ipl-logo

Essay On The Menedez Boys Unethical

970 Words4 Pages

The Menedez Brothers, Erik and Lyle, are two of the most notorious criminals in American history. They were convicted of the 1989 murder of their wealthy parents, Jose and Kitty Menedez. The trial was a sensationalized media event that revealed a story of abuse and neglect at the hands of their parents. It also highlighted questions about the justice system's ability to deal with such heinous crimes. This case has been studied for decades by legal scholars and has become an important part of criminal law history.

Erik and Lyle lived in a country and time with laws which perceive domestic abuse victims as mentally ill or cold-blooded killers for killing their parents after years of prolonged abuse. A country which provides more protection to …show more content…

So Erik and Lyle, as parent-murderers, were cultural defendants even before they were legal ones.

But was the motive for the killings just desperation to escape from this insufferable abuse or was it simply just greed?
Well, the brothers, claimed life for them wasn't as it seemed. The abuse they suffered from both of their parents is a incredibly long list and is so brutal that i can’t mention half of it as it would be too inappropriate but to give you an idea; they had
Beat Erik with a belt or fists
SlappedErik across the face
Thrown Erik into walls, doors, furniture, fences etc.
Thrown Erik through a glass door until it …show more content…

The abuse they had face started when Lyle was 6 until he turned 23. A whole 17 years of never ending trauma induced by the people who are supposed to love and care for you the most. Erik and Lyle, as well as their defendants, believe Jose was a domineering, ruthless father and Kitty Menendez as a kind of passive pill-popping alcoholic.
The brothers expressed how they felt they were under imminent danger from their parents, mixed with the complicated entanglement of love and fear, of paranoia and projection involved with living with sexual abuse. Adding to that situation, Jose had allegedly threatened to kill the brothers after they told him they were going to share about all the abuse they had faced from him to the public. So after years of abuse had made them so paranoid, how were they going to react with anything else but violence in order to protect themselves?
Even with these statements the brothers were convicted with two accounts of first degree murder and no chance of parol. Possibly due to an unjust trial as their lawyer claims that they were using the boys to get re-elected. Even their own family picked side depending which would benefit them the

Show More
Related

MONSTER, By Walter Dean Myers

200 Words | 1 Pages

In the novel MONSTER, written by Walter Dean Myers, tells the story of two men under the age of 25 on trial for felony murder. Steve Harmon is a 16 year old boy who is accused of being the lookout to a robbery that James King, a 22 year old and his friend Bobo Evans were planning. James King is accused of being the one that ripped Alguinaldo Nesbit’s gun from him and used it to shoot and kill Mr.Nesbit. Prosecutor Sandra Petrocelli works to convince the jury that their age isn’t an excuse that a man died at their hands. Kathy O’brien and Asa Briggs both work as the attorneys to prove that one of these men are innocent.

Read More

Why Did Austria-Hungary Blame For Ww1

760 Words | 4 Pages

In the context of World War I’s outbreak it is agreeable that Germany carries most of the blame, however both Russia and Austria-Hungary carry some of the blame as well. Germany can be held accountable for the outbreak because of their carelessness and impulsive actions. Germany was careless in regards of the Ultimatum sent to Serbia. Germany was impulsive when giving out the blank check and invading Belgium. On the account of Austria Hungary is of fault because they assumed that Russia would not join the war and they were hostile with Serbia.

Read More

Antoine Thomas And The Murder Of Luis Cruz

157 Words | 1 Pages

Antoine Thomas was the eyewitness who tipped police on the identity of the murderer who killed Luis Cruz, and it was Arthur Bauer. When the police showed up to take Arthur away, Paul seized his chance to stand up to his monstrous elder brother Erik. So, he informed the police that not only was Arthur involved with the murder, but that Erik had given the order to kill,“I saw—I heard Erik Fisher tell him to do it.” In addition to Paul being able to slip the cold and unforgiving grasp of his elder brother, but also to gain the astrayed attention that had been directed at his superstar brother. Now his dad who had been too busy to witness any of his soccer games finally pays attention to his son and even drives him to his first day of school.

Read More

Laci And Scott Peterson: Guilty Of First Degree Murder

457 Words | 2 Pages

On the night of December 24th, 2002 there was a huge crime scene down in San Francisco Bay. It is said that Scott Peterson had committed first degree murder on his wife Laci Peterson and second degree murder on his unborn son Conner. In the beginning of Laci and Scott’s marriage, Scott was not a happy person. He started to have affairs and was stressed with work, amongst preparing for a baby. Originally, Scott had wanted to divorce Laci but he found a less expensive route:murder.

Read More

Summary Of Columbine By Dave Cullen

534 Words | 3 Pages

Even serial killers lose interest for a few days.” (Cullen 350). The author allows the readers to see the conceding thoughts that come from the killers, and what lies in their minds. In efforts to develop the reader's knowledge of Klebold and Harris’ mindset and thoughts, Cullen treats Klebold as the “follower” while Harris made all the decisions. “Eric was likely proud and inflated, but tired of it already.

Read More

What Was The Legal Significance Of The Case Of Gerald Gault

878 Words | 4 Pages

On the same day the boys, both Lewis and Gault were taken to the state’s children detention center. Gault’s parent were never notified of the arrest until they went to look for him, and the Lewis’s family told Gault’s older brother. The parent went to the detention center, where the superintendent told them

Read More

Justin Morton Case Study

518 Words | 3 Pages

The criminal case I have selected for this assignment is on Justin Morton; who at the age of fourteen years old Morton was the first youth convicted of first-degree murder section 231 CC. Although, The report show that the young man was raised in a healthy and supportive home with his mother and father. In spite of this, Justin expresses to his psychiatrist his impulse and desire for inflicting pain on others; he claims to have no remorse for the murder of Eric Levrack. Not to mention, He also voiced to former classmates that "Eric was annoying, always invading his space. "As a matter of fact, after the killing on April 1, 2003, Morton had turned himself in, he described the event as an open game of trust just before he strangled Eric with a belt.

Read More

Debate On Saving Society's Lost By Don Terry Summary

832 Words | 4 Pages

Terry goes upon many sources that say statements and give background information that call for sympathy for the young boys. For example, he brings up that the boys were, “Ignored, neglected and failed for most of their lives by parents, teachers and social workers,” [Terry]. This is, in a way, a guilt trip into having the reader feel bad for the boys because they had horrible upbringing. Terry connects his main point to the background information of the boys because it sheds light as to why the boys turned out the way they are. Also, the majority of the article was about the side of the argument that fought for giving the boys treatment rather than imprisonment.

Read More

Kray Twins Research Paper

1254 Words | 6 Pages

A pair of criminals, widely known as the Kray Twins, aimed to create fear in everyone that may or may not have crossed their path. These twins became the most feared criminals with their violent acts of aggression and gang like style within the 1960s. The Kray twins were born Reginald and Ronald Kray, identical schizophrenic twins birthed in Easton, London to Charlie and Violet Kray. These twins grew up on intense streets of Easton which were filled with crime, street trade, and violence, following in their grandfather’s footsteps; there was no real acknowledgement of their mental illness. The boys were quiet different in personality and sexual orientation but that did not prevent them from building, securing, and protecting their empire and themselves.

Read More

Comparing The Somber Voice And The Death Of Mike Costello

1087 Words | 5 Pages

Imagine this, a child not much older than you, murdering someone. Yes, this has happened and this person just happens to be Erik Fisher. In the novel it states that Erik Fisher was involved of the murder of Luis Cruz. While one may be thinking, “What” or “murder?!” , another could be thinking well maybe there's a reason.

Read More

Bryan Stevensons Grandfather's Murder

693 Words | 3 Pages

The kids who had committed the murder of his grandfather were once again not raised in a stable environment to teach them to not commit an awful crime. Stevenson states, “My grandfather’s murder left us with so many questions. Now, decades later, I was starting to understand”(Stevenson 221). He also states, “On top of all the stresses all teens experience, those who grow up in poor, or in environments marked by abuse, violence, dysfunction, or neglect are vulnerable to this sort of extremely poor decision making”(Stevenson 222). These show how after the murder of his grandfather, it changed his understanding of children commiting crimes and where it all starts from.

Read More

Unethical Behavior In Miss Evers Boys

1342 Words | 6 Pages

In the film, Miss Evers' Boys, Eunice Evers demonstrates some unethical behavior when her and a fellow colleague begin a study on a group of African American men who suffer from syphilis. Prior to their study on the men, there had been a similar study conducted on white men. Doctor Brodus and Miss Evers were trying to prove to the people that syphilis can affect anyone. They began the study by testing the African American men for the disease, then provided them with treatment. Miss Evers provided them with minimal information about the disease, in order to get them to participate in the study.

Read More

Menendez Brothers Research Paper

1010 Words | 5 Pages

Each day, the courtroom was filled with reporters, writers, and friends who camped out at 2 am with hopes of getting a seat. At the first trial, they had brought up sexual molestation and the self-defense plea. Lyle falsely testified that his father violated him when he was 7 years old, and 13 when his mom stopped. Erik dishonestly explained Lyle and he shared that their parents were abusing them when Kitty slapped Lyle, and Erik was shocked when his brother’s hair fell off. Lyle’s old girlfriend, Jamie Pisarcik, testified that Erik couldn’t have been shocked when Lyle’s baldness was revealed because Erik had told her the previous spring about Lyle wearing a toupee.

Read More

Road Beyond Abuse Analysis

692 Words | 3 Pages

As I watched the documentary “Road Beyond Abuse,” I experienced a whirlwind of emotions. From disgusted and disappointed to impressed and joyful, I felt it all. It truly disturbed me to hear about the experiences both Michael McCain and Johnnetta McSwain endured. I was disgusted that no one protected these innocent children from being verbally abused, beaten, raped, and left to fend for themselves. It was shocking to hear that these children withstood this amount of abuse from their family members until they were teenagers.

Read More

Ethical Issues In Juvenile Justice

1678 Words | 7 Pages

In the article, “Greg Ousley Is Sorry for Killing Parents. Is That Enough?,” by Scott Anderson proves that some young individuals may act violently for certain matters because of how their parents treat them. It is unclear as to why juveniles and adolescents automatically go into extreme measures, however, this may be caused by lack of support from their parents. Anderson asserts, “What Phillips couldn’t see was that Greg’s behavior masked a rapidly deteriorating home life, where he was now the sole focus of his mother’s rage. Almost daily, Greg told me, his mother would rip into him about something- his grades, his appearance, his choice of friends- ferocious tirades that often culminated in her telling him, “I know you’re going to leave me just like your sisters did.”

Read More

More about Essay On The Menedez Boys Unethical

Related Topics

Open Document