ipl-logo

Essay On Does The Officer's Actions Towards Joe Count As Custodial Interrogation

710 Words3 Pages

Statement of Assignment: This memo is intended to investigate the following issues: Does the Officer’s actions towards Joe count as “custodial” “interrogation”? If so, does that negate the charge of Curfew violation?

Incident: A 14 year old boy, Joe, was allegedly seen by an officer on the steps to an apartment at 12:30 AM. His parents or guardians weren’t reported nearby, and he allegedly was attending a party at the time. The officer approached Joe, ordered him into the police car, and asked him for his name, date of birth, address, parents’ names, and parents’ phone number, citing him for curfew violation after the information was provided.

Issue 1: Was Joe placed into “Custody?”

Law: ““Custody” is defined …show more content…

“Custody” is defined as a reasonable person’s liberty is retrained to the extent they believe they are not free to leave. “Interrogation” is defined as being asked any questions that would likely lead to an answer that would incriminate oneself.

Analysis: It is unclear whether there is a “custodial interrogation” or not. Interrogation is defined as “being asked any questions that would likely lead to an answer that would incriminate oneself”. Given the rule of law displayed, it is unclear whether being asked routine questions about one’s identity that would not incriminate a suspect normally but would for curfew violation counts as interrogation. He was not read his Miranda Rights, so it would likely not be an admissible “Custodial …show more content…

A minor commits a curfew violation whenever they are out past 12:30 a.m. without parental supervision. If Joe had a parent supervising him, such as if they were at the party, there is no curfew violation, irrespective of any other factors. An improper interrogation does not change the fact that Joe was violating curfew (if he was), and will likely not be the method police could use to establish curfew violation. If the police cannot place Joe at the location but for his statements, then whether the interrogation is valid or not becomes

Show More
Related

US 707 Fare Case Summary

556 Words | 3 Pages

Case 442 U.S. 707 Fare v. Michael C. February 27, 1979 through June 20, 1979. This case involves Michael C., a sixteen year old juvenile, brought to the police station in California by Van Nuys police on a murder investigation. The juvenile was read his Miranda prophylactic protection rights before being questioned; he requested to speak to his probation officer but was denied. Michael agreed to speak with the officers and also waived his rights to counsel. While doing this, he brought forward incriminating statements against him that in return, the juvenile landed himself in court on a murder trial.

Read More

Brendan Dassey Trial In Jerican Mckinsey's

540 Words | 3 Pages

but I wanted to go in with Brendan, the police wouldn 't let me." Investigators pulled Brendan Dassey out of class to question him without his parent 's permission. In the US if you do anything with a minor you have to have parental/guardian consent you want to take their picture at a public event a waiver has to get signed if you want to quote them and an article about something they 're doing someone has to approve it Brendan does his mother had absolutely no idea some of the questions he was being asked by investigators because they had

Read More

Julian Steele Police Misconduct Case

583 Words | 3 Pages

The police misconduct case that will be reviewed today by police review board is the case of State V. Steele. “On May 26, 2009, police officer Julian Steele was indicted on ten Counts, including abduction and intimidation, and sexual battery” (Supreme Court of Ohio, n.d). Julian Steele was an officer doing an investigation into robbery that occurred in a “Cincinnati neighborhood in 2009”. Officer Steele was accused of misusing his power to retrieve details about the robbery and sexual intercourse. Police office Julian Steele begins his investigation with an arrest of Ms. Maxton three young children.

Read More

Hayes V. Wells Affirmative Hearing

279 Words | 2 Pages

Procedural History: At the suppression hearing, Hayes said he asked Macabeo basic questions that he would normally ask on a stop. He thought the defendant was acting fidgety so he conducted a patdown which did not reveal anything suspicious. He removed his cell phone out of his pocket and handed it to Officer Raymond. Raymond searched the phone without consent from the defendant.

Read More

Pinkerman's Level 3

723 Words | 3 Pages

Once Officer Martin grabbed Mr. Youngs’ arm, he attempted to pull away and began to kick at other officers and flail his arm. The Level I response by Officer Pinkerman was based off Mr. Youngs’ actions and were reasonable to prevent Mr. Youngs from entering the residence. Once on the ground in the doorway to Mr. Youngs apartment, Mr. Youngs tightly held his arms under his body and would not follow commands to stop resisting. Not knowing if Mr. Youngs possessed a knife or any other weapons on his person, Officer Martin followed her training and

Read More

Summary Of Fare V. Michael C.

734 Words | 3 Pages

Fare v. Michael C. is a case from 1979 where the United States Supreme Court reviewed what would make a juvenile’s confession inadmissible in court (Elrod & Ryder, 2014). The case begins with the respondent, Michael C., a 16-year-old juvenile being taken into custody by Van Nuys police in California on the suspicion of murder. He was immediately taken to the police station for questioning. Prior to the beginning of questioning, police fully advised Michael of his rights under Miranda v. Arizona. At the beginning of the questioning, Michael, who was on probation in the Juvenile Court, asked for his probation officer to be present.

Read More

Felony Argument Against Oleg For Order Violation

234 Words | 1 Pages

I knocked on the door, announced I was the Police, told Oleg he was under arrest for an order violation, and advised him to come outside. I heard a male inside the playhouse ask multiple times why we were there, and heard someone walking back and forth inside. After a few minutes, a male, who identified himself as Oleg, came outside. I placed Oleg into handcuffs and again advised him he was under arrest for violation of an order. Officer Benavente advised Oleg of his Constitutional Rights, and Oleg said he understood and was willing to speak with Police.

Read More

Brenton Butler Interrogation Case Study

678 Words | 3 Pages

In fact, when one of the police officers was asked if he was there to get a confession, he responded, “yes.” Over the course of this interrogation, the police officers physically and emotionally

Read More

Examples Of Will There Ever Be Justice For Michelle O Connell

795 Words | 4 Pages

They questioned him in a squad car instead of in an office. They allowed other people to

Read More

Miranda Vs. Arizona Policing Cases

538 Words | 3 Pages

Policing was forever changed in 1966 after the deciding factor of the case Miranda vs. Arizona. The case also addressed three other cases involving custodial interrogations, the cases were Vignera vs. New York, Westover vs. United States, and California vs. Stewart. Ernesto Miranda was arrested for rape, kidnapping, and robbery, after he was identified by the victim. Miranda was not informed of his 5th amendment rights to self incrimination, and also his 6th amendment right to have a counsel. Miranda was then interrogated by the Phoenix Police where he was arrested for two hours, and allegedly confessed to the crimes which was recorded by the police.

Read More

Detention Center Scandal

386 Words | 2 Pages

On 10/26/15 Ms. Calhoun visited Deven at the detention center where he’s being detained. The reporter stated when interviewing the child, she witnessed his right eye was swollen with a dark mark under it. According to the reporter, Deven wrote a detailed statement of grievance that gives a detail account of an altercation between him and Officer Kennedy on 10/23/15. In the detailed statement, Deven described the incident as follow: Deven states he asked Officer Kennedy if he could go to his room and was told to have a seat. Officer Cole gave Deven permission to go to his cell and as he waited at his cell door for it to be opened, Officer Kennedy told the child to have a seat.

Read More

In Re Gault Case Study

863 Words | 4 Pages

He claimed that the arresting officer never told the teen what he was being

Read More

To What Extent Should Parents Be Held Responsible For Children's Crimes

1267 Words | 6 Pages

The young boy spent two months in juvie until his court date arrived. In the courtroom the judge declared that the parents were to blame for their child's actions; they would be held accountable and later be fined. In the law it states that parents have a responsibility to teach and supervise their children under the age of 18. If a minor committed an offensive violent crime that results in time spent in juvenile detention then the parents can be very much held accountable and fined. Parents of

Read More

Vincent Van Gogh The Great Depression

1132 Words | 5 Pages

Vincent Van Gogh was the greatest artist in European history. Someone who is the greatest artist in European history must have a life full of art and personal art work. They will have had to work hard to get recognized and must have put lots of effort into their work. They must have very important pieces of art and they need to have invented or created a fantastic new form of art. Although known for his sad depression and unsuccessful first attempts at painting, Vincent Van Gogh is the greatest artist in European history because he was ahead of his time with his impressionist paintings, he never gave up on his artwork, and his paintings are some of the most popular in the world.

Read More

Obesity Should Be Taught In Schools Essay

676 Words | 3 Pages

In today’s society health is one of the biggest issues. Doctors, scientists, and every day people are always trying to find new ways to eat healthier not just for themselves but for their children, patients, and loved ones. The obesity rate has been going up rapidly for years now especially for children and teens. The topic I will cover is “Should changes be made to the regulations for foods that are served in public schools?” Simply because most of the hours spent a day in a child/teens life is at school and it is important to lower the obese weight for children for their fu-ture.

Read More

More about Essay On Does The Officer's Actions Towards Joe Count As Custodial Interrogation

Related Topics

Open Document