ipl-logo

Legal Studies: The Court Case Of Vickie Lee Roach

1020 Words5 Pages

Sam Richards
Legal Studies:
Vicki Lee Roach

On December the 14th, 2002, Vickie Lee Roach, in a failed attempt to evade police after a robbery gone wrong, smashed into a young mans car, inflicting grievous burns to over 45 percent of his body. She was sentenced to 6 years prison with a non-parole period of 4 years. In 2006, the Coalition, under the hard line right wing John Howard, passed the Electoral and Referendum Amendment (Electoral Integrity and Other Measures) Act that made it impossible for any prisoner to vote during their period of incarceration. Prior to this, prisoners voting rights were protected under the the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (amended 1983). The Electoral act of 1918 made it possible for any prisoner serving under …show more content…

Having been abandoned by her mother at birth, she was sent to live with foster parents who imposed a strict regime of schooling and discipline upon her. At 13, Roaches foster parents sent her back to live with her mother, considering Vicki to be 'undesirable'. Although Vickie was happy to be back in the care her biological mother, she was still desperate for money. At 14, she was forced to turn to prostitution in order to survive. From this point on, an ever growing criminal record, usually for petty crimes, resulted in several stints in prison. After her conviction and imprisonment for robbery and dangerous driving, Roach gained newfound purpose when Prisoners were stripped of their voting rights. Citing her past as one of the main reasons she pursued the case in court, Vickie stated that 'after years of feeling useless, I could finally do some good for others like me.' It was Vickie Lee Roach that went to lawyers in order to determine if there was potential to launch a test case. It is important to note that Vickie not be restoring her own voting rights in her attempt to restore Victoria's voting practices to the status quo, as she was serving 6 years. This was a case of principle for Vickie, rather than one for personal gain. A test case can be conducted in order to establish a common law precedent in an area of law where one did not currently exist. Alternatively, a test case can also be designed to gain a court …show more content…

The outcome was hailed a victory for representative government, democracy, government accountability and fundamental human rights. However, perhaps the biggest social issue related to the case, the result was in essence a vindication of Indigenous and Aboriginal rights. Obvious social issues applied in the case, after all, societal prejudice against prisoners is what first spawned the Howard governments blanket ban of prisoners voting rights. However, Aboriginal issues were also called into question, as Indigenous Australians are incarcerated at a rate 13 times higher than that of non Indigenous Australians. The case also brought to light serious flaws relating to the system of representative and accountable government. The legal issues in the case directly related to prisoners structural rights, and the concept of representative government. Vickie did not believe that a government could truly be 'by the people, for the people' if all citizens did not get a say. The case also bought into question whether it was 'constitutional' for the government to overrule previous legislation in an attempt to disenfranchise all prisoners from voting.

The High Court on considering the arguments from both Vickie Lee Roach and the Commonwealth of Australia/ Australian Electoral Commission ruled in favour of Vickie. The High court

Show More
Related
1526 Words | 7 Pages

Regardless of her appointment, she was met with heated resistance by her male peers. Her first case was challenged by the defence lawyer claiming she was not a person under the British North America Act of 1867 3. This was due to ambiguous and gendered language in Section 24 of the British North America Act of 1867. The BNA act of 1867, also known as the Constitution Act, were a collection of policies in the Constitution of Canada. Section 24 stated that only “qualified persons” could be appointed to the Canadian Senate5.

Read More
588 Words | 3 Pages

Former delinquent takes on Government and wins Vickie Lee Roach receives her degree. August 31, 2007 The champion of prisoners ' rights had an unlikely path to High Court victory, writes Karen Kissane. VICKIE Lee Roach was taken from her mother when she was two and thinks of herself as a member of the stolen generation.

Read More
272 Words | 2 Pages

Over Louise Raggio’s 50 plus year career, she was prominent in changing the rights for women in Texas, earning her the nickname “Mother of Family Law in Texas.” Surviving the Depression, World War II, and the Cold War, she graduated number two in her class, and found a job as assistant District Attorney in 1954, becoming the first woman prosecutor in a Texas Criminal Court. She supported her family by working, while her husband started his own law firm. Later she quit the DA’s office to join her husband at his firm and practice with him. The 1960s were not the best of times for women.

Read More
409 Words | 2 Pages

She was to serve a total of 6 years imprisonment with a non-parole period of 3 years. Roach overcame her rocky past and became somewhat of a model prisoner, earning a Master's Degree in professional writing. Whilst

Read More
434 Words | 2 Pages

He challenged the law that took away his right to vote while in prison, he argued that s.51(e) of The Canadian Elections Act violated his Charter Rights by excluding every person who is imprisoned in a correctional facility for the commission of any offence. Sauvé claimed that it contradicted s.3 of The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms - Every citizen of Canada has the right to vote in an election of the House of Commons or of a legislative assembly. Sauvé was a citizen and as a citizen under the Charter, he was guaranteed the right to vote.

Read More
1103 Words | 5 Pages

She started with the backstory of each woman then divided the trials by date while going in-depth with detail about the women. She divided the trials by date and by women. Roach first gave information on the women and then the trials which helped the reader understand the period. What sticks out the most after reading the book is the sheer resilience and agency of the six women at the center of the controversy.

Read More
1422 Words | 6 Pages

“While the power is vested in the people, it is exercised by electing representatives.” Vivian Paige: Time to increase representation. Vivian is saying that although

Read More
498 Words | 2 Pages

The paper is divided into three time frames providing a better framework by which one can understand the conversations that take place in different periods of the trial. Firstly, I will be exploring the Australian society of the 1980’s whereby retelling the story of Australian identity and exploring the themes of family, attitudes to bush, religion and legal system of Australia. This will set the context of the time and the cultural beliefs that were prevalent in making this trial one of the more infamous public trials. Secondly, the event of the crime and trial proceedings will be of primary focus which lasts from 1980 to 1986. This period will be examined through the scope of legal framework and that of the society and media.

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

Whereas the government allows those “in favor of dope addicts and welfare cheats,” cheat the system and disobey the rules, yet nothing happens to them. This widow is trying to speak out to the governor and other leaders who could help to make people all equal in certain circumstances. A lot of the conservatives believed that the society was losing a lot of the traditional morals and values. They were becoming less formal and disorganized by allowing the federal government control and have more of a say rather than letting the people decide what is best for themselves. Even other women have started to push back on the rights of women.

Read More
623 Words | 3 Pages

On Sunday 04/16/17 at 2103 hours I was dispatched to a suspicious circumstance report by phone. Dispatch advised the reporting person, Juanita Terry was calling from the Seasons on Lea Hill apartments #F-101 located at 12722 SE 312th ST in the City of Auburn, King Co, WA, and stated children at the location relayed to her sometime today a male she has a court order with on the apartment complex asking about her (Juanita), and telling the children Juanita owed him money. I contacted Juanita by phone, and she told me a neighbor, Shanija Palmer, had just told her she saw and spoke to Justin Watkins, who is Juanita 's ex-boyfriend, at about 2020 hours. Juanita said Shanija told her Justin had left the property in a black SUV. Juanita stated she has a

Read More
203 Words | 1 Pages

There are many theories that could provide an expatiation to overrepresentation of Aboriginal people in justice system. First is the culture clash theory that was purposed by the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (RCAP) (1996), this theory suggests that the overrepresentation occurs when Aboriginal people’s value does not fit to justice system, due to the fact that Aboriginal people concept of justice is different than Euro-Canadian concept. An example of culture clash theory that contributes in overrepresentation of Aboriginal people is a result of non-Aboriginal people understanding the cultural norms of an Aboriginal community. An example of differences in Aboriginal community and non-Aboriginal community is that for Aboriginal

Read More
1137 Words | 5 Pages

In her speech she continues to say, “And it is a downright mockery to talk to women of their enjoyment of the blessings of liberty while they are denied the use of the only means of securing them provided by this democratic-republic government -- the ballot.” (Anthony,1)

Read More
481 Words | 2 Pages

America is the land of the free and all citizens, both men and women should be able to exercise their right to vote. Susan claims, “ I not only committed no crime, but, instead, simply exercised my citizens' right, guaranteed to me and all United States citizens by the National Constitution, beyond the power of any state to deny.” This quote implies that Susan is trying to prove how her personal experience of voting should not have been counted against her since citizens of the United

Read More
2522 Words | 11 Pages

However, it seems the roles have changed with respect to the granting of extensive powers to the police to impose bail conditions, which would mean they have the ability to control persons who are not charged for extended periods of time. This can cause possible infringement of rights and possible a false imprisonment claim. Both the police and the courts must therefore interpret the Bail Act 1976 and other legislation relevant to bail in a way which is compatible with the convention. Paragraph 3 of Parts I and II of Schedule 1 to the Bail Act (1976) permit courts to refuse bail if the court is satisfied that the defendant should be kept in custody for his own protection. This would assist in keeping the defendant out of harms way and prevent him from repeating a

Read More
786 Words | 4 Pages

They do not get the right to vote, why should they be able to break the law whenever they please to have it function when it benefits them? The moment they break the law, it should no longer be able to be used to their advantage. However, it has been stated that some of those prisoners are innocent and do not deserve to be cut off from the world 's biggest decision involving citizens. As a result of this it has been impossible to take a decision on this matter, can we really put the future of multiple countries into jeopardy for a small amount of the population, which claims to be innocent which may or may not be true? Even if innocents should get the right to vote, this decision is too important to risk a disaster to make a minuscule amount of the population prosper.

Read More

More about Legal Studies: The Court Case Of Vickie Lee Roach

Related Topics

Open Document