ipl-logo

Masculinity In Military

1577 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Conclusion statesments on womens role in the military

In a career dominated by masculinity and it is hard for females to be recognized for their contributions and skills. In Canada around 1885, the first women to be too considered part of the military served as nurses. At the start of World War II women were employed by the army and air forces to serve as clerks, administrative, and support personnel, so that more men could be freed up for combat. Unfortunately, the Canadian Women’s Army Corps and the Royal Canadian Naval Service were disbanded in 1946. This left nursing as the only source of employment for women by the Canadian government. It wasn’t until 1971, that women were given equal service rights as men. This allowed, Heather Erxleben to be the first women to serve in the regular force …show more content…

Women are viewed as either being extraordinary in their effects or problematic in the army as they couldn’t “clear the physical or mental hurdles” that are necessary to pass to be able to go into combat (citation). Those against the idea on women in combat zones or holding positions in the military believe they will not meet the required standards necessary for the military, qualifications which are based on male recruits and not structured for female recruits. In contrast the military is not structured to support its women recruits. It is arguable to say that women should be allowed on the front lines of combat as they can meet the physical demands required to fight, they will not affect unit moral or cohesion, and as they challenge the prehistoric traditional roles of the military for the …show more content…

Although it is granted that men are stronger than women, it can still be maintained that countless women have tried and passed the issued physical fitness tests. In addition, many would suggest that women lower the moral and unit cohesion as an argument against women fighting in combat. In some units cohesion may not be gained between male and female recruits. However, studies done on Norwegian and Israel armies women bring useful skills to their units and have increases the cohesion within their assigned units. Another argument many believe in is that the military is not appropriate for women due to its traditional gender stereotypes. These people tend to object to soldiers showing stereotypical feminine qualities. Yet, it has been proven that women can show the qualities of a stereotypical soldier and leave their femininity behind while working. Although women in combat may seem as a concern to only a small group of people, it should in fact concern anyone who cares about the equality of women in masculine ruled careers. Women should be given the same and equal opportunities as males when it comes to the military, as they are able to perform to the same physical fitness standards and training, increase cohesion and moral in a military unit, and challenge the old traditional masculine stereotypes

Show More
Related

Pros And Cons Of The Women's Armed Services Integration Act

372 Words | 2 Pages

The Women’s Armed Services Integration Act was a law passed by President Harry S. Truman, allowing women to join the army. Before the act was passed, only men were permitted to be in combat, while women in the army worked in clinical positions. When World War II began, despite women not being allowed to join the “regular” army, the Women’s Army Corps was created and granted full army status during wartime. The growth in the number of women in the corps, along with the fact that they performed equally to the army, were two of the main factors for the law to be created and passed. The WAC was set to be expired in 1948, but the act was passed in the same years which meant that women would continue to be allowed to fight in the army.

Read More

The Canadian Women's Army Corps (CWAC)

219 Words | 1 Pages

During World War II, Woman’s were assembled for duty in the Canadian Armed Forces, for the first time. The armed force was shy of men in war services and administration, which lead the Canadian government to choose and declare on August 13, 1941 to give woman’s the privilege to take an interest in war utility. 50,000 women were enlisted and more than half provided service in the Canadian Army. Most were doled out occupations including customary female work, for example, cooking, clothing and administrative obligations, also woman had pioneer roles in the mechanized and specialized fields. The Canadian Women 's Army Corps (CWAC) performed fundamental administrations, both at home and abroad, that achieved Allied victory.

Read More

Ann Dunwoody Accomplishments

1265 Words | 6 Pages

With the women’s rights movement and the end of the draft the pentagon was compelled to review the status of women in the military. (Moore) The Army committee had recommendations to separate the women’s corps to increase the specialties offered to women. The Army committee also pushed opening ROTC and military academies to women and also changed the law that required automatic discharge if a woman became pregnant. It was after these recommendations were followed that women could serve in 430 of the 467 military specialties, but they could not command any unit that had a combat mission.

Read More

Australian Women In Ww2 Essay

534 Words | 3 Pages

An important change in the role of Australian women was their participation in military services. In October 1940, the Women’s Auxiliary Australian Air Force was established and quickly followed by the women’s Army and Navy forces. Women began to join in the military services and to work in these services. “They lived and worked under the same conditions as the men.” It was said by Lorna Byrne, who was a member of the AWAS (Australian Women’s Auxiliary Service).

Read More

Summary Of All Guts, No Glory By Molly Ginty

215 Words | 1 Pages

In the feature article “All Guts, No Glory”, I agree with the author Molly M. Ginty, that women participating in combat. If I was in the military some of the things that might affect me would be probably because of my gender. First, women would not be put into battle because people think women cannot handle the work or bloodshed. They think women are better off bring a nurse for helping men in battle if they get injured. Second, they think women in combat would be a distraction.

Read More

How Did The Colonel Mary Hallaren Serve In The Military

450 Words | 2 Pages

The Colonel Mary Hallaren, was known as the godmother of the women in the American military. She was a true advocate, before and after her retirement, for women’s rights to serve in the military, especially in the regular army. She believed that women were not the exception in serving. Therefore, she began to alter the society she lived in by proving that women were able to perform more than certain tasks and showed that women were able to serve the the same way as men did.

Read More

How Did Canadian Women Change Canada

925 Words | 4 Pages

“Those involved in recruiting women for war work in the civilian labour market also sought to allay fears that women doing jobs formerly performed by men were not upsetting the basic gender order. For instance, it was argued that women’s “natural” endowments of “dexterity, patience and keen eyesight” made them eminently suitable for the “deft-fingered” precision work required at various stages of aircraft, gun and ammunition manufacture, especially in electronics and optics.” (3 specialists) Around the world it was common that women were considered less worthy and capable than men. However, the fact that the Canadian government was letting women join the military in what had been considered a manly job meant only for strong brave men.

Read More

How Did The Revolutionary War Affect Women

752 Words | 4 Pages

Wives, mothers, and daughters, of Patriot soldiers were left to operate businesses and keep up with the duties of farms. Other women followed their soldiers to the battlefield. Though their presence around the army men was oftentimes controversial - they were commonly regarded as nuisances - having women around to clean and cook, along with being companions, benefited the American army. Women that wanted to fill the boots that their husbands left, or step up to the plate on their own, would disguise themselves as men so they could participate in battle. Post-war women’s roles were seemingly regarded the same as they had been before.

Read More

What Role Did Conscription Play In Ww1

420 Words | 2 Pages

At first, there was refusal towards hiring women for what was known as ‘men’s work’, once conscription was introduced in 1916, the need for women workers was crucial. Women started working in areas such as railway guards and ticket collectors, buses and tram conductors, postal workers, police, firefighter and as bank ‘tellers’ and clerks. Some even worked on heavy machinery. Nonetheless, women earned lower wages for doing the same work, and then demands for equal pay began. Since women were paid less than men, people worried that when the men would come back from the war,

Read More

How Did Nubia Develop Ancient Egypt

495 Words | 2 Pages

Located in the sand of the desert close to the Nile in the new Sudan, the very old culture of Nubia played an attention-grabbing part in the conversion of Egypt from the VIIIth century B.C., serving like the dynasty of this kingdom in the era later. After the Pharaohs of Nubia lost the power, they went back to Egypt, in the south area to arrange the Kingdom of Kush, some people confuse this term, which did well living very far or alone like the other people of Egypt, this country back in the days many people wanted to conquer them like the Assyrians, Persians because of the gold. It was founded after an age that they called bronze because it was when they started to use this material because it was very proficient to make some tool. So they

Read More

Unbinding Revolutionary Women

885 Words | 4 Pages

Women were well suited for providing nourishment and necessities for the army due to their skills obtained by their accustomed housework. “...the American army often recruited the many female camp followers to fill these jobs” (Brooks 2013, para. 17). They had slowly began to achieve recognition in society, especially war. It was then, that woman had begun to silently “protest” on having the same equal opportunity as men. During the war, women created a role for themselves to side amongst the male soldiers: a secret soldier.

Read More

Women's Role In The Civil War

785 Words | 4 Pages

Many women dressed like men to fight in the war to show not all women are weak. No soldiers in the fight knew women were upon them until after they were wounded or killed. Most of the time women joined the fight to be with a relative or their fiances and/or husbands because they didn’t want them to be alone in the fight and they never wanted to let them go. Not only did women fight on the

Read More

Women In The Military Draft Analysis

856 Words | 4 Pages

By including women in the military draft it would permit women to view themselves as strong and capable. In an article written by Kelly Antoine, she states that by including women in the draft, “As a nation, we are telling women and girls that we expect the same selflessness, determination, heroism, and grit from them as we do from men and boys,” this expresses that authorizing women to be part of the military draft they will be able to see themselves for who they really are. This opportunity would also cause them to be more confident in themselves because women would be included in something that the patriarchal society said used to be only for the

Read More

Outstanding In The Military Essay

817 Words | 4 Pages

“It was only after that evening that I really started to question whether or not the Canadian Forces, now called the Canadian Armed Forces, had evolved into a welcoming environment for women over the last two decades” (Perron, 309). In the memoir Outstanding in the Field, Sandra Perron fights to be Canada’s first female infantry officer. She battles against her allies, trying to be a woman in a ‘mans world’. The absence of concrete progress in the treatment of women in the military, altered Perron’s naïve view.

Read More

Women's Suffrage Thesis

1063 Words | 5 Pages

In the book written by (Gavin, 1997) it was cited that “As women took over from their absent men in hundreds of new and challenging occupations, many of which had previously been considered inappropriate”. From the beginning of the World War 1, the German women were participating a great deal. They contributed to half a million-people working on the munitions manufacturing alone (Gavin, 1997). It also mentioned in the book that over in the U.S, the men in charge refused to let the women participate up until April 1917 (Gavin, 1997). The U.S government never formally authorize the enrolment of women, despite Army officials repeatedly asking for such personnel’s.

Read More

More about Masculinity In Military

Related Topics

Open Document