ipl-logo

Debate Over Prohibition And The Bloomberg Soda Ban

469 Words2 Pages

Prohibition, the temperance movement, and the Bloomberg soda ban illustrate that the US constitution and legal systems are “living documents.” Both the debate over Prohibition and the soda ban were regarding the allowance of government to change legal documents and laws in response to changing times and new scientific research. In both cases, laws were proposed, and accepted, in the method of an amendment and a ban, respectively, and were ultimately changed, in the method of an amendment and an overturn, respectively. One argument was to keep the status quo and not introduce any changes, with the counterargument being that, despite freedoms promised to all Americans, if negative health and social benefits came as a result that freedom should be rescinded. …show more content…

58% of New York City adults, as well as an astonishing 40% of children, are overweight or obese. Sugar is a major contributing factor to weight gain, as it is high in calories and promote fat storage. In recent years, companies have pounced on the opportunity to make money with larger portions of drinks such as soda. NYC Mayor Michael Bloomberg decided that it was time for the city to take action. In 2013, he introduced a ban on large drinks in the city. However, the ban was only on drinks like soda, not milkshakes, and not in all locations, either. The counterarguments to the ban included that it infringed on people’s liberties and that it actually was not efficient. According to one poll, people bought more soda when offered smaller portions than when buying larger portion. Additionally, 60% of New Yorkers opposed the

Show More
Related
343 Words | 2 Pages

“The Portion Cap Ruling, commonly known as the soda ban, was to restrict the sale of sugary drinks larger than 16 ounces…” (Dr. Lisa Firestone). The New York City Board of Health exceeded its power limit. Along with the fact that New York City lost its final appeal when the rule was in place. Whereas sugary drinks are a key driver, personal limits make it a key driver of obesity.

Read More
1110 Words | 5 Pages

The Eighteenth Amendment which instituted prohibition in America and its territories was an interesting attempt at using the constitutional amendment process to shape social and moral behavior in America. Until the Twenty-First Amendment which repealed prohibition, the road to prohibition in America dates back to colonial days. Although the amendment did not last as it was reversed by the Twenty-First Amendment less than 15 years later, along the way, the battleground for prohibition grew from local organizations to a national political party and set new interpretations for the Constitutional amendment process and played an important role in in American history. The Eighteenth Amendment was the high-water mark for what is often referred to

Read More
317 Words | 2 Pages

As the New York Mayor Michal Bloomberg is taking action against a soft drink industry. Mayor says that a ban is imposed on it because it has a big sugary drink. The mayor behavior could be considered biased towards specific company or product. There are lots of other, he should not ignore others. Everyone knows that lots of sugar are becoming the cause of problems in people like we drink almost daily like Coca-Cola, Pepsi, and other major soft drinks.

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

The country was trying to control America’s alcohol problems by law. The ban on alcohol worsened America’s alcohol problem, in fact, it did quite the opposite of its intention. All caused by prohibition, America had an increased crime rate, death rate, and to top it off, America was losing slathers of money.

Read More
686 Words | 3 Pages

One reason why I'm against the ban is the government shouldn't be the ones making decisions for us. For example, in "Ban the Ban" by SidneyAnne Stone, she stated that "People might think it is not important because it is just soda but it is so much more than that—it is about freedom and the

Read More
644 Words | 3 Pages

In 1933, the United States Congress made history, doing something that had never been done before. By popular vote, Congressmen decided to repeal the 18th Amendment which banned the consumption, purchase, and transportation of alcohol, and alcoholic beverages (Background Essay). This is the only time in United States history where Congress removed an amendment from The Constitution. When Congress passed the 18th Amendment in December of 1917, it seemed like the right thing to do, as alcohol seemed to be the cause of domestic abusers, hungover, drunk, or absent employees, but after 14 alcohol free years, three out of every four Americans were in favor of repeal (Background Essay). One question historians ask themselves is “Why did Congress make alcohol legal again?”

Read More
958 Words | 4 Pages

The purpose of the Prohibition proposal is to bring forth information about how and why the Prohibition Era failed as a law due to the reactions of citizens across the nation. The Prohibition Era has two sides to its story as America arose in protests against liquor and protests against Prohibition. Along with protests and criminal acts, the history of Prohibition explains how the law began and ended, businesses across the United States were struggling to stay open, and the long term effects the era had on people among the nation. The Prohibition Era was a time that the United States experienced protests and criminal acts against their own government, loss of business among the nation, and the downfall of a law.

Read More
58 Words | 1 Pages

With careful input, after more than 10 long years of trying to enforce the unrealistic law, the government acknowledge that prohibition was a grand loss. The 21st amendment, approved in 1933, finished the failed experiment and reestablished Americans’ legal right to drink whatever they would please. Prohibition should have educated the government about attempting to readjust personal

Read More
2046 Words | 9 Pages

How significant was Prohibition in changing the lives of the American people in 1919-1933? . “First you take a drink, then the drink takes a drink, then the drink takes you”. F. Scott Fitzgerald, ‘The Great Gatsby’ (1) As early as 7000 BCE, mankind was first acquainted with alcoholic beverages, became an inseparable companion of humanity throughout history, and was praised for being present during joyful and sorrowful times, neglecting the common knowledge that they give nothing but fraud, ecstasy, and illness when consumed. The Volstead Act, also known as the ban on alcohol, had a deep and far-reaching impact on American society. In this essay, how this legislation shaped the lives of Americans both during and after its application will be

Read More
887 Words | 4 Pages

¨Several critics questioned why the city was making proposal on sugary drinks a priority when some city schoolchildren have no physical education classes.¨ (Washington TImes) In New York, Mayor Bloomberg placed a law on the sizes of soda citizens are allowed to get. However, this caused a lot of controversy on whether the ban was good or bad. Despite the amount of people supporting the ban´s choice, the ban does have some downsides on it. It is not a good idea to limit the amount of a soda a person can purchase (or propose the ban) because it's not applying to all, it's taking rights away from people, and itś not a big deal.

Read More
307 Words | 2 Pages

The New York soda ban was a big issue for citizens. There are a lot of Americans that are obese and were worried about the ban of large size sodas. The ban was rejected and there is a good reason. Banning sodas is not the solution for obesity. The New York soda ban is not effective and people need to understand that it is not just sodas that causes it.

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

The ratification of the 18th amendment to the repeal of and creation of the 21st amendment are a great example of the process to change the document that our country is based upon. To ratify the Constitution is a very strenuous task and it took place twice between 1919 and 1933. In this essay I will discuss the why prohibition came under effect and why it was repealed, and how difficult it would be to change the constitution today. Prohibition the 18th amendment - (Historical

Read More
959 Words | 4 Pages

The soda ban is a defective idea in itself because of the loopholes in the plan. As Karin Klien talks about the problem in her article “Sodas a Problem but…”, “Convenience stores such as 7-Eleven are overseen by State and would be exempt , but a Burger King across the street would be restricted” (Klien, 288). In addition, there isn’t a need for this soda ban because it makes no sense for a customer at a fast food restaurant (like Subway) to walk across the street and go to a 7-eleven, which is a state-ran store that has drinks that are over 16oz., and even over 64oz. People could even go to a grocery store and buy a 2-liter bottle of the sugary drink because it isn’t run by the city. Another way the soda ban contradicts itself is because of how you’d get the same amount of sugar if you were to drink a drink from a smoothie

Read More
1192 Words | 5 Pages

Everything can be viewed from two perspectives; A fist fight, a murder, bullying, just to name a few situations. This is still the case with Iran and it’s people. Iran and its neighboring countries are often portrayed negatively as terrorist, or failed nations. This is not always the truth, however, and one can learn that through Marjane’s coming of age story, Persepolis. The personal nature of the story is told through Marjane’s loss of innocence, her opinions on religion, and her observation of the prominent gender roles.

Read More
593 Words | 3 Pages

Each year, billions of gallons of soda are sold in the United States alone.” Soda must be allowed to middle schoolers during school hours. Soda should be allowed because kids need more of a choice at school and soda is not the cause of all the bad stuff. Soda must be allowed at middle school because kids need more of a choice at school. At many schools the only things to drink are milk, water, and a few other juices you have to pay extra for.

Read More

More about Debate Over Prohibition And The Bloomberg Soda Ban

Related Topics

Open Document