ipl-logo

I Was Just Following Orders Milgram Essay

1082 Words5 Pages

'I was just following orders': Reviewing Milgram's Paradigm and the Underlying Causes of Obedience Susan Jaramani Psychology 288 American University of Beirut Abstract Fifty years after Milgram's famous Obedience to Authority Paradigm, a lot of studies are reexamining Milgram's findings, and finding gaps and discrepancies between the actual data and the published results. In this study I present the Milgram's Baseline Study, which drove the entire paradigm. I also present Milgram's "agentic state" explanation and provide its arguments that were based on footage evidence, reexamined at Yale. I also explain the situational features present when obedience is elicited, the motives behind doing those studies, and the positive and negative implications that obedience has. Having an inclusive understanding of obedience can be a breakthrough in countless aspects of our day to day lives by trying to do a positive social change. keywords: Milgram's Baseline study, OTA, obedience, dissent 'I was just following orders': Reviewing Milgram's Paradigm and the Underlying Causes of Obedience …show more content…

The "Obedience to Authority Paradigm" abbreviated as OTA has been a field of interest for psychologists, sociologists and countless others who till this very day try to create a comprehensive and holistic theory of obedience. According to Jetten and Mols (2014), Milgram designed an experiment to yield the highest obedience rates and to decrease or even omit disobedience, resulting in the predicted outcomes after having had a vast amount of pilot

Show More
Related

Examples Of Conformity In Fahrenheit 451

1146 Words | 5 Pages

It is simply just human nature to conform and obey when you are told to do something. Therefore, authority and obedience hold great power in society and what it can do. It can change things so fast and take control with a group of brainwashed

Read More

Summary Of The Perils Of Obedience By Stanley Milgram

1205 Words | 5 Pages

The author explains that there are many philosophies about obedience but they don’t give much information about the behaviors of subjects in critical or complicated situation. Milgram sets up an experiment at Yale University to see the reaction of a citizen when ordered by the experimenter to hurt other person. The author

Read More

Obedience In The Crucible, The Ethnic Theory Of Plane Crashes, And

1537 Words | 7 Pages

People do this to avoid consequences, have respect for all authority, don’t question authority, and most are too afraid to speak up. Overall, throughout “The Crucible” by Arthur Miller, “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson, “The Milgram Experiment” by Stanley Milgram, “The Ethnic Theory of Plane Crashes” by Malcolm Gladwell, and “Zimbardo - Stanford Prison Experiment” by Saul McLeod, all exploit and explain the dangers of blind obedience. In the Crucible, blind obedience is shown during the witchcraft investigation that resulted in the deaths of innocent people which was led by Abigail Williams. In the Lottery, blind obedience is shown when in the brutal stoning of a member in the village without questioning the ethical standpoint. In the Milgram experiment, blind obedience is shown when individuals get pressured into causing harm to others when they were instructed by the authority.

Read More

Review Of Stanley Milgram's The Perils Of Obedience

1297 Words | 6 Pages

Milgram, supporting Kelman and Hamilton, would impart how extremely few individuals are able to resist authority due to their desire to please their superior (Milgram 86). If Markinson confided in Jessup because he was a former comrade, then it probably was more difficult to disobey him. Robert Prentice, a professor at the University of Texas at Austin’s McCombs School of Business, coincides with Milgram, Kelman and Hamilton as he portrays in “Obedience to Authority,” that Markinson’s obedience to Jessup likely occurred strictly because Markinson was more concerned with Jessup accepting his decision rather than the content of the decision itself (Prentice). If this is true, than it is probable all humans are capable of following similar unethical commands that are a result the desire to please a higher authority. In addition, Kelman and Hamilton would effectively reason Markinson followed Jessup’s mandate due to routinization.

Read More

Comparing Milgram And Stanford's Psychological Experiments

130 Words | 1 Pages

Why do we conform, and how far does it go? Solomon Asch asked this question and devised an experiment to see if subjects would conform even if they were uncertain that the group norm was incorrect, this eventually led to Milgram’s and Stanford’s own psychological questions about not only conformity, but also obedience and the roles in which people adapt. This paper will take a deeper look into these experiments, and apply their findings to current and past national events such as the American Armed Forced at detention facilities and the systematic torture of prisoners, along with how these experiments relate to advertising and how it is designed to stimulate a since of conformity among a generation. Finally how does society react towards

Read More

Dichotomy In A Few Good Men

741 Words | 3 Pages

Waverly Lopez Dr. Kreis DCAC 5th Date of submission A Few Good Men In “Obedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem” by Erich Fromm, brings up the argument that humans will obey authority till then end.

Read More

What Rationale Does The Author Give For Conducting The Study

424 Words | 2 Pages

Americans are not naturally less likely to obey something that they no is wrong. The amount of obedience was highly underestimated. The subjects endured both emotional strain and tension, which was unexpected. 6. What do the results of this study mean in practical terms?

Read More

Compare And Contrast Milgram And Zimbardo

1397 Words | 6 Pages

In Stanley Milgram’s “The perils of obedience” and Philip G. Zimbardo's “The Stanford Prison Experiment” the influence that authority holds is analyzed and tested in a variety of social experiments. Milgram asserts that any individual can excuse themselves from the responsibility of their role, regardless of how evil, on the grounds that there is someone ordering them to do so. However, Zimbardo claims that authority doesn’t have to be an individual, stating that anyone, be it a prison guard or a prisoner, will ultimately fill and perpetuate their assigned role as a result of authoritative factors and environments. However, the way in which both of the authors go to reaching these conclusions differs greatly.

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Milgram Experiment And The Stanford Prison Experiment

810 Words | 4 Pages

Since the beginning of the human existence, man has always dominated and ruled over one another be it empires, corporations, or small groups. Authority and obedience has always been a factor of who we are. This natural occurrence can be seen clearly through the psychological experiments known as The Milgram Experiment and the Stanford Prison Experiment. Both of these studies are based on how human beings react to authority figures and what their obedience is when faced with conflict.

Read More

Police Brutality In A Few Good Men

1123 Words | 5 Pages

They are being forced to respect every other person and their requests. Such as in the film, A Few Good Men, individuals unconsciously perform obedience to higher ranked personnel, although it’s already enforced. Bringing into the light, no one is born obedient. Being obedient is learned. Who must we be obedient to, how can you tell, what makes it okay to obey?

Read More

Milgram Experiment And Dr. Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Study

661 Words | 3 Pages

Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Study, concluded that high percentages of people would cause harm to others if an authority figure persuaded them to do so. The Milgram experiment included an experimenter, teacher, and student. The teacher (participant) would say a word to the student and when the student answered incorrectly the teacher was told to shock them. Although most participants were reluctant to keep increasing the voltage of shocks when they felt the student was in real pain, a surprisingly two-thirds continued following the orders of the experimenter (ABC Primetime, 2007). It appears that all of us are capable of following an authority figures directions even if it causes pain to others or even death.

Read More

Why Did Jim Jones Use Conformity To Gain Control Over His Followers?

767 Words | 4 Pages

Obedience is compliance with an order/law or submission to someone’s authority. People often obey authority figures, even if it goes against their moral beliefs for several reasons: “Legitimacy” of authority: In any social, political or organizational environment, authority figures frequently occupy positions of responsibility and influence. the belief that these individuals have the right to decide or issue commands may cause people to obey them even when they don't agree. Socialization: People learn early on to listen to and obey parents, teachers, and law enforcement as examples of authoritative adults. The sense of duty and obligation to submit to authority is created by this socialization.

Read More

Similarities Between The Perils Of Obedience And The Stanford Prison Experiment

1154 Words | 5 Pages

In 1963, Yale psychologist Stanley Milgram conducted a controversial, but highly revered, study on obedience. The experiment was designed to test people’s morals versus an extreme authority, but, as predicted, obedience prevailed. Then in 1973, Philip G. Zimbardo created his own experiment, not unlike Milgram’s, that analyzed the potential of individuals to withstand the pressure of succumbing to an obedient role based on the environment. Both Stanley Milgram, author of “The Perils of Obedience,” and Philip Zimbardo, author of “The Stanford Prison Experiment,” conducted these experiments to show how an ordinary person’s obedience could be affected based off of the situation they are put in.

Read More

Authority In The Short Story Antaeus, By Borden Bear

1076 Words | 5 Pages

Renowned psychologist and social experimenter Stanley Milgram once said that “obedience is the psychological mechanism that links individual action to political purpose. It is the dispositional cement that binds men to systems of authority.” In other words, man succumbs to authority because it is rooted in his obedience to jurisdiction. An example of this is the American judicial system, which man is obedient to because that is what’s known. His political or societal purpose however is a learned behavior, or one that he matriculates from the dynamic of his culture.

Read More

The Importance Of Conformity In 1984 By George Orwell

1500 Words | 6 Pages

Obedience is when people listen to directions from an authority figure, often without questioning reasoning, While there are societal benefits to obedience, like people listening to directions from firefighters, lifeguards, and others who work to keep people safe, there are also potential negative impacts of the obedience modern society has managed to cultivate. For example, “Obedience is often at the heart of some of the worst of human behavior- massacres, atrocities, and even genocide” (Burger 4). These horrendous

Read More

More about I Was Just Following Orders Milgram Essay

Related Topics

Open Document