ipl-logo

Frank Desmoulin Case Study

1011 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Aboriginal people injustices in canada

Background: The case focuses on an appeal formed by the decision of the Criminal Injuries Compensation Board based on the applicant Frank Desmoulin. Desmoulin is an aboriginal man who resided in St. Joseph’s Training School in Alfred for a duration of 11 months from 1965-1966, where he endured physical and mental abuse. Desmoulin had been severely beaten on several occasions, forced to kneel all day, handcuffed while forced to face the wall, and was a victim of countless other abusive treatment while attending St. Joseph’s Training School. Following up into his adult years, Desmoulin has had multiple run ins with the law, forming a lengthy criminal record. His negative engagements with the law have accumulated to 38 different charges withdrawn …show more content…

This hearing made their final decision on whether Frank Desmoulin would be compensated by weighting the suffering faced as a result of the mistreatment and abuse exhibited by the school to the suffering Desmoulin inflicted on the victims involved in his criminal activities of more recent years. The board came to the conclusion that it would not be sensible to compensate Frank Desmoulin for his pain and suffering due to the degree of suffering he imposed on others, thus his application was denied. It is vital to consider the legal grounds the appeal lies on by analyzing section 5 of the Compensation for Victims of Crime Act, which details the criteria and limitations bound to an application. The sections goes to state : “Where any person is injured…by any act or omission in Ontario of any other person occurring in or resulting from, (a) the commission of a crime of violence constituting an offence against the Criminal Code (Canada), including poisoning, arson, criminal negligence and an offence under section 86 of that Act but not including an offence involving the use or operation of a motor vehicle other than assault by means of a motor …show more content…

. . (d) Pain and suffering;” Following section 17 that highlights “(1)In determining whether to make an order for compensation and the amount thereof, the Board shall have regard to all relevant circumstances, including any behaviour of the victim that may have directly or indirectly contributed to his or her injury or death.” Issues: The issues presented in this case are regarding whether it is fair that the decisions are reviewed on a standard of correctness rather than a standard of review of reasonableness deemed appropriate for a tribunal’s applicant. Thus, the issue arising from this is the arguable interpretation and application of section 17 of the Compensation for Victims of Crime Act. Question remains as to whether the board exercised within its discretion or choose to not incorporate all relevant circumstances including his aboriginal status and whether Gladue principles were factored in the decision making

Show More
Related
1020 Words | 5 Pages

The outcome was hailed a victory for representative government, democracy, government accountability and fundamental human rights. However, perhaps the biggest social issue related to the case, the result was in essence a vindication of Indigenous and Aboriginal rights. Obvious social issues applied in the case, after all, societal prejudice against prisoners is what first spawned the Howard governments blanket ban of prisoners voting rights. However, Aboriginal issues were also called into question, as Indigenous Australians are incarcerated at a rate 13 times higher than that of non Indigenous Australians. The case also brought to light serious flaws relating to the system of representative and accountable government.

Read More
1230 Words | 5 Pages

He believed that because Blackburn bore a striking resemblance to a photograph of the offender, he must be the culprit (New South Wales 1990). Furthermore, victim identification of Mr Blackburn through ‘operation photo’ fuelled this opinion despite negative identification and other conflicting evidence. In Addition, direct involvement by senior police into the matter resulted in confusion and miscommunication between the lines of enquiry and command which led to a lack of questioning to check the worth or value of the evidence created through ‘operation photo’ (New South Wales 1990). This essay will argue that the miscarriage of justice for Mr Blackburn was founded on police incompetence and negligence regarding the evaluation of evidence and a failure to objectively and neutrally approach the case. It will do this through critique of the evidence, in particular the identification evidence, presented or ignored which could implicate Mr Blackburn under the law as it stood then and as it stands

Read More
699 Words | 3 Pages

Legal History/Procedure: The tribunal for the Ellison v. Burger King Corp. case was presiding judge, Blackburn of the Court of Appeals of Georgia. The trial court granted summary judgement in favor of defendants Burger King, SRH (Southern Restaurant Hospitality), Carl Payton (SRH president), and the manager. Ellison appealed the judgement of the trial court to the Court of Appeals contending that material issues of fact impeded summary judgment. Operative Facts: Sharon Ellison, went to a Burger king to put in her order and wanted to know why no one was serving her. She claims the manager on duty put her hands around her neck and eventually started shaking her head.

Read More
334 Words | 2 Pages

In the case of Tara Brown’s murder, various groups of individuals are affected. As well as maintaining principles of fair punishment and deterrence, the criminal justice system has to consider perceptions of the victim’s family (secondary victim), the community’s demand for crime prevention, and the offender’s rights to a fair court hearing. The most likely outcome is imprisonment for Lionel John Patea due to committing an indictable offence. It is important to note that if this was only a case of domestic abuse without murder, it would utilise more time, effort and expenses to come to a resolution. This is due to the different circumstances and degree of abuse that the judge has to assess.

Read More
1344 Words | 6 Pages

The case of R. v. Schoenborn is a troubling case involving the death of three children and the defence of not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder. This defence must be critically analyzed along with the evidence and expert opinions as it could absolve the accused of the charges. As well, the precedent that the verdict provides is critical to the legal system and its future implication and thus give the decision more importance. After a thorough examination of the facts, it is evident that the verdict of the Supreme Court of British Columbia is correct and reflects the administration’s objectives and beliefs. This will be demonstrated through the application of legal principles and elements.

Read More
891 Words | 4 Pages

According to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, “Any person charged with an offence has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty according to law in a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal” (Legislative Services Branch, 2017, para. 11). In the significant Canadian case R. v. Kokopenace, an Aboriginal man was tried by an unfair jury as the community where the trial took place was 25 percent First Nations, however, the jury only included 4 percent of First Nations people (Pinder, 2015). This report will summarize the major facts of the case, court’s decisions, and dissenting opinions of the judges. Clifford Kokopenace was an Aboriginal man who lived on the Grassy Narrows First Nations reserve

Read More
330 Words | 2 Pages

The Eatock v Bolt (2011) FCA 1103 case is a striking example of how unregulated Media power can undermine and humiliate the interests of the vulnerable. It was alleged that Mr Andrew Bolt, Australian journalist and right-wing political commentator, racially vilified Mrs Pat Eatock and various other members of the Indigenous community. Bolt’s comments were reportedly insensitive to the “light-skinned” Aboriginals of Australia, in which he vilified unlawfully under Section18C (1) through “insulting, humiliating, offensive” commentary. At the conclusion of the case it was found that Bolt did indeed breech the provisions of Section18C. But it was the nature of his punishment which reignited the flame to the Section18 debate.

Read More
1340 Words | 6 Pages

“On July 30, 1992, an innocent person was convicted of a heinous crime”. Guy Paul Morin, an ordinary man, was arrested, imprisoned and convicted of first degree murder. The victim was Christine Jessop, a nine-year-old girl from Ontario, Canada. She was found murdered in a field about fifty kilometres from where she lived. Due to the investigation team’s carelessness and tunnel vision, the systematic failure of the justice system, and the poor handling of evidence by the crown there was not only one, but two victims in this case.

Read More
1587 Words | 7 Pages

In order for a person to be found guilty of a crime, two elements must be present which are the actus reus (guilty act) and the mens rea (guilty mind). The first part of this essay seeks to consider the liability for homicide offences and also assess whether Jason, Welch, Ellis and Stevens have any potential defences based on the crimes they committed. P360 Will Jason be held liable for the death of pinky? Pinky suffered harm from Jason’s act, in a situation like this, we would need to look at s. 18, s. 20 and s. 47 of the offences against the person act 1861.

Read More
616 Words | 3 Pages

The reason for the legislation was so victims could have a voice during the proceedings. The judicial systems also felt that the victims were not being adequately accounted for by the courts. Victims felt as if their own personal experience of the crime was being brushed aside. Victims felt as though the sentence of the defendant was not proportional to the crime they committed leaving victims feeling ignored. The Victim impact statement was also introduced to help victims with trauma and gain closure to the crime committed against them (victimsofcrime.gov.au,

Read More
218 Words | 1 Pages

Recognising Indigenous traditional law will strengthen traditional authority within Australia indigenous community and help to maintain order particularly for the traditionally oriented person because customary punishments will be understood in terms of traditional values (ALRC report, 31 1986). Making punishment more applicable and having significant impact upon individuals (ALRC report, 31 1986). Acknowledging customary laws can also help with interrogations issues faced by indigenous people. Language barriers and an inadequate understanding of Australian criminal justice system can lead to individuals providing authority figures with responses that are anticipated rather than what occurred (Debelle, 2008). Police conducting interviews can

Read More
1370 Words | 6 Pages

The partial legal defence of provocation in Queensland’s criminal justice system exists to protect a person who has been charged with a criminal offence if they were provoked into committing the criminal offence. The defence aims to protect the accused by reducing their sentence if their actions are considered a reasonable reaction to being provoked. The defence of provocation is not justifiable in its current state, as it does not meet the expectations of modern society. While the defence has already undergone reforms, in consideration of criticisms, these have been ineffective in causing the defence to be fair and justifiable, showing its need for reform.

Read More
325 Words | 2 Pages

Victim compensation is a governmental program that seeks to award victims of crime with monetary reimbursement or certain tools aid them begin the healing process. The people eligible for this kind of program are articulated to either be victims of various crime such as murder, rape, theft, assault, threats to life and in some instances burglary. Family members and the dependents of homicide victims are eligible to this compensation. Persons who have the responsibility for funeral preparations can be awarded as far as they can apply for this fund. Often, such victims are in dire need of medical attention and treatment, occasioned by the atrocities done by the act of crime of another.

Read More
922 Words | 4 Pages

The physical effects of violence often cause less damage to the individual victim than the psychological effects.’ (Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, 1991). The Inquiry recommended the government introduced measures to include civil solutions for racist harassment and incitement to racial hostility, which would broaden the range in which the RDA was ‘enforceable’ to include public places and ease civil unrest. (Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, 1991) Similarly, the Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody requested the RDA introduce further legislation to ‘proscribe racial vilification and to offer a conciliation mechanism for dealing with complaints of racial vilification’ (Commonwealth of Australia, 2002) or simply ‘hate speech’.

Read More
1376 Words | 6 Pages

Furthermore, another issue arises when an offender is compared to the reasonable person as a standardised role model and it becomes apparent that one may demand too much from this particular human being. However, if the judgement gets altered in order to fit the actual defendant and his characteristics, the hypothetical reasonable person will disappear due to the degree of individualisation and the standard becomes obsolete (Nourse, 2008). Often, courts will equal reasonable with normal which can cause complications (Moran, 2010). Moran (2010) uses the example of the decision of the Australian High Court in McHale v Watson where she argues that judges have a higher tolerance for wrongdoing in children, and especially boys, because they identify carelessness as “boys will be boys” (Moran, 2010). In this case, a 12 year old boy injured a girl on the playground by throwing a sharp object toward her head.

Read More

More about Frank Desmoulin Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document