ipl-logo

Freud Vs Jung

452 Words2 Pages

Two of the most famous psychologists/psychiatrists in our history Sigmund Freud (May 6, 1856-September 23, 1939), was an Austrian Neurologist responsible for the theory of psychoanalysis, and Carl Jung (July 26, 1875-June 6, 1961) a Swiss psychologist responsible for the theory of analytic psychology. Both attended the school of psychology in Vienna, and Jung at one point was Freud’s student. Both Freud and Jung had very distinct views on how religion begins in our psyche. Religion is very powerful and has influenced every aspect of our lives, Freud and Jung understood this and have attempted to answer the complexity of religion. Jung believed that our unconscious is multi layered and that religion affords people a safe place. Jung …show more content…

Marx had a difficult time in believing something that could not be seen and thought that people should use reasoning because religion was misleading them. Freud believed people needed to be “cured” of religion, and could explain away religion through science namely psychology. Jung appeared to be more knowledgeable on religion compared to Freud being able to discuss the symbolism of religions around the world. Freud thought religious symbolism was allowing people to escape reality, while Jung believed these symbols brought us closer to reality. The theological views of Freud and Jung couldn’t have been more different in statements made by both men. In Freud’s book “The Future of an Illusion” in 1927 he wrote, “The Gods retain the threefold task: they must exorcize the terrors of nature, they must reconcile men to the cruelty of fate, particularly as it is shown in death, and they must compensate them for the suffering and privations which a civilized life in common has imposed on them.” On the other side of the theological

Show More
Related

Freud Vs Lewis Essay

1351 Words | 6 Pages

Introduction The lives of two great giants compared side by side in one book. Dr. Armand M. Nicoholi Jr.’s book, The Question of God, takes two renowned philosophers and thinkers who started life in similar circumstances with similar outlooks on living. However these two men, Sigmund Freud and C.S. Lewis, turned out to lead very different lives. As children, both men experienced a significant loss in their families.

Read More

Comparing The Views Of C. S. Lewis And Freud Debate

1990 Words | 8 Pages

Both men agreed that one’s worldview impacts their experience of happiness throughout life. Only Lewis resolved his pessimistic worldview when he converted to Christianity. Freud basked in his pessimistic worldview until death and he never attempted to change it since he was an atheist. As a Christian who has seen people convert to Christianity from an atheistic background, it would have been fascinating to see how Freud’s life would have been different had he been convinced of Christ.

Read More

Sacrifice In Homer's Odyssey

507 Words | 3 Pages

All their afflictions come from us, we hear. And what of their own failings?” (page 2). The gods, although they are powerful, cannot prevent every wrongful decision made by man, yet men do not blame themselves but turn to supernatural causes

Read More

Lewis Views On The Existence Of God

381 Words | 2 Pages

He strongly believes that “the scientific method is our only source of knowledge” (58). I disagree with his belief because people also possess their own sense of knowledge. They gain this knowledge through the different obstacles they come across in their lives, which indicates that not all knowledge comes from scientific method. Freud describes “the teachings of Jesus as “psychologically impossible and useless for our lives” (38). I cannot agree with his statement because there are people who study and believe in Jesus because Jesus gives them an optimistic view to life.

Read More

Comparing Marx And Nietzsche's View Of Religion

221 Words | 1 Pages

Marx and Nietzsche both agreed that religion is unnecessary. Marx viewed religion as a form of dissent from the working class. He believed that using religion was an expression of the individual`s personal suffering. Therefore, humans made religion to run away from their daily problems, in the end creating more problems with the concept of religion itself. Marx viewed religion as something made by humans to provide reasoning and answers for their questions and desires.

Read More

Sigmund Freud's Dibss In Search Of Self

2606 Words | 11 Pages

Notable psychologists namely Sigmund Freud, Melanie Klein and

Read More

Religion Worksheet

1381 Words | 6 Pages

Question 1: Looking at the religion worksheet, Karl Marx has been quoted saying " . . . is the sigh of the oppressed creature...” and "...is only the illusory sun which revolves around man as long as he does not revolve around himself.” Also, has been quoted saying the this " ... the fantastic realization of the human essence because the human essence has no true reality. The struggle against religion is, therefore ... the fight against the other world, of which religion is the spiritual aroma.”

Read More

How Did Freud And Jung View Religion

329 Words | 2 Pages

First of all, Freud and Jung saw religion as a product of the psyche since “(b)oth were committed to advancing a new framework for explaining human behavior, one that pictured humans in terms of the relation between a conscious but fragile ego and the unconscious” (Paden 48). In their teachings, humans are not only minds but also psychological beings with defensive and neurotic egos who may choose to suppress emotions only to be discovered with the art of psychoanalysis. Furthermore, Jung and Freud view religion as “fragments of one’s unresolved childhood memories (and)…positive mediators between the ego and a deeper part of the self” (Paden 49). In this way, the idea of the psyche is all encompassing; religious thought does not tell us what

Read More

Examples Of Theodicy In The 21st Century

958 Words | 4 Pages

Freud regarded God as an illusion, based on the need for a powerful father figure, and religion as more or less a teaching tool to inhibit violent impulses in early civilization before science and logic. In Freud’s psychodynamic theory, our behavior is deeply influenced by our unconscious thoughts, impulses and desires. The drive of our unconscious, Freud argued, was sexual and destructive in nature. Therefore, evil is part of the unconscious of all humankind and people could not be cured until their unconscious thoughts were brought to consciousness to gain a better understanding of themselves and their desires. Emile Durkheim was a French sociologist who proposed religion had three functions in society.

Read More

The Views Of Sigmund Freud's Nature-Nurture

1322 Words | 6 Pages

Sigmund Freud- Psychoanalysis Sigmund Freud was in the center of the debate he was getting more knowledge about nurture but he was also giving some credibility to nature. Although Freud was at the center of the debate through nurturing he showed us how this theory truly does work with a person and how it makes us who we are. This was after years of research and study in psychoanalysis.

Read More

Deconstructing Ethical Advocacy

995 Words | 4 Pages

That is to say, God becomes an antidote for the fear of death, poverty and other calamities that plague his mind. God is a substitute for man’s perpetual fear of existence having no inherent meaning. As a result of God’s absolute power being the dictating force behind the believer’s reality, faith in the deity provides intrinsic value and purpose to man’s existence. Instead of having his personal life be governed by potential absurdities or unknown causes, the fear of God’s authority is preferred over the anxiety of the unexplainable. Acts of piety grant man a sense of control over God’s judgement and grace, therefore awarding him an imagined agency of influence over his reality.

Read More

Freud Religious Illusion

434 Words | 2 Pages

The realities of nature and of fate plague the existence of every man and to which they are powerless to escape. The primary reality is what Freud calls the “painful riddle of death”, for no man can escape the force of the realization of their eventual annihilation. Thus the state of man is in perpetual fear, angst, hostility, and frustration, yearns to attain some balance of power. The result of this is a yearning for power is the birth of religious ideas for man, in his attempt to combat his own helpless existence, humanizes the natural forces that seem to be bearing down on him. In this way man can “alleviate some of his angst” since humanizing these natural, inevitable forces can as this can allow us to defend, rebel, appease, and bribe them.

Read More

Similarities Between Freud And Freyd

1887 Words | 8 Pages

Repression in Freud and Freyd Freud describes repression as the act of blocking unacceptable urges, but this phenomenon is not that simple. Ever since he popularized using repression to describe cases of abnormal forgetting, alternative theories of repression have been formulated. In contrast to Freud, Freyd theorizes that repression occurs when someone is abused by a close caregiver, and to survive, they must repress their memories of the abuse to maintain a relationship with their caregiver. Her theory diverges from Freud’s as she is more focused on the abuse causing the repression while Freud is more concerned about the ramifications of acting upon taboo desires. Likewise, both authors use survival as a core concept in their theories.

Read More

Gods In The Iliad

1846 Words | 8 Pages

The gods represent the best and worst, and they show us both the possibilities and limitations of human behavior. If nothing else, the gods remind us of the overwhelming

Read More

Overview Of The Psychology Of Religion

1724 Words | 7 Pages

1. Psychology of Religion Sigmund Freud Sigmund Freud 's understanding of the psychology of religion comes from a place not without disdain. This might be somewhat understandable given he lived not too long removed from a time in which any statements that were deemed to be blasphemous could lead to very serious consequences for the author. He touches on this very point and even lists arguments against his coming out so vociferously against even the potential veracity of religion; however, he quickly attempts to demolish these arguments so as to make his real point (Freud, 2018, pp. 179,188). Put quite concisely, Freud explains that the idea of God is nothing short of an illusion – even a form of neurosis.

Read More

More about Freud Vs Jung

Related Topics

Open Document