ipl-logo

Electroconvulsive Therapy Argumentative Essay

2163 Words9 Pages

Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a somatic therapy, or a type of psychotherapy designed to engage a person’s body, invented in 1938. It’s one of three types of shock therapies that has been historically used in psychiatry. The other two types of shock therapies, insulin shock therapy and metrazol shock therapy, were established first and influenced the development of ECT. Understanding the history of shock therapies as a whole contextualizes the invention, use, and public and medical opinions of ECT. While both proponents and opponents of ECT agree on some key details of the history, there are factors each side tends to ignore or include in favor of presenting a specific narrative. The history of ECT is oft-debated and has been used as a …show more content…

The media often framed the use of ECT as part of a grand battle against mental illness, and in viewing treatment this way, side effects or dangers of treatment were seen as somewhat inevitable quote-unquote “casualties” of this fight (Hirshbein & Sarvananda 4). Further, evidence of ECT’s success represented a triumph of man and science over seemingly incurable disease, a feat so magnificent it made people more willing to dismiss potential consequences. From the point of view of practitioners, ECT benefited them significantly in multiple ways. First, their success and the idea that they were able to cure such a seemingly hopeless condition improved the reputation of psychiatry as whole. Its tendency to calm erratic patients also bettered the atmosphere of psychiatric hospitals, as the patients undergoing this treatment were often violent or dangers to themselves (Hirshbein 149). This, along with the treatment’s apparent success, helped practitioners justify its use. While they were aware of side effects, such as memory loss and confusion, they also noted that patients undergoing ECT tended to have better outcomes than those who did not. Some patients were even able to leave the inpatient hospitals, which was considered the best possible outcome. …show more content…

The first, a film from 1948 called The Snake Pit, features a benevolent psychiatrist doing his best to cure the main character (Hirshbein & Sarvananda 4). ECT is among the therapies he tries, and eventually, the psychiatrist is successful. While the movie portrays the doctor-patient dynamic in a way that clearly shows the psychiatrist has all the power, neither the doctor nor psychiatry itself is portrayed as a malevolent force. The second movie, a 1975 film titled One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, uses much more dramatic and horrific images of ECT, showing a patient undergoing the treatment without anaesthesia (Hirshbein & Sarvananda 9). Unlike in The Snake Pit, ECT is portrayed in this film primarily as a method of control exerted over the patient by the psychiatrist. These movies show a shift in the way the media portrayed ECT and psychiatry as a whole, especially the power dynamics between doctors and patients. For most people, the only exposure they had to ECT was through the media, so movies such as these greatly impacted the public perception of the treatment and psychiatry at

Show More
Related
295 Words | 2 Pages

1)In the Ghostbusters ESP study ,the aspect that was experimentally wrong is that the man was supposedly testing the effect of negative reinforcement on ESP ability ,and negative reinforcement occurs when a person do a behavior in order to avoid an unpleasant consequence .If the guy was the subject he received positive punishment instead ,the woman in this case don’t do anything to avoid that electric shocks ,she was just doing the same that the guy did trying to answer what figure was on the card ,but the experimenter were lying then both. It could be improving following scientific standards taking account of relevant evidence without disregard, and adulteration.2) My hypothesis in this case would be “applying electro shocks to the experimental

Read More
846 Words | 4 Pages

According to the ADAA, the Anxiety and Depression Association of America, in 2015, 16.1 million adults in the United States have experienced depression at one point of their life. A well-known electrical procedure called Electroconvulsive Shock Therapy (ECT) was used back in the 1930’s and 1940’s and still currently used today to treat depression and other mental illnesses to trigger a brief seizure. It was to believe to result to reversing symptoms of certain mental illnesses and can be an option for mentally ill patients when medications are not effective. However, ECT was often represented as an abusive form of control towards mentally ill patients in movies and TV shows when their behavior is unmanageable. In the film, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest, Nurse Ratched uses ECT to

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

Although life during the 1800s and early 1900s weren’t all that great, to begin with, compare that to how asylums treated patients during this time, the normal population life should have seen life as a simple breeze in the wind. There is a reason that our first thoughts when thinking of asylums is horror and it’s because of all of the horror shows that actually happen at these areas. Then comes in a place that has a new idea of treating patients, a new of thinking that never had been seen before. A new revolution when it comes to the psychological medical field. Step in Danvers State Hospital.

Read More
993 Words | 4 Pages

They were using these things to control the patients so that the patients would become sociable, quiet, and would conform. These treatments or therapys really were ways of manipulating the patients into acting like everyone else in society because the nurses in the mental institution as well as the rest of society and government wanted there to be no individuals, everyone had to be the same. These treatments would

Read More
746 Words | 3 Pages

From her experience with “madness,” she concluded that psychiatry was a naive field. Early in the book, she explains how society viewed mental illness in the past, saying it was demonic possession, where the treatment was to drill a hole in the patient’s skull. As the book advances, the author turns to David Rosenhan, a noted psychologist, and his study that included 8 normal people going undercover in different psychiatric facilities and claiming they heard empty, hollow voices in their heads, all of them were admitted, and most were diagnosed with schizophrenia. The study showed how psychiatry did not know how to differentiate between the sane from the insane, it also uncovered the mistreatment that patients received when they were admitted and the conditions that the patients lived in. Rosenhan’s study created mistrust in the field of psychiatry with some people saying that patients are more likely to recover if they are not admitted to a facility.

Read More
1623 Words | 7 Pages

For instance, the word is a factory to fix mistakes and problems (Kesey 41). This means that the asylum will help patients instead of causing harm. Furthermore, EST, also known as Electroshock Therapy, can be useful if done in an ethical way. This improved treatment option may be the solution to insanity or emotional instability. Although they were not aware of these conditions back then, they may have found solutions to mental problems (Fink).

Read More
504 Words | 3 Pages

The two main issues in this movie were patient treatment and experimental drug use. Both topics are very important when it comes into conversation. These are sensitive topics to talk about especially when talking about psychology or even psychiatric centers. In relation to the movie “Awakenings” these were two key situations.

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

People find it intriguing how mental health was poorly treated in the 1800’s. They were abandoned, until Eli Todd came along. For example, Eli Todd has innovated mental health with better tactics. He treated them with care and compassion. After his late sister passed, he vowed to do his best for anyone suffering mentally, leading him to build the retreat with $300k.

Read More
1099 Words | 5 Pages

In One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest, the nurse exposes the patients to harsh procedures in hopes to either cure them of their illness or stop unwanted behavior. Harding explains one of the treatments the patients endure: “Electro-Shock Therapy. Those fortunate souls in there are being given a free trip to the moon. No, on second thought, it isn’t completely free. You pay for the service with brain cells instead of money.”

Read More
1218 Words | 5 Pages

Many saw these treatments as the best solution but based on all the effects that happened without any type of consent, and how much they targeted women, there is no doubt that mental health practices in the early 1900s hurt more people than they helped. It is easy to look back to where the practices started to see how poorly they hold up by current standards. One of the first “cures” was referred to as hydrotherapy, this was

Read More
1708 Words | 7 Pages

Given the unethical and medically inappropriate role, such treatment casts mental health

Read More
1476 Words | 6 Pages

Published in 1962, Ken Kesey’s One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest tells the story of Patrick McMurphy, a newly-admitted patient at a psychiatric hospital where individuals with various mental conditions are treated. Run primarily by Nurse Ratched, a demeaning autocrat who exhibits complete control over others, the patients are subjected to various forms of treatments and therapy with the intent of rehabilitation (Kesey 5). Most forms of treatment depicted in Kesey’s novel, such as group therapy, are an accurate representation of what typical psychiatric patients may encounter while under care at a mental facility. Yet others, particularly electroshock therapy and lobotomies, were quite controversial at the time of the novel’s publication. Such treatments were questioned for their effectiveness at improving patients’ condition – and while these procedures were still occasionally performed at the time, they often did not benefit the treated individual.

Read More
789 Words | 4 Pages

In trying to unravel the puzzle of Stoker's narrative decisions, one must keep in mind that Seward's relation to Lucy, both in the finished novel and in the aforementioned outlines, cannot be purely romantic – it must also professional. Unlike the idealized but frequently absent Arthur, Seward must balance his desire for Lucy as a suitor with the detachment that is eventually expected of him as her doctor. In the novel as published, this tension between these dual roles is explicit, with Seward confessing after his initial examination of Lucy that he is unable to take “the full opportunity of examination such as [he] should wish” regarding her, as their “very friendship makes a little difficulty which not even medical science or custom can

Read More
1784 Words | 8 Pages

For example one patient quoted, “‘You get blown up and you go unconscious, like something boils up,’ described one patient of treatment. ‘I felt every time I took that as if I was going to die,’”(Fabian). Patients were put through such terrible procedures with no chance of getting out. Many patients in these hospitals and institutions were not mentally insane, however they said they were. For instance, in Illinois a husband had his wife sent to a mental institution, they came to her house, took her pulse, and declared her mentally insane.

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

In the movie I saw many disorder with all the women within the mental institution but I also notice the amount of pills the women were given. I found out the psychological term for this was Psychopharmacology.

Read More

More about Electroconvulsive Therapy Argumentative Essay

Related Topics

Open Document