ipl-logo

Extraordinary Leadership: Implementation Of The Engstrom Auto Mirror Plant

969 Words4 Pages

The Engstrom Auto Mirror Plant in Richmond, Indiana, had manufactured high-quality mirrors for trucks and automobiles since 1948. The plant had been a symbol of success until the late 1990´s where it had redesigned it production lines with new technology. This led to the resignation of the former manager, and in 1998, Engstrom hired the new manager, Ron Bent. Bent had to make a turnaround for the plant, and central to this was the implementation of the Scanlon Plan. The Scanlon Plan was an employee incentive program developed in the 1930´s by Joseph Scanlon. The plan worked as a bonus plan to motivate employees by rewarding them for increased productivity and, thereby, cost savings. For several years, the Scanlon Plan worked perfectly for Engstrom, …show more content…

Theoretical Framework
To understand the underlying and the lesser visible aspect of Engstrom, this theoretical framework will give insight in theories about the system and motivation in the organization. In this case, organizational structure and culture can influence employee motivation which will impact productivity, satisfaction, and overall success. Therefore, this framework will be used to answer the research questions throughout this paper.
In “Extraordinary leadership: Addressing the gaps of senior executive development” by Oshry et. al (2010), the system of an organization is laid upon focus. Organizational structures are important for good leadership and communication. A transparent hierarchy inside an organization can help and, thereby, solve the principle-agent problem of achieving the same goal for the employer and employees. The employer and employees have power over each other, and in the absence of a well-working hierarchy, tension can …show more content…

People are intrinsically motivated when they find the activity itself enjoyable, interesting, or personally rewarding. The motivation to participate in the activity comes from within, driven by a sense of a desire for personal growth. All three factors from RSA (2010) were intrinsic.
On the other hand, extrinsic motivation is driven by external factors or incentives that are separate from the activity itself. Individuals are motivated by external rewards or recognition. The motivation to engage in the activity comes from the desire to attain something external such as a social reward or money.
It is important that both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation is used to obtain the optimal level of motivation. Extrinsic motivation can have a crowding out effect on intrinsic motivation when it is used in the means of controlling. This controlling effect will work as a lack of trust and understanding, and the wages will crowd out and reduce performance. Extrinsic motivation can also have a crowding in effect when it is used as a concerning tool about the employees’ skills where it has an informing effect. The optimal level can be achieved when intrinsic motivation is supported by appropriate extrinsic

Show More
Related
840 Words | 4 Pages

The participative model of organizational behavior emphasizes the involvement of employees in the process of making decisions and encourages their continuous participation in crafting the organization's direction. This model recognizes the value of employee input, thoughts, and perspectives in achieving organizational goals and fostering a positive work environment (Newstrom, 2015). In the Engstrom study, the Scanlon Plan is described as a tool to foster teamwork and communication. Constant meetings were conducted where employees would share their suggestions, concerns, and new ideas. This participative approach would allow employees to have a voice in shaping the organization and would contribute to a sense of shared responsibility for achieving performance targets.

Read More
1335 Words | 6 Pages

These motivations are the reason an individual participates in the activity, either for an intrinsic or extrinsic reward. In my swimming career I have noticed that Motivation of an athlete varies based on the individual and can be applied accordingly by the coach when coach/athlete relationship is increased. An example of an intrinsic motivated individual was when I was shown a lane of individuals that weren’t necessarily the strongest swimmers but included a few athletes that are doing a second sport. I was informed that many of them compete for their personal enjoyment. These swimmers strived for personal improvement by some of the swimmers putting personal goals on their kickboard as they kicked.

Read More
5624 Words | 23 Pages

Organizational Behavior Issues in Engstrom Auto Mirror Plant Organizational issues Engstrom Auto Mirror Plant faces multiple quandaries associated with human behavior. Workers feel unappreciated as an integral part of the company, disposable and insignificant. Suspicion about bonus calculations, lack of transparency, job insecurity, and perceptions of inequitableness in the payment scheme have instigated uncertainty and open rebellion against the company. One of the core problems at the organization is low productivity.

Read More
1607 Words | 7 Pages

Specific motivations can be invoked by external goals or rewards, such as working to get money to buy a desired product or service. People are also driven by the desire to reach their own potential,

Read More
2919 Words | 12 Pages

According to the National Institute of Health, “Intrinsic motivation is defined as the doing of an activity for its inherent satisfaction rather than for some separable consequence. When intrinsically motivated, a person is moved to act for the fun or challenge entailed rather than because of external products, pressures, or rewards' ' (Oudeyer P-Y, Kaplan F). AdvoCare works with intrinsic motivation by having their customers feel more energized, helping them improve their overall health, and guiding them to feel accomplished for following through with a program built to help them improve themselves. Through the scope of extrinsic motivation, according to the National Institute of Health, “ extrinsic motivation is defined as being motivated for instrumental value or doing something because it leads to a separable outcome” (Oudeyer P-Y, Kaplan F).

Read More
871 Words | 4 Pages

He focused on meeting schedule dates, and on business needs. In order to be on schedule people had to work extra time on certain things without being paid. Overall, Peeters Kivestu strategy worked throughout ResNet. During the ResNet project there were meeting with member to deal with any potential scope changes. To control quality the industrial engineers took important actions.

Read More
546 Words | 3 Pages

For drivers of educational, some people do it by external because money; for example, to find a good job need a good qualifications; and others aspiration for obtaining knowledge. I think this can be distinguished into intrinsic and extrinsic drivers. Although they can all driving people to receive education, their results are not the same. Daniel H. Pink introduces two new concepts in the book Drive-Type I and Type X, Motivation 2.0 depended on and fostered Type X (Extrinsic) behavior- in my opinion Type X, they focused on external rewards, and Motivation 3.0 depended on and fostered Type I (Intrinsic) behavior-they main motivator is the freedom, in other words,Type X and Type I can be divided into two types: Extrinsically motivated and Intrinsically motivated. “To be sure, reducing human behavior to two categories sacrifices a certain amount of nuance.”(76)

Read More
475 Words | 2 Pages

Issues/Problem Many of Engstrom Auto Mirror plant’s struggles during the recent economic downturn are clearly the cause of problems implementing the Scanlon plan. The first fundamental problem is the complicated formula that the Scanlon plan uses to determine an individual’s bonus based off of the company’s results, which remains confusing and vexing to employees. The bonuses paid out by the company also do not reflect individual productivity, as each employee takes home the same check regardless of the amount of effort shown. In addition, the way these bonuses were doled out over many years caused many of the workers to assume that they were simply a part of their salary, not expecting them to vanish when tough times hit the company.

Read More
460 Words | 2 Pages

However, both of these conditions are quite difficult to achieve in the workplace. The implications of this research in the real world are evident and plenty. This research provides a general framework for how businesses and groups should operate. Instituting a hierarchy is an essential step to an organized and efficient firm. Based on the results and conclusion of this article, the researchers took the initiative of supplying more advice on effective business managing that had been extrapolated from their data.

Read More
2051 Words | 9 Pages

If people can’t do something, for sure they will tell you can’t do it too. And if you want something, go and get it. (Will Smith Movie Quotes That Will Motivate You Through Adversity, n.d.). Motivation can further divided into two subtypes which are intrinsic motivation and extrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation is the motivation that comes from inner side of one self and urges him in doing something no matter what is the external reward given.

Read More
1010 Words | 5 Pages

Do you know the importance of having a hierarchy structure within any given work space?   Without structure there would be no clear line of communication between workers.  Having a structure in a workplace establishes communication skills, defuses conflicts, and also provides awareness of leaders who are in charge of you.  

Read More
989 Words | 4 Pages

As humans, we are animals of motivation. We are motivated for and from different things since the day we are born. We are motivated mostly by two motivational factors: intrinsic and extrinsic. Extrinsic factors happens when we are motivated to perform a behaviour in order to get a reward or to avoid punishment or something unpleasant.

Read More
922 Words | 4 Pages

However, as I think human learning should be life-long, extrinsic motivation cannot be stand out from the crowd without intrinsic motivation as human wants are always changing in grow up process according to the hierarchy of needs by Maslow from “outer needs to inner needs”. Sometimes competing for extrinsic motivators may not be good for people at all time, such as students. If students are just focusing on their GPA instead of the knowledge they are able to acquire from the books, the knowledge will be no longer to be life-long as students’ goals are completing their desired GPA or achieving a good ranking in their class instead of they try to remember certain knowledge that they could be utilize even after their graduation. Extrinsic motivation is definitely a good tool in human learning, it should be best utilized together with intrinsic motivation. If it is able to understand the key differences between the two types of motivation and better consider on the each may impact on behaviors, learning can be efficient and rewarding in its original

Read More
909 Words | 4 Pages

This type of motivation arise from outside the individual, as opposed to intrinsic motivation, which originates inside of the individual. This includes parental expectations, expectations of other trusted role models, earning potential of study, and grades. Students who are extrinsically motivated might say something like, “I need a B in statistics to get into business school”, and/or “If I flunk chemistry, I will lose my scholarship.” Extrinsic motivators more readily produce behavior changes and typically involve relatively little effort or preparation. The disadvantage to extrinsic motivators can distract students from learning the subject at hand.

Read More
762 Words | 4 Pages

Intrinsic motivation is defined as taking some action solely to

Read More

More about Extraordinary Leadership: Implementation Of The Engstrom Auto Mirror Plant

Related Topics

Open Document