is no way to change the world. Turning citizens into experts changes the world.

Read More

Technology In Fahrenheit 451 Essay

696 Words | 3 Pages

In today’s society, technology plays a very important role in its ability to function, it helps people find information, communicate with others far away and provides entertainment. In “Fahrenheit 451”, a book written by Ray Bradbury, a dystopian future where books have been made illegal is presented. In the article, “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” by Nicholas Carr, raises many questions about technology and its effects on society. It’s quite evident that we have become quite dependent on technology due to our overconsumption of it.

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of 'Is Google Making USupid?'

972 Words | 4 Pages

Rhetorical Analysis In the article “Is Google Making us Stupid?”, author Nicholas Carr expresses his idea that the internet is taking over society and our thinking process. Google is affecting our abilities to read books, longer articles, and even older writings. Carr believes that we have become so accustomed to the ways of the internet, and we are relying on Google 's ability to sort through the details for us so we don 't have to, in order to get the information we find necessary more efficiently. He finds that this process has become almost too handy, and that it is corrupting us from becoming better educated.

Read More

Does The Internet Make You Smarter Analysis

358 Words | 2 Pages

Clay Shirky, the author of “Does the internet make you smarter?” wrote about how ignorance has poisoned the internet with incorrect information. Not only does technology has its flaws, but so do books and novels dating back to the Protestant Reformation. Even though many people are against the internet Shirky reassures that if used correctly and appropriately, then it can become a very useful tool that can “tap our cognitive surplus”. The increased collaboration of technology is important to society for the reason that the internet is full of valuable knowledge that can be claimed very quickly and easily. Increased collaboration is absolutely a benefit.

Read More

Annotated Bibliography Things Fall Apart By Chinua Achebe

1600 Words | 7 Pages

However, citation of Wikipedia may be considered unreliable, because educators do not consider Wikipedia an authoritative source. This is because anyone can edit the information given at any time, and although most errors are quickly fixed, some errors go unnoticed. A writer must be careful when using wikipedia and be sure to cross check the information with a more credible source. Chinua Achebe Quotes (Author of Things Fall Apart).

Read More

Nicholas Carr's Argument Summary: Is Google Making People Stupid?

456 Words | 2 Pages

Three things will be discussing in this essay facts, evidence, and causes. Carr states that when it comes to the internet searching we are sacrificing our ability to read and think deeply. His opinion was that the internet is easy to access for quick answers. Carr findings strongly backs up his opinions. His facts are all backed up with research, and experiments done by mostly universities and scientists.

Read More

Does The Internet Make You Dumber By Nicholas Carr Analysis

925 Words | 4 Pages

Imagine living in a world without any internet. Imagine the amount of trouble a person would require to go through in order to find out the simplest things. The internet nowadays has become an essential part of almost every human being’s life. Cutting the internet off for just one day my actually leave the world in a state of commotion. Every type of technology may be used in either a way that benefit’s a person, or a way that may harm a person.

Read More

Analysis Of Informing Ourselves To Death By Neil Postman

906 Words | 4 Pages

Even just a couple years ago, if a student was writing a research paper, they would go to the library to read and learn about the topic, so they could complete the assignment. Now people depend on the internet to do most of the searching for them. With information easily attained, people no

Read More

The Importance Of Information Literacy

1222 Words | 5 Pages

Importance of Information Literacy Information literacy is important for today’s learners, it promotes problem solving approaches and thinking skills when asking questions and seeking answers, finding information, forming opinions, evaluating sources and making decisions fostering successful learners, effective contributors, confident individuals and responsible citizens. People need to be able to identify what is real and relevant not just for school but for learning, life and work. Information literacy skills have been around for quite some time in different guises and several frameworks and definitions have been produced both nationally and internationally.

Read More

Essay On Access To Information

815 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction This essay discusses the impact that access to information has on the public in this day and age. Political aspects such as laws that for as well as against access to information will be addressed and discussed. The actions that are taken against active whistle-blowers in providing access to information will be highlighted. The aim of this is to highlight contradictory facts and allegations concerning access to information.

Read More

Essay On Media And Information Literacy

869 Words | 4 Pages

Information literacy helps students recognize misleading, out-of-date, or false information. It also helps them sort through the data and interpret it intelligently. Libraries full of books are still available and a valuable resource for students, but information literacy includes the Internet and beyond. Teachers are involve into it, they act as channel of information.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Diane Murley's Article In Defense Of Wikipedia

Related Topics

Open Document