ipl-logo

Comparison Between Myers-Briggs And Enneagrams

1725 Words7 Pages

Topic: Recruiting the ‘right’ employee is critical in terms of securing current corporate culture, current business demands of the organisation, planning for the future and integrating new skills. Myers-Briggs and Enneagrams are personality tests used by human resource practitioners to assist in identifying employees with the correct emotional and skill profiles for their organisation. Compare and contrast the use and respective abilities of these tests as tools to assist an organisation in employee selection.
Introduction
The recruitment process, which refers to the overall process of attracting, selecting, and appointing suitable candidates for a job within the organisation, is used to in a way predict its own success through the individuals …show more content…

For the sake of job performance, the most notable behaviours such as leadership, responsibility, emotional stability, personal relations and sociability will be used to compare and contrast two personality tests as tools to assist an organisation in employee selection. The two personality tests that will be discussed are the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator and Enneagram tests.
The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator test
The MBTI theory suggests that all people have an innate preference that determines how they will behave in all situations [5]. It also says that each person’s personality fits into one of 16 types. These personality types are based on four dimensions of personality, each consisting of two opposite preferences. The four dimensions are:
Extraversion (E) vs. Introversion (I). This dimension reflects the perceptual orientation of the individual. Extraverted individuals are outgoing, sociable and assertive. Introverts are quiet and shy.
Sensing (S) vs. Intuitive (N). Sensing types are practical and prefer routine and order focusing on details. People with an intuitive preference rely on unconscious processes and look at the ‘big picture’
Thinking (T) vs. Feeling (F). Thinking types use reason and logic to handle problems. Feeling types rely on their personal values and …show more content…

The Enneagram as a ‘nurture’ personality approach organisations can use it to determine if potential employees will thrive under work pressure.

Conclusion
Assessing some of the behaviour traits using the MBTI test showed that it is not always a good tool to use in the selection process. The MBTI which suggests that traits are inborn came short when analysed against the workplace behaviour traits because some individuals for example who ‘naturally’ introverted can compensate in extraverted situations. This test therefore should strictly be for development where individuals can identify their weaknesses to strengthen them.
The enneagram on the other hand, taking the ‘nurture’ side of things stands a better chance to be used as a tool in employee selection. This is because at that moment when a potential candidate is tested they would already have acquired that certain personality type that may be required by the organisation. Certain enneagram personality types translate into key positions within an organisation e.g. A Protector a

Show More
Related
335 Words | 2 Pages

3. Personality tests as the name suggests are conducted to measure the prospective employee’s motivation to function in a particular working condition.

Read More
1580 Words | 7 Pages

Annotated Bibliographies for a Candidacy Selection Project: Analysis of Literature Reviews Luis Navarro, Jr. Southern New Hampshire University Annotated Bibliographies for a Candidacy Selection Project: Analysis of Literature Reviews Arthur, W., Woehr, D. J., & Graziano, W. G. (2001). Personality testing in employment settings: Problems and issues in the application of typical selection practices. Personnel Review, 30(6), 657-676. The authors explain, within in this article, the issues of multi-dimensional issues of personality, linear selection model(s), effects of self-selection, biases’ with social desirability, impressionism, and among other complexes (e.g., top-down selection, legal implications).

Read More
2496 Words | 10 Pages

These became the basis for one of the most popular tools for non-psychiatric populations in the area of clinical, counseling, and personality assessment known as the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator. In this assessment, there are four different categories: extroversion or introversion, thinking or feeling, sensation or intuition, and lastly judgment or perception. Extroversion is when the psyche is focused on the outside world and how the person relates to the society, whereas introversion is when the psyche is focused on themselves. Thinking refers to a person using logic in a situation, but feeling is when a person uses their own personal values or beliefs. Sensation is when a person uses their five senses and real

Read More
1772 Words | 8 Pages

The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) is an important look at the methods humans use in our interaction with our shared environments and how we relate differently to shared experiences (Cohen, D., Cohen M., Cross, H., 1981). Differences in how individuals relate to and understand our surroundings are displayed and sorted using scales for several fields. Extroversion and introversion are determined and assigned to this indicator using either E or I. A clear definition between sensing and intuition is also defined by the assignment of S or N. Also, thinking and feeling are compared and determined adding the letters of either T or F to the result. The last letter in ones conformed profile will include either J or P for judging compared to perception.

Read More
506 Words | 3 Pages

While being in a position of leadership it is important to understand that not any two individuals are exactly the same. We do not all think, perceive, analyze or problem solve all the same way. There are many categories of personalities and there is even a self assessment you can take to see which personality traits you hold. This self-report questionnaire is also known as the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator “MBTI” and it is modeled around four different personality traits. By the end of the assessment you will have a four letter accroynm summarizing how you perceive things in the world and how you make decisions.

Read More
156 Words | 1 Pages

According to the Myers-Briggs personality type indicator, there are sixteen personality types (Robbins, DeCanzo and Coulter, 2015, p.254). As you can imagine, a mix of personalities in the workplace can be both positive and negative. It can be positive because unique personalities bring different traits and ideas into the workplace. On the other hand, it could be negative when it comes to clashing personalities that cause unhealthy and petty rivalries. I took the Myers-Briggs personality test during my first CSU-Global class and it was able assists me with understanding my personality better.

Read More
943 Words | 4 Pages

An efficient staff understands the goal and objectives of the group and is prepared to go the extra mile for the attainment of the set goals. Understanding the personality types help in a great deal in identifying suitable staffs for specific jobs. My understanding of the lecture on Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) helped to appreciate the various combinations of perspectives on personality and knowing myself. This perspective on personality types recognizes that each individual is unique but suggests that there are some broad psychological preferences that may help explain typical patterns of behavior. It reveals how individuals become accomplished at particular ways of doing things.

Read More
1139 Words | 5 Pages

I was given the traits ISFJ, which stands for introverted,

Read More
351 Words | 2 Pages

Nuclear power is a bad idea because it is not environmentally safe. These nuclear power plants are also a lot more expensive, there are cheaper ways. Nuclear power could cause a massive amount of deaths if not done right or under control. One reason is the Nuclear power activities that are involving the environment; mining, enrichment and generation.

Read More
1818 Words | 8 Pages

Strengths of using our feeling over thinking is that we can make decisions based on what we like. We regard others feelings so we strive to not say things that we know might hurt the individual. ENJs make their job choices based on how their work environment would make them feel. In comparison, the weaknesses of our personality type are that our feelings can conflict with our thoughts and we can become indecisive. According to the text, “decisions that we find most difficult are those in which we have conflicts between our Thinking and Feeling sides” (Heyward, 2015).

Read More
413 Words | 2 Pages

Natural selection and speciation drives biodiversity and evolution within a species to help that species survive while in a changing environment. Within animal species, predator and prey will evolve together, with the adaptations of one forcing the other species to adapt to survive (Keim, B. 2008). Genetic mutation and speciation within a species favors specific traits to allow future generations the advantage of survival. One of the most referred to examples of this biodiversity are the 14 species of Galapagos finches that are derived from the same one ancestral species, as documented by Charles Darwin in 1831. This study showed the world a classic example of adaptive evolution from breeding to create a dominant trait that allowed the beaks

Read More
1413 Words | 6 Pages

The counter-argument to this is that individuals will adapt their behaviour to fit the situation, and generally demonstrate some pare of their personality in a given situation (Coaley, 2014). However, personality is a broad and rather ambiguous concept, meaning that is it difficult to define succinctly; and yet how we define it plays a crucial part in how we investigate it. Eysenck’s theory of personality concluded that there were 3 dimensions: extraverted-introverted, neuroticism-stability, psychoticism-socialisation (Eysenck & Eysenck, 1964). With the broadening field of psychometrics, the Eysencks were the first to make their approach more quantifiable and legitimate than others had been in the past. Eysenck published the Eysenck Personality Inventory (EPI) in 1964 – a uni-dimensional self-report questionnaire consisting of 57 items.

Read More
1530 Words | 7 Pages

'A psychological test is any procedure on the basis of which inferences are made concerning a person 's capacity, propensity or liability to act, react, experience, or to structure or order thought or behaviour in particular ways ' (The British Psychological Society). The psychometric tests which companies make use of when selecting among job applicants have the potential to provide us with information about the kind of skills which employers are really looking for and they do provide additional information to that available in skill surveys. Psychometric tests are most likely to be used for managerial and graduate vacancies, and are seldom used for manual vacancies. The costs of these tests are substantial. This implies that

Read More
1383 Words | 6 Pages

Hence, the aim of this report is to reflect over my current personal skills and abilities assessment with a particular focus on self-development to become a management professional in order to fit into the organization and to become successful. 1.1 Personality, Assessment and Evaluations Psychologists have long recognizes the importance of work in our lives and they proposed that, personality play a significant role in all the process of work starting from how people actually perform their jobs and the attitudes they hold about them (i.e. job satisfaction) through the factors that increase or decrease their

Read More
3190 Words | 13 Pages

Recruitment means to estimate the available vacancies and to make suitable arrangements for their selection and appointment. Recruitment is understood as the process of searching for and obtaining applicants for jobs, from among whom the right people can be selected. A formal definition states “It is the process of finding and attracting capable applicants for the employment. The process begins when new recruits are sought and when their applicants are submitted. The result is the pool of applicants from which new employees are selected”.

Read More

More about Comparison Between Myers-Briggs And Enneagrams

Related Topics

Open Document