ipl-logo

Differences And Similarities Between Pearl Harbor And 9/11

523 Words3 Pages

Pearl Harbor: Compare and Contrast “History doesn’t repeat itself, but it does rhyme.” This quote by Mark Twain is clearly exemplified by the comparisons between the events that occurred on September 9th, 2011 and at Pearl Harbor in 1941. To begin, both 9/11 and Pearl Harbor were defining moments for two separate generations. They were also both appalling surprise attacks that killed thousands on American soil. Additionally, these attacks brought the realization that the U.S. was not immune from worldwide threat and eventually lead the States into two different wars. Then while both of the attacks may have terrified the country, they were also soon followed by surges in patriotism and national unity (Collins, Michaels). The wars that resulted …show more content…

On the other hand, many of the men in George W. Bush’s administration, such as Donald Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz and Vice President Dick Cheney were members of the “Project for the New American Century,” or PNAC. The members of PNAC called for a new aggressive military foreign policy for the U.S. However, the members of this organization knew that Congress or the American people “absent a catastrophic and catalyzing event like a new Pearl Harbor” would not accept this idea As a result the “New Pearl Harbor” and the original ended up being a blessing in disguise for FDR and PNAC. Despite the fact that Pearl Harbor and 9/11 have many similarities, they are still drastically different. For example, the Japanese attack was well thought out, clearly tactical, and its success depended on the predictability of the United States, which had been observed for months. In contrast, the assault on 9/11 was irrational would have failed if not for the acquiescence of airline passengers and crew, the incompetence of amateur pilots, and the unprecedented ineptness of North American Air Defense Command. Additionally, the United States knew after Pearl Harbor that they were facing a formidable enemy with an obvious, however ever the intention behind the attack on the Twin

Show More
Related
378 Words | 2 Pages

“December 7th 1941- A date that will live in infamy”. This sentence is forever engrained in the minds of the youth for its significant impact in American History. Roosevelt’s response to the horrific betrayal of the Japanese Empire by bombing Pearl Harbor is tremendous significant. Roosevelt’s timing as he met with the Congress during their joint session and urges the congress to declare war on Japan, it brought America into World War II since most of the world was already at war.

Read More
416 Words | 2 Pages

However Japan was responsible for attack on Pearl Harbor. 9/11 and the attack on Pearl Harbor are similar because they were both terrorist attacks. They were both surprise attacks. Both of these attacks were unprovoked. Besides all of these similarities they also have differences.

Read More
697 Words | 3 Pages

Do you remember the day that changed America forever? Two hijacked planes crashed into the side of the Twin Towers in New York City killing thousands. Another plane went into the pentagon and the last was stopped before it got to its destination. In the afternoon of September 11, 2001 George W. Bush delivered a speech that gave relief to the American people after the massacre. This was a disturbing moment in our history that shook the very foundation of America.

Read More
1441 Words | 6 Pages

George W Bush Address to the Nation September 11, 2001: Rhetorical Analysis September 11, 2001 is a day that will be remembered in American history forever. This day was one of the worst terrorist attacks on American soil. More than 3,000 innocent people lost their lives that day. George W Bush had been president of the Untied States for less than a year at the time of the attacks.

Read More
462 Words | 2 Pages

I. Introduction A. Attention Getter: Tuesday September 11th 2001 started off like any other day. Men and women prepared themselves for another work day and school children settled in their seats for a day’s lesson. But before the mornings of people’s everyday life could begin, a tragic incident occurred, killing thousands of American citizens and breaking the hearts of many more. B. Thesis: The World Trade Center crashes were significant in many different ways to the U.S. and when they were destroyed, American citizens were stunned and heartbroken. C. Main Points: 1.

Read More
879 Words | 4 Pages

The Pearl Harbor Address to the Nation by Franklin Delano Roosevelt was delivered on December 8, 1941 in Washington, D.C., a day after one of America’s largest tragedies. The bombing of Pearl Harbor is an event that is unforgettable and President Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s speech in response to this shocking attack is one of the most significant speeches of all time. The significance of the speech is the fact that America joined into the fighting of World War II, something the Americans didn’t want to do at first. This speech has a stark resemblance to the speech George W. Bush gave after the terrorist attacks of The Twin Towers in New York City, an equally shocking event. FDR’s use of ethos, logos, and pathos was extremely effective in spurring

Read More
1034 Words | 5 Pages

was their first experience of an attack. As you compare the two it is mind blowing how equivalent of Pearl Harbor and 9/11 are to one another. One similarity between 9/11 and Pearl Harbor is the fact that these were unprovoked attacks, without benefit of declaration of war on U.S. soil. The aftermath of both Pearl Harbor and 9/11 there were exaggerated fears of follow-up attacks. In California, people feared that a Japanese attack on the West Coast would occur.

Read More
280 Words | 2 Pages

Pearl Harbor was the first serious foreign attack on American soil. Being an attack from a foreign military, carrying out an order from the government. Resulting in large a amount of American casualties and forcing America to enter the war against the Axis Powers. But, could this attack been avoided all together? The Japanese invaded China in 1937, which forced America to take action.

Read More
2595 Words | 11 Pages

The attacks of September 11, 2001 on our country was one of the most tragic and deadly days in our history. It brought a country together and the American strength of freedom and unity became a battle cry. After the dust had cleared, the questions came about that asked, how could this have happened? Were there not security and intelligence infrastructures and policies in place?

Read More
1611 Words | 7 Pages

9/11: The Day That Changed America Forever On September 11, 2001, nineteen terrorists boarded four planes, all transcontinental flights full of jet fuel. 9/11 became the first of many hijackings in the United States. The terrorists turned two flights into flying weapons of destruction, knocking down America’s tallest buildings. The third plane rammed into the Pentagon and the fourth plane was crashed into a field in Pennsylvania.

Read More
972 Words | 4 Pages

It is almost sixteen years since that fear was imposed on us and the age of terror began in earnest. From the moment the Twin Towers fell, 9/11 was seen as a watershed, a historical turning point of grand and irreversible proportions. With the acrid smoke still swirling above ground zero, the mantras repeated constantly were that 9/11 had ?changed everything that nothing would ever be the same.? By now we see those mantras for what they were: natural, perhaps inevitable, exaggerations in the face of

Read More
1131 Words | 5 Pages

These attacks were a changing point in American society because it increased the security in American airports, started a war in Iraq and Afghanistan,

Read More
800 Words | 4 Pages

“Terrorist attacks can shake the foundations of our biggest buildings, but they cannot touch the foundation of America. These acts shatter steel, but they cannot dent the steel of American resolve.” George W. Bush delivered this speech on the night of the September 11 attacks. The shattered steel of the Twin Towers, once towering the New York City skyline, forever changed America and its response to terrorism. The largest foreign attack on U.S. soil appropriately gave reason to Americans to recoil in fear and lose trust in the future, but in reality, the country displayed the opposite reaction.

Read More
515 Words | 3 Pages

In conclusion from both events of Pearl Harbor and 9/11, we have learned that we still stood strong as a nation. We never gave up and never will. Both presidents during each event gave a very respectable speech. We can see from each speech that there were different vibes. Roosevelt believed in our arm forces would get the job done.

Read More
452 Words | 2 Pages

Pearl Harbor was based on the actual attack on Pearl Harbor so their were many similarities to show what actually happened. In the first scene of the Japanese raid, a low-flying Japanese plane flew over Oahu and it passed over a sandlot baseball field where the pilot warned the children of the attack. This similarity is shown when, “The [Japanese] tail gunner waves at the kids below, warning them to take cover before bombs begin to fall” (Robert Sullivan, Daniel S. Levy). Also the main characters are based on actual men and their actions. The main characters, Rafe McCawley and Danny Walker, are based on George Welch and Kenneth Taylor who were two of the few pilots that were able to become airborne and engage the Japanese attackers.

Read More

More about Differences And Similarities Between Pearl Harbor And 9/11

Related Topics

Open Document