ipl-logo

Freedman's Criticism Of Junk Food

1589 Words7 Pages

In society today, junk food has become a major issue in the fight against obesity amongst a large portion of United States citizens. There is no disagreement that "junk food" is observed at negatively and as one of the key causes of obesity. It is a public knowledge that the more you consume these sugary fattening foods the fatter you get. Freedman's article, “How Junk Food Can End Obesity” tests whether junk food is assisting the development of obesity or can truly decrease the total of obese people living in the United States. The statement that junk food could terminate obesity is very ironic because most people believe it to be the cause. Through analysis of this article it is easier to comprehend why Freedman believes that advances in …show more content…

Freedman backed up his criticism about the wholesale and processed foods by visiting wholesome foods markets and comparing foods. Throughout Freedman’s time he spent in these wholesome food stores, he did his own research to find facts and information to support his claims, to prove what Pollan says about food is inaccurate. For example, Freedman confirmed that a cheesy vegan salad that is organic and healthier, contents more fat content per an ounce compared to McDonald’s Big Mac. The fact is, “fat carries more than twice as many calories as carbohydrates and protein do per gram, which means just a little fat can turn a serving of food into a calorie bomb” (144). He also mentions that healthy greens are pretty much similar when purchasing from wholesale markets and regular supermarkets, which can be brought for less at a regular supermarket. Another issue Freedman talks about is Pollan’s opinions on the rise of obesity. Pollan is critical of food processing and says it is “a source of society’s health problems” (140) and states the major factors causing obesity is due to the amounts of sugar, salt, and fat that is placed into foods. Pollan believes that one can resolve this problem by swapping these foods “… through public education and regulation -with fresh, unprocessed, local season real foods” (140). …show more content…

Freedman goes into depth how that the people in a poorer community can’t afford fresh, healthy foods from the grocery store (or even the transportation to get to the store). This leads to the poor population relying on the easily accessible, cheap fast food chains that are generally walking distance of any location. Lenard Lesser, from the Palo Alto Medical Foundation and Freedman did an experiment to see what people eat depending on the areas people reside in. Freeman mentions, as they drove through Berkley, they noticed the town is filled with Whole Foods Markets and sushi restaurants, unlike Oakland, they observed gas station markets and barbecued rib stands. They also pointed out the changes of advertisements on the billboards as they traveled from town to town. Berkley had an ad for fruit juice on one of their billboards, while Oaklands billboard ads were filled with fast food restaurants. Freedman states, “According to Lenard Lesser, …The food industry has mastered the art of using in-store and near store promotions to shape what people eat,” (149) and for many reasons like this one, obesity rates going up in poor communities. For the past couple of years, fast food places, McDonalds for one, have been quietly making changes to add healthy alternatives to their menu and reducing

Show More
Related
825 Words | 4 Pages

Sometimes, it is as if we’ve truly forgotten the true purpose of why it is that we eat. With this section, Pollan continues to add onto the doubt and uncertainty of the way that food is in modern times, based upon how it used to be. Slowly, he is beginning to warm up to his main

Read More
565 Words | 3 Pages

In recent decade, the United States has seen supermarkets continuously get filled with packages labeled with things like “Low sodium” or “No Trans Fats.” Companies stick these labels on their food to match the current fads of what is good for you and what is not. In his essay Unhappy Meals, Michael Pollan advocates a return to natural and basic foods, and deplores nutritionism. Pollan argues that nutritionism does not actually tell people what is healthy or not, and that the only way to be sure you are eating healthy is to eat natural, fresh food.

Read More
132 Words | 1 Pages

In “How Junk Food Can End Obesity” David Freedman argues that ending processed food is not going to help solve obesity problems. He knows that “Junk food is bad for you because it’s full of fats and problems carb” (Freedman 515). Freedman believe that we should use technology to improve fast-food by taking out the unhealthy products in it, instead of getting rid of fast-food entirely. He also talks about his experiences with food between wholesome food and McDonald’s. He discusses how McDonald’s smoothies have the lowest calories and are cheapest out of all other smoothies he had.

Read More
639 Words | 3 Pages

The author himself mentioned the modern industry made its impact on the “whole food”. So people need to check product’s chemical content to be sure they eat the real food; it makes it impossible to separate diet from science, like Pollan wanted. I also do not think the author treated the nutritionism fairly. While he was right in his critique of debates between different “cults” of direct nutrients, the nutritionism has the true basis. Food’s value really is in its nutrients, and the problem of the Western Diet is that meals lack of some compounds and have an excess of other.

Read More
1339 Words | 6 Pages

Unfortunately, for most people this trust has been broken and without a major industrial overhaul, we cannot make the choices we so desperately need. Pollan agrees when he writes, “This sounds like a sensible rule of thumb until you realize that industrial processes have by now invaded many whole foods too”(424). The essence of his argument is that even if food label says the food within is healthy, it is not always true. The food was probably industrially processed, making it a less whole food than we think. Basic things like apples are processed and we, as consumers, do not always know it.

Read More
730 Words | 3 Pages

Michael Pollan’s Escape from the Western Diet connects well with what Mary Maxfield says in her article. Both Pollan and Maxfield talk about the ways that dieting is taking over American people’s healths and causing them to become even unhealthier. In Mary Maxfield’s argument she talks about how people believe everything that diet industries say, even though they know that the information they give you is false. This connects really well with what Michael Pollan talks about in his article, which is that people know that these theories that are used for the Western diet are not accurate, but yet they still decide to use the Western diet to help them become healthier.

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

In turn, he provides his own rules for escaping the western diet as well as the idea of nutritionist set forth by scientists.   Then Pollan explains that scientific theories of nutritionist focus on individual nutrients rather than foods as a whole. He further goes on to refute this claim mentioning that these scientific theories contradict with one another. Pollan explains “the scientists who blame our health problems on deficiencies of [micronutrients] are not the same scientists who see a sugar soaked diet leading to metabolic syndrome and from there to diabetes, heart disease…” (Pollan, 421).

Read More
1020 Words | 5 Pages

Junk food is responsible for the growing rate of obesity. This is outlined by David freedman in his article of “How junk food can end obesity.” David Freedman has credited the “health-food” motion, and followers of it along with Michel Pollan. Freedman claims that if the America desires to stop the obesity epidemic, or at least reduce its effects, they must shift to the fast meals and processed meals enterprise for assist, now not the “health-food” movement.

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

However, this is not his only purpose in writing this essay. Additionally, Michael Pollan seeks to reassure the reader that this change will eventually occur and how it will happen. He argues that the food movement of our generation has been successful in changing popular consciousness. However, it has been struggling with shifting, in any impactful way, the “standard American diet,” which he purports has only gotten worse since the 1970s (Envision in Depth p.g

Read More
1218 Words | 5 Pages

In David Freedman’s essay How Junk food Can End Obesity, Freedman makes the claim to policy arguing that instead of demonizing processed foods, Americans should instead support the idea and production of healthier processed and junk foods. He calls on the public to recognize that while many products on the market these days are labeled as “wholesome” and “healthy”, consumers should learn to become aware of the fat and calorie content in these products because many times they have the same- if not more- fat and calorie contents as that of a typical Big Mac or Whopper. In his essay, Freedman primarily places blame on the media and the wholesome food movement for the condemnation of the fast and processed food industries saying, “An enormous amount of media space has been dedicated to promoting the notion that all processed food, and only processed food, us making us sickly and overweight” (Freedman), he further expresses that this portrayal of the

Read More
683 Words | 3 Pages

Eating Healthy Michael Pollan, a health food spokesperson, made some interesting critiques on how he believes that there is an American paradox such as, “a notably unhealthy population preoccupied with… the idea of eating healthy” (Maxfield, 442). The idea taken from Michael Pollan’s quote is that he believes the definition of healthy eating has more to do with how it is “driven by a well-funded corporate machine” (Maxfield, 442). He is also claiming that the food industry is benefiting on our lack of knowledge on how to eat properly when it comes to being healthy. In her article Food as Thought: Resisting the Moralization of Eating, Mary Maxfield directly attacked Pollan’s claims, pointing out the hypocrisy in his words because he is sharing

Read More
563 Words | 3 Pages

By comparing what is, to what could be possible if a food policy were to be established. In doing so, he is using a scare tactic for readers to visualize the reality that is impacting Americans today. Pollan emphasizes the need to prevent deaths caused by unhealthy eating as a priority. Pollan's goal is aimed at "a food system in which healthful choices are accessible to all and in which it becomes possible to nourish ourselves without exploiting other people or nature. " Pollan has earned respect by readers due to his concern for the greater good of Americans.

Read More
812 Words | 4 Pages

Americans Who Tell The Truth. N.p., n.d. http://www.americanswhotellthetruth.org/portraits/michael-pollan). In the book, Pollan tries to distinguish between healthy and harmful foods. He says, “Eating in our time has gotten complicated.” (Food Rules, page ix).

Read More
934 Words | 4 Pages

He speaks about how as a society we need to get away from the Western Diet. Pollan states “This sounds like a sensible rule of thumb until you realize that industrial processes have by now invaded many whole foods too. Is a steak from a feedlot steer that consumed a diet of corn, various industrial waste products, antibiotics, and hormones still a ‘whole food’? I’m not so sure” (424). When we eat food, we don’t normally think about where that food has come from and what they were fed.

Read More
670 Words | 3 Pages

In “How Junk Food Can End Obesity,” by David H. Freedman, he claims that processed foods can help fix the obesity crisis in a more realistic manner, rather than whole-some foods. The popular opinion emphasizes whole-some foods because they aren’t informed about the similitude between processed and unprocessed foods. The essence of the essay is that people believe processed foods are bad and unhealthy for us, therefore whole-some foods are highly recommended for the health of an individual. Freedman mentions many prominent authors who wrote books on food processing, but the most influential voice in the food culture Freedman makes a point of is, American journalist, Michael Pollan. The media and Michael Pollan indicate that everything should be replaced with real, fresh, and unprocessed foods, instead of engineering in as much sugar, salt, and fat as possible into industrialized foods.

Read More

More about Freedman's Criticism Of Junk Food

Related Topics

Open Document