ipl-logo

Edward Snowden: Whistleblower Or Traitor

893 Words4 Pages

Edward Snowden: Whistleblower or Traitor

Edward Snowden, was he a whistleblower exercising his right to expose the government for it's unconstitutional actions, or was he simply a traitor who sold our secrets to foreign entities? American opinion is still split over Snowden. Some believe that he should be allowed to return to the U.S., while others believe that he should be tried and imprisoned for exposing state secrets to the world. These contrasting views can be partly attributed to how people view the NSA. Some see the NSA's spying programs as a serious breach of their privacy while others see it as a justifiable response to terrorism.
Continue reading, and I will attempt to explain the reasoning behind both of these arguments with …show more content…

The defense of Snowden is mainly those comparing him to a muckraker exposing the wrong doings of big businesses during the Progressive Era. Edward Snowden told The Guardian newspaper “I’m just another guy who sits there day to day in the office, watching what’s happening, and goes, “This is something that’s not our place to decide. The public needs to decide whether these programs or policies are right or wrong”.[5] This argues against those saying Snowden thought he had the right to choose what got leaked, he simply wanted the people to choose. Edward’s leaks did not contain any U.S. secret plans, identities of agents or secret algorithms.[6] Also, Edward Snowden did not simply release all the information he could, he studied each document.[6] Edward Snowden purposefully released only documents proving that the U.S. was spying on its people without telling them. Edward Snowden remarked “The only thing I fear is the harmful effects on my family, who I won’t be able to help anymore”.[7] That makes it seem as though leaking this information was so important it took precedence over his family. Most people need a very strong conviction to abandon their family, and also to leave such a “paradise”, as was said about Snowden’s life in Hawaii. When asked, by the Guardian, why he decided to leave his so called “paradise” to leak his information he said “I'm willing to sacrifice all of that because I …show more content…

Those who think that the NSA has the right to act in the way they do would tend to brand Snowden a traitor. Those against the NSA’s national security tactics find that Snowden was a hero, and consider his current circumstance a worthy

Show More
Related

Who Is Joseph Mccarthy A Victim Of The Second Red In The 1950s

3563 Words | 15 Pages

The Second Red during the 1950s was a period of heightened political repression against communists as well as a campaign spreading fear of their influence on American institutions. It was this social setting where thousands of Americans were accused of being communists or communist sympathizers and became the subject of aggressive investigations and questioning before the United States government. The most visible public figure of this attack against communist subversion was Senator Joseph McCarthy from Wisconsin. He was noted for making claims that there were large numbers of Communists and Soviet spies and sympathizers inside the United States federal government and elsewhere. His name and legacy would forever be synonymous with the term

Read More

Espionage Act Case Study

370 Words | 2 Pages

Your Honor, my client is pleading guilty to the charges of breaking the Espionage Act. Although Mr. Debs is extremely sorry for the disturbance he has caused but he was only exercising his first amendment right, peacefully. My client is aware, and has a clear understanding in what the Espionage Act is put in place for; the real problem is how could a law such as this exist? The espionage Act is in place to stop treason, and anti -americanism thoughts, but there is not enough war propaganda that exist to prohibit people from realizing war is not completely glorious. Any person that is anti- war does not make them anti-American.

Read More

9/11 Security Research Paper

441 Words | 2 Pages

“Ed Snowden from the N.S.A 30 year-old former contractor for N.S.A

Read More

Civil Disobedience Dbq Essay

518 Words | 3 Pages

For example, Edward Snowden exposed the National Security Agency for eavesdropping on Americans and people around the world, despite the possibility of being arrested and charged with heavy crimes. " So, what did the leaks tell us? First, they confirmed that the U.S. government, without obtaining any court warrants, routinely collects the phone logs of tens of millions, perhaps hundreds of millions, of Americans, who have no links to terrorism whatsoever,"(Source 3). The question is who is truly at fault? The government for doing that or Snowden for ratting them out to the public about

Read More

Watergate Throat Analysis

2406 Words | 10 Pages

The Article kept true to the facts but Mark Felt was a hero, a patriot an original Edward Snowden who did the right thing even against something that was bigger than

Read More

Letters From A Birmingham Jail By Martin Luther King Jr.

781 Words | 4 Pages

With Edward Snowden's NSA leaks, this issue was brought into relief. Was he full of moral superiority over a gray issue, or was he "that most awkward and infuriating of creatures-- a man of conscience," as John Cassidy wrote in his article "Why Edward Snowden is a Hero." Because, while Jeffrey Toobin wrote in "Edward Snowden is No Hero" that Snowden's leak was cemented in grandiose narcissism over an issue American citizens should have already digested, wasn't it after his leak that there arose an uproar over the NSA activities, which inevitably placed a modicum of agency back in the hands of the American people? I still wonder whether my perspective would be the same had Snowden released files which did more lasting harm to national security. But in that case, would that activism now be violent, instead of

Read More

Letter From Birmingham Jail

518 Words | 3 Pages

Snowden took it upon himself peacefully resist the law

Read More

Rudy Giuliani Logical Fallacies

758 Words | 4 Pages

Giuliani responds by diverting attention away from President Trump's attack on the media and towards former President Obama's attacks on the press. While in the Oval Office, Obama retaliated against whistleblowers and journalists. A notable example is that of Edward Snowden. Snowden leaked classified information about the National Security Agency, including their mass surveillance programs and their partnerships with the United Kingdom’s Government Communications Headquarters. The U.S. government responded to the leak by using the Espionage Act against Snowden, thereby choosing to ignore the unethical nature of the NSA’s programs.

Read More

Similarities Between Socrates And Snowden

1280 Words | 6 Pages

Snowden, who was a computer systems contractor, worked for the National Security Agency and revealed to the public how the American Government was spying on its own citizens and foreigners. Snowden was committed to the truth which allowed him to reason and understand the difference between what is right and what is legal. Snowden was convinced that the truth requires an individual to do the right thing and not necessarily what is legal. However, doing the right thing could sometimes require an individual to break the law.

Read More

Fourth Amendment Closets

846 Words | 4 Pages

A few weeks later, these documents were released by The Guardian, and Edward Snowden was the reliable source. Now, people all over knew that the United States Government was spying on its own people through messages, internet searches, browser history, smart T.V’s and many many more. This case is ongoing, as he seeks asylum in other countries. This newfound information raises the question, is Mr. Snowden a traitor, or did he save us all by “blowing the whistle” to warn us about the unconstitutional collection of our private possessions protected by

Read More

Why Is Edward Snowden Punished

1017 Words | 5 Pages

In the case of Edward Snowden and what he did is somewhat controversial. The controversy on this subject is that some think he should be punished for his actions and others think he should be free and have no charges. The people that think he shouldn’t be punished also think that the government is wrong for doing what it was doing. They also think he shouldn’t be punished for exposing something the government is doing that is against the law. Now if a person is in a government agency and is doing things to keep the mass majority safe will see him as a traitor and want him to be punished.

Read More

'The Vine' By Robert Herrick

621 Words | 3 Pages

People hide and refuse to accept their deepest secrets and desires. But what happens when it is time to face the truth? “The Vine” by Robert Herrick is about the narrator’s secret desire to rape a young virgin girl. In the poem about the narrator’s wet dream, Herrick uses phallic imagery to express this secret idea to the unsuspecting reader. The poem also includes the idea of repressed dreams to explain his undesirable desires.

Read More

The Argument Against Civil Disobedience

793 Words | 4 Pages

Law and order, as far as most westernized intellectuals are concerned, is the absolute protector of rights. Every advanced democracy subscribes to the continuing presence of law and order, and it’s hard to argue with the results seen and enjoyed today. As Abraham Lincoln once said, “Let every man remember that to violate the law is… to tear the charter of his own and his children’s liberty.” While this sentiment is deeply relevant, it trivializes legitimate grievances citizens have against the legal system. Many of these issues can, indeed, be worked out within the system, and permanent change is achievable.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Whistleblowing

1089 Words | 5 Pages

He is known for his part in leaking top secret NSA documents leading to revelations about the US surveillance on phone and internet communications. Snowden is now seeking asylum in Russia. He does not have the documents with him anymore as he has handed them over to First Look Media set up by Glenn Greenwald. The US government believe that the documents will never be returned to the NSA which leaves them to wonder what will be the next story to be revealed as not even the government can get access to the documents. Snowden actually tried to leave digital breadcrumbs when taking the documents so that the government would see what documents he looked at and what ones he copied and stole.

Read More

Edward Snowden Ethical Issues

1471 Words | 6 Pages

The main issue in the Snowden controversy is the conflicting rights of private individuals and the US government with regard to the use of telecommunications and the internet. There are ethical issues surrounding this controversy and the most applicable ethical approach for this case is “Ethics by Rights Approach”. As a background, the reason why US government had declared Edward Snowden a traitor is his involvement in the leaking of about 1.7 million confidential US documents, 15,000 Australian intelligence files and 58,000 British intelligence files from the National Security Agency (or NSA) to the public. These confidential information were acquired by the NSA through the PRISM program by collaborating with big internet companies such

Read More

More about Edward Snowden: Whistleblower Or Traitor

Related Topics

Open Document