ipl-logo

Does Johnny Deserve A Light Punishment Research Paper

495 Words2 Pages

Does Johnny deserve harsh or light punishment? Johnny deserves to be punished whether he did or didn't mean to kill Bob. However, the question arises: does Johnny deserve a light punishment or a harsh punishment? Many people will say Johnny deserves a harsh punishment, except there are several reasons why Johnny deserves and should get a light one. To understand why he deserves a light one, looking into the circumstances is essential. Johnny deserves a light punishment because it is self-defense. We know this because Johnny was beaten up and Ponyboy was drowned by Bob before the incident took place. Well, why didn't Johnny run for help? The attack took place in the middle of the park at night, if Johnny had tried to call for help chances are …show more content…

If Johnny yelled for help, he would have ended up in the same position as Ponyboy, if not worse. Therefore, if Johnny had not stabbed Bob, Ponyboy would have died in the hands of Bob. Another big reason Johnny deserves a light punishment is the argument that Johnny is still a minor in high school and this could potentially affect him in the future. Johnny is also still in high school, meaning if he were to get a harsh punishment it could ruin his education and plans, as well as getting a job in the future. Johnny also had no issues with the law or the record, he had no issues with fights and wasn't problematic at school. In the past, Johnny had also been jumped by Bob and his gang. This also explains why he reacted in that manner of fear and aggression from seeing his attackers. On the other hand, people say Johnny should be severely punished. This point of view makes sense because Johnny left Bob at the park instead of trying to help him. However, Bob had gone to the park with his friends and they did not attempt to call for help. Bob had been drinking with his friends the night of the fight and they were there when he attacked

Show More
Related

Analysis Of The Greasers In S. E. Hinton's The Outsiders

581 Words | 3 Pages

) This means that he killed Bob for a reason and that was to protect Ponyboy from his death and it wasn't an intent to kill off of anger from the previous attacking, So this obviously proves that he killed Bob for a reason and that was to protect Ponyboy. The second reason Johnny is innocent is that he was trying to protect himself. He tries to protect himself because they were about to jump and Johnny says in the text that they had switchblades too.

Read More

Ponyboy Curtis's Trial

1363 Words | 6 Pages

(Page 56-57) The Greasers were clearly going to kill Ponyboy here and so Johnny had every right because he committed Justifiable Homicide according to https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2010/crime-in-the-u.s.-2010/offenses-known-to-law-enforcement/expanded/expandhomicidemain “The killing of a felon, during the commission of a felony, by a private citizen. Because these killings are determined through law enforcement investigation to be justifiable, they are tabulated separately from murder and nonnegligent manslaughter. Justifiable homicide information can be found in Expanded Homicide Data Table 14, “Justifiable Homicide, by Weapon, Law Enforcement, 2006–2010” and Expanded Homicide Data Table 15, “Justifiable Homicide, by Weapon, Private Citizen, 2006–2010.” “ This means that Johnny had the right to kill the Socials because he was stopping them from committing a felony which was killing Ponyboy so legally Johnny did nothing wrong and the Socials are to blame for the death of Bob.

Read More

Ponyboy Quotes And Analysis

452 Words | 2 Pages

This impacts the story because they were a big target for the Socs. Even though Johnny stabbed Bob, they still didn’t get caught by the police. The theme is developed through Dallas being shot by the police because he pulled a gun out on the police.

Read More

Johnny Cade Research Paper

525 Words | 3 Pages

Instead, he killed Bob. Killing someone who is not the aggressor is a crime. Johnny is guilty because he did not kill the aggressor, instead he killed Bob. To continue my point, in the argumentative debate, we had the opposing side continuously bring up the fact that Bob was the aggressor but by definition, “A person, group or nation who attacks first” and with that we know that Bob was not the one attacking Ponyboy, it was David making him the aggressor. In the book, it states Johnny saying “I killed that boy, Bob the handsome Soc” (pg 56 S.E. Hinton)

Read More

Jonathan Andrew Cade Is Not Guilty Of Murder

749 Words | 3 Pages

Since the first attack, Johnny always carried around a six inch switchblade because he feared that he may be jumped again. Johnny acted out of self defense. He was merely protecting himself, because he did not want to die nor to see his best friend get

Read More

The Greasers Dialectical Journal

1809 Words | 8 Pages

Because of Ponyboy’s guilt for thinking he started the fire, he ran in the building and saved the kids. He risked his life because he has nothing else to lose. Jail is most likely in both Ponyboy and Johnny’s future now. This impacts the reader's understanding of the book because the reader gets an insight into how much Ponyboy is willing to risk his life for someone he doesn’t even know. He’s brave

Read More

Is Johnny Justified In The Outsiders

473 Words | 2 Pages

Not over his dead body…” (34). In this piece of text Johnny is displayed as the most innocent of the group. However, it also shows that Johnny will be willing to do whatever it takes to not be afraid like he was ever again. Even if that means killing someone to do

Read More

The Outsiders By S. E. Hinton: Johnny As A Hero

1064 Words | 5 Pages

(Hinton 87). This quote describes how Johnny was willing to turn himself into the police for the crime he has committed. Although there were many consequences of doing this, such as going to jail and everybody knowing he killed Bob, Johnny still wanted to turn himself in and make things right with the law. This shows Johnny as a hero because he is showing his inner strength to have the courage to want to turn himself in. He doesn’t have to go to the police.

Read More

Is Bob Justified In The Outsiders

521 Words | 3 Pages

Ponyboy to death. According to a professional article, “What Exactly is Self Defense?” It states, “Self-defense can be a defense to assault, battery, and homicide (murder)” Since David who was ordered by Bob is considered the aggressor, Johnny was justified in killing Bob in defense of them committing homicide to his friend, Ponyboy.

Read More

Eisenhower's Domestic Affairs Analysis

398 Words | 2 Pages

This investigation of Eisenhower’s domestic affairs has given me insight into the methods, limitations, and challenges that historians face on a regular basis. I believe that I have learn more about how historians deal with different perspectives and the way time affects the way historians look at certain events. I learned that, when analyzing historical events, an essential skill is the ability to use a variety of sources in order to come to a well-informed conclusion. During this investigation, I had to read material written made by many different people. From the leader of civil right groups to Dwight D. Eisenhower, I had to gather information in order to make a proper judgement on Eisenhower’s administration and its effect on civil rights.

Read More

Toxic Stress Caused By Johnny Cade

383 Words | 2 Pages

Ponyboy was being drowned in the water and “(He) couldn’t hold (his) breath any longer”(Hinton 64). David was drowning Ponyboy to the point where he couldn't breathe and “only sucked in water”(64). If Johnny never “Killed (Bob)” he would either have drowned or got abused (63). In essence, he was only doing this for self-defense. He has gotten attacked by the Socs and now he’s taking action to defend himself and Ponyboy.

Read More

Was Ponyboys Murder Justified

229 Words | 1 Pages

It would have made Johnny and the greasers and Ponyboy’s family devastated and would be heartbroken that such a young life that had so much potential was lost rather than saving him by murdering the attacker. Furthermore, Ponyboy explains, “… [h]is [Johnny’s] voice quavered slightly...

Read More

Loss Of Innocence In The Outsiders

598 Words | 3 Pages

His sense of guilt and the fear of facing the repercussions ultimately lead to Johnny's sacrificial act, wherein he gives up his own life to save others. Johnny's journey epitomizes the tragic loss of innocence caused by the harsh realities of the

Read More

Johnny Cade As A Hero In The Outsiders

569 Words | 3 Pages

Instead of fearing for his life, he went past his comfort zone and protected PonyBoy. Johnny also acted independently with no instruction from Pony in a high pressure situation with a lot on the line, including his life. Even After being brutally beaten by Randy and Bob he still stood his ground, even when he was afraid he still confronted them and fought both of the Socs till the bitter end. As shown from multiple parts in the chapter Johnny was truly brave at the park. “Never contest a man with

Read More

Good And Bad Choices In The Outsiders

526 Words | 3 Pages

Johnny made this spontaneous decision because the Socs were trying to drown Ponyboy in the park’s fountain. When Ponyboy realized Johnny murdered Bob, Ponyboy was as frightened as if he was at a haunted house . The consequence of this choice was that Johnny and Ponyboy felt guilty ,and they Both decided to run away for a like one million years. Johnny said, “I killed him. I killed that boy (pg56).”

Read More

More about Does Johnny Deserve A Light Punishment Research Paper

Open Document