ipl-logo

Discuss The Pros And Cons Of Equalization Program In Canada

2365 Words10 Pages

A Controversial Debate: The Canadian Equalization Program As part of the Canadian Constitution in 1982, the equalization program was one of the prominent changes that was ingrained into this constitution that aimed to bring national unity among all Canadian provinces. Like many different government-mandated ideas, the equalization program was developed to help certain “poorer” provinces. More specifically, those unable to meet the national average due to economic discrepancies (Department of Finance Canada, 2023). However, unlike many other government-funded programs, this specific initiative raises concerns as to whether or not there is fairness of contribution between the different provinces. This has led to many political debates about whether …show more content…

Many of these programs are still being utilized today and still play important roles in Canada’s growing economy and society. Additionally, like many things mandated by the government, there will always be pros and cons to beneficiaries or projects that are constantly up for political debate. However, this particular constitutional program has faced many repercussions as the prominent concept of it seems to be disoriented and lost in translation. Although advocates want to abolish the specific program, it can seem to be nearly impossible for the constitutionally enshrined program to be implemented. Furthermore, this paper aims to explain the strengths and weaknesses of Canada’s equalization program, while suggesting possible updated changes to this controversial legal …show more content…

One of the first notable critiques of the program is the tension between provinces. As odd as it may be, considering the program was designed to unify the provinces together, there still is some disagreement on how funds may be distributed by the way provinces perceive it to be. Some provinces believe they are entitled to more funding and others believe they should not be contributing more than others. For instance, when there was some unsustainability with centralizing tax rentals (essentially where the provinces would give their taxation to acquire fixed payments from the federal government) as Québec was fully starting to pick up nationalism on their end (Béland et al., 2022). Another flaw in the program would be the incentives given for any fiscal responsibility that provinces may use to their advantage. While the program was designed to make sure every province/territory was equal and that no one was above another, there are certain disincentives provided that could potentially allow provinces to inflate their fiscal capacity by pursuing indubitable policies. To further elaborate, this means that there is no proper way of determining what outcome of the program could have

Show More
Related
2747 Words | 11 Pages

Additionally, Trudeau then was tasked with attempting to negotiate a settlement with the reluctant premiers, which argues that Trudeau's strategic maneuvers and the premiers' unyielding resistance reflect the clash between centralizing and decentralizing forces within Canada's political landscape. The disagreement over the language rights made the settlement process far more complicated than expected. The amending formula and the provisions on language rights became central points of contention, reflecting the deeply entrenched regional divisions and divergent views on federalism and individual rights. Trudeau was very passionate about his version of the Charter, and Graham argues that Trudeau used his abilities and background in his longstanding commitment to human rights and democratic freedoms, shaped by his experiences as a student and his efforts to combat oppression and discrimination in Quebec in the 1940s to push for said

Read More
1366 Words | 6 Pages

Section 33 of the Canadian Constitution’s Charter of Right, also known as the “Notwithstanding Clause” has many different pros and cons for Canadians and has been a hot topic for a long time among Canadians. Such a clause within the highest law of our land was bound to stir up controversy in Canada, and there are many people who are both for and against the clause for a variety of different reasons. There were several mitigating factors surrounding the clause as well as players behind it and several effects it had on Canadian people. There are also factors needed to implement such a clause, and there are several effects such a clause have on the government who attempts to use it. The cause was part of what was known as “The Kitchen Accord”

Read More
974 Words | 4 Pages

However contemporary Canada is not without its issues, as stated earlier. Even with these important lessons, and our written out charter that has the basic rights for humans, we still fail to support and provide these rights to many marginalised communities and

Read More
1182 Words | 5 Pages

The accord encompasses the larger debate over centralization and decentralization in the Canadian government.

Read More
935 Words | 4 Pages

The pros of having a more representative system are strong enough that it is something that Canada needs to adopt if it wants to consider itself a truly democratic, inclusive and fair country. The flaws of the MMP system revolve around the fact that the likelihood of governments having majorities is lower, which creates a higher likelihood of coalitions for more “power” so to speak. The more representative system also allows for people to have more choice in their votes, which leads to shorter lifetimes for most parties as voters have more control with their votes. A party that is run badly is less likely to see another term, this is of course a good thing, but inconsistent governments is brought up as a con against the Mixed-Member Proportional System. The Mixed-Member Proportional system also allows a better foundation for smaller parties to form, parties with more singular focuses have a much higher chance of having seats.

Read More
1456 Words | 6 Pages

Though it is a huge social accomplishment in Canadian politics, it does have some flaws. One unique quality in our constitution is section 33, also referred to as the "Notwithstanding Clause". Since it's inception in 1982, this clause has been the cause of much controversy. The "Notwithstanding Clause" should be removed from the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms because it violates the equality that the rest of the charter tries to protect. Almost immediately after the constitution had been passed into law 1982, Quebec showed us how this act could be abused.

Read More
1515 Words | 7 Pages

316). Rocher draws upon the same historical timeline as Trudeau when he alludes to the period of modernization in Quebec after WWII, however he focuses on the distribution of autonomy and responsibility to provinces for managing their own institutions separate from the central government (p. 316). The transfer of health care, education, social services, and economic development was representative of the pragmatism of the constitution and the sharing of jurisdictions between regional and central governments (p. 316). Although there is no mention of the role of nationalism by Rocher, he thoroughly mentions the role the central government plays in ensuring national unity, he describes the position of the federal government as “having to consult, coordinate and, inevitably, compromise in the face of mounting federal-provincial conflict”, this is connected to the discussion of compromise between the central and regional governments described by Trudeau (p.

Read More
980 Words | 4 Pages

Many questions were in Canadians heads as they wondered about how this power was going to be implemented. Will the federal government be allowed

Read More
1249 Words | 5 Pages

POL113: Ideas and Ideologies Instructor: Dr. Aslan Amani Justin Trudeau’s quest to stop income inequality in Canada By Sebastian Velez-Bolivar 1003506495 March 18 2017 1330 The concept of equality, and making sure everyone is treated well has become an important value in most societies. I am someone who has grown up in a North American society and have had these values instilled in me.

Read More
1524 Words | 7 Pages

The constitution was written with Canada’s regionalism in mind by constructing safeguards and minority guarantees while excluding overarching principles and ideas that may not be compatible with every region (Trudeau, p. 42). In conjunction with a pragmatic constitution, the central government preserved relations with the provinces by implementing several strategies (p. 42-43). The central government allowed a certain amount of leeway for provinces to countervail constitutional matters that were not connected to the economy, alongside a representative central bureaucracy that made each province feel that their interests were heard by the central government (p. 42). These two strategies allowed for regions to feel that they had power and autonomy because the central government was compromising for them, by doing so the central government prevented feelings of dissatisfaction with regional representation (p. 42). Furthermore, the promotion of Canadian nationalism in the form of celebrating its British heritage brought regions under one identity to try and create an attractive national identity to replace regional nationalism as described previously (p.

Read More
619 Words | 3 Pages

Canada, among other advanced countries, has a serious and growing inequality problem. The popular saying “rich become richer”, is actually in existence in Canada. It is hypothesized in Canadian society that dominant groups and members of society can rule and survive much better in the country. Such kind of assumptions let superior people maintain their socio-economic status. In the upcoming paragraphs, I will be talking more about the social factors like class and gender in order to explain social inequality in Canada and the concepts of ideology, dominant culture, and hegemony.

Read More
1479 Words | 6 Pages

Much research can be put into the practices of the Canadian Government, to determine the level of lobbying and other influence that business has on Governmental decisions in Canada. For brevity, it can be stated that such practices likely had a bearing on the Canadian Government. Internal metrics, such as revenue, employment, GDP and other economic factors that are closely tracked by governments are also a factor, if not the prime motivation for governments to act. Based on these factors, as well as the breach of ethics of defending “culture” as discussed above, it may be argued that the government was mainly if not wholly pressured to protect the market on financial

Read More
1851 Words | 8 Pages

Fiscal Federalism: Power of the Provinces versus Equitable Programs Fiscal Federalism and Equalization in Canada thoroughly catalogues the dynamics of Canada’s federal government and the provinces in relation to equalization payments and the equitable distribution of public services. The book examines the unequal distribution of services in Canada and attempts to offer solutions drawing on foreign federations with equalization payments and comparing the differences. However, as Canada is unique in the amount of autonomy the provinces individually hold, the relationship that the provinces have towards the federal government severely impacts the applicability of foreign systems to address the equity of services. In addition, the inequity of the

Read More
420 Words | 2 Pages

Criticism from certain provinces regarding the federal government's initiative to establish a Canada-wide early learning and childcare system stems from longstanding debates about federalism in Canada. At its essence, federalism in Canada delineates powers and responsibilities between the federal and provincial governments, aiming to strike a balance between national cohesion and regional autonomy, as expressed in class discussions as "a will to live together and a will to live apart" (La Selva, 1996). The roots of this criticism can be traced to historical tensions between federal and provincial authorities over jurisdictional boundaries. Rooted in classical federalism, provinces often advocate for increased autonomy and control over policy domains within their purview, including crucial areas like childcare.

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

Which exemplifies how unequal Canadian society is becoming. The issue social inequality is that it directly affects people health. That is because

Read More

More about Discuss The Pros And Cons Of Equalization Program In Canada

Open Document