ipl-logo

Right To Self Determination Gender

1475 Words6 Pages

Gender and the Right to Self-Determination

Submitted By: Kaustub Narendran – 31LLB14

The conception of the realm of the ‘self’ is central to issues involving the recognition of identities. Conceptions of the ‘self’ in modern times, especially since the Enlightenment era, have referred to the fiction of the fully-possessed rights-bearing subjects of western modernity. However, the conception of ‘self’ for an individual who belongs to a marginalized community is not individual but is rather collective in nature. It is defined in relation to the ‘other’ and is in dialectic opposition to that other.
The border between the self (marginalized) and the other is characterized by a vague sense of horror (known as abjection). This sense of horror …show more content…

Thus self-determination, as understood by the contemporary anticolonial, black power and anti-prison movements, which is also consistent in the case of gender, is the recognition of the identity and the potentiality of freedom encompassing recognition, liberty and dignity.
This essay tries to make the point that the ‘choice’ is fundamental to this conception of gender self-determination. That until there exists the absolute ability to choose and determine one’s gender, to be its sole judge and the right to be recognized by the gender that one chooses, the ideals of liberty and dignity cannot be effectively extended to the Trans community. The progress (or the lack of it) that has been made on this front in the Indian context shall form the centerpiece of the …show more content…

By stating that there exists a ‘real trans-person’ the committee essentialises the transgender community. Further this creates a pigeon-hole wherein certain choices fit the norm of the screening committee and are thus protected whereas other choices that are deviant from that norm are disregarded. This would lead to a further fracture within the transgender community between those who subscribe to a particular ideal and those who don’t. This fracturing is a much greater a problem in such societies because individuals who belong to the transgender community, a community that has been historically marginalized, identify themselves only through a collective identity. This compartmentalization threatens to destroy their conception of

Show More
Related
1765 Words | 8 Pages

Today, gender inequality in the workplace still remains a popular discussion within institutional and social realms. In Just One of the Guys? by Kristen Schilt, through a variety of methods she shows how transmen are susceptible to systemic gender inequality even if they go through different experiences. Schilt performs in-depth interviews with transmen in the workplace to show how the types of experiences transgender people go through, good or bad, can be influenced on what race or social class they are in. She uses informational tables showing yearly statistics, real life examples of transmen’s stories, and her own observational data to provide an explanation of how individuals participate in the reproduction of gender inequality within

Read More
1211 Words | 5 Pages

This past October an intersex U.S. Navy veteran, Dana Zzyym, gained national attention after they were denied a passport. Zzyym identifies as neither male nor female, so they were denied the right to a passport after refusing to select a gender box on the application. After the denial Zzyym filed a federal discrimination lawsuit on the grounds that it is a constitutional violation to force an intersex person to select a gender box. Their argument is that gender, or lack of thereof, has nothing to do with travel, so why should it restrict or force people to declare a gender marker they do not identify as. Zzyym’s case finally brings to light how significant two little boxes can truly be, especially for those who live their lives outside

Read More
769 Words | 4 Pages

The LGBTQ community is one that faces an ongoing storm of stereotyping and stigmas and the media is no relief from it. One major factor in this is the common trope of the violent and aggressive transgender woman, which is often shown through

Read More
1326 Words | 6 Pages

These ideals, according to the author, shape the foundation for the borders of belonging. The author defines personhood as, “legal recognition and protection of self-ownership, that is, of a right to one’s person, one’s body, and one’s labor” (Welke, 3). Essentially, the author works to convey the essence of individuality under the law, including the accessibility that certain groups have to legal recognition and self-protection. Therefore, the author, through introducing her analysis of personhood, reveals how personhood and citizenship are interdependent. Welke then introduces her understanding of citizenship as she

Read More
793 Words | 4 Pages

In their essay “Transforming Carceral Logics: 10 Reasons to Dismantle the Prison Industrial Complex Through Queer/Trans Analysis and Action,” Lambie mentions that transgender, queer, and gender-variant people are more likely to experience “widespread discrimination, harassment, and violence… [which] translates into higher risk of imprisonment” (240). In addition, they mention how queer and transgender people are criminalized because of their gender and sexuality, yet the state will turn around and claim how they will protect them from harm (239). While transgender people are in prison, they experience “human rights abuses, including assault, psychological abuse, rape, harassment, and medical neglect” (Lambie 243). In some instances, they suffer these abuses while within the general population; nonetheless, they are also abused when they are placed in solitary confinement.

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

The Stonewall Riots are said to mark the beginning of the modern LGBT rights movement, and it was largely initiated by transgender women of color. Over the next few decades, legislation would be enacted to aid the cause for equality. By 1977, trans athletes could play on the teams of their gender identities, and by 1993 anti-discrimination laws were extended to transpeople in Minnesota. In the 21st century alone, transpeople were getting invited to the White House, playing in college sports, and serving as judges, all without having to hide who they were (“Milestones in the American Transgender Movement”). Hardships are still all too common, unfortunately, but much progress has been made nonetheless, and the fight continues to this

Read More
1357 Words | 6 Pages

One’s own identity is crucial in defining a person. Some believe identity is defined by an individual, whereas others believe identities are defined by the context of one’s own surroundings. It seems more reasonable to believe the notion that people’s identities are chosen by the influence of their surroundings through the fourth class system which was expressed in Susan Faludi’s work, the Naked Citadel, the Stanford and the Seminaraian experiements which was explained in The Power of Context by Malcolm Gladwell, and through the influence of mega marketing like in Ethan Watters work, The Mega Marketing of Japan. The fourth class system creates an environment in which students are abused and mistreated in order to change the students

Read More
277 Words | 2 Pages

Canadians take pride in their health care system; however, most Canadians are unaware of the disparities that exist for transgender persons within health care. Being ridiculed, denied care, or treated unjustly because of a self-identification as transgender goes against the core values of the nursing profession (Canadian Nurses Association, 2009); despite this, ten percent of transgender participants in the Ontario Trans PULSE survey reported that they had experienced these demonstrations of prejudice when accessing emergency room services. This statistic may be lower than the reality due to transgender persons frequently avoiding the health care system (Bauer & Scheim, 2015). According to the Canadian Nurses Association (CNA) Code of Ethics (2009) nursing staff are expected to provide, “safe, compassionate, competent, and ethical care” (p. 3); however, due to lack of policies and lack of education nursing staff and physicians are detrimentally adding to the stressors of transgender life.

Read More
466 Words | 2 Pages

The Tasmanian Council for Sex and Gender Diverse People (Australian Human Rights Commission 2011) argued that trans people should not be forced into incarceration on the basis of their gender at birth or put into isolation for their protection.

Read More
1377 Words | 6 Pages

This was the end, I survived here for a little over 2 years. I wasn’t Marshal Schwartz, a 35 year old man anymore, I was 566732. I needed to stay alive until I was free, I wanted to tell my tale. My first job was working in the bathrooms, however, the guards realized that my strength could be used to sweep up dead bodies. I hated that job, it was so hard to see the helpless little children.

Read More
899 Words | 4 Pages

Notably, the “T” in LGBT stands for transgender, which includes those who do not conform to the traditional ideals of their ‘gender’ or birth sex (Ard & Makadon, 2012). In some cases, these individuals may decide to go through hormonal therapy or surgery to alter their gender identity. Due to the fact that the transgender population in the US is known to only be 0.3%, many are uneducated about the medical needs of these individuals, including physicians (Ard & Makadon, 2012). Moreover, a policy to diminish LGBT care disparities should also educate people (especially physicians) in understanding the cultural context of their patients’ lives (LGBT individuals) in order for all people to attain the best possible

Read More
652 Words | 3 Pages

Do you know someone who you believe to exemplify the word bravery? Maybe you view this person as being fearless, adventurous, or even strong, accompanied with an S on their chest. However, bravery doesn’t have to belong to a superhero. Most people have a common misapprehension of what the word bravery actually means. Although most of us trust the dictionary to give us an accurate definition, some abstract words such as bravery, have complex meanings that can vary from person to person.

Read More
657 Words | 3 Pages

Transgender is the term used to describe an individual whose gender identity does not align with their sex assigned at birth. The documentary, “Growing up Trans”, is a sensitive clip to watch about young youths who attempt to navigate family, friends, gender, and the medical decisions they face at puberty. “Growing up Trans” focuses mainly on transitioned young youths. The transgender youth from the documentary links to many theories from chapter eight. Theories such as socialization, gender, sexuality, homophobia, transphobia, and microaggression are associated with “Growing up Trans”.

Read More
934 Words | 4 Pages

Their role in society was believed to be that of wife and mother but our mind was changing. Women started to fight for some rights such as the access to the labour force during World War I, the improvement in education allowing women to attend university, and the equality within the marriage, in order to avoid subordination of women. Probably their greatest achievement was the access to the electoral process in the United States of America. Earning the right to vote meant a recognition of women power and intelligence, as well as their ability to participate in politics. This essay will analyze how women fought for their right through some feminist movements.

Read More
1306 Words | 6 Pages

The term “transgender” is a label that was never used until the mid 1960s. According to history, “Psychiatrist John F. Oliven of Columbia University coined the term transgender in his 1965 reference work Sexual Hygiene and Pathology (“Transgender”)”. When a transgender person desires to be the opposite gender, they may get an invasive surgery to fully transition into their new identity. Multiple transgender people have started to announce the having of the surgery has destroyed their future (Bindel). People have the right to be whatever gender they aspire to be, but transgender people should do public activities and should stay grouped with their biologically assigned sex.

Read More

More about Right To Self Determination Gender

Related Topics

Open Document